Personality Stability, Development, and Change Notes
Causes and Nature of Personality Stability
- Personality is characterized by stability over the life span, while also involving significant change.
- Temperament: This is partially determined by genetics.
- Heterotypic Continuity: Effects of fundamental tendencies change with age (e.g., a shy child does not hide behind a parent as an adult, but may still avoid social situations). Basic aspects involve:
- Positive emotionality.
- Negative emotionality.
- Effortful control.
- Physical and Environmental Factors: Attributes like height or attractiveness, and the environments one is born into, contribute to stability.
- Birth Order: This is based on the idea that parents treat the first child differently from subsequent children. It should be noted that this concept has mixed research support.
- Early Experience: Personality stability is influenced by both early adverse and early positive experiences.
Person-Environment Transactions
- Active Person-Environment Transaction: An individual seeks out compatible environments and avoids incompatible ones.
- Example: An aggressive person intentionally goes to a bar where fights are frequent.
- Example: An introvert avoids social gatherings.
- Reactive Person-Environment Transaction: Different people respond differently to the same situation.
- Example: An extravert finds a party enjoyable, whereas an introvert finds the same party unbearable.
- Evocative Person-Environment Transaction: An aspect of an individual's personality leads to behavior that changes the situation itself.
- Example: A conscientious person tells a group, "It's time to get to work."
- Example: A disagreeable person starts an argument over a minor matter.
Personality Development and Social Factors
- Causes of Development:
- Physical development and changes in physical strength.
- Increases in intelligence and linguistic abilities.
- Hormone-level changes.
- Changes in social roles and responsibilities (informed by Erikson’s theory of development).
- The Social Clock: This concept refers to systematic pressures placed on people to accomplish certain milestones by certain ages.
- Research indicates that women who followed either a feminine or masculine social clock reported higher contentment and satisfaction than women who followed neither.
- Narrative Identity: This refers to how a person views their life and how its trajectory fits into their goals and dreams. It consists of three aspects:
1. Actor.
2. Agent.
3. Author.
- Themes in Narrative Identity: Themes differ by individual. These are related to personality; for instance, themes of agency and conscientiousness are linked, as are themes of redemption and the development of healthier habits.
Personality Change: Methods and Motivations
- Desire for Change: Typical among most people. Usually, the desired change is in a socially desirable direction with the goal of making life better.
- Four Potential Methods of Change:
1. Psychotherapy: This can produce long-term behavior change. It is often combined with psychiatric drugs but might have a downside.
2. General Interventions: These are usually aimed at important outcomes. Evidence shows success for intensive programs targeting high-risk preschool students.
3. Targeted Interventions: These address specific personality traits such as openness to experience, tolerance for stress and defensiveness, neuroticism, narcissism, and self-control.
4. Life Experiences.
- Sociogenomic Trait Intervention Model:
- Step 1: Identify what the person wants to change.
- Step 2: Perform behaviors outside of the comfort zone until they become habitual and automatic.
- Focus: Identify important goals and the behaviors that would lead to the achievement of those goals.
Life Experiences Impacting Personality
- Positive Experiences:
- Physical exercise.
- Starting college or a new job.
- Beginning a serious relationship.
- Negative or Challenging Experiences:
- Trying drugs.
- The onset of a chronic disease.
- Becoming unemployed.
- Experiencing negative life events.
- Other Developmental Factors:
- Travel.
- Military training.
Obstacles to Personality Change
- Several factors act as barriers to change:
- Not seeing a reason or motivation for change.
- The process takes significant effort.
- A tendency to blame negative experiences and failures on external forces rather than one's own personality.
- A natural human preference for consistency and predictability.
- Three-Part Framework for Overcoming Obstacles (Hennecke et al., 2014):
- Precondition 1: Changing trait-related behaviors is considered desirable or necessary.
- Precondition 2: Changing trait-related behaviors is considered feasible.
- The above lead to Self-regulated behavioral changes.
- Precondition 3: Self-regulated changes become habitual, leading to formal Trait change.
The Change Goals Inventory (Hudson & Roberts, 2014)
- This inventory measures the extent to which an individual wants to change specific personality traits.
- Response Scale:
- Much more than I currently am: +2
- More than I currently am: +1
- I do not want to change in this trait: 0
- Less than I currently am: −1
- Much less than I currently am: −2
- Inventory Items:
1. I want to be talkative.
2. I want to be reserved.
3. I want to be someone who is full of energy.
4. I want to be someone who generates a lot of enthusiasm.
5. I want to be someone who tends to be quiet.
6. I want to have an assertive personality.
7. I want to be sometimes shy, inhibited.
8. I want to be outgoing, sociable.
- Scoring Procedure:
- Reverse the scores for items 2, 5, and 7 by multiplying the answers by −1.
- Add the eight resulting scores together.
- Divide the total by 8 to find the average.
Principles of Personality Continuity and Change
- Cumulative Continuity Principle: Personality traits increase in rank-order consistency as people get older.
- Maturity Principle: People become better equipped to deal with the demands of life as they acquire experience and skills.
- Plasticity Principle: Personality can change at any time, but such change may not be easy.
- Role Continuity Principle: Taking on roles or images (e.g., being a "jock" or "brain") can cause personality to be consistent over time.
- Identity Development Principle: People seek to develop a stable sense of who they are and strive to act consistently with this self-view.
- Social Investment Principle: Changing social roles at different life stages (e.g., spouse, parent, boss) can cause personality to change.
- Corresponsive Principle: Person-environment transactions can cause personality traits to remain consistent or even magnify over time.
Evaluation of Personality Change
- Is personality change good or bad? The answer is that it is both.
- Instability and inconsistency can cause significant problems.
- Most personality change is adaptive, though it typically occurs slowly.
Questions & Discussion
- Question 1: Research has shown that:
- a) it is possible to intentionally change personality, such as make someone more self-controlled. (Correct Answer)
- b) personality does not change after about age 50.
- c) longitudinal studies reveal different patterns of development from what have been found in cross-sectional studies.
- d) one principle is sufficient to explain personality change.
- Question 2: Personality stability:
- a) is only affected by genetics.
- b) increases as people get older. (Correct Answer)
- c) is so low that adult behavior cannot be predicted by childhood personality.
- d) is certainly not affected by birth order.
- Question 3: Which statement about personality development is true?
- a) Personality changes very little after age 30.
- b) Rank-order stability tends to be high.
- c) The mean levels of traits change over time.
- d) Both b and c are correct. (Correct Answer)