IPM 452/552 – Lecture 5 Notes (Pesticide Classes – Insecticides & Acaricides)

Pesticide Naming & Regulatory Basics

  • Three common “names” for every pesticide:

    • Chemical name (IUPAC chemical name): precise structural description.

    • Common name: internationally accepted short form (e.g., carbaryl, glyphosate).

    • Product/brand name: formulation-specific; contains active ingredient (AI) + solvents, adjuvants, emulsifiers, etc. EPA risk-assesses the AI but legally registers each formulated product.

    • Example 1:

      • IUPAC: 1-naphthyl methyl carbamate

      • Common name: carbaryl

      • Product name: Sevin

    • Example 2:

      • IUPAC: N-(Phosphonomethyl) glycine

      • Common name: glyphosate

      • Round up

  • EPA conducts risk assessments on the active ingredient but registers individual procucts (formulation of active ingredients)

  • Average efficacy of pest control practices worldwide in reducing yield loss potential of pathogens, viruses, animals (mostly insects) and weeds is a surrogate for impact of pest damage on crop production

  • Mammalian toxicity data appear on labels per formulation.

  • Example (lambda-cyhalothrin product “Karate”):

    • Oral LD50 = 93 mg/kg (females)

    • Dermal LD50 = >2000 mg/kg

    • This indicates that the oral exposure is significantly more toxic compared to dermal exposure, highlighting the importance of handling precautions.

  • Active Ingredient (AI): Lambda-cyhalothrin is a synthetic pyrethroid that targets the nervous system of insects.

    • Oral LD50 = 56 mg/kg (females)$LD_{50}\,(♀)=56\;\text{mg·kg}^{-1}

    • Dermal LD50 = 632 mg/kg (males)$LD_{50}\,(♂)=632\;\

Global Yield Losses & Use Statistics

  • Average untreated (“do-nothing”) pest loss ≈ 17\%(allpests)inmajorcrops;treatinginsectsalonereduceslossto(all pests) in major crops; treating insects alone reduces loss to\sim 10\%(Oerke2005).</p></li><li><p>U.S.pesticidemarkettrends(1964−2010):</p><ul><li><p>Totalpoundsa.i.peakedlate1970s;insecticidesrepresentshrinkingsharecomparedwithherbicides.</p></li><li><p>“Other”class=fumigants,desiccants,growthregulators,harvestaids.</p></li></ul></li><li><p>Insecticideuse2009−2010(USDA−NASS):</p><ul><li><p>Highestpounds:corn>cotton>soybean>potatoes;applestreat(Oerke 2005).</p></li><li><p>U.S. pesticide market trends (1964-2010):</p><ul><li><p>Total pounds a.i. peaked late 1970s; insecticides represent shrinking share compared with herbicides.</p></li><li><p>“Other” class = fumigants, desiccants, growth regulators, harvest aids.</p></li></ul></li><li><p>Insecticide use 2009-2010 (USDA-NASS):</p><ul><li><p>Highest pounds: corn > cotton > soybean > potatoes; apples treat99\%ofacreageyetpoundsdeclinedbyof acreage yet pounds declined by\sim1.5\times10^{6} lb over 30 yr.

  • Neonicotinoid ("neonic") expansion (1995-2011):

    • Acreage mainly through seed treatments; corn + soybean dominate.

    • Invasive soybean aphid outbreak → spike then gradual decline in foliar neonics; host-plant resistance affects use curves.

  • Social vs. Biochemical Classification

    • “Social” categories – how regulators/industry group products:

      • Conventional insecticides (older, often broad spectrum).

      • Reduced-risk insecticides.

      • Biopesticides / PIPs (plant-incorporated protectants).

    • Mode-of-action (MOA) divisions (IRAC numbering):

      • Neurotoxins (sodium, acetylcholinesterase, nicotinic, GABA, glutamate/Cl⁻, ryanodine).

      • Respiratory (mitochondrial) inhibitors.

      • Endocrine mimics (ecdysone, juvenile hormone).

      • Metabolic inhibitors (chitin, lipid synthesis, etc.).

      • Sensory agonists (feeding blockers, repellents).

      • Microbial agents / PIPs.

    Market & Chemistry Evolution

    • Organochlorines (DDT & cyclodienes) nearly abandoned → Organophosphates (OPs) dominated 1970-1990 → Pyrethroids, carbamates, neonics, diamides, spinosyns, METIs expand post-1990.

    • 2013 global sales by MOA (Sparks & Nauen 2015): diamides, neonics, and spinosyns comprise fastest-growing segments.

    • \$13.9\,\text{billion}=totalinsecticidemarket(2010);neonicsalone= total insecticide market (2010); neonics alone\$8.8\,\text{billion}.

    IRAC & Resistance Management

    • IRAC website supplies searchable MOA tables, wall posters, phone apps.

    • Each MOA assigned a number now printed on labels—facilitates rotation for resistance management.

    Reduced-Risk Concept (EPA, 1993 → updated post-FQPA 1996)

    • Qualifying criteria (ideally all):

      • Low human toxicity; minimal non-target effects; low water contamination potential; low use rates; lower resistance risk; IPM compatibility.

    • Incentives: accelerated review & registration (first 22 AIs approved by 1997).

    • Comparative mammalian toxicology table shows OPs (red) vs. reduced-risk AIs (green) – log orders safer.

    • Vertebrate Selectivity Ratio SR=\frac{LD{50}\,\text{rat}}{LD{50}\,\text{insect}}increasingoverdecadeswhilefielduse−rate(lb/acre)decreases(Sparks2013).</p></li></ul><h3id="0ea0a95b−b36a−4e6f−af30−02424902d167"data−toc−id="0ea0a95b−b36a−4e6f−af30−02424902d167"collapsed="false"seolevelmigrated="true">InsectNervousSystemPrimer(necessaryforMOAunderstanding)</h3><ul><li><p>Neuronparts:dendrites(receptors)–soma–axon;synapse≈increasing over decades while field use-rate (lb/acre) decreases (Sparks 2013).</p></li></ul><h3 id="0ea0a95b-b36a-4e6f-af30-02424902d167" data-toc-id="0ea0a95b-b36a-4e6f-af30-02424902d167" collapsed="false" seolevelmigrated="true">Insect Nervous System Primer (necessary for MOA understanding)</h3><ul><li><p>Neuron parts: dendrites (receptors) – soma – axon; synapse ≈20\,\text{nm}gap.</p></li><li><p>Restingpotential≈gap.</p></li><li><p>Resting potential ≈-70\,\text{mV}createdbyselectiveNa+/K+permeability.</p></li><li><p>Actionpotential(AP):Na+influxthenK+efflux;all−or−nonespiketocreated by selective Na⁺/K⁺ permeability.</p></li><li><p>Action potential (AP): Na⁺ influx then K⁺ efflux; all-or-none spike to\sim+40\,\text{mV} propagating unidirectionally.

    • Chemical transmission: ACh released into synapse, binds nicotinic receptor (nAChR) → new AP; AChE quickly hydrolyzes ACh.

    • Inhibitory neurotransmitter GABA opens Cl⁻ channels → hyperpolarization.

    • Two chief vulnerable sites:

      1. Axonal ion channels (Na⁺).

      2. Synapse (AChE, nAChR, GABA receptors).

    Neurotoxic Insecticides

    Sodium Channel Modulators (delay closing)

    Pyrethrins & Pyrethroids (and DDT)
    • Natural pyrethrum (6 esters, \sim1!–!2\% in dried flowers) unstable to sunlight (t½ water < 1 h, soil < 24 h).

    • Piperonyl butoxide (PBO) discovered 1949—synergist inhibiting P450s, lowers cost & dose; human dermal absorption \approx1.7\%.</p></li><li><p>MichaelElliot1960s:syntheticpyrethroids(e.g.,permethrin,bifenthrin,cyhalothrin)10−100×morestable;userate.</p></li><li><p>Michael Elliot 1960s: synthetic pyrethroids (e.g., permethrin, bifenthrin, cyhalothrin) 10-100× more stable; use rate0.1!–!0.2\,\text{lb·A}^{-1}.</p></li><li><p>Isomerismcritical—only.</p></li><li><p>Isomerism critical—only1S−transpermethrinisbioactive.</p></li><li><p>Negativetemperaturecoefficient:redflourbeetlesurvival↑astemp↑(cyfluthrinresidues).</p></li><li><p>Selectivityfactors(Narahashi2001):temperaturedependence(×5),intrinsicsensitivity(×10),rapidmammaliandetox(esterases),skinpenetrationlow,smallbodysize,etc.</p></li><li><p>MammalianPK:cyfluthrinhalf−life-trans permethrin is bioactive.</p></li><li><p>Negative temperature coefficient: red flour beetle survival ↑ as temp ↑ (cyfluthrin residues).</p></li><li><p>Selectivity factors (Narahashi 2001): temperature dependence (×5), intrinsic sensitivity (×10), rapid mammalian detox (esterases), skin penetration low, small body size, etc.</p></li><li><p>Mammalian PK: cyfluthrin half-life\sim5!–!7\,\text{h}; poor skin absorption (Hughes & Edwards 2010).

    Sodium Channel Blocker – Indoxacarb
    • Pro-insecticide bio-activated in Lepidoptera to decarbomethoxylated metabolite that blocks Na⁺ current leading to sub-threshold APs.

    • Highly selective: fall armyworm oral LD_{50}=0.01\,\text{ng·mg}^{-1}vs.ratvs. rat1277\,\text{ng·mg}^{-1}.

    • Uses: lepidopteran control in crops, ant/cockroach baits.

    Acetylcholinesterase (AChE) Inhibitors

    • Organophosphates (OPs) & Carbamates (CBs).

      • OP pro-insecticides (phosphorothioates) require P450 oxidation to oxon; only oxon binds AChE.

      • Examples: chlorpyrifos, malathion, azinphos-methyl (cancelled), aldicarb, carbaryl, formetanate.

      • High acute toxicity; broad spectrum; OP phase-outs ongoing, still limited use.

    Nicotinic ACh Receptor Modulators

    Neonicotinoids (IRAC 4A) & Sulfoximines (4C)
    • Mimic ACh but bind insect nAChR with far > affinity than vertebrate (Tomizawa & Casida 2005). Selectivity ratios up to >10^{3}.</p></li><li><p>MainAIs:imidacloprid,clothianidin,thiamethoxam,acetamiprid,thiacloprid,dinotefuran;sulfoxaflor(4C).</p></li><li><p>Lowmammalianacutetoxicity(oral.</p></li><li><p>Main AIs: imidacloprid, clothianidin, thiamethoxam, acetamiprid, thiacloprid, dinotefuran; sulfoxaflor (4C).</p></li><li><p>Low mammalian acute toxicity (oralLD_{50}>2000\,\text{mg·kg}^{-1}formost)andhighNOAELs(clothianidinfor most) and high NOAELs (clothianidin>9\,\text{mg·kg}^{-1}\text{/d}Feeding).</p></li><li><p>Fieldrates<Feeding).</p></li><li><p>Field rates <0.5\,\text{lb·A}^{-1}; seed-treatment dominates corn/soy (USA) & canola (UK).

    Spinosyns (IRAC 5)
    • Fermentation metabolites of Saccharopolyspora spinosa; spinosad = A + D; spinetoram semi-synthetic (higher potency).

    • Bind distinct site on nAChR (not neonic site) → excitation; excellent selectivity; oral/dermal LD_{50}>5000\,\text{mg·kg}^{-1};fastenvironmentaldegradation;organicformulations(Entrust)available.</p></li><li><p>Caveat:Highbeetoxicity.</p></li></ul><h4id="d4cc449c−6c44−4748−8af2−fbcee3030eab"data−toc−id="d4cc449c−6c44−4748−8af2−fbcee3030eab"collapsed="false"seolevelmigrated="true">GABAergicModulators</h4><ul><li><p><strong>Cyclodienes,endosulfan,lindane</strong>(historical):non−competitiveGABAantagonists,highpersistence;manycancelled.</p></li><li><p><strong>Fipronil(IRAC2B)</strong>phenylpyrazole—blocksGABAreceptor;IC50insect; fast environmental degradation; organic formulations (Entrust) available.</p></li><li><p>Caveat: High bee toxicity.</p></li></ul><h4 id="d4cc449c-6c44-4748-8af2-fbcee3030eab" data-toc-id="d4cc449c-6c44-4748-8af2-fbcee3030eab" collapsed="false" seolevelmigrated="true">GABAergic Modulators</h4><ul><li><p><strong>Cyclodienes, endosulfan, lindane</strong> (historical): non-competitive GABA antagonists, high persistence; many cancelled.</p></li><li><p><strong>Fipronil (IRAC 2B)</strong> phenylpyrazole—blocks GABA receptor; IC50 insect\sim7\,\text{nM}vs.humanvs. human\sim942\,\text{nM}→selective.Products:Termidor(termites),Frontline(pets),Regent.</p></li></ul><h4id="537b00f8−ee4f−4263−bb4a−cf5cfa5b5b09"data−toc−id="537b00f8−ee4f−4263−bb4a−cf5cfa5b5b09"collapsed="false"seolevelmigrated="true">Glutamate−GatedCl−ChannelAgonists–Avermectins(IRAC6)</h4><ul><li><p>Abamectin,emamectin,ivermectin:openGluClchannelscausingparalysis;powerfulacaricide/nematicide;verylowapplicationrates→ selective. Products: Termidor (termites), Frontline (pets), Regent.</p></li></ul><h4 id="537b00f8-ee4f-4263-bb4a-cf5cfa5b5b09" data-toc-id="537b00f8-ee4f-4263-bb4a-cf5cfa5b5b09" collapsed="false" seolevelmigrated="true">Glutamate-Gated Cl⁻ Channel Agonists – Avermectins (IRAC 6)</h4><ul><li><p>Abamectin, emamectin, ivermectin: open GluCl channels causing paralysis; powerful acaricide/nematicide; very low application rates0.025!–!0.05\,\text{lb·A}^{-1};moderateintrinsicmammaliantoxicitymitigatedbylowexposure.</p></li></ul><h4id="49371cfe−51e0−419e−acc6−7ef42db4796b"data−toc−id="49371cfe−51e0−419e−acc6−7ef42db4796b"collapsed="false"seolevelmigrated="true">RyanodineReceptorActivators–Diamides(IRAC28)</h4><ul><li><p>Chlorantraniliprole(Rynaxapyr/Altacor),cyantraniliprole,flubendiamide.</p></li><li><p>ProlongCa2+releasefromSR,depletingstores→muscleparalysis;vertebrateRyRinsensitive.</p></li><li><p>Mammalian; moderate intrinsic mammalian toxicity mitigated by low exposure.</p></li></ul><h4 id="49371cfe-51e0-419e-acc6-7ef42db4796b" data-toc-id="49371cfe-51e0-419e-acc6-7ef42db4796b" collapsed="false" seolevelmigrated="true">Ryanodine Receptor Activators – Diamides (IRAC 28)</h4><ul><li><p>Chlorantraniliprole (Rynaxapyr/Altacor), cyantraniliprole, flubendiamide.</p></li><li><p>Prolong Ca²⁺ release from SR, depleting stores → muscle paralysis; vertebrate RyR insensitive.</p></li><li><p>MammalianLD_{50}>5000\,\text{mg·kg}^{-1};rates; rates0.02!–!0.09\,\text{lb·A}^{-1}; excellent codling moth control.

    Feeding Blocker – Pymetrozine (IRAC 9B)

    • Agonist of TRPV chordotonal organ channels → stops stylet insertion & feeding; aphid-specific; formulations Fulfill, Endeavor; harmless to most natural enemies.

    Respiratory / Mitochondrial Electron Transport Inhibitors (METIs)

    • Target Complex I (NADH-CoQ reductase) in mites.

    • Key acaricides: pyridaben, fenpyroximate, bifenazate (pro-acaricide via ester hydrolysis).

    • METIs show fast mite knockdown, \text{LD}_{50}\,\text{oral} > 245\,\text{mg·kg}^{-1},dermalusually>, dermal usually >2000\,\text{mg·kg}^{-1};selectiveduetorapidvertebratemetabolism.</p></li></ul><h3id="6c629d73−e914−437a−af5c−8d87952f2583"data−toc−id="6c629d73−e914−437a−af5c−8d87952f2583"collapsed="false"seolevelmigrated="true">Endocrine/DevelopmentalDisruptors(InsectGrowthRegulators–IGRs)</h3><h4id="48755d98−4f51−4ffb−a4f9−aa96abe630a3"data−toc−id="48755d98−4f51−4ffb−a4f9−aa96abe630a3"collapsed="false"seolevelmigrated="true">EcdysoneReceptorAgonists(Diacylhydrazines,IRAC18)</h4><ul><li><p>Tebufenozide(Confirm),methoxyfenozide(Intrepid).</p></li><li><p>Non−steroidalmimic→prematuremolt,feedingstops,deathbystarvationwithin; selective due to rapid vertebrate metabolism.</p></li></ul><h3 id="6c629d73-e914-437a-af5c-8d87952f2583" data-toc-id="6c629d73-e914-437a-af5c-8d87952f2583" collapsed="false" seolevelmigrated="true">Endocrine/Developmental Disruptors (Insect Growth Regulators – IGRs)</h3><h4 id="48755d98-4f51-4ffb-a4f9-aa96abe630a3" data-toc-id="48755d98-4f51-4ffb-a4f9-aa96abe630a3" collapsed="false" seolevelmigrated="true">Ecdysone Receptor Agonists (Diacylhydrazines, IRAC 18)</h4><ul><li><p>Tebufenozide (Confirm), methoxyfenozide (Intrepid).</p></li><li><p>Non-steroidal mimic → premature molt, feeding stops, death by starvation within\sim48\,\text{h}.</p></li></ul><h4id="45719bb2−eef9−4496−8e1b−120c995770c6"data−toc−id="45719bb2−eef9−4496−8e1b−120c995770c6"collapsed="false"seolevelmigrated="true">JuvenileHormoneMimics(IRAC7A)</h4><ul><li><p>Methoprene,hydroprene,pyriproxyfen(Esteem).</p></li><li><p>Maintainjuvenilestate→arrestdevelopment/sterilizeeggs;earlycodlingmothsuppression.</p></li></ul><h4id="3824fe81−6e9f−4bab−b70e−07cecd30077c"data−toc−id="3824fe81−6e9f−4bab−b70e−07cecd30077c"collapsed="false"seolevelmigrated="true">ChitinSynthesisInhibitors(Benzoylureas,IRAC15)</h4><ul><li><p>Diflubenzuron(Dimilin),novaluron(Rimon),hexaflumuron(Recruit),lufenuron(Program).</p></li><li><p>Blockchitinsynthaseduringcuticleformation→failedmolt;extremelylowmammaliantoxicity(oral.</p></li></ul><h4 id="45719bb2-eef9-4496-8e1b-120c995770c6" data-toc-id="45719bb2-eef9-4496-8e1b-120c995770c6" collapsed="false" seolevelmigrated="true">Juvenile Hormone Mimics (IRAC 7A)</h4><ul><li><p>Methoprene, hydroprene, pyriproxyfen (Esteem).</p></li><li><p>Maintain juvenile state → arrest development / sterilize eggs; early codling moth suppression.</p></li></ul><h4 id="3824fe81-6e9f-4bab-b70e-07cecd30077c" data-toc-id="3824fe81-6e9f-4bab-b70e-07cecd30077c" collapsed="false" seolevelmigrated="true">Chitin Synthesis Inhibitors (Benzoylureas, IRAC 15)</h4><ul><li><p>Diflubenzuron (Dimilin), novaluron (Rimon), hexaflumuron (Recruit), lufenuron (Program).</p></li><li><p>Block chitin synthase during cuticle formation → failed molt; extremely low mammalian toxicity (oralLD_{50}>4500 mg·kg⁻¹).

    • Termite baits (hexaflumuron, noviflumuron) & flea control (lufenuron) highlight urban IPM.

    Lipid Synthesis Inhibitors – ACCase Blockers (IRAC 23)

    • Inhibit acetyl-CoA carboxylase (first step fatty acid synthesis) → incomplete molt + desiccation; oral LD_{50}>2000\,\text{mg·kg}^{-1}.

    Comparative Toxicology & Application Rates

    • OPs: oral LD50 often <5\,\text{mg·kg}^{-1};neonics,diamides,spinosynsgenerally>; neonics, diamides, spinosyns generally >2000\,\text{mg·kg}^{-1}.</p></li><li><p>Neonicapplication.</p></li><li><p>Neonic application<1.5lba.i./acrevs.chlorpyrifosoftenlb a.i./acre vs. chlorpyrifos often>1lba.i./acre.</p></li><li><p>NOAELs:neonicslb a.i./acre.</p></li><li><p>NOAELs: neonics>1mg⋅kg−1⋅day−1;nicotinemg·kg⁻¹·day⁻¹; nicotine0.002$$ mg·kg⁻¹·day⁻¹ (far more toxic).

    Environmental & IPM Implications

    • Ideal insecticide: selective, low persistence, low non-target toxicity.

    • Post-1990 chemistries meet many criteria → favored in IPM; yet legacy OP/CB still used where cost/resistance drive.

    • Resistance management relies on rotating IRAC groups, integrating biological/ cultural tactics.

    • Biotech PIPs and host-plant resistance can sharply alter insecticide use trends (e.g., Bt crops, aphid-resistant soybean).

    Bottom Line

    • Overall U.S. insecticide pounds continue downward owing to higher potency AIs and IPM adoption.

    • Majority of new products exploit subtle biochemical differences (receptor binding, metabolic activation) to gain mammal safety and pest specificity.

    • Understanding nerve physiology, endocrine regulation, and mitochondrial respiration is essential for both discovery and responsible stewardship of modern insecticides.