Religious Liberties- Overview

Free Exercise Doctrine — Big Picture

The timeline

1940 — Cantwell v. Connecticut
→ First Amendment Free Exercise protection applies to the states through the 14th Amendment.
→ Government cannot decide whether a religion is “legitimate” before allowing religious activity.
→ Belief is absolute; conduct can be regulated.

⬇

1963 — Sherbert v. Verner
→ Government action can violate Free Exercise even when it isn't directly banning religion.
→ If government substantially burdens religious exercise, it needs a compelling governmental interest.
→ This develops the Sherbert/strict-scrutiny approach.

⬇

1972 — Wisconsin v. Yoder
→ Applies the strong protection from Sherbert to religiously motivated conduct and parental religious upbringing.
→ Government needs an interest of “highest order” when its law substantially interferes with religious practice.
→ The Court still does not judge whether the religion itself is true.

⬇

1990 — Employment Division v. Smith
→ Major shift.
→ Neutral, generally applicable laws do not ordinarily violate Free Exercise merely because they incidentally burden religion.
→ The Sherbert compelling-interest test is not automatically applied to every religious burden.

⬇

1993 — Church of Lukumi Babalu Aye v. Hialeah
→ Clarifies Smith.
→ A law must actually be neutral and generally applicable.
→ If government targets religion—through its wording, exemptions, operation, or context—strict scrutiny applies.

⬇

2025 — Mahmoud v. Taylor
→ Modern application involving public education and parental religious upbringing.
→ Mere exposure to ideas someone dislikes isn't automatically a Free Exercise violation.
→ But a Yoder-type burden on parents' religious upbringing can trigger strict scrutiny.


Comparison Chart

Case

What happened?

Main rule

How religion is treated

Cantwell (1940)

State required approval before religious solicitation

Government cannot license religious activity based on whether officials think the cause is religious

Don't judge the truth/validity of beliefs

Sherbert (1963)

Woman denied unemployment benefits because she wouldn't work on Sabbath

Substantial burden → compelling interest

Focus on burden, not whether belief is correct

Yoder (1972)

Amish parents objected to compulsory high school

Strong religious burden requires an interest of highest order

Religious practice deeply connected to community/way of life

Smith (1990)

Religious peyote use violated neutral drug law

Neutral + generally applicable law → generally valid

Don't ask whether practice is “central” to religion

Lukumi (1993)

Hialeah restricted animal sacrifice in a way that targeted Santeria

Not neutral/general → strict scrutiny

Government cannot disguise religious targeting through secular laws

Mahmoud (2025)

Parents objected to LGBTQ+-inclusive schoolbooks; opt-outs removed

Yoder-type burden → strict scrutiny in this context

Government can't substantially interfere with religious upbringing

The easiest way to remember the doctrinal progression

Cantwell:

“You can't decide whether my religion is legitimate.”

Sherbert:

“You can't substantially burden my religion without a really strong reason.”

Yoder:

“That protection can be especially strong when government interferes with religious life/upbringing.”

Smith:

“BUT a neutral, generally applicable law can usually apply to everyone, even if religion is incidentally burdened.”

Lukumi:

“Unless that ‘neutral’ law is actually targeting religion.”

Mahmoud:

“And Yoder-type burdens can still matter in specific contexts, like parents' religious upbringing of their children.”


The 4 Professor Questions — One Answer

1. What makes a religion “legitimate”?

The Court generally doesn't decide whether religious beliefs are true, logical, or theologically correct.

Instead, the question is whether the claimed practice is genuinely connected to religious belief.

2. How does government get into trouble identifying religion?

The government can become a religious censor if officials decide which beliefs are acceptable, reasonable, traditional, or “real” religions.

That's especially dangerous with unfamiliar or minority religions.

3. Is the Free Exercise test always the same?

No. Context matters.

The major distinction to remember is:

Neutral + generally applicable law
→ Smith framework

Targeting religion / not neutral / not generally applicable
→ Strict scrutiny

Serious Yoder-type burden
→ Strict scrutiny

4. How did the test evolve?

Cantwell → Sherbert → Yoder → Smith → Lukumi → Mahmoud

Think:

Protection expands → strong scrutiny → strong parental protection → Smith limits it → Lukumi qualifies Smith → Mahmoud brings Yoder-type protection into a modern school context.


🧠 The One-Minute Blurt

If you had to explain the entire unit without looking at your notes:

Cantwell incorporated Free Exercise against the states and said government can't decide whether someone's religion is legitimate. Sherbert said that when government substantially burdens religious exercise, it needs a compelling interest. Yoder strengthened that protection when government interfered with deeply rooted religious practice and parental upbringing. Smith changed the framework by saying neutral, generally applicable laws can usually apply even when they incidentally burden religion. Lukumi clarified that Smith doesn't protect laws that actually target religion—if they're not neutral or generally applicable, strict scrutiny applies. Mahmoud shows that Yoder-type protection can still matter when government action substantially interferes with parents' religious upbringing, while mere exposure to ideas isn't automatically enough.

Memory chain:

C → S → Y → S → L → M

Cantwell = Can’t censor religion
Sherbert = Substantial burden
Yoder = Youth/upbringing
Smith = Same law for everyone
Lukumi = Law targets religion
Mahmoud = Modern school/upbringing application