02.07 Market Disequilibrium and Changes in Equilibrium

Market Disequilibrium: Detailed Notes

Introduction

  • Definition: Market disequilibrium occurs when the market price does not equalize quantity supplied and quantity demanded.

  • Cause: Imbalance in the market that moves it away from equilibrium.

Causes of Disequilibrium

  • Underestimation or Overestimation of Demand: Producers misjudge consumer demand.

  • Sudden Shifts in Supply or Demand: Viral social media posts or unexpected events.

  • Government Intervention: Price floors, price ceilings, or quantity regulations.

  • Market Power: A producer with a large market share sets prices to drive out competition.

  • External Shocks: Changes or shocks to the market.

Consequences of Disequilibrium

  • Market Shortage: Quantity demanded exceeds quantity supplied.

  • Market Surplus: Quantity supplied exceeds quantity demanded.

The Return to Equilibrium

  • Market Forces: The laws of supply and demand drive price and quantity back toward equilibrium.

  • Example:

    • A restaurant experiences a sudden increase in demand after a news anchor raves about their dessert on television. The demand curve shifts to the right, creating a shortage.

Key Objectives

  • Interpreting Scenarios: Understand how various events impact the determinants of supply and demand.

  • Drawing Curves: Practice drawing supply and demand curves to illustrate changes in equilibrium price and quantity.

  • Elasticity and Impact: Determine how elasticities influence whether consumers or producers are more affected by disequilibrium.

AP Pro Tip

  • Market Surplus: More is supplied than demanded (inefficient).

  • Economic Surplus: The difference between the actual price and consumers' and producers' willingness to buy or sell.

  • Productive Efficiency: Any point along the PPC where all productive resources are being used.

  • Allocative Efficiency: The point where total economic surplus is maximized (equilibrium).

Elasticity's Role in Disequilibrium

  • Impact on Equilibrium: Changes in supply or demand affect equilibrium price and quantity, as well as consumer and producer surplus.

  • Elasticity's Influence: The magnitude of these effects depends on elasticity.

  • Example: If a good has a perfectly elastic supply curve (horizontal line), there is no producer surplus.

Concepts to Nail Down (Ceteris Paribus)

  • The more price-elastic the demand for a good, the smaller the consumer surplus. This means consumers are closer to the maximum price they'd pay.

  • At equilibrium:

    • If supply is more elastic than demand, consumer surplus will be greater than producer surplus.

    • If demand is more elastic than supply, producer surplus will be greater than consumer surplus.

    • If supply and demand are equally elastic, consumer and producer surpluses will be equal.

  • These principles reveal who has more to lose when prices change from equilibrium due to taxes or other events.

  • Total economic surplus is maximized at equilibrium, even if consumer surplus (CS) and producer surplus (PS) are unequal.

  • A normative economist might view the lack of balance as a problem.

Effects of Shifts in Supply and Demand

  • Supply Decrease (Shift Left):

    • Consumer surplus decreases.

    • Price increases, quantity decreases.

    • Impact on producer surplus is indeterminate.

  • Supply Increase (Shift Right):

    • Consumer surplus increases.

    • Price decreases, quantity increases.

    • Impact on producer surplus is indeterminate.

  • Demand Decrease (Shift Left):

    • Consumer surplus decreases.

    • Producer surplus decreases.

    • Price and quantity both decrease.

  • Demand Increase (Shift Right):

    • Consumer surplus increases.

    • Producer surplus increases.

    • Price and quantity both increase.

  • When only one curve shifts (supply or demand), the impact on consumer surplus matches the direction of change.

  • With a shift in supply, the impact on producer surplus may be indeterminate.

Double Shifts (Shifts in Both Supply and Demand)

  • With a double shift, there is uncertainty.

  • Either the new equilibrium price or quantity will be indeterminate.

  • Thus, the impact on economic surplus will also be indeterminate.