Riviere
Abstract
Overview of the study that investigates the effects of modifying instructions on the Posttraumatic Stress Disorder Checklist (PCL) for military populations.
Objective: To determine if changes in instruction wording impact PTSD symptom reporting and prevalence.
Sample: 1691 soldiers assigned randomly to complete one of three versions of the PCL, varying only in wording of instructions.
Outcomes measured: Demographic variables, combat exposure, mean PTSD symptoms, and PTSD prevalence estimates.
Results: No statistically significant differences observed across PCL versions.
Conclusion: Modifications to PCL instructions can be made to fit research needs without affecting symptom reporting or prevalence estimates.
Introduction
The PCL is among the most widely utilized measures for PTSD in military and civilian populations.
Documentation of the effect of modified instructions in specific populations was previously lacking.
Previous research indicates that question wording can influence responses in surveys (Rabinski, 1989; Schwarz, 1999; Brener et al., 2004).
Importance of understanding how instructions might affect responses, particularly in military settings.
Background on PCL Versions
Three published versions of the PCL:
PCL-M: Military-focused, referring to “a stressful military experience.”
PCL-C: Civilian version; references “stressful life experiences” without military context.
PCL-S: Stressor specific, where respondents identify a specific traumatic event and respond based on that experience.
Importance of referring to both military and nonmilitary experiences for broader applicability in PTSD assessment.
Limitations of PCL Versions
PCL-M: Limited for active duty due to reference to veterans.
PCL-C: Difficulties in interpreting “past stressful experiences” due to temporal implications.
PCL-S: Advantageous due to flexible event references, allowing for assessment of symptoms related to both recent and distant events.
Study Aim and Hypothesis
Aim: To assess whether variations in the wording of PCL-S instructions impact the reporting of PTSD symptoms.
Hypothesis: Different instruction wording might lead to significant differences in symptom endorsement and prevalence estimates.
Methodology
Participants and Procedures
Sample: 1691 Active Duty soldiers, primarily from Army Special Operations Command.
Random assignment: Soldiers completed one of three questionnaires with consistent questions but differing wording in PCL-S versions.
Measures
Broader and stricter criteria used based on the DSM-IV to identify those screening positive for PTSD:
Broad criteria: 1 intrusion symptom, 3 avoidance, and 2 hyperarousal symptoms at moderate or greater levels.
Strict criteria: Must meet the broad criteria and score 50 or more on PTSD symptoms.
Potential covariates included:
Demographics: age, gender, rank, education, race/ethnicity, marital status.
Combat experiences: Data assessed via the Walter Reed Army Institute of Research Combat Experiences Scale.
Data Analysis
Mean PCL sum scores and mean symptom cluster scores (re-experiencing, avoidance, hyperarousal) were compared across variations.
Statistical analyses: Chi-square for demographic associations and ANOVA for symptom differences.
Results
Response Distribution:
PCL-S: 564 participants, Version A: 566 participants, Version B: 561 participants.
Demographic comparison revealed no statistically significant variations across questionnaire versions.
PTSD Symptom and Prevalence Estimates:
No significant differences in PCL Mean, symptom clusters, or prevalence across versions.
Findings remained non-significant even with a liberal p value of 0.10.
Tables
Table 1: Sample Demographics and Combat Exposure by PCL Versions
Provides breakdown of age, gender, education, race/ethnicity, marital status, and combat exposure statistics across groups.
Table 2: PTSD Symptoms and PTSD Estimates Across PCL Versions
Comparison of means for PTSD symptoms and probable PTSD across versions indicating no significant differences.
Discussion and Conclusions
Findings suggest that modifications to PCL-S wording do not significantly differ PTSD symptom endorsement in military samples.
Conclusion indicates that minor adjustments to PCL-S can be made for specific research needs without adversely affecting data.
Limitations include low PTSD prevalence within this sample, necessitating further research with varied symptomatic populations.
Consideration of how participants might overlook instruction details due to the notable nature of their deployment experiences.
Acknowledgments
Recognition of contributions by COL Carl Castro, LTC Robert Forsten, and statistical analysis support staff.
References
A list of cited studies and relevant articles backing the research.
Notable studies focusing on PTSD prevalence, instructional influences, and psychological assessments among military personnel.