Riviere

Abstract

  • Overview of the study that investigates the effects of modifying instructions on the Posttraumatic Stress Disorder Checklist (PCL) for military populations.

  • Objective: To determine if changes in instruction wording impact PTSD symptom reporting and prevalence.

  • Sample: 1691 soldiers assigned randomly to complete one of three versions of the PCL, varying only in wording of instructions.

  • Outcomes measured: Demographic variables, combat exposure, mean PTSD symptoms, and PTSD prevalence estimates.

  • Results: No statistically significant differences observed across PCL versions.

  • Conclusion: Modifications to PCL instructions can be made to fit research needs without affecting symptom reporting or prevalence estimates.

Introduction

  • The PCL is among the most widely utilized measures for PTSD in military and civilian populations.

  • Documentation of the effect of modified instructions in specific populations was previously lacking.

  • Previous research indicates that question wording can influence responses in surveys (Rabinski, 1989; Schwarz, 1999; Brener et al., 2004).

  • Importance of understanding how instructions might affect responses, particularly in military settings.

Background on PCL Versions

  • Three published versions of the PCL:

    • PCL-M: Military-focused, referring to “a stressful military experience.”

    • PCL-C: Civilian version; references “stressful life experiences” without military context.

    • PCL-S: Stressor specific, where respondents identify a specific traumatic event and respond based on that experience.

  • Importance of referring to both military and nonmilitary experiences for broader applicability in PTSD assessment.

Limitations of PCL Versions
  • PCL-M: Limited for active duty due to reference to veterans.

  • PCL-C: Difficulties in interpreting “past stressful experiences” due to temporal implications.

  • PCL-S: Advantageous due to flexible event references, allowing for assessment of symptoms related to both recent and distant events.

Study Aim and Hypothesis

  • Aim: To assess whether variations in the wording of PCL-S instructions impact the reporting of PTSD symptoms.

  • Hypothesis: Different instruction wording might lead to significant differences in symptom endorsement and prevalence estimates.

Methodology

Participants and Procedures

  • Sample: 1691 Active Duty soldiers, primarily from Army Special Operations Command.

  • Random assignment: Soldiers completed one of three questionnaires with consistent questions but differing wording in PCL-S versions.

Measures

  • Broader and stricter criteria used based on the DSM-IV to identify those screening positive for PTSD:

    • Broad criteria: 1 intrusion symptom, 3 avoidance, and 2 hyperarousal symptoms at moderate or greater levels.

    • Strict criteria: Must meet the broad criteria and score 50 or more on PTSD symptoms.

  • Potential covariates included:

    • Demographics: age, gender, rank, education, race/ethnicity, marital status.

    • Combat experiences: Data assessed via the Walter Reed Army Institute of Research Combat Experiences Scale.

Data Analysis

  • Mean PCL sum scores and mean symptom cluster scores (re-experiencing, avoidance, hyperarousal) were compared across variations.

  • Statistical analyses: Chi-square for demographic associations and ANOVA for symptom differences.

Results

  • Response Distribution:

    • PCL-S: 564 participants, Version A: 566 participants, Version B: 561 participants.

  • Demographic comparison revealed no statistically significant variations across questionnaire versions.

  • PTSD Symptom and Prevalence Estimates:

    • No significant differences in PCL Mean, symptom clusters, or prevalence across versions.

    • Findings remained non-significant even with a liberal p value of 0.10.

Tables

Table 1: Sample Demographics and Combat Exposure by PCL Versions
  • Provides breakdown of age, gender, education, race/ethnicity, marital status, and combat exposure statistics across groups.

Table 2: PTSD Symptoms and PTSD Estimates Across PCL Versions
  • Comparison of means for PTSD symptoms and probable PTSD across versions indicating no significant differences.

Discussion and Conclusions

  • Findings suggest that modifications to PCL-S wording do not significantly differ PTSD symptom endorsement in military samples.

  • Conclusion indicates that minor adjustments to PCL-S can be made for specific research needs without adversely affecting data.

  • Limitations include low PTSD prevalence within this sample, necessitating further research with varied symptomatic populations.

  • Consideration of how participants might overlook instruction details due to the notable nature of their deployment experiences.

Acknowledgments

  • Recognition of contributions by COL Carl Castro, LTC Robert Forsten, and statistical analysis support staff.

References

  • A list of cited studies and relevant articles backing the research.

  • Notable studies focusing on PTSD prevalence, instructional influences, and psychological assessments among military personnel.