Comprehensive Notes on Managing Costs and Revenues in Healthcare
Financial Management in Healthcare Organizations
Financial management involves providing oversight for the day-to-day operations of an organization while planning its long-range financial direction. The primary goals are to increase revenues and decrease costs.
The major objectives of financial management in both outpatient and inpatient settings include:
Generating reasonable net income.
Setting appropriate prices for services.
Facilitating relationships with third-party payers, such as Medicare and private insurance companies.
Recording and analyzing cost information to ensure smooth facility operations.
Preparing, auditing, and disseminating financial reports in a timely manner.
Investing in long-term capital assets, which are categorized as investments held for longer than .
Ensuring the generation of sufficient income to pay wages, salaries, and suppliers.
Providing adequate responses to government regulators, external auditors, and accrediting agencies like the Joint Commission.
Maintaining excellent control over the financial risks of the organization.
Tax Status and Organizational Attributes
For-Profit Organizations:
Owned by private owners or investors.
Organized as C Corporations, LLCs, S Corporations, or General Partnerships.
Goal: Maximize profits for owners and investors.
Tax Obligations: They pay state and federal taxes. However, certain states such as Nevada, Ohio, Texas, and Washington do not require for-profit organizations to pay corporate income tax; instead, they pay taxes on gross income at different rates.
Political Activity: They may participate in political campaigns but cannot donate directly to parties; they must contribute via Political Action Committees (PACs).
Community Role: They have a limited obligation to provide care for the indigent.
Capital: They can issue stock to raise capital (e.g., Apple Corporation).
Not-For-Profit Organizations:
Tax Status: They are tax-exempt if they meet IRS Section 501C3 requirements.
Categories: Includes charitable, educational, literary, religious, scientific, public safety, amateur sports promotion, and prevention of cruelty to children or animals.
Governance: Managed by a governing body or board of directors rather than individual owners.
Profit Requirement: They must still turn a profit to ensure continued existence and community service.
Political Activity: They are prohibited from participating in political campaigns or influencing legislation.
Community Role: They must provide funds for community benefit and indigent care.
Private foundations are another form of not-for-profit organization.
Financial Governance Roles
Financial governance refers to a set of rules and guidance to ensure financial processes are well-governed. Key parties include:
Governing Body (Board of Directors or Trustees): The highest level of oversight.
Chief Executive Officer (CEO): Leads the organization.
Chief Financial Officer (CFO): Manages financial risks and planning.
Controller: Found mostly in large organizations; handles high-level accounting, operating budgets, and dealings with regulators and tax authorities.
Treasurer: Responsible for financial planning, establishing budgets, and making corporate investments.
Internal Auditor: Provides objective evaluations of financial and operational activities and advises management on improving financial practices.
Reimbursement Methods
Healthcare organizations must manage reimbursements from various third-party payers using different methodologies.
Private Insurance Methods:
Retrospective: Charges are determined after services are delivered. This includes actual charges or charges minus a negotiated discount.
Cost Plus: An excess amount allowed over billed charges to provide for a profit.
Prospective: Reimbursement is determined before care is furnished. Types include:
Per Diem: A fixed payment per day of service (e.g., a hospital receives a set amount per patient day regardless of actual costs).
Per Diagnosis: Reimbursement based on the diagnosis and its severity; higher acuity diagnoses receive higher rates.
Capitation: A fixed amount paid per patient to cover a period (usually a month), regardless of the number of services provided.
Medicare and Medicaid (MediCal in California):
Contractual Allowances: The difference between what a hospital bills and what Medicare/Medicaid reimburses. For example, if a hospital bills but receives , the hospital writes off the difference. The is the allowance.
Diagnosis-Related Groups (DRGs): A system focused on transparency and fairness, paying similar rates for similar care across different states (e.g., a kidney transplant in Florida vs. South Carolina).
Case Mix Index (CMI): Takes into account the average cost per patient and the CMI to adjust care costs. Formula example: If the average cost is and the CMI is , the adjusted cost is .
Physician Reimbursement:
Resource-Based Relative Value Scale (RBRVS): Payments vary based on the resource cost of providing services, including physician work, practice expense/overhead, and professional liability insurance.
Medicare Part B: Providers (physicians, PTs, OTs, speech pathologists) are paid based on Current Procedural Terminology (CPT) codes. Each code has a specific assigned reimbursement rate.
Resource Utilization Groups (RUG Levels): Used for skilled nursing facilities (SNFs) based on patient acuity and complexity. There are five levels:
Ultra High: At least of care.
Very High: At least of care.
High: At least of care.
Medium: At least of care.
Low: At least of care.
The Uninsured and Financial Impact
Despite the Affordable Care Act (March 2010), approximately non-elderly individuals remained uninsured as of December 2016.
Lack of insurance leads to personal bankruptcies because patients are billed full charges.
Organizations often write off these unpaid amounts or provide charity and pro-bono care when patients lack resources.
Cost Control and Accounting
Cost accounting helps managers estimate and manage costs, set charges, analyze profits, and make decisions about adding or eliminating services.
Cost Classification:
By Behavior:
Fixed Costs: Remain constant regardless of patient volume (e.g., credit installments, liability insurance).
Variable Costs: Increase or decrease in relation to the number of patients treated.
By Traceability:
Direct Costs: Can be assigned completely to a product or service (e.g., therapist salaries).
Indirect Costs: Difficult to assign directly (e.g., front office manager salary).
Full Costing: The sum of both direct and indirect costs.
By Decision-Making Ability:
Controllable Costs: Expenses management can influence (e.g., limiting hiring to control wages).
Uncontrollable Costs: Determined by outside entities (e.g., taxes and fees).
Cost Allocation: Assigning costs from non-revenue-producing departments (e.g., Human Resources) to revenue-producing departments (e.g., Rehab) to ensure accurate fee setting and identify inefficiencies.
Activity-Based Costing (ABC): An accounting method that identifies activities performed and assigns indirect costs to services based on the relationship between activities and products.
Setting Charges and Prices
Charges: The published prices consumers see.
Prices: The money actually spent, including perceived value and opportunity costs.
A disparity often exists between published charges (e.g., for therapy) and contract prices with insurance (e.g., ).
Determinants of pricing include legal/regulatory issues, management goals, market supply/demand, competitor pricing, and third-party payer policies.
Break-even Point: The point where costs incurred equal the revenue received for a service.
Pricing Tactics:
Bundling/Packaging: Offering groups of services at a discount. Example: A package of for instead of per visit saves the client .
Managing Working Capital and Assets
Working Capital: Current assets minus current liabilities. Elements include:
Permanent Working Capital: The minimum amount maintained regardless of business fluctuations.
Temporary Working Capital: Includes net assets or liquid assets, short-term debt/loans, and trade credit from delayed vendor payments.
Purpose of Capital Management:
Increasing revenue and reducing expenses.
Making capital assets productive (e.g., buildings, equipment, land, information technology).
Conserving cash for short-term investments.
Managing daily/weekly cash flow (the life of the business).
Managing liquidity (the ability to trade assets like stocks or bonds at current price as quickly as possible).
Enhancing goodwill by paying employees and vendors on time.
Accounts Receivable (AR)
Definition: Current assets consisting of recognized revenue not yet collected as cash (e.g., a bill sent to Medicare that is awaiting reimbursement).
AR does not provide interest, and collection becomes less likely over time.
Associated Costs: Carrying costs, delinquency costs, and collection costs.
Financing Methods:
Factoring Receivables: Selling AR at a discount (e.g., selling in AR to a bank at to receive immediately).
Pledging Receivables: Using AR as collateral for a line of credit to cover cash flow shortfalls.
Materials and Inventory Management
Effective materials management provides cost control and ensures appropriate patient care.
Non-productive Assets: Equipment not in use or non-functional (e.g., a broken treadmill) that takes up space.
Inventory loses value over time (e.g., bulk TheraBand remaining unused).
Goal: Improve the bottom line by securing best pricing and reducing over-utilization.
Budgeting and Capital Expenditures
Budget: A plan for turning organizational objectives into programs for earning revenue and controlling expenditures.
Types of Budgets:
Operating Budget (Cash Budget): Annual forecast of cash inflows, outflows, and borrowing needs.
Expense Budget: Allocation of funds for normal monthly operations.
Revenue Budget: Forecast of sales revenues, expenses, and capital expenditures aimed at growth and maintenance (usually for or ).
Capital Budget: Planning for long-term assets with a useful life greater than .
Capital Budgeting Considerations:
Does the asset pay for itself? (Case study: Investing in an Ultra G Treadmill costing to requires enough patient visits to cover the cost).
Does the asset add value to the organization or patient recovery?
Items include: Land acquisition, construction, facility renovation, clinical equipment, IT upgrades, and staff/physician acquisitions.
Decision Rules for Capital Budgets:
Accept or reject proposals.
Capital Rationing: Selecting items with the highest profitability index.
Non-criteria Based (Safety Valve): Items purchased regardless of standard criteria, often for safety/urgency, requiring approval from the governing body and administration.