Comprehensive Notes on Managing Costs and Revenues in Healthcare

Financial Management in Healthcare Organizations

  • Financial management involves providing oversight for the day-to-day operations of an organization while planning its long-range financial direction. The primary goals are to increase revenues and decrease costs.

  • The major objectives of financial management in both outpatient and inpatient settings include:

    • Generating reasonable net income.

    • Setting appropriate prices for services.

    • Facilitating relationships with third-party payers, such as Medicare and private insurance companies.

    • Recording and analyzing cost information to ensure smooth facility operations.

    • Preparing, auditing, and disseminating financial reports in a timely manner.

    • Investing in long-term capital assets, which are categorized as investments held for longer than 36 months36 \, \text{months}.

    • Ensuring the generation of sufficient income to pay wages, salaries, and suppliers.

    • Providing adequate responses to government regulators, external auditors, and accrediting agencies like the Joint Commission.

    • Maintaining excellent control over the financial risks of the organization.

Tax Status and Organizational Attributes

  • For-Profit Organizations:

    • Owned by private owners or investors.

    • Organized as C Corporations, LLCs, S Corporations, or General Partnerships.

    • Goal: Maximize profits for owners and investors.

    • Tax Obligations: They pay state and federal taxes. However, certain states such as Nevada, Ohio, Texas, and Washington do not require for-profit organizations to pay corporate income tax; instead, they pay taxes on gross income at different rates.

    • Political Activity: They may participate in political campaigns but cannot donate directly to parties; they must contribute via Political Action Committees (PACs).

    • Community Role: They have a limited obligation to provide care for the indigent.

    • Capital: They can issue stock to raise capital (e.g., Apple Corporation).

  • Not-For-Profit Organizations:

    • Tax Status: They are tax-exempt if they meet IRS Section 501C3 requirements.

    • Categories: Includes charitable, educational, literary, religious, scientific, public safety, amateur sports promotion, and prevention of cruelty to children or animals.

    • Governance: Managed by a governing body or board of directors rather than individual owners.

    • Profit Requirement: They must still turn a profit to ensure continued existence and community service.

    • Political Activity: They are prohibited from participating in political campaigns or influencing legislation.

    • Community Role: They must provide funds for community benefit and indigent care.

    • Private foundations are another form of not-for-profit organization.

Financial Governance Roles

  • Financial governance refers to a set of rules and guidance to ensure financial processes are well-governed. Key parties include:

    • Governing Body (Board of Directors or Trustees): The highest level of oversight.

    • Chief Executive Officer (CEO): Leads the organization.

    • Chief Financial Officer (CFO): Manages financial risks and planning.

    • Controller: Found mostly in large organizations; handles high-level accounting, operating budgets, and dealings with regulators and tax authorities.

    • Treasurer: Responsible for financial planning, establishing budgets, and making corporate investments.

    • Internal Auditor: Provides objective evaluations of financial and operational activities and advises management on improving financial practices.

Reimbursement Methods

  • Healthcare organizations must manage reimbursements from various third-party payers using different methodologies.

  • Private Insurance Methods:

    • Retrospective: Charges are determined after services are delivered. This includes actual charges or charges minus a negotiated discount.

    • Cost Plus: An excess amount allowed over billed charges to provide for a profit.

    • Prospective: Reimbursement is determined before care is furnished. Types include:

      • Per Diem: A fixed payment per day of service (e.g., a hospital receives a set amount per patient day regardless of actual costs).

      • Per Diagnosis: Reimbursement based on the diagnosis and its severity; higher acuity diagnoses receive higher rates.

      • Capitation: A fixed amount paid per patient to cover a period (usually a month), regardless of the number of services provided.

  • Medicare and Medicaid (MediCal in California):

    • Contractual Allowances: The difference between what a hospital bills and what Medicare/Medicaid reimburses. For example, if a hospital bills $180\$180 but receives $150\$150, the hospital writes off the $30\$30 difference. The $150\$150 is the allowance.

    • Diagnosis-Related Groups (DRGs): A system focused on transparency and fairness, paying similar rates for similar care across different states (e.g., a kidney transplant in Florida vs. South Carolina).

    • Case Mix Index (CMI): Takes into account the average cost per patient and the CMI to adjust care costs. Formula example: If the average cost is $1,000\$1,000 and the CMI is 0.800.80, the adjusted cost is 1,0000.80=$1,250\frac{1,000}{0.80} = \$1,250.

  • Physician Reimbursement:

    • Resource-Based Relative Value Scale (RBRVS): Payments vary based on the resource cost of providing services, including physician work, practice expense/overhead, and professional liability insurance.

    • Medicare Part B: Providers (physicians, PTs, OTs, speech pathologists) are paid based on Current Procedural Terminology (CPT) codes. Each code has a specific assigned reimbursement rate.

    • Resource Utilization Groups (RUG Levels): Used for skilled nursing facilities (SNFs) based on patient acuity and complexity. There are five levels:

      • Ultra High: At least 700 minutes700 \, \text{minutes} of care.

      • Very High: At least 500 minutes500 \, \text{minutes} of care.

      • High: At least 350 minutes350 \, \text{minutes} of care.

      • Medium: At least 150 minutes150 \, \text{minutes} of care.

      • Low: At least 45 minutes45 \, \text{minutes} of care.

The Uninsured and Financial Impact

  • Despite the Affordable Care Act (March 2010), approximately 28.2 million28.2 \, \text{million} non-elderly individuals remained uninsured as of December 2016.

  • Lack of insurance leads to personal bankruptcies because patients are billed full charges.

  • Organizations often write off these unpaid amounts or provide charity and pro-bono care when patients lack resources.

Cost Control and Accounting

  • Cost accounting helps managers estimate and manage costs, set charges, analyze profits, and make decisions about adding or eliminating services.

  • Cost Classification:

    • By Behavior:

      • Fixed Costs: Remain constant regardless of patient volume (e.g., credit installments, liability insurance).

      • Variable Costs: Increase or decrease in relation to the number of patients treated.

    • By Traceability:

      • Direct Costs: Can be assigned completely to a product or service (e.g., therapist salaries).

      • Indirect Costs: Difficult to assign directly (e.g., front office manager salary).

      • Full Costing: The sum of both direct and indirect costs.

    • By Decision-Making Ability:

      • Controllable Costs: Expenses management can influence (e.g., limiting hiring to control wages).

      • Uncontrollable Costs: Determined by outside entities (e.g., taxes and fees).

  • Cost Allocation: Assigning costs from non-revenue-producing departments (e.g., Human Resources) to revenue-producing departments (e.g., Rehab) to ensure accurate fee setting and identify inefficiencies.

  • Activity-Based Costing (ABC): An accounting method that identifies activities performed and assigns indirect costs to services based on the relationship between activities and products.

Setting Charges and Prices

  • Charges: The published prices consumers see.

  • Prices: The money actually spent, including perceived value and opportunity costs.

  • A disparity often exists between published charges (e.g., $120\$120 for therapy) and contract prices with insurance (e.g., $75\$75).

  • Determinants of pricing include legal/regulatory issues, management goals, market supply/demand, competitor pricing, and third-party payer policies.

  • Break-even Point: The point where costs incurred equal the revenue received for a service.

  • Pricing Tactics:

    • Bundling/Packaging: Offering groups of services at a discount. Example: A package of 12 visits12 \, \text{visits} for $1,000\$1,000 instead of $100\$100 per visit saves the client $200\$200.

Managing Working Capital and Assets

  • Working Capital: Current assets minus current liabilities. Elements include:

    • Permanent Working Capital: The minimum amount maintained regardless of business fluctuations.

    • Temporary Working Capital: Includes net assets or liquid assets, short-term debt/loans, and trade credit from delayed vendor payments.

  • Purpose of Capital Management:

    • Increasing revenue and reducing expenses.

    • Making capital assets productive (e.g., buildings, equipment, land, information technology).

    • Conserving cash for short-term investments.

    • Managing daily/weekly cash flow (the life of the business).

    • Managing liquidity (the ability to trade assets like stocks or bonds at current price as quickly as possible).

    • Enhancing goodwill by paying employees and vendors on time.

Accounts Receivable (AR)

  • Definition: Current assets consisting of recognized revenue not yet collected as cash (e.g., a $30,000\$30,000 bill sent to Medicare that is awaiting reimbursement).

  • AR does not provide interest, and collection becomes less likely over time.

  • Associated Costs: Carrying costs, delinquency costs, and collection costs.

  • Financing Methods:

    • Factoring Receivables: Selling AR at a discount (e.g., selling $30,000\$30,000 in AR to a bank at 80 cents per dollar80 \, \text{cents per dollar} to receive $24,000\$24,000 immediately).

    • Pledging Receivables: Using AR as collateral for a line of credit to cover cash flow shortfalls.

Materials and Inventory Management

  • Effective materials management provides cost control and ensures appropriate patient care.

  • Non-productive Assets: Equipment not in use or non-functional (e.g., a broken treadmill) that takes up space.

  • Inventory loses value over time (e.g., bulk TheraBand remaining unused).

  • Goal: Improve the bottom line by securing best pricing and reducing over-utilization.

Budgeting and Capital Expenditures

  • Budget: A plan for turning organizational objectives into programs for earning revenue and controlling expenditures.

  • Types of Budgets:

    • Operating Budget (Cash Budget): Annual forecast of cash inflows, outflows, and borrowing needs.

    • Expense Budget: Allocation of funds for normal monthly operations.

    • Revenue Budget: Forecast of sales revenues, expenses, and capital expenditures aimed at growth and maintenance (usually for 6 months6 \, \text{months} or 1 year1 \, \text{year}).

    • Capital Budget: Planning for long-term assets with a useful life greater than 1 year1 \, \text{year}.

  • Capital Budgeting Considerations:

    • Does the asset pay for itself? (Case study: Investing in an Ultra G Treadmill costing $40,000\$40,000 to $50,000\$50,000 requires enough patient visits to cover the cost).

    • Does the asset add value to the organization or patient recovery?

    • Items include: Land acquisition, construction, facility renovation, clinical equipment, IT upgrades, and staff/physician acquisitions.

  • Decision Rules for Capital Budgets:

    • Accept or reject proposals.

    • Capital Rationing: Selecting items with the highest profitability index.

    • Non-criteria Based (Safety Valve): Items purchased regardless of standard criteria, often for safety/urgency, requiring approval from the governing body and administration.