Organising: Concepts, Structures, and Delegation Summary
Case Study: Wipro Technologies Restructuring
- Project Objective: Wipro Technologies, led by Premji, restructured to improve customer orientation and compete globally with IBM and Accenture.
- Restructuring Actions: Separated into subsidiaries by product line (telecommunications, engineering, financial services, etc.) earning approximately 300million in annual earnings each.
- Management Shift: Moved from a centralised to a decentralised system; removed an entire layer of executive management to empower business leaders.
Concept and Process of Organising
- Definition: Organising is a process that initiates implementation of plans by clarifying jobs and relationships.
- Louis Allen: The process of identifying and grouping work, defining and delegating responsibility, and establishing relationships.
- Theo Haimman: The process of defining Enterprise activities and establishing authority relationships.
- Four-Step Process:
- Identification and Division of Work: Dividing work into manageable activities to avoid duplication.
- Departmentalisation: Grouping similar activities by criteria such as territory (North, South) or products (Cosmetics, Appliances).
- Assignment of Duties: Allocating jobs to members based on skills and competencies.
- Establishing Authority and Reporting Relationships: Creating a hierarchy where every individual knows who to take orders from and to whom they are accountable.
Importance of Organising
- Specialisation: Repetitive performance of specific tasks enhances productivity.
- Clarity in Relationships: Clarifies lines of communication and specifies responsibility.
- Optimum Utilisation of Resources: Avoids duplication and minimises wastage of material, financial, and human resources.
- Adaptation to Change: Allows structures to be modified to accommodate dynamic environmental shifts.
- Effective Administration: Provides clear job descriptions to avoid confusion.
- Development of Personnel: Delegation allows managers to innovate; strengthens subordinates' potential.
- Expansion and Growth: Enables diversification into new product lines and geographical territories.
Organisational Structures
- Span of Management: The number of subordinates that can be effectively managed by a superior; determines management levels.
- Functional Structure:
- Basis: Jobs grouped by functions (e.g., Production, Marketing, Purchasing).
- Advantages: Occupational specialisation, better control, and easier training.
- Disadvantages: Functional empires (ignoring overall goals), coordination problems, and inter-departmental conflicts.
- Divisional Structure:
- Basis: Jobs grouped by product lines (e.g., Cosmetics, Garments, Footwear).
- Advantages: Product specialisation, accountability for profits, and easier expansion.
- Disadvantages: Inter-divisional fund conflicts and increased costs due to duplication of functions.
- Formal Organisation: Designed by management for goal achievement; defined by rules, procedures, and a clear scalar chain.
- Pros: Fixed responsibility and stability.
- Cons: Procedural delays and limited recognition of creativity.
- Informal Organisation: A network of social relationships arising spontaneously (Keith Davis).
- Pros: Fast information spread and fulfillment of social needs.
- Cons: Potential for rumors and resistance to management changes.
Delegation and Decentralisation
- Delegation: The downward transfer of authority (Louis Allen).
- Authority: Right to command; flows downward.
- Responsibility: Obligation to perform duty; flows upward.
- Accountability: Answerability for outcome; cannot be delegated; flows upward.
- Decentralisation: Delegation of authority throughout all levels of the organisation.
- Centralisation: Retaining decision-making at the top.
- Importance: Develops initiative, enables quick decisions, and provides relief to top management.
Case Studies: ONGC and Johnson & Johnson
- ONGC: Transitioned in the 1990s from functional groups to an "asset-based" structure recommended by McKinsey to resolve organisational atrophy and delays.
- McNeil Consumer Healthcare (Johnson & Johnson): Uses decentralized management, operating as 190 smaller companies to maintain agility found in small firms.
- History: Robert McNeil opened a drug outlet in 1879; incorporated in 1933; joined Johnson & Johnson in 1959.
Questions & Discussion
- Think About It: Managers must address potential monotony and absenteeism resulting from repetitive tasks in specialised work.
- Exercises: Neha's shoe factory expanding to leather bags is advised to adopt a divisional structure to manage diverse product lines.
- Case Analysis: A toy company diversifying into electronic toys should adopt a divisional structure to allow for product-specific expertise.
- Management Dilemmas: In a scenario where a foreman is given a target of 200 units per day without the authority to requisition materials, the manager cannot blame the foreman for failure because authority must match responsibility.