W1L2: Observing, Recording, and Graphing Behavior in Behavior Modification

Review of Behavioral Principles

During the second class session, a review was conducted regarding the definition of behavior and behavior modification from Chapter 11.

Definition of Behavior

  • Behavior is something a person does or says.

  • It is observable, quantifiable, and lawful.

  • It has an effect on the environment.

  • It is not a label.

Behavior Modification Behavior modification is the study of psychology utilizing different strategies based on behavioral principles to modify specific behaviors.

Types of Behavior

  • Overt Behavior: Behaviors that are observable by others. The majority of behaviors addressed in behavior modification are overt.

  • Covert Behavior: Internal behaviors that others cannot see, such as internal counting, prayer (often associated with OCD), or thoughts.

Dimensions of Behavior There are 44 dimensions of behavior that are observed and quantified:

  1. Frequency: The number of occurrences of a behavior.

  2. Duration: The time elapsed from the beginning to the end of a behavior's occurrence.

  3. Latency: The time between a specific stimulus event and the occurrence of the target behavior (e.g., the time between a parent's request and the child picking up a toy).

  4. Intensity: The magnitude of the behavior. This can be measured numerically (e.g., amount of weight used) or through a created Likert scale (e.g., a scale from 00 to 55 or 00 to 1010).

Behavioral Observation Exercise: Tail Wagging

To test knowledge of behavior definition and frequency, the instructor utilized a video of dog tail-wagging behavior. Students were asked to count the occurrences of tail wags to determine if they could achieve an identical count for an "A plus" grade.

Results of the Exercise

  • On the count of 33, students provided their results, revealing that they did not arrive at the same count.

  • Interference Factors:

    • Definitions: There was no clear, complete, or concrete definition of what constitutes a single "tail wag." Questions arose regarding whether one "back and forth" motion counted as one wag or two, and how to account for dogs with no tails or wiggling backs.

    • Technical Issues: Video lagging affected the accuracy of the observation and recording.

Purpose and Foundation of Behavioral Assessment

Behavioral observation and recording are foundational components of behavior modification. Unlike other clinical psychology approaches (like Freudian inference), behavior modification strictly adheres to the scientific method and is data-driven, focusing on observable dimensions of behavior.

Importance of Behavioral Assessment

  1. Identifying Need for Treatment: Assessment determines if a behavioral excess or deficit actually exists. The instructor noted a case where a parent requested treatment for a child's "tantrums" that were actually developmentally appropriate. Another example involved a company that suspected employees were regularly late, but data showed lateness happened infrequently, negating the need for an intervention.

  2. Guiding Treatment: Observation helps identify antecedents (events preceding behavior) and consequences (events following behavior). For example, if a child is disruptive to get teacher attention, the treatment might involve the teacher providing attention only when the child is quiet.

  3. Measuring Treatment Effects: Baseline assessments are taken before treatment, and behavior is measured throughout different phases—as well as months or years later—to determine long-term effectiveness.

  4. Measurement as Treatment Component (Reactivity): In some cases, recording behavior creates change, a phenomenon often used in health-tracking apps. For instance, recording food intake can cause eating behaviors to shift automatically.

Types of Behavioral Assessment

There are 22 broad categories of behavioral assessment:

Indirect Assessment

  • Does not involve direct observation of the behavior.

  • Methods include interviews, questionnaires, and rating scales.

  • Rely on retrospective accounts from the client or collateral informants (parents, teachers, etc.).

  • Helpful for narrowing down when and where to conduct direct observations (e.g., a student who bites their nails only at home watching TV).

Direct Assessment

  • Involves the direct observation and recording of the target behavior as it occurs.

  • Requires the observer to be in close proximity or for the behavior to be video-recorded for later review.

  • Can include by proxy assessment, such as counting remaining cigarettes in a pack as a proxy for how many were smoked.

III. Recording Behavior

1. Operational Definitions Developing an operational definition is the first and most critical step in recording behavior. Common mistakes include using labels instead of clear, concrete descriptors of what people say and do.

  • Rule of Thumb: A definition should be specific enough that two independent people can agree on whether the behavior occurred.

  • Examples of Poor Definitions:

    • "Losing my temper" (defined as "getting mad") is a label involving internal motivation and inference rather than observable action.

    • "Overeating" (defined as "feeling bloated" or "belt too tight") is an internal sensation, not an observable behavior.

2. Who Records

  • Independent Observer: A professional, parent, or teacher trained to identify and record the behavior immediately.

  • Self-Monitoring: Used when behavior occurs infrequently, in secret (e.g., binge-purge behavior), or for self-management purposes.

When and Where to Record

  • Observation Period: The specific timeframe identified for recording. This should occur when the behavior is most likely to happen (e.g., observing social interactions during recess rather than during a lecture).

  • Settings:

    • Natural Setting: Where the behavior occurs in real life (home, school).

    • Contrived Setting: A laboratory or office environment.

  • Structure:

    • Structured: The observer provides a prompt or arranges an event (e.g., asking a family to discuss a "hot button" issue).

    • Unstructured: The observer provides no direction and simply watches the interactions.

Direct Observation Recording Methods

Continuous Recording

  • Remember frequency, duration, intensity, and latency

  • The observer records every instance of behavior during the entire period.

Real-time recording

  • Captures the exact onset and offset of each instance. Real-time recording allows for both frequency and duration data.

Product Recording (Permanent Product)

  • Involves measuring a tangible outcome (e.g., counting empty cigarette packs or completed homework assignments).

  • Advantage: The observer does not need to be present.

  • Disadvantage: You cannot be certain who engaged in the behavior that produced the product.

Interval Recording

  • The observation period is divided into consecutive time intervals.

  • Partial Interval Recording: Record if the behavior occurred at any point during the interval.

  • Whole Interval Recording: Record only if the behavior occurred throughout the entire duration of the interval.

Time Sample Recording

  • The observation period is divided into intervals, but behavior is recorded during only part of the interval (e.g., only the last 3030 seconds of each 2020-minute block).

Recording Instruments

  • Historically included stopwatches, PDAs (Personal Data Assistants), and clipboards.

  • Modern recording is predominantly done via smartphones due to their practicality and the importance of immediate, accurate recording.

  • Recording must be IMMEDIATE and PRACTICAL

Reactivity and Interobserver Reliability (IOR)

Reactivity Reactivity (or the Hawthorne Effect) occurs when people change their behavior because they know they are being observed. Methods to manage reactivity include:

  • Lengthening the observation period until behavior stabilizes to its true form.. Wait until the person being observed becomes accustomed to the observer or to self-monitoring

  • Recording surreptitiously, using one-way mirrors, video cameras, or participant observers.

Interobserver Reliability (IOR) Consistency between two or more independent observers.

  • Calculations:

    • For Frequency/Duration: Smaller NumberLarger Number×100\frac{\text{Smaller Number}}{\text{Larger Number}} \times 100

    • For Interval Recording: Total AgreementsTotal Intervals×100\frac{\text{Total Agreements}}{\text{Total Intervals}} \times 100

  • Research studies typically require at least 80%80\% agreement to validate an observer.

Graphing Behavior and Research Designs

Components of a Graph

  • Y-axis (Ordinate): Represents the dimension of the behavior (frequency, duration, etc.).

  • X-axis (Abscissa): Represents time (days or sessions).

  • Labels: Axes must be clearly labeled.

  • Data Points: Represent the measured values.

  • Phase Lines: Vertical lines indicating a change in condition (e.g., moving from baseline to treatment).

  • Phase Labels: Identified as A (Baseline) and B (Treatment).

Research Designs

  1. AB Design: One baseline phase and one treatment phase. It is simple but cannot demonstrate a functional relationship (causation) because it does not rule out extraneous variables.

  2. ABAB Reversal Design: Baseline and treatment phases are implemented twice. This can demonstrate a functional relationship. Considerations include whether it is ethical to withdraw treatment (e.g., dangerous behaviors) or if the behavior will actually reverse (e.g., education/knowledge cannot be "unlearned").

  3. Multiple Baseline Designs: Treatment is replicated across different baselines without withdrawal.

    • Across Subjects: Same behavior/setting, different people.

    • Across Behaviors: Same subject/setting, different behaviors.

    • Across Settings: Same subject/behavior, different settings.

  4. Alternating Treatment Design: Rapidly switching between baseline and treatment (or two different treatments) to compare effects quickly.

  5. Changing Criterion Design: Sequential performance criteria are set within the treatment phase. If the subject hits the increasing (or decreasing) goals, a functional relationship is established.

Questions & Discussion: Course Logistics and Exams

Questions from Students & Audience

Q: How do you decide which dimension (frequency, duration, etc.) to measure?A: It is tied to the client's goals. If the goal is for a child to stay in their seat, it is likely frequency. If it is about how long someone studies, it is duration. There is no single right answer.

Q: Are there practice questions available?A: Yes, weekly practice questions are due every Friday by 11:59 PM11:59\,PM Pacific Time. These are for points (participation) rather than accuracy and help with self-quizzing for the exams.