Psyc232 Lecture 4: sampling and sampling biases

Overview of Sampling Biases and Studies

Introduction to Sampling and Bias

  • Sampling refers to the process of selecting individuals from a larger population to represent the entire group.

  • Survivorship bias is essential to consider, as it biases the conclusions by only focusing on subjects that survived a selection process.

  • Abraham Wald: A key figure in statistical reasoning who identified the flaws in armor placement on WWII planes based on bullet hole patterns.

Context of the Example (World War II)

  • Historical instance where planes returned with visible bullet holes (survivors) led to incorrect conclusions about armor placement.

  • Wald emphasized that armor should be placed where there were no bullet holes since those planes did not survive.

  • Demonstrated a critical understanding of survivorship bias.

Importance of Sampling in Research

  • Sampling is a significant part of research, as it affects the validity of the study.

  • Improper sampling can ruin an entire research study or lead to the saving of resources through effective design.

  • Expected you will spend 80% of your future work on sampling-related tasks.

Types of Sampling Techniques

1. Probability Sampling
  • Also known as random sampling, where each member of the population has an equal chance of being selected.

  • Example: Jury selection in New Zealand based on the electoral roll.

  • Defined as: "Everyone in a population is available and has an equal chance of being selected."

2. Stratified Sampling
  • Population is divided into distinct subgroups, and random samples are taken from each.

  • Example: Electoral polling, where groups such as urban vs. rural voters are represented.

  • This reduces bias associated with demographic representation.

3. Purposive Sampling (Targeted Sampling)
  • Researchers deliberately choose specific individuals based on characteristics pertinent to the study.

  • Example: A patient with retrograde amnesia chosen for a specific psychological study based on their condition.

4. Convenience Sampling
  • Utilizes individuals who are easily accessible or involved, rather than randomly selected.

  • A less scientific approach but commonly used in practical studies due to ease.

Examples of Research Studies

Study Example: Life Is Pretty Meaningful
  • Aim: To determine the perceived meaning of life across cultures.

  • The potential sampling methods discussed included probability, stratified, purposive, and convenience.

  • The conclusion was that convenience sampling may be the best method if the aim is to measure a broad societal phenomenon without geographical barriers.

Another Study: Mataranga Maori in Primary Schools
  • The targeted sampling method was used to interview principals who successfully incorporated Mataranga Maori.

  • Researchers knew beforehand about the schools' practices related to Mataranga Maori, emphasizing purposive sampling.

Study Example: Vaping Research
  • Target population: Adults in New Zealand with an initial sampling method based on the electoral roll.

  • Identified as probability sampling since it randomly selects participants.

Key Issues in Sampling

  • Survivorship Bias: Focuses on outcomes based on those who participated and can lead researchers to draw biased conclusions about the entire population.

  • Generalizability: How well can findings be applied to a broader context? This is often a limitation in convenience sampling.

  • W.E.I.R.D Phenomenon (Western, Educated, Industrialized, Rich, Democratic): Dominates psychological research sources, creating an unbalanced representation of global populations.

Visualizing and Analyzing Data

  • Emphasis on normal distribution: Understanding how the data appears can help identify biases.

  • Examined sexiness ratings from speed dates with a general bias showing people tend to rate others more generously than themselves.

  • Negative and Positive Skew: Classification of distributions based on extremities in data ratings.

Sampling Interpretation
  • Normal Distribution: Ideally, would work with over 30 participants in psychology research to capture broader trends.

  • Deviations from normal distributions can highlight various biases present in the sample, questioning the legitimacy of conclusions drawn.

Takeaways and Implications

  • Consider a balance in sampling strategies: Define the research goal against budget constraints.

  • Recognize that perfect sampling is impractical—successful studies can be achieved even with limited sample sizes.

  • Ultimately, reflection on participant representation is vital to ensure insights and conclusions reflect reality and account for broader perspectives.