Institutional Powers and Individual Rights
Institutional Powers
Powers granted to institutions like police and courts for effective crime prevention, investigation, and prosecution.
Police Powers
Allow police to prevent, investigate, and prosecute crimes.
Examples: Asking for name/address, searching (with/without warrant), entering property (with/without warrant), arrest, reasonable force, breath/drug tests, questioning, fingerprinting, photographing, custody, deciding charges, police cautions.
Courts' Powers
Resolve disputes fairly.
Examples: Granting/denying bail, determining admissible evidence (e.g., hearsay), determining guilt, imposing sanctions.
Individual Rights
Protect individuals against institutional power, assisting justice.
Rights When Dealing with the Police
Remain silent, be informed of arrest reasons, make two phone calls, access interpreter, inform Victorian Aboriginal Legal Service (if applicable), make complaints.
Rights for Under 18s
Searches: Specific rules for graffiti, chroming, strip searches (parent/guardian presence).
Interviews/Statements: Parent/guardian or independent person present.
Fingerprinting: Restrictions based on age.
Rights During Court Proceedings
Address power imbalances.
Tried without unreasonable delay, remain silent, trial by impartial judge/jury (indictable offenses), apply for bail, legal advice, legal representation, know evidence, present case, cross-examine witnesses.
Balance
Powers and rights must balance to protect against abuse while ensuring justice.
Examples: Questioning vs. silence, arrest vs. lawyer, custody vs. translator, court decisions vs. presenting case, evidence rules vs. legal representation.
Changing Powers
Old: Fining for public intoxication.
New: Health-based response; no arrest for public intoxication.
Principles of Justice
Fairness through powers and rights.
Strengths and Limitations
Right to silence (presumption of innocence).
Timely trials (court backlogs).
Stop and search (warrant or specific circumstances).
Impartiality (unconscious biases).
Services (translators).
Legal representation (accessibility issues).