Institutional Powers and Individual Rights

Institutional Powers
  • Powers granted to institutions like police and courts for effective crime prevention, investigation, and prosecution.

Police Powers

  • Allow police to prevent, investigate, and prosecute crimes.

  • Examples: Asking for name/address, searching (with/without warrant), entering property (with/without warrant), arrest, reasonable force, breath/drug tests, questioning, fingerprinting, photographing, custody, deciding charges, police cautions.

Courts' Powers

  • Resolve disputes fairly.

  • Examples: Granting/denying bail, determining admissible evidence (e.g., hearsay), determining guilt, imposing sanctions.

Individual Rights
  • Protect individuals against institutional power, assisting justice.

Rights When Dealing with the Police

  • Remain silent, be informed of arrest reasons, make two phone calls, access interpreter, inform Victorian Aboriginal Legal Service (if applicable), make complaints.

Rights for Under 18s

  • Searches: Specific rules for graffiti, chroming, strip searches (parent/guardian presence).

  • Interviews/Statements: Parent/guardian or independent person present.

  • Fingerprinting: Restrictions based on age.

Rights During Court Proceedings

  • Address power imbalances.

  • Tried without unreasonable delay, remain silent, trial by impartial judge/jury (indictable offenses), apply for bail, legal advice, legal representation, know evidence, present case, cross-examine witnesses.

Balance
  • Powers and rights must balance to protect against abuse while ensuring justice.

  • Examples: Questioning vs. silence, arrest vs. lawyer, custody vs. translator, court decisions vs. presenting case, evidence rules vs. legal representation.

Changing Powers

  • Old: Fining for public intoxication.

  • New: Health-based response; no arrest for public intoxication.

Principles of Justice
  • Fairness through powers and rights.

Strengths and Limitations

  • Right to silence (presumption of innocence).

  • Timely trials (court backlogs).

  • Stop and search (warrant or specific circumstances).

  • Impartiality (unconscious biases).

  • Services (translators).

  • Legal representation (accessibility issues).