Impeachment of President Andrew Johnson

President Andrew Johnson's Impeachment

Introduction

  • President Andrew Johnson assumed office after Abraham Lincoln's assassination.
  • He clashed with Congress early in his presidency over the direction of Reconstruction.
  • Both the executive and legislative branches sought control, leading to political gridlock.
  • Republicans gained a two-thirds majority in Congress in the 1866 elections, giving them the power to override presidential vetoes and pass legislation.

Tenure of Office Act

  • Congress, frustrated with Johnson's actions, passed the Tenure of Office Act.
  • The act restricted the president's power to remove cabinet members without Senate approval.
  • President Johnson defied the act by firing Secretary of War Edwin Stanton to challenge Congress's authority.

Impeachment by the House of Representatives

  • In early 1868, the House of Representatives voted 126 to 47 to impeach President Johnson.
  • This was the first instance of the impeachment process being carried out as outlined in the Constitution.
  • Impeachment is the formal process of charging a government official with misconduct.
  • Article II, Section 4 of the Constitution allows for the removal of the president for "treason, bribery, or other high crimes and misdemeanors."
  • Congress believed Johnson violated the Tenure of Office Act and thus committed an impeachable offense.

The Senate Trial

  • The Senate trial became a major public event, with tickets issued for attendance.
  • The House of Representatives presented the case against President Johnson.
  • The Senate was required to have a two-thirds majority to convict and remove the president.
  • The Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, Salmon P. Chase, presided over the trial.
  • President Johnson was permitted to present evidence in his defense.

Republican Expectations and Doubts

  • Republicans initially expected a straightforward conviction due to their majority in Congress.
  • However, some Republican senators had reservations about the fairness of the proceedings.
  • Concerns arose about Johnson's potential successor, Benjamin Wade, the President pro tempore of the Senate.
  • Some senators believed that interfering with the president's cabinet appointments disrupted the balance of power.

The Vote and Acquittal

  • The trial reached a critical point in early May 1868.
  • Senator Edmund Ross of Kansas played a pivotal role, remaining noncommittal throughout the trial.
  • Ross voted not guilty, resulting in President Johnson's acquittal.

Aftermath and Significance

  • President Johnson remained in office but became a "lame duck," lacking the power to advance his agenda.
  • He ceased fighting the Republican Congress over Reconstruction.
  • The impeachment process demonstrated the system of checks and balances within the government.
  • A new president was elected in the fall of 1868.

Historical Context

  • Only two other presidents, Richard Nixon and Bill Clinton, have been impeached.
  • Richard Nixon resigned, while Bill Clinton was acquitted.
  • Johnson was charged for trying to appeal directly to the people during the eighteen sixty six elections
  • President Johnson replaced Secretary of War Edwin Stanton with Adjutant General Lorenzo Thomas on 02/21/1868. When Congress was informed of this, it took the House of Representatives three days to impeach Johnson for high crimes and misdemeanors, when in all actuality Congress had no case at all.
  • Stanton had been appointed by former President Lincoln, and the Tenure of Office Act allegedly had no authority over past appointments.

Conclusion

  • The impeachment of Andrew Johnson highlights a critical period in American history.
  • It showcases the tensions between the executive and legislative branches during Reconstruction.
  • The outcome affirmed the importance of due process and the balance of powers within the government.