Edwin Porter and Early Cinema Analysis

Course Schedule and Assignment Overview

  • Three dedicated class sessions focus on the work of filmmaker Edwin Porter, incorporating inspiration from George Bellet.
  • An in-class film analysis assignment is scheduled for next Thursday.
  • The assignment centers on an unseen film directed by Edwin Porter with an approximate runtime of 12 to 15 minutes.
  • The assignment structure involves playing the film, pausing at select moments, and asking specific questions regarding the sequence just viewed to work through the material step-by-step.
  • Film length during this period increases rapidly compared to earlier cinema.

Biography and Professional Context of Edwin Porter

  • For a comprehensive biographical account, Charlie Busser authored a book on Porter titled Before the Nickelodeon.
  • Dedicated careers in filmmaking did not exist during this early era; individuals built careers in other fields prior to entering film production.
  • Edwin Porter worked professionally as an electrician before being hired by Thomas Edison's laboratory based on his technical skills.

Mass Amusement Venues and Wax Museums

  • Porter was employed at the even Musee (also referred to as Abeon Museum), located in Manhattan, New York City, which had its name painted on its roof tiles.
  • The venue operated as a late nineteenth-century mass amusement parlor that originally opened and functioned predominantly as a wax museum.
  • Wax museums were widely attended, popular nineteenth-century commercial attractions that charged entry in quarters.
  • These establishments routinely featured wax statues of prominent historical figures as well as a dedicated "Chamber of Horrors" showcasing gruesome displays.
  • A specific modern exhibit example from the Wax Museum of Mexico City includes a display of Jeffrey Dahmer, the Milwaukee cannibal who has been the subject of multiple television shows, videos, and movies. The display depicts Dahmer in his kitchen with an open refrigerator door and cut-up body parts on his table.

Technical Evolution and Visual Effects in Early Cinema

  • Films from this historical era represent the point at which cinematic techniques begin to look recognizable and familiar to modern audiences.
  • Although early films contain aspects that are indecipherable without external documentation, the underlying visual trick concepts remain fundamental to contemporary filmmaking.
  • A core visual technique of this era was the slice edit, which allowed filmmakers to perform seamless substitutions on camera.

Film Analyses

  • An Artist's Dream: Demonstrates exceptionally smooth slice-editing techniques, though the narrative action can be challenging to interpret without context.
  • Another Job for the Undertaker: Released in 1901 (the year following An Artist's Dream), this film utilizes numerous magic special effects. Even with the clues provided by its title, deciphering the character roles and narrative logic requires careful analysis of who the characters are and how their identities are established.

Questions & Discussion

  • Audience Observation: A comparison was raised noting that character disappearances and appearances in early film tricks resemble satchel work or teleportation where individuals disappear and reappear without communicating with anyone.
  • Explanation: These visual illusions were highly achievable using slice edits (splice edits) to slice the film stock and seamlessly cut between action frames.