9c. Design for Milling Notes

Manufacturing 3 - Design for Milling (MEE3014)

Contact Information

  • Dr. Arfauz A Rahman
    • Email: arfauz.arahman@qub.ac.uk
    • Ashby Room 6.18
  • Prof. Yan Jin (Coordinator)
    • Email: y.jin@qub.ac.uk
    • Ashby Room 5.18

Learning Outcomes

Part A: Design for Machining (DFM) and Drilling
  • Basics of machining.
  • Drilling operations.
  • Drilling machines and bits.
  • Design rules for drilling.
Part B: Design for Turning
  • Turning operations.
  • Turning machines and bits.
  • Design rules for turning.
Part C: Design for Milling
  • Milling operations.
  • Milling machines and bits.
  • Design rules for milling.

Design for Machining (DFM): Milling Introduction

  • Introduction to milling tools, processes, and design rules.

What is Milling?

  • Milling is a versatile basic machining process.
  • Milling setup has many degrees of freedom.
  • Milling is typically less accurate than turning or grinding.
  • Milling is essential for fabricating non-axially symmetric objects.
  • A wide range of different milling machines exists, from manual light-duty Bridgeports to huge CNC machines for parts of hundreds of feet long.

Milling: Column-and-Knee Manual Mill

  • Column-and-knee manual mills are common in job shops.
    • These shops specialize in parts and offer low-volume, quickly fabricated components.
  • Parts of the manual mill:
    • The knee moves up and down along guideways in the column.
    • The table can move in x and y on the knee.
    • The milling head can move up and down.

Milling: End Mill

  • Milling tools are highly diverse.
  • An "end mill" is a common type of milling cutter.
    • Used for cutting horizontal and vertical surfaces.

Milling: Arbor Cutters

  • Illustrates two types of solid milling arbor cutters.
  • Illustrates the detailed nomenclature for a solid milling arbor cutter.

Milling: Cutter Collets

  • The collet of a mill is critical for holding the workpiece and easily releasing it.
  • Shows three types of collets and a cut-away of a collet.

Milling: Collet Fixturing

  • Illustrates the configuration of a standard end mill fixtured in a knee-type milling machine using a collet.
  • A collet can also be fixtured horizontally.
    • This configuration allows materials to be cut at specified angles on a cylindrical part.

Milling: Special Cutter Fixturing (1) - Boring Bar Milling Fixture

  • Illustrates the boring head for fixturing a boring bar tool on a mill.
  • Boring a hole using a mill is usually not as accurate as it is on a lathe due to the lathe being dedicated to machining solids of revolution.

Milling: Special Cutter Fixturing (2) - Fly Cutter Fixture

  • Illustrates the fixturing for a fly cutter.
  • Fly cutters are used to rapidly mill a surface flat.
  • Metal stock often has fly cut marks after being milled to shape.

Milling: Special Cutter Fixturing (3) - Slitting Saw Fixture

  • For milling deep & narrow grooves, a slitting saw is better than an endmill.
  • A slitting saw with an angle head is illustrated here.
  • An endmill would be dangerously long and thin for this application.

Milling: Table Clamping Fixture

  • Mill vises are commonly used to fixture rectangular workpieces on a mill table.
  • For more flexible fixturing of work pieces, step clamps can be used.
  • The T-shaped pieces fit into corresponding female grooves in the mill table.
    • The stepped blocks mate together.
    • Height adjustments are possible depending upon which steps are used.

Milling: Rotational Indexers

  • A dividing head is used to rotate a turned workpiece by a specified amount.
    • So that hole patterns and other axially symmetric patterns can be milled.
  • A rotary table mounted on a mill table.
  • Rotary tables are similar to dividing heads with the axis oriented vertically.
    • But rotation is continuous rather than in discrete increments.

Design Rules for Milling (1)

  • Design milled areas so that the end mill required is limited to a 3:1 length-to-diameter ratio.
    • Longer end mills are prone to chatter.
  • If long end mills cannot be avoided, clearances can be implemented.

Design Rules for Milling (2)

  • When designing a three-edge inside corner, one of the inside edges must have the radius of the end mill.
  • A separate hole can serve to allow relief for a male ninety-degree corner to fit.
    • The hole must be drilled first since drills cannot withstand significant side loading.

Design Rules for Milling (3)

  • Standard tool bit sizes should be used whenever possible.
  • Where possible, allow inside radii to be determined by the fabrication personnel.
    • This allows for flexibility to use tools that are easily obtained and maintained.
  • For machined surfaces with a high degree of flatness, bosses should be used.
    • This clearly defines what areas need to be flatness controlled.
    • Simplifies painting and other finishing operations.

Design Rules for Milling (4)

  • For outside corners, chamfers are preferable over radii.
    • An outside radius requires a form-relieved cutter and a precise setup.
    • Both are expensive.

CNC Milling

  • CNC mills can perform the functions of drilling and often turning.
  • CNC Mills are classified according to the number of “axes” that they possess.
    • Axes are labeled as x and y for horizontal movement, and z for vertical movement.
  • A standard manual light-duty mill is typically assumed to have four axes:
    • Table x
    • Table y
    • Table z
    • Milling Head z

CNC Milling (cont.)

  • The number of axes of a milling machine is a common subject of casual "shop talk" and is often interpreted in varying ways.
  • A five-axis CNC milling machine has an extra axis in the form of a horizontal pivot for the milling head.
    • Allows extra flexibility for machining with the end mill at an angle with respect to the table.
  • A six-axis CNC milling machine has another horizontal pivot for the milling head.
    • Perpendicular to the fifth axis.
  • CNC milling machines are programmed using a set of commands known as “G-codes”.
    • G-codes represent specific CNC functions in alphanumeric format.

References

  • efunda (2017) Machining [Online] Available: http://www.efunda.com/processes/machining/machin_intro.cfm
  • Boothroyd, G., Dewhurst, P., & Winston, A. (2010). Product Design for Manufacture and Assembly (3rd ed.). CRC Press. Taylor & Francis Group.

Contact Details

  • DR ARFAUZ A RAHMAN
  • Room 06.018, Ashby Building
  • Stranmillis Road Belfast Northern Ireland BT9 5AH
  • Tel: +44 (0) 28 9097 5495
  • Email: arfauz.arahman@qub.ac.uk