Homer I Notes

Introduction to Homer and the Iliad

The author reflects on returning to Columbia University and revisiting the classic texts of the Lit Hum and C.C. courses. He expresses a sense of excitement at the prospect of engaging with these challenging works.

Achilles: The First Great Hero?

The central question is posed: Can Achilles be considered the first great hero of Western literature? He is portrayed as a complex figure, characterized by rage (menin), a quality associated with divine fury in ancient Greece. However, to modern readers, Achilles' anger may seem more like vanity and egotism, stemming from the loss of his war booty.

Despite his flaws, Achilles dominates the Iliad through his self-preoccupation and aura of specialness, reminiscent of Marlon Brando's sullen performances. His anger fuels a destiny greater than the desires of ordinary men.

Achilles is described as young, fearless, strong, and acutely aware of his own importance. His sulking leads to dire consequences for the Greeks, as the Trojans, led by Hector, gain the upper hand. Achilles' beloved friend Patroclus enters the battle wearing Achilles' armor and is slain by Hector, prompting Achilles to finally rejoin the fight.

Achilles' Rampage and the River Xanthos

Achilles' return to battle is marked by a cataclysmic event, signaling the entry of unstoppable forces. Homer vividly describes Achilles driving the Trojans back towards Troy, with the river Xanthos becoming a scene of carnage:

But when they came to the crossing place of the fair-running river
of whirling Xanthos, a stream whose father was Zeus the immortal,
there Achilleus split them and chased some back over the flat land
toward the city, where the Achaians themselves had stampeded in
terror

Achilles, likened to an immortal, slays Trojans with his sword, turning the river red with blood. He captures twelve young men to be sacrificed in vengeance for Patroclus' death.

The graphic description includes details such as the leather thongs cutting into the flesh of the captives, highlighting the savage nature of Achilles' actions.

Ethical Considerations and the Greek Worldview

The author questions how a modern American reader, accustomed to ethical narratives, should respond to Achilles' brutality. He contrasts the modern concern for victims with the ancient Greek worldview, which was savage but honest.

The Greeks experienced the world in terms of glory and shame rather than good and evil. Homer presents a noble conception of life, where strength, beauty, and divine favor determine one's fate. This aligns with Tayler's concept of "binary opposites," but with a different set of values.

The "Other" in Western Culture

The author addresses the academic debate on Western classics, which urges readers to consider marginalized cultures and individuals. He argues that the ancient Greeks themselves represent a kind of "other" within Western culture, with their marauding behavior and unfamiliar customs.

Observations of Columbia Students

The author observes Columbia students on campus, noting their pale complexions and serious demeanor. He contrasts this with his own experiences as a student in the 1960s, when the college was populated by bookish young men preoccupied with intellectual pursuits.

He notes the changes in the student body, including the admission of women and the increase in minority representation. In one Lit Hum section, there were only four white males out of twenty-two students.

Contemporary Civilization (C.C.) and the Nature of Objectivity

The author describes his experience in a Contemporary Civilization class where the professor, Anders Stephanson, challenges the notion of objectivity. Stephanson questions the ideological underpinnings of the Western calendar and the dominance of European perspectives in the course material.

Stephanson argues that nothing can be considered objective, natural, or universal, including the books on the C.C. reading list. He emphasizes that these texts represent a specific way of presenting education and culture, not an innocent or unbiased selection.

Critique of the Canon and the "Hegemony" of Western Culture

The author explains the attacks on the traditional literary canon, which is seen as exclusionary and representative of a unitary sensibility that favors white European males. Critics argue that the canon perpetuates the "hegemony" of Western culture and its associated ideologies, such as individualism, capitalism, imperialism, racism, and sexism.

Tayler's and Stephanson's Approaches to Teaching

The author contrasts Tayler's approach, which emphasizes the formal analysis of texts, with Stephanson's deconstructionist perspective. Tayler focuses on the structure and patterns within the Iliad, while Stephanson encourages students to interrogate the texts and question their assumptions.

Tayler's method is described as derived from the New Criticism, which focuses on the formal unity of a work of art. He guides students to see the recurring patterns and symmetries within the Iliad, such as ring composition. Tayler uses analogies, such as the "cat" and the "pig," to illustrate the importance of recognizing the underlying structure of the poem.

The Importance of Structure and the Heroic Code

Tayler emphasizes the importance of understanding the structure of the Iliad in order to grasp its meaning. He argues that the poem is not simply a glorification of war but a complex exploration of the heroic code. By examining the minor heroes and recurring patterns, students can better understand Achilles' significance as a figure who both embodies and violates the code.

Intellectual Thumbscrews and Reading from Another Culture

Tayler acknowledges the intellectual challenges he poses to his students, comparing it to applying "intellectual thumbscrews." He emphasizes the importance of reading works from other cultures and encourages students to move beyond their own cultural baggage.

Resistance to Reading the Iliad

The author mentions the resistance to reading the Iliad among some faculty members, who view it as a poem that oppresses women and glorifies war. He suggests that deconstructing the poem based on modern perceptions of class, power, and gender obscures its true meaning.

The Weight and Consequence of Everything in the Iliad

The author reflects on the weight and consequence of everything in the Iliad, from the warriors' deaths to their boasts. He notes the formal manner in which the characters address one another, recounting their family honors and triumphs. He emphasizes that glory is possible everywhere, even in the shining helmets of the warriors.

The Absence of Pity and the Splendor of the Iliad

The author notes the absence of pity in the Iliad and the untrammeled physical exultation. He argues that the splendor of the poem would not be possible if the ethical component ruled. He concludes that the Iliad is not a humanist work and cannot be made into one.

Distractions and Daydreaming

The author admits to experiencing distractions and daydreams while reading the Iliad, reflecting on his diminished concentration compared to his youth. He attributes this to the complexities of his life and suggests that daydreaming may be a form of disguised commentary from the deep.

Achilles as the Hero of an Epic

The author poses the question of how Achilles, who stays out of the action for much of the poem, can remain the hero of an epic. He suggests that the answer lies in the fact that Achilles' rage and withdrawal lead him to a new conception of war and honor.

Achilles' Staggering Speech in Book IX

The crux of the poem, according to the author, comes in Book IX, when Achilles rejects the gifts offered by the Greek ambassadors. His speech in this scene is described as unlike anything else in the poem, showing a man struggling to say what has never been said before.

Achilles declares his detestation for those who hide their true feelings and asserts that neither Agamemnon nor the Danaans will persuade him to fight. He recognizes that fate is the same for all men, regardless of their actions, and that life cannot be recovered once it is lost.

Achilles' Revolt and the Limits of Consciousness

The author argues that Achilles' rage has awakened him to a new sense of honor that is not dependent on external validation. He has come close to breaking with the honor/shame code of Homer's warrior society and reaching a private or spiritual sense of worth.

However, Achilles' revolt is incomplete. After Patroclus' death, his wrath turns into personal rage at Hector, leading to a rampage of killing and destruction.

The Humanist Reading and Its Limitations

The author critiques the complacent "humanist" reading of the Iliad, which sees Achilles as achieving completeness as a hero through his compassion towards Priam. He argues that this interpretation is too simplistic and overlooks the unresolved tension and unease that the poem leaves behind.

The Enduring Power of the Iliad

The author concludes that the Iliad remains a powerful and challenging work that questions its own ethos and leaves the reader profoundly uneasy. He suggests that the poem's ambivalence about glory and death challenges our current ideas about what is right and wrong, true, heroic, and human.

Identity and the Cultural Left

The author reflects on his own identity as a white male and a bourgeois, acknowledging that this is how he is seen from the outside by the cultural left. However, he questions whether this identity can account for the use that any of us makes of the cards we've been dealt or for the way we feel about our own experience.

Personal Reflections on Rereading the Iliad

The author recalls his initial dismay at reading the Iliad as an eighteen-year-old, feeling overawed by physical courage and the poem's grandeur. He contrasts this with his later experience of rereading the poem as a New York householder and father, finding himself intoxicated by its amoral magnificence and savage celebration of physical joy.

The Iliad's Challenge to Modern Ideas

The author concludes by emphasizing that the Iliad challenges most of our current ideas about what is right and wrong, what is true, what is heroic, and finally, what is human. He cites a passage from the Iliad to illustrate the relentless and overpowering nature of battle:

As when along the thundering beach the surf of the sea strikes\text{As when along the thundering beach the surf of the sea strikes}
beat upon beat as the west wind drives it onward; far out\text{beat upon beat as the west wind drives it onward; far out}
cresting first on the open water, it drives thereafter\text{cresting first on the open water, it drives thereafter}
to smash roaring along the dry land, and against the rock jut\text{to smash roaring along the dry land, and against the rock jut}
bending breaks itself into crests spewing back the salt wash;\text{bending breaks itself into crests spewing back the salt wash;}
so thronged beat upon beat the Danaans’ close battalions\text{so thronged beat upon beat the Danaans' close battalions}
steadily into battle, with each of the lords commanding\text{steadily into battle, with each of the lords commanding}
his own men….\text{his own men….}

He emphasizes that Homer celebrated remorseless cruelty and loathed the results of remorseless cruelty.