assignment 8 DEBTORS’ & CREDITORS’ RIGHTS Fall 2025 - Assignment 8 Study Notes
DEBTORS’ & CREDITORS’ RIGHTS Fall 2025
ASSIGNMENT 8: THE DEBTOR’S RIGHT TO EXEMPT AND REDEEM PROPERTY
Contents
- § 8.01 The Debtor’s Right to Claim Property As Exempt
- § 8.02 Effect of Claiming Property as Exempt
- Problem 1
- Problem 2
- Problem 3
- Problem 4
- [A] Tale of Two Schemes
- Problem 5
- Problem 6
- [B] To File or Not to File
- Problem 7
- [C] Preservation of Certain Liens on Exempt Property
- Problem 8
- Problem 9
- Problem 10
- § 8.03 Conversion of Non-Exempt to Exempt Assets on the “Eve” of Bankruptcy
- IN RE JOHNSON (Johnson I)
- IN RE JOHNSON (Johnson II)
- IN RE ADDISON
- § 8.04 The Entireties Property Exemption
- SAPIR v. SARTORIUS
- § 8.05 The Debtor’s Interest as Lessee of Real Property
- MATTER OF SANTIAGO-MONTEVERDE
§ 8.01 The Debtor’s Right to Claim Property As Exempt
- Definition of Estate (11 U.S.C. § 541): The commencement of a case creates an "estate" consisting of all legal and equitable interests of the debtor in property as of the commencement of the case.
- Exemption Process:
- After property is swept into the estate by the broad code § 541(a), it is subject to being claimed as exempt from creditors under code § 522.
- Individual Debtors Only: Exemptions are available only to individual debtors (as noted in § 522(b)) and not to corporate or partnership debtors.
- Rationale for the Exemption System:
- Property begins as part of the bankruptcy estate to ensure that it may be turned over even if held by third parties under § 542(a).
- Debtors might choose not to claim property as exempt, or fail to do so timely, meaning property may remain in the estate.
- Claim Filing Timeline:
- Code § 522(l) requires that a debtor file a schedule of exempt property within 15 days after the order for relief, unless extended by the court.
- Creditors have 30 days following the conclusion of the § 341 meeting to object to claimed exemptions.
- The burden of proof regarding objections rests with the objecting party (Rule 4003(c)).
- Court Precedent:
- In Taylor v. Freeland & Kronz, 503 U.S. 638 (1992), if a property is claimed as exempt without objection, it becomes exempt despite potentially lacking foundation for that claim.
- Example: A debtor claimed a $100,000 employment discrimination settlement as exempt; the trustee failed to object believing it was worthless. The court ruled that the objection was time-barred after the relevant period passed.
- Consequences of Abuse: If a debtor conceals non-exempt property, penalties include denial of discharge under § 727 and possibly surcharging exempt claims (as seen in Malley v. Agin, 693 F.3d 28 (1st Cir. 2012)).
§ 8.02 Effect of Claiming Property as Exempt
- Understanding Exempt Property: Claiming an exemption generally shields property from creditors' reach.
- Effects on Creditors: Different types of creditors may have distinct rights against exempt property.
Problems for Review:
Problem 1: Debtor owes $1000 to a doctor and files a Chapter 7 petition. The estate has $500 in non-exempt assets and $300 in exempt assets (tools of the trade). Debtor’s liability on debts arising before relief order is discharged under § 727(b).
- Can the doctor pursue the $950 balance against the $300 in exempt assets?
Problem 2: Can the doctor levy against property that the Debtor receives after the commencement of the case, e.g. a salary check?
- Reference Bankruptcy Code § 524(a).
Problem 3: Citibank recovers $500 of its $5000 claim on an educational loan after a bankruptcy filing. Can they recover the remaining $4500 via exempt assets?
- Reference §§ 522(c)(1), 523(a)(8).
Problem 4: A former spouse seeks to enforce a $12,000 support claim after the Debtor files for bankruptcy. Can she pursue the wedding ring claimed as exempt?
- Reference §§ 522(c)(1), 523(a)(5).
[A] Tale of Two Schemes
- Historical Context:
- For over a century Congress has debated property exemptions and their governing laws.
- Federal to State Exemptions: Initial federal laws allowed general exemptions to apply; later laws favored state law.
- This led to debtors moving states pre-bankruptcy to claim more favorable exemptions.
- Current § 522(b) allows debtors to choose either federal exemptions (under § 522(d)) or state exemptions plus non-bankruptcy federal exemptions.
- State Opt-Out Laws: Many states have opted out of federal exemption schemes (like New York did in Section 284).
- In 2011, New York amended its law to allow debtors to choose between federal and state exemptions again, under § 285.
- The debtor must choose one to the exclusion of the other; cannot select items from both.
State Comparisons and Impacts:
- Example: Compare exemptions under Bankruptcy Code § 522(d)(1) versus New York CPLR § 5206 regarding home equity.
- Non-Bankruptcy Federal Exemptions: Certain benefits like Social Security, veterans’ benefits are exempt under federal law even in states that have opted out of federal schemes.
§ 8.03 Conversion of Non-Exempt to Exempt Assets on the “Eve” of Bankruptcy
- Context: Strategies involving timing in converting assets may affect exemption eligibility.
Case Studies:
- IN RE JOHNSON (Johnson I):
- Johnson converted significant non-exempt assets pre-bankruptcy under Minnesota law. No fraud found in exemption claims under pretext of shifting assets to exempt forms.
- The court held that mere intent to convert non-exempt to exempt is not sufficient to deem fraudulent without further evidence.
- IN RE JOHNSON (Johnson II): Remanded with an instruction for the bankruptcy court to determine if any extrinsic evidence of fraud existed related to other claimed exemptions.
- IN RE ADDISON: Focuses on the intent behind asset conversion prior to bankruptcy filing, evaluating the specifics of how much and what type of property was involved.