Introduction to Qualitative Research and Research Paradigms

Class Representatives and Student Support

  • Class Representatives: Vera and Nicole are the class representatives for the current semester.

  • Role and Feedback: They serve as the primary contact for students to provide feedback or ask questions. Students are encouraged to share harsh feedback about lectures or tutorials (e.g., teaching methods) via an upcoming anonymous Jot form. This feedback will be presented at meetings to facilitate change.

  • Communication Channels:

    • Contact Info: Emails are located on the "Meet the Team" page under the modules, found at the bottom of the page.

    • Instagram Group Chat: A group chat for Psychology 208208 students is being created. The invitation link will be posted in the course announcements soon.

Introduction to the Qualitative Research Module

  • Module Transition: The course is moving from a module on the importance of ethics in research (taught by Haniaatua) into the qualitative module. Future modules will cover mixed methods and integrated perspectives.

  • Lecture Scope: This lecture serves as a surface-level, basic introduction to qualitative research, its basics, and its application.

  • Instructional Team:

    • Shiloh (Lead Lecturer): An academic at Auckland University for approximately 1414 to 1515 years (since 20122012). Shiloh's background includes social, community, and indigenous psychologies, with research interests in homelessness, poverty, indigenous well-being, and relational ethics.

    • Tycho (Guest Speaker): A PhD candidate who recently submitted their thesis on community-oriented qualitative research. Tycho provides a perspective closer to the student experience, illustrating the application of qualitative methods.

Learning Objectives and Philosophical Foundations

  • Primary Objectives:

    • Explain the relationship between quantitative and qualitative research (antagonistic vs. complementary).

    • Define a research paradigm and its components.

    • Describe the scope and dimensions of qualitative research.

    • Determine the suitability of qualitative approaches for specific projects.

    • Describe diverse data generation and analytic approaches.

  • The Concept of a Research Paradigm:

    • Definition: A framework or "culture" that holds research together. It influences every stage of research, from the initial question to the final outputs.

    • Components of a Paradigm:

      1. Axiology: The values and ethics inherent in the research.

      2. Ontology: Assumptions about what is known and the nature of reality.

      3. Epistemology: Assumptions about how we acquire knowledge and what constitutes valid knowledge.

      4. Methodology and Methods: The specific procedures and data collection tools used to investigate a phenomenon.

Deconstructing Popular Myths about Qualitative Research

  • Myth 1: It is not a science.

    • Reality: This depends on the definition of science. Qualitative research has long traditions rooted in Greek philosophy. The dominance of quantitative research emerged post-World War II, influenced by US political fears (distancing from communitarian values associated with socialism). Qualitative research uses structured, rigorous methodologies to ensure valid findings.

  • Myth 2: It is too subjective and biased.

    • Reality: Qualitative researchers acknowledge "positionality" and subjectivity rather than ignoring the "elephant in the room." All methods of inquiry have inherent biases; qualitative research interrogates these subjectivities as powerful research tools.

  • Myth 3: It is just anecdotal.

    • Reality: Qualitative research deals with complex data (stories, emotions, histories, trauma). Systematic coding, software, and methods like abductive reasoning are used to turn "chaos" into actionable insights. Thematic analysis is the most popular analytic approach.

  • Myth 4: Findings cannot be generalized.

    • Reality: While qualitative research does not seek statistical generalization, it seeks theoretical transferability. It provides in-depth context that quantitative data cannot capture.

  • Myth 5: It is the "softer," feminized version of research.

    • Reality: Quantitative research asks "how much" or "how often." Qualitative research asks "why" and "how" to conceptualize action frameworks that respond to reality.

  • Myth 6: It is quick and easy.

    • Reality: It is incredibly time-intensive. Community obligations often conflict with research timelines, requiring flexibility and dynamic pivoting.

The Qualitative Research Mindset: Ten Fundamentals

  • Focus on Meaning: Prioritizes depth of meaning over numerical frequency.

  • No Single Objective Truth: Rejects the idea of one knowable reality independent of the researcher.

  • Context is Vital: Treats the environment and context of participants as essential data.

  • Valuing Subjectivity: Researcher identity and perspective are integral to the process.

  • Philosophical Underpinnings: Grounded in specific ontological and epistemological frameworks.

  • Diversity of Approaches: Includes thematic analysis, indigenous epistemologies, and various non-positivist traditions.

  • Use of Varied Data: Can utilize narrative, visual, and experiential data.

Positivism vs. Non-Positivism

  • Positivist Paradigm (The Quantitative Standard):

    • Common in the "North American variant" of psychology.

    • Belief in an absolute, knowable world independent of the researcher.

    • Attempts to eliminate bias through design.

    • Produces objective, replicable, and statistically generalizable data.

  • Non-Positivist Paradigm (Qualitative Context):

    • Includes Critical, Feminist, Queer, and Indigenous (e.g., Kaupapa Māori) traditions.

    • Realism and Structural Constructionism: Influenced by British, German, and French philosophies.

    • Emphasis on interpretation of meaning, experience, and well-being.

    • Subjectivity as an Ethical Stance: Recognizes the researcher as a part of the study rather than a detached observer.

Qualitative Research in Practice: Focused Case Study (Tycho)

  • Research Topic: Trans and gender diverse people's experiences of homelessness in Aotearoa, New Zealand.

  • Theoretical Frameworks:

    • Community Psychology: Focuses on transforming society and working with rather than on communities.

    • Liberation Psychology: Originating from Latin America, aiming to empower marginalized groups.

    • Phronetic Knowledge: Validating lived experience as a primary form of knowledge.

  • Addressing Community Mistrust:

    • Psychology has historically "royally fucked over" trans and gender diverse populations.

    • Marginalized communities are often "over-researched" and wary of data extraction that does not benefit them.

    • Relational Ethics: Ethics are practiced through ongoing accountability and advocacy, not just as a one-time approval from a committee.

  • Methodology: Photo Testimonial:

    • A form of photo elicitation where cameras are placed in the hands of participants to capture their everyday lives.

    • Example 1: The "No Entry" Sign: A participant used a photo of a no-entry sign to symbolize being locked out of all homelessness services and experiencing abandonment.

    • Example 2: DIY Chest Binding: A participant photographed wounds caused by using duct tape for binding. This illustrated discrimination from service providers who withheld gender-affirming care.

    • Example 3: The "3030 mph" Sign: A participant with learning difficulties used a street sign to articulate the feeling that a trans, homeless person's life is "kept at 3030 years old" (a life-shortening imposition).

  • Conceptual Outcome: Webs of Abandonment: The research identified how trans individuals in New Zealand get caught in "webs of abandonment" when seeking help from service providers, leading to literal physical harm and shortened life expectancy.

Questions & Discussion

  • Question on Bias: "Are biases always present, and should researchers just acknowledge them?"

  • Response: Biases are inherent in how we ask questions, choose paradigms, and interpret data. Qualitative researchers adopt an ethical stance to acknowledge subjectivity because they are part of the research process. Objectivity is a myth in this context; instead, the researcher moves toward recognizing their role in the findings.

  • Question on Quality and Replicability: "Is there poor quality qualitative research?"

  • Response: Yes. With methods like thematic analysis becoming highly popular (attributed to Professor Virginia Brown), it is often treated as a formulaic "tick-box" exercise. This proliferation of formulaic research without deep theoretical understanding is the qualitative equivalent of a "replication crisis." Replicability is often not the goal; rather, the intent is for the research to trigger social change so that future studies cannot replicate the same negative findings.