Protectionism and free trade


Protectionism: refers to government policies and regulations (such as restrictive

quotas and tariffs on imported goods), which are designed to benefit local

producers of goods and services in their competition with imported goods, thus

helping them to survive.


Free trade: occurs where government creates very few barriers to international trade. This allows the free flow of goods and services into the country from any other country that can produce these goods cheaper, better, or in the required volumes.


Export promotion

Definition

Export promotion involves providing incentives to encourage local

businesses to produce goods for export.


Reasons for export promotion

Some of the reasons for export promotion are:

•The country achieves significant export-led economic growth.

•Export promotion enlarges the production capacity of the country.

•Export markets are much bigger than local markets.

•More workers will be employed.

•Prices will be reduced.


Methods of export promotion

Methods used to support export promotion include:

• Incentives: The government supplies information on export markets,

research on new markets, concessions on transport charges, export

credit, etc. in order to stimulate exports.

• Subsidies: These include direct and indirect subsidies:

– Direct subsidies: Cash payments to exporters.

– Indirect subsidies: Refunds on import tariffs and general tax

rebates.

• Trade neutrality: Subsidies equal in size to import duties, are paid.

Neutrality can be achieved through trade liberalisation.


Advantages of export promotion

The advantages of export promotion include:

•There are no limitations to size and scale of market.

•Production is based on cost and efficiency.

•There is increased domestic production.

•Exchange rates would be realistic.


Disadvantages of export promotion

The disadvantages of export promotion include:

•The real cost of production is reduced by subsidies and incentives.

•Incentives and subsidies reduce prices and force competitors out of

the market. This leads to a lack of competition.

•Export promotion results in increased tariffs and quotas by powerful

overseas competitors.

•Export promotion results in the protection of labour-intensive

industries by developed countries.


Import Substitution

Definition

Import substitution is part of South Africa’s international trade policy. It

occurs when locally produced goods replace goods that had previously

been imported. This has a positive impact on the balance of trade.


Reasons for import substitution

Reasons for import substitution include the following:

• Diversification: when goods that were previously imported are

produced locally domestic manufacturing expands and an economy

becomes less reliant on foreign countries.

• Industrialisation is promoted: the development of new industries to

produce previously imported goods can increase tax revenues and

create jobs.

• Balance of payment problems: if the deficit on the BoP is too high,

a decrease in imports can help to rectify this.

• Trade: developing countries’ reliance on natural resources as a

basis for growth and development limits their ability to grow. If these

resources are used to produce goods and services which can be

used domestically or exported, economic growth might be increased.


Methods of import substitution

The government imposes certain measures to restrict the amount of

imports into the country and to support local industries. Restrictive

measures used to reserve the domestic market for local manufacturers

are:

  • Tariffs: Customs duties or import duties are taxes on imported goods.

They can be ad valorem (based on the value) or specific to certain

goods. Prices of imported goods increase for domestic consumers,

and they tend to shift demand from imports to domestic products

(goods).

  • Quotas: Limits are put on the supply of goods and services. Supply

is reduced and prices rise. Foreign enterprises benefit if demand for

their products remains high.

  • Subsidies: They enable relatively high cost domestic enterprises to

undercut more efficient foreign enterprises in the domestic market.

  • Exchange control: Government reduces imports by limiting the

amount of foreign exchange made available to those who wish to

import.

  • Physical control: A complete ban or embargo is imposed on the

import of certain goods from a particular country.

  • Diverting trade: Monetary deposits, time-consuming customs

procedures and high-quality standards are imposed to make the

importing of goods more difficult.


Advantages of import substitution

Some of the advantages of import substitution are:

• Increased employment: More local workers are employed. This

stimulates the economy and GDP increases.

• More choice: Available foreign exchange can be used for other

imports, thus increasing choices.

• Diversification: By producing more goods locally, the range of

available goods increases, and the country becomes less vulnerable

to foreign actions and conditions.


Disadvantages of import substitution

Some of the disadvantages of import substitution for the local economy

are:

  • Capital and entrepreneurial talent: This is drawn away from

comparative advantage.

  • Technology borrowed from abroad: This may be unsuitable for local

production.

  • Competitiveness of certain sectors decreases: Where comparative

advantages exist.

  • Import substitution leads to demand for protection: This demand

comes from industries that provide inputs to local industries.



*Many economists argue for protection, especially for developing countries.

Many other economists insist that free trade is the best way to regulate

markets. Governments often choose a mix of selected protectionist and

free trade policies that suit the particular conditions of their country.


Protection

Definition of protection

A trade policy whereby the state discourages the importing of certain

goods and services in order to protect local industries against unequal

competition from abroad


Arguments in favour of protection

  • Industrial development: Some developing countries are well suited

to establishing certain kinds of industries. Free trade makes it

difficult for these countries to compete with countries with well-

established industries.

  • Infant industries: Newly established industries find it difficult to

survive because of high average costs of production which are higher

than those of well-established foreign competitors.

  • Stable wage levels and higher standards of living: A country with

high wages has a view that the standard of living will be undermined

if cheaper goods are imported from countries with low wages.

  • The protection of job opportunities: If local industries cannot find

profitable markets because of cheaper imports, production may

decrease and this will lead to more unemployment.

  • Economic self-sufficiency and strategic key industries: In times

of conflict, cut-off or friction between countries occurs. Protection

should be granted, especially to key industries to ensure the

availability of these key products.

  • Dangers of dumping: Some countries sell their surplus goods in

a foreign country at lower prices than it cost them to produce the

goods. Local producers cannot compete, and their factories may

close.

  • Stabilise exchange rates and balance of payments: Traders buy in

the cheapest markets and sell in the most expensive ones. Countries

export primary products and import manufactured goods, causing

disrupted balance of payments and exchange rates.

  • Protection of natural resources: Free trade can easily exhaust natural

resources, therefore protection is needed to protect local industries

and indigenous knowledge systems so that they can survive. The

South African government has taken steps to protect Rooibos tea as

natural resource and safeguard indigenous knowledge that allows the

hoodia plant to be used for medicinal purposes.


Free trade

Definition of free trade

When producers and consumers are free to buy goods and services from

anywhere in the world without the interference of government.


Arguments in favour of free trade

  • Specialisation: The theory of comparative advantage shows that

world output can be increased if countries specialise in what they

are relatively best at producing. If each nation does what it does

best, everyone will enjoy lower prices and higher levels of output.

  • Economies of scale: Free trade allows economies of scale to be

maximised and thus unit cost are reduced. Economies of scale are a

source of comparative advantage.

  • Choice: Free trade allows consumers the choice of what to buy

from the whole world, and not just what is produced domestically.

Consumers’ welfare is thus increased because some consumers at

least will prefer to buy foreign goods rather than domestic goods.

  • Innovations: Free trade increases competition and this encourages

innovation in goods and processes.

  • Improves global efficiency: Under free trade, resources are

allocated more efficiently as markets expand, because each country

specialises in its most effective production. Free trade leads to greater world production of traded goods, leading

to an increase in economic welfare. Free trade leads to mutual gains from international trade to all

countries.


A desirable mix of protection and free trade

Import substitution and export promotion

The strategies of Import substitution and export promotion should not

be regarded as unavoidable opposites. Many countries started out by

protecting their domestic industries and then applied export-orientated

policies only after a considerable length of time. Import substitution almost

inevitably leads to export promotion.


Protection and free trade

Regionalisation, in the form of trade blocks, makes use of free trade and

protection. Member countries pursue free trade with one another but

apply trade restrictions outside their block. (Free trade area, e.g. NAFTA

and Custom unions, e.g. Mercusor)


Globalisation

Restrictive practices, whether they relate to imports or to exports have the

same effect – they reduce the potential volume of world production that

would be possible if there was complete free trade and only those goods

for which countries had comparative advantage were produced. To pursue

this objective of free trade, an independent facilitator was required. The

WTO (world trade organisation) is such a facilitator.


Economic integration

Some of these trade protocols that focus on economic integration are:

  • Free trade areas (FTAs) – Member countries agree to the removal of

all tariffs. Each member country is still permitted to maintain its own

level of trade protection against non-member countries.

  • Customs unions – Member countries agree to the removal of all

tariffs. However, in a custom union, member countries all set and

maintain the same external restrictions on non-member countries.

  • Common markets – Are a form of economic integration that satisfies

all the requirements of a customs union but also allows for the free

movement of factors of production between member countries.

  • Economic unions – Meet all the requirements of a common market,

but go further which results in member countries establishing a

single authority responsible for joint economic policy making, a single

monetary system, one central bank, a unified fiscal system and a

common foreign economic policy.


Evaluation of South Africa’s trade policies

Export promotion and import substitution

South Africa’s export promotion policy unfolds as follows:

Export promotion

  • 1970’s – measures such as cash grants, tax concessions on export

turnover and profits and rail freight concessions were introduced

in order to reduce costs for manufacturers of goods with export

potential.

  • 1980’s – some quotas were removed and replaced with tariffs.

Export subsidies were introduced. A list of importers that needed

approval replaced a list of imports that did not need approval.

  • 1985 – When the US banks refused to roll over import guarantees,

South Africa declared a debt standstill and unilaterally restructured

the payment of its foreign loans. The rand depreciated substantially

and surcharge of 10% on imports was introduced. This led to the

effective protection rate increase from 30% to 70%.

  • 1990’s – the General Export Incentive Scheme (GEIS) was

introduced for the purpose of encouraging the production of value-

added exports. For the first time the official policy stance was one of

export-orientated industrialisation.


South Africa’s Import substitution policy unfolds as follows:

Import substitution

  • Tariff protection – in 1910 the Cullinan Commission was appointed

to investigate the feasibility of establishing a domestic manufacturing

industry in South Africa. Tariffs were introduced by the Customs

Tariff Act of 1914 and provided protection for local manufacturing

industries. In 1925 a new act was implemented and the ‘South Africa

first campaign’ was introduced. South Africa thereby introduced an

official inward-looking policy.

  • The Second World War – Iscor (now Arcelor Mittal) was established

as a strategic industry in 1928, in time to take advantage of the

opportunities brought about by the Second World War. The SWW

stimulated manufacturing and industrial development in general.

This was because SA was isolated from many imports and had to

produce many products itself.

  • Export ready – After the SWW it was accepted that import

substitution was the best policy to enhance economic growth.

Sasol was established in 1955 to produce oil from coal. From the

mid-1960’s, import substitution reached a mature phase when

manufacturing increasingly focused on intermediate and capital

production. Domestic demand was the main stimulus. However

large markets were essential for these goods and necessitated

exports. South Africa was ready for an export promotion policy. SA

manufacturing sector’s contribution to GDP increased from 5,8

in 1912 to 31,1% in 1981. Import substitution had indeed been

successful.