Moral Intuitionism Study Notes
Moral Intuitionism
Moral Judgement Examples
Julie's and Mark's Story
- Julie and Mark, siblings, are on summer vacation in France.
- They decide to engage in sexual relations during their stay in a secluded cabin, finding it an interesting and fun experience.
- Julie is on birth control pills, and Mark uses a condom for extra safety.
- Afterward, they cherish the memory as a secret, feeling closer to one another.
- Question Raised: Was their sexual encounter morally wrong?Jennifer's Story
- Works in a medical school pathology lab, preparing human cadavers for medical instruction.
- Sees a body set for cremation and, conflicted by her vegetarian ethics, takes a piece of flesh to cook.
- Justifies the act due to the body being a wasted resource, as it belonged to someone who died of a heart attack.
- Question Raised: Is there anything morally wrong with Jennifer's actions?
Traditional Moral Psychology
Historically rooted in rationalist philosophy that moral judgments stem from reasoning processes.
Key Figures: Piaget and Kohlberg's assumption on moral judgement relies on rational reasoning.
A recurring philosophical theme is the conflict between desire and reason.
Platonic and Descartian Perspectives
Plato's View:
- Describes the creation of perfect rational souls, immortal and encased in the head.
- Bodies reflect a second, inferior, mortal soul, focused on passions like pleasure and pain.Descartes' Perspective:
- Argues that higher souls master their passions through reason, leading to true happiness.
- Contrarily, common souls succumb to passions, resulting in a lack of control.
Rationalist vs Emotivist Philosophy
David Hume's Contradiction:
- Claims that reason is driven by passions rather than ruling over them, portraying a more emotivist stance compared to rationalists.
The Rationalist Model of Moral Judgement
The sequence involved in moral reasoning comprises:
1. Eliciting Situation
2. Reasoning Process
3. Final Judgement
Insights into Moral Judgement Dynamics
Judgement Formation:
- Moral affects like sympathy can influence the reasoning process substantially.
- Rationalist model outlines affect leading to reasoning, then culminating in judgement.Challenging Rationalist Model (Part 1): - Moral intuitions precede reasoning (Chapters 1-4).
Research on Moral Dumbfounding
Study by Haidt, Bjorklund, and Murphy (2000):
- Explores reactions to traditional moral dilemmas like Kohlberg's ‘Heinz dilemma’ vs. intuitive judgement scenarios designed to invoke disgust.Behavioral Intuition Scenarios:
- Roach Juice Experiment: Participants’ reactions to a cockroach dipped in apple juice showed a reluctance to consume it despite assurances of cleanliness.
- Soul Task Experiment: Test subjects sign a paper “selling” their soul for $2, highlighting cognitive dissonance in morally trivial tasks.
Moral Intuition Tasks
Moral Intuition Stories:
- Moral scenarios related to incest (Julie and Mark) and cannibalism (Jennifer).Participants' responses indicated difficulty in articulating reasons for their moral intuitions.
Results from Behavioral Intuition Scenarios
Few participants were willing to comply with tasks even when challenged; only a minority changed their judgement upon questioning.
Interview transcripts confirmed participants often displayed moral dumbfounding.
Results from Moral Intuition Stories
Similar outcomes as behavioral intuition scenarios; only a minority affirmed moral compliance.
Participants expressed confusion and failed to provide justified reasons for their moral standpoints.
Comparison Across Moral Scenarios
Data compiled reflects varying degrees of confusion across different moral scenarios (Heinz, Roach, Soul, Incest, Cannibalism).
The numerical scale ranges from severe moral confusion to judgments perceived as reasoned without rational support.
Conclusions on Moral Intuition
Findings reveal that participants operated more on intuition rather than reason when faced with moral intuition stories.
Moral judgements generally arise from quick intuitive responses, followed by a slower, deliberative reasoning process.
The 'Rider and the Elephant' Metaphor
Rider (Reason): Represents controlled cognitive processes.
Elephant (Intuition): Represents automatic emotional and intuitive responses.
This metaphor clarifies that moral judgements often root in intuitive feelings, subsequently rationalized through reasoning processes.
Dual Process Models of Cognition
Various models suggest a framework where intuitive (System 1) and reasoned cognition (System 2) play distinct yet interrelated roles in moral judgement.
Examples referenced include Kahneman's System 1 and System 2 framework and Margolis' conceptualization of intuitive seeing versus reasoned why.
Social Intuitionist Model (Haidt, 2001)
Structure:
1. Triggering Event
2. Intuition Formation
3. Judgement Conclusion
4. Reasoning JustificationThis model posits that intuition and reasoning are contrasting cognitive processes, largely shaped by social contexts.
Extended Processes in Social Intuitionist Model
A detailed framework explains the dynamics of intuitive judgment through social influences encompassing reasoning and persuasion methodologies.
Psychological Reporting on Moral Judgements
Published in the Psychological Review demonstrating the evolution of moral judgement research dominated by rationalist perspectives and highlighting the social intuitionist model as a viable alternative.
Implications of Intuitionist Approach on Moral Judgments
Research Findings: Highlight the precedence of intuitions in moral judgments and the social influence on moral discourse.
Challenges to rationalist models stem from empirical studies revealing the emotional underpinnings of moral decision-making processes.
Responses and Counterarguments to Social Intuitionist Model
Notable critiques from philosophers like Paul Bloom arguing the need for rational deliberation in moral evolution, countered by Haidt as misrepresentative of the model’s stance on reason and emotions.
Additional Challenges and Counterpoints
Pointed discussions regarding the coexistence of rational and intuitive processes in moral reasoning, emphasizing the necessity for dual processing in achieving equitable moral progress.
Societal and Psychological Considerations
Noted effects of societal norms and expectations influencing moral judgments and the innate human tendency towards confirmation biases and strategic justifications in reasoning.
Highlighted perceptions that moral reasoning sometimes serves ulterior motives rather than pure truths, as noted in various studies.