Reasoning, Sequences, and Problem Solving

Fundamentals of Reasoning

  • Definition of Reasoning: Reasoning is the act of thinking about something in a logical, sensible way. It provides the structured approach used to support a supposition and arrive at a logical conclusion.
  • Two Core Types of Reasoning:
    • Inductive Reasoning: Deriving a generalization from specific situations or examples; arriving at a general rule by observing and analyzing specific instances.
    • Deductive Reasoning: Applying general facts, rules, definitions, or established principles to reach a conclusion for a specific situation.

Inductive Reasoning

  • Definition: Inductive reasoning is a form of reasoning that constructs a conclusion based on the examination of specific examples or patterns.
  • Conjecture: The formal term for a conclusion reached through inductive reasoning.
  • Properties and Limitations of Conjectures:
    • Involves analyzing empirical patterns to predict subsequent terms or general behaviors.
    • A conjecture may be true or false; observing a pattern over a limited set of examples does not guarantee absolute proof for all cases.
  • Exhaustive Examples of Inductive Reasoning:
    • Example 1: Visual Geometric Pattern:
    • Pattern Description: A sequence of figures consisting of a square with one-fourth (14\frac{1}{4}) of its area shaded. The shaded quadrant rotates in a clockwise direction across sequential steps.
    • Step Analysis: Figure 1 has the bottom-left shaded, Figure 2 top-left, Figure 3 top-right, Figure 4 bottom-right, Figure 5 bottom-left, Figure 6 top-left, Figure 7 top-right, and Figure 8 bottom-right.
    • Conjecture: The next figures will continue the cyclic clockwise rotation of the shaded quadrant.
    • Example 2: Numerical Pattern (2,4,8,16,…2, 4, 8, 16, \dots):
    • Pattern Analysis: Each succeeding term is generated by doubling the value of the preceding term (2×2=42 \times 2 = 4, 4×2=84 \times 2 = 8, 8×2=168 \times 2 = 16).
    • Conjecture: The next three terms in the sequence are 3232, 6464, and 128128.
    • Example 3: Operational Procedure Analysis:
    • Procedure: Choose any number, multiply it by 66, add 88 to the product, divide the sum by 22, and subtract 44.
    • Trial 1 (Starting with 11):
      • 1×6=61 \times 6 = 6
      • 6+8=146 + 8 = 14
      • 142=7\frac{14}{2} = 7
      • 7−4=37 - 4 = 3
    • Trial 2 (Starting with 66):
      • 6×6=366 \times 6 = 36
      • 36+8=4436 + 8 = 44
      • 442=22\frac{44}{2} = 22
      • 22−4=1822 - 4 = 18
    • Conjecture: Performing this multi-step operational sequence on any initial number consistently produces a final output that is exactly three times (3×3\times) the original starting number.

Deductive Reasoning

  • Definition: Deductive reasoning is the process of using general facts, rules, accepted definitions, logical theorems, or algebraic properties to prove a valid specific conclusion.
  • Algebraic Verification Examples:
    • Example 4: Proof of the Expansion (x+y)2=x2+2xy+y2(x + y)^2 = x^2 + 2xy + y^2:
    • Step 1: Definition of the square of an algebraic expression:       (x+y)2=(x+y)(x+y)(x + y)^2 = (x + y)(x + y)
    • Step 2: Apply the distributive property of multiplication over addition:       (x+y)2=x(x+y)+y(x+y)(x + y)^2 = x(x + y) + y(x + y)
    • Step 3: Apply the distributive property a second time:       (x+y)2=x2+xy+xy+y2(x + y)^2 = x^2 + xy + xy + y^2
    • Step 4: Combine like terms using addition:       (x+y)2=x2+2xy+y2(x + y)^2 = x^2 + 2xy + y^2
    • Logical Classification: Because this conclusion is rigorously constructed from standard algebraic laws and definitions, it represents a formal deductive proof.
    • Example 5: Deductive Analysis of an Algebraic Operation:
    • Procedure: Choose a number, add 11 to it, and multiply the resulting sum by one less than the original number. Show that this always yields one less than the square of the original number.
    • Algebraic Proof: Let nn represent the original number.
      • Add 11 to the number: n+1n + 1
      • Multiply by one less than the number (n−1n - 1):         (n+1)(n−1)=n2−1(n + 1)(n - 1) = n^2 - 1
    • Conclusion: Starting with variable nn logically leads to n2−1n^2 - 1, proving deductively that the final result is always one less than the square of the initial number.

Reasoning Classification and Counterexamples

  • Classifying Scenarios as Inductive or Deductive:
    • Scenario 1: Detective Mark Joseph reaches a conclusion about a thief's height because he knows the scientific relationship between a man's height and the distance between footprints.
    • Classification: Deductive Reasoning (Applies an established general rule/formula to a specific instance).
    • Scenario 2: During the past 10 years, the university increased its tuition fees every other year. Because there was a tuition increase last year, there is no increase in tuition fees this year.
    • Classification: Inductive Reasoning (Draws a prediction based on historical observations and empirical patterns).
    • Scenario 3: Examining a sequence of numbers and determining that it is an arithmetic progression.
    • Classification: Inductive Reasoning (Observes specific numerical instances to infer a general sequence rule).
    • Scenario 4: Knowing the length and width of a rectangle, Nadine uses the formula A=LWA = LW to compute the area of the rectangle.
    • Classification: Deductive Reasoning (Uses a known, universal geometric formula to calculate a specific outcome).
  • Counterexamples:
    • Definition: A counterexample is a specific case or exception that shows a statement or conjecture to be false.
    • Significance: It takes only one valid counterexample to completely disprove a general assertion.
    • Examples of Refuting Statements via Counterexamples:
    • Statement 1: "If you are using the internet, then you own a computer."
      • Counterexample: A person could be using the internet on a computer at an internet café or on a public workstation.
    • Statement 2: "If A÷B=1A \div B = 1, then AA and BB are whole numbers."
      • Counterexample: Let A=0.5A = 0.5 and B=0.5B = 0.5. Here 0.50.5=1\frac{0.5}{0.5} = 1, but 0.50.5 is a decimal value, not a whole number.
    • Statement 3: "When James did not eat lunch, he must not feel well."
      • Counterexample: James may feel completely healthy, but was simply not hungry or was observing a religious fast.

Sequences and Sequences Analysis

  • Definition of a Sequence: A sequence is an ordered succession of numbers formed according to a definite rule.
    • Representation: Denoted as a1,a2,a3,…,ana_1, a_2, a_3, \dots, a_n
    • Terms: The numbers ana_n are called the terms or elements of the sequence. a1a_1 represents the first term, a2a_2 the second term, and ana_n the nthn\text{th} term.
    • Finite Sequence: A sequence with a designated last term (a finite count of terms).
    • Infinite Sequence: A sequence that continues indefinitely without a final term.
    • Defining Rule: A sequence is well-defined when an explicit rule or mathematical formula provides the value of the nthn\text{th} term (ana_n) for every positive integer n$.\n* **Primary Types of Sequences**:\n * **Arithmetic Sequence**: A sequence of numbers in which each term after the first is obtained by adding a fixed constant, called the **common difference** (d), to the preceding term.\n * **Geometric Sequence**: A sequence of numbers in which each term after the first is obtained by multiplying the preceding term by a fixed constant, called the **common ratio** (r).\n* **Determining the n\text{th}TermFormula(Term Formula (a_n)**:\n * **Example 8**: Sequence 1, 8, 27, 64, 125, \dots\n * Relationship: Terms correspond to cubing the term index n((1^3 = 1,,2^3 = 8,,3^3 = 27,,4^3 = 64,,5^3 = 125).\n * Formula: a_n = n^3\n * Next Term (a_6):):a_6 = 6^3 = 216\n * **Example 9**: Sequence 3, 6, 9, 12, 15, 18, 21, \dots\n * Relationship: Terms increase by a constant difference of 3((d = 3).\n * Term Index Analysis:\n * For n = 1::a_1 = 3 \times 1 = 3\n * For n = 2::a_2 = 3 \times 2 = 6\n * For n = 3::a_3 = 3 \times 3 = 9\n * Formula: a_n = 3n\n * Next Term (a_8):):a_8 = 3 \times 8 = 24\n * **Example 10: Non-Linear Difference Analysis (3, 9, 25, 51, 87, \dots)**:\n * First Differences between adjacent terms:\n * 9 - 3 = 6\n * 25 - 9 = 16\n * 51 - 25 = 26\n * 87 - 51 = 36\n * Second Differences:\n * 16 - 6 = 10\n * 26 - 16 = 10\n * 36 - 26 = 10\n * Next First Difference: 36 + 10 = 46\n * Next Term Calculation (a_6):):87 + 46 = 133\n* **Applying the Arithmetic Sequence Formula (a_n = a_1 + (n - 1)d)**:\n * **Problem A**: Find the 100\text{th}termofterm of1, 7, 13, \dots\n * Parameters: a_1 = 1,,d = 7 - 1 = 6,,n = 100\n * Calculation:\n      a_{100} = 1 + (100 - 1) \times 6\n      a_{100} = 1 + 99 \times 6\n      a_{100} = 1 + 594 = 595\n * **Problem B**: Find the 16\text{th}termofterm of2, 6, 10, \dots\n * Parameters: a_1 = 2,,d = 6 - 2 = 4,,n = 16\n * Calculation:\n      a_{16} = 2 + (16 - 1) \times 4\n      a_{16} = 2 + 15 \times 4\n      a_{16} = 2 + 60 = 62\n\n# Polya's Four-Step Problem-Solving Technique\n\n* **Historical Origin**: Developed by mathematician George Polya and published in his landmark 1945 book, *"How to Solve It"*.\n* **Detailed Four-Step Structure**:\n * **Step 1: Understand the Problem**:\n * Restate the problem clearly in your own words.\n * Identify all given quantitative and qualitative data.\n * Explicitly state what is required to be found.\n * Identify and eliminate any extraneous information.\n * Draw diagrams or visualize the problem scenario.\n * **Step 2: Devise a Plan**:\n * List given information and check unit consistency (perform required conversions).\n * Assign variables to unknown quantities and construct equations.\n * Draw diagrams, make organized tables, or search for numerical patterns.\n * Consider solving a simpler related problem, working backwards, experimenting, or trying systematic guess-and-check.\n * **Step 3: Carry Out the Plan**:\n * Execute the selected strategy with precision and clear step-by-step documentation.\n * Practice patience; if the initial strategy fails, revise the approach or implement an alternative plan.\n * **Step 4: Review the Solution (Looking Back)**:\n * Double-check answers against all original problem constraints.\n * Ensure the calculated values fall within reasonable limits.\n * Determine whether the solution method can be generalized to other mathematical problems.\n\n# Applied Problem Solving Using Polya's Method\n\n* **Problem 1: Coin Value Word Problem**:\n * *Problem*: Tiffany has \text{P } 3.05 in 5-centavo and 10-centavo coins. If there are 19 more 5-centavo coins than 10-centavo coins, how many coins of each kind does she have?\n * *Step 1 (Understand)*: Determine the count of 10-centavo (\text{P } 0.10)and5−centavo() and 5-centavo (\text{P } 0.05)coinsthatsumto) coins that sum to\text{P } 3.05, given that 5-centavo coins exceed 10-centavo coins by 19.\n * *Step 2 (Plan)*: Let xrepresentthenumberof10−centavocoins,makingrepresent the number of 10-centavo coins, makingx + 19 the number of 5-centavo coins. Express monetary values in pesos to set up an equation.\n * *Step 3 (Carry Out)*:\n    0.10x + 0.05(x + 19) = 3.05\n    0.10x + 0.05x + 0.95 = 3.05\n    0.15x = 2.10\n    x = \frac{2.10}{0.15} = 14\n    10-centavo coins = 14\n    5-centavo coins = 14 + 19 = 33\n * *Step 4 (Review)*: 33is19morethanis 19 more than14.Totalvaluecheck:. Total value check:0.10(14) + 0.05(33) = 1.40 + 1.65 = 3.05. The solution is verified.\n* **Problem 2: Age Ratio Word Problem**:\n * *Problem*: Fred is three times as old as his sister Mary. Four years ago, he was five times as old as his sister. How old are they now?\n * *Step 1 (Understand)*: Find the present ages of Fred and Mary given their current age ratio (3:1)andtheirageratio4yearsago() and their age ratio 4 years ago (5:1).\n * *Step 2 (Plan)*: Let xbeMary′scurrentageandbe Mary's current age and3x be Fred's current age. Create an age matrix for present and past values.\n * *Step 3 (Carry Out)*:\n * Age Matrix:\n * Mary: Present = x,Past(4yearsago)=, Past (4 years ago) =x - 4\n * Fred: Present = 3x,Past(4yearsago)=, Past (4 years ago) =3x - 4\n * Past Age Equation:\n      3x - 4 = 5(x - 4)\n      3x - 4 = 5x - 20\n      2x = 16\n      x = 8 (Mary's present age)\n      3x = 24 (Fred's present age)\n * *Step 4 (Review)*: 24is3timesis 3 times8.Fouryearsago,Fredwas. Four years ago, Fred was20andMarywasand Mary was4;;20 = 5 \times 4. Ages are confirmed.\n* **Problem 3: Motion and Velocity Word Problem**:\n * *Problem*: Mario took 3 minutes and 45 seconds to complete a race while Manny took 4 minutes. Find their rates if Manny runs 0.40\,\text{m/s} slower than Mario.\n * *Step 1 (Understand)*: Determine running rates in \text{m/s} given completion times and speed difference over an identical distance.\n * *Step 2 (Plan)*: Convert times into seconds. Let rbeMario′srateinbe Mario's rate in\text{m/s},making, makingr - 0.40Manny′srate.Equatethedistancesrun(Manny's rate. Equate the distances run (\text{Distance} = \text{rate} \times \text{time}).\n * *Step 3 (Carry Out)*:\n * Time Conversions:\n * Mario: 3(60) + 45 = 225\,\text{seconds}\n * Manny: 4(60) = 240\,\text{seconds}\n * Distance Equation:\n      225r = 240(r - 0.40)\n      225r = 240r - 96\n      15r = 96\n      r = 6.4\,\text{m/s} (Mario's rate)\n      r - 0.40 = 6.0\,\text{m/s} (Manny's rate)\n * *Step 4 (Review)*: Mario's distance = 225 \times 6.4 = 1440\,\text{m}.Manny′sdistance=. Manny's distance =240 \times 6.0 = 1440\,\text{m}. Results are correct.\n* **Problem 4: Combinatorics without Repetition**:\n * *Problem*: Given six available digits {2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 9} without repetition:\n * a) How many 3-digit numbers can be formed?\n * b) How many are less than 400?\n * c) How many are even?\n * *Step 1 (Understand)*: Form 3-digit numbers using 6 available distinct digits without repeating any digit.\n * *Step 2 & 3 (Carry Out)*:\n * **Part a (Total 3-digit numbers)**:\n * Hundreds place: 6 options\n * Tens place: 5 options\n * Units place: 4 options\n * Total = 6 \times 5 \times 4 = 120 numbers\n * **Part b (Numbers less than 400)**:\n * Hundreds place restriction: Digits 2oror3((2 options)\n * Tens place: 5 options remaining\n * Units place: 4 options remaining\n * Total = 2 \times 5 \times 4 = 40 numbers\n * **Part c (Even numbers)**:\n * Units place restriction: Digits 2oror6((2 options)\n * Tens place: 5 options remaining\n * Hundreds place: 4 options remaining\n * Total = 4 \times 5 \times 2 = 40 numbers\n* **Problem 5: Geometry Dimensions Problem**:\n * *Problem*: The perimeter of a rectangle is 68\,\text{m}andthelengthisand the length is14\,\text{m} more than the width. Find the dimensions.\n * *Solution*:\n * Let width = wandlength=and length =w + 14\n * Perimeter formula: P = 2l + 2w = 68\n * 2(w + 14) + 2w = 68\n * 2w + 28 + 2w = 68\n * 4w = 40 \implies w = 10\,\text{m}\n * Length = 10 + 14 = 24\,\text{m}\n * Dimensions: Width = 10\,\text{m},Length=, Length =24\,\text{m}\n* **Problem 6: Division and Remainder Problem**:\n * *Problem*: The sum of two numbers is 36. If the larger is divided by the smaller, the quotient is 2 and the remainder is 3. Find the numbers.\n * *Solution*:\n * Let smaller number = xandlargernumber=and larger number =y\n * Equation 1: x + y = 36 \implies y = 36 - x\n * Equation 2: y = 2x + 3\n * Substitute: 36 - x = 2x + 3\n * 3x = 33 \implies x = 11 (smaller number)\n * y = 36 - 11 = 25 (larger number)\n * The two numbers are 11andand25.\n* **Problem 7: Multi-Person Age Problem**:\n * *Problem*: John is twice as old as Peter. Peter is 5 years older than Alice. In 5 years, John will be three times as old as Alice. How old is Peter now?\n * *Solution*:\n * Let x = Peter's current age\n * Current Ages: Peter = x,John=, John =2x,Alice=, Alice =x - 5\n * Ages in 5 Years: Peter = x + 5,John=, John =2x + 5,Alice=, Alice =(x - 5) + 5 = x\n * Future Age Equation: 2x + 5 = 3x \implies x = 5\n * Peter is currently 5$$ years old.

Academic References

  • Mathematics of the Modern World by E. Rosalena and J. Siangco
  • College Algebra by Spiegel and Moyer