Notes from 'My Savage,' 'My Man': Racial Multiplicity in Robinson Crusoe
Introduction to Racial Multiplicity in Robinson Crusoe
- Daniel Defoe's Robinson Crusoe has fascinated critics, particularly regarding Crusoe's relationship with Friday.
- Twentieth-century scholars have been slow to address the dynamic of race in the novel.
- Earlier analyses often neglect the nuances of race in the 18th century, applying contemporary paradigms instead.
- The essay aims to develop a different approach to 18th-century ideas about race and Crusoe's relations with non-British men.
The Significance of Racial Multiplicity
- Reading for racial multiplicity allows for a better analysis of race as an emergent concept in the early 18th century.
- The binary of black and white is inadequate for understanding the representation of race or colonial relations.
- Racialized categories beyond skin color, such as "savage," "Christian," and "slave," complicate the understanding of race at this time.
- Focusing on color alone cannot explain the juxtapositions of the British with other Europeans, Moors, West Africans, or Native Caribbeans in Robinson Crusoe.
- Studying multiple meanings does not erase colonial hierarchies but registers the complexity of their operation.
Analysis of Racial Representation
- The analysis examines the novel's representation of racial multiplicity and its engagement with 18th-century articulations of race and colonial power.
- It demonstrates how Robinson Crusoe defines boundaries between people in racialized terms.
- The novel's difficulty in situating Friday in a stable category (Carib, cannibal, or slave) is central to its analysis.
- This reflects a larger cultural uncertainty about the significance of racial difference in the early 18th century.
Toni Morrison's Contemporary Reading
- Toni Morrison's analogy of Robinson Crusoe to Clarence Thomas's position in U.S. racial politics (1992).
- Morrison identifies Crusoe's relationship with Friday as paradigmatic of colonial relations.
- Homogenizing race to a rigid binary divorces the literary work from its social text.
Morrison's "Friday on the Potomac"
- Juxtaposes Clarence Thomas's Senate confirmation hearings to Robinson Crusoe.
- The analogy critiques U.S. politics and unveils racial discrimination.
- The Senate Judiciary Committee and the media coverage of the hearings situated the two main players on an historical binary depicting Africans in slavery: the "tom" (Clarence Thomas) and the "savage" (Anita Hill).
- Morrison's interpretation represented a process "to reorder those signifying fictions ['natural servant' and 'savage demon']."
Rewriting Racial Dynamics
- Morrison's essay significantly changes the racial dynamics depicted in Robinson Crusoe to characterize modern race relations in the United States.
- She mistakenly recalls the novel's origin, confusing Selkirk's story with the finding of an "almost drowned Indian".
- Morrison conflates instances of solitary individuals on Juan Fernandez Island, misremembering Will, the Mosquito Indian, and Alexander Selkirk.
- She replaces Friday (an Amerindian) with a character she refers to as a "black," "savage," "cannibal."
Misremembering Friday
- Morrison recalls a fiction of the fiction, describing the Indian as a 'savage cannibal' within Defoe's novel.
- She characterizes Crusoe's narrative as civilizing a "black, barbarous, stupid, servile, adoring" man to be like a white one.
- However, in the novel, the "savage" is a Carib, attached to a group with specific customs, religious and social beliefs, and rules of governance.
- While agreeing that Friday is taught to be like a white man (a servant), the extended analogy significantly rewrites the original.
Detachment from Historical Conditions
- The Robinson Crusoe myth detaches itself from 18th-century historical conditions in Morrison's analysis.
- Morrison misremembers not only Selkirk but also Robinson Crusoe, recalling an African Friday rather than a Caribbean Friday.
- In the novel, Friday is neither "black," "stupid," nor considered "biologically handicapped."
- These stereotypical features reflect 19th-century racism and a post-Civil Rights critique, acting as a proxy for all oppressed groups.
Internalized Racism
- Morrison observes that the interaction between Crusoe and Friday takes place on Crusoe's terms.
- She comments on Friday's assimilation into British culture, the loss of his "mother tongue," and the consequences for internalizing the norms of the master's language.
- She concludes that "both men [Thomas and Friday] … are condemned … never to utter one single sentence understood to be beneficial to their original culture."
- This critique, however, erases the Caribbean Friday and associates blackness exclusively with servility.
Political Hegemony in the United States
- Current political hegemony in the United States constructs only one other at a time.
- If the black/white color binary breaks down, it is in racist ways, such as the construction of a "model minority."
- Only one group at a time is positioned as other, marginalized, or disenfranchised.
- In the quintecentenary of Columbus's "discovery," Friday becomes an allegory for an African-American man.
Contradictions in Racial Politics
- Morrison's critique allows us to read contradictions in dominant United States's racial politics.
- Substituting a black Friday repeats the material eradication of native Indian cultures.
- This replacement fails to articulate historical connections and discontinuities between native Caribbean populations and Africans.
- By linking Robinson Crusoe to contemporary race relations, Morrison's essay demonstrates the way that race has become inextricably linked to negritude in the United States.
Binary Racial Understandings
- Morrison's elisions appear symptomatic of binary racial understandings and the ways that critical attention to differences between non-Europeans is often collapsed and confused in Robinson Crusoe.
- The novel is caught in the shift from a subsistence-based to profit-oriented colonial economy dependent on African slaves.
- Its ideology manifests a desire for European difference constructed in relation to Caribbean peoples.
Colonial Discourse
- Robinson Crusoe is framed as a study of colonial discourse and the significance of cannibalism to constructions of European identity.
- Critics emphasize the novel's construction of difference, as power relations in the Atlantic benefited Europeans.
- The Caribbean is linked to other aspects of colonialism in the early 18th century.
- The novel produces both racial difference and racial multiplicity.
Colonial Factors Driving the Plot
- Several colonial factors give impetus to the plot:
- Crusoe's desire to improve his station.
- Fear of bodily harm from the Caribs.
- Necessity of eradicating the cannibals.
- Desire to domesticate Friday.
Crusoe's Desires for Advancement
- Crusoe's desires for advancement beyond his allotted station propel the plot forward.
- These goals result from capital accumulation made possible through global trade and colonization.
- Expanded trade routes and new colonies altered economies to satisfy British consumer desire.
- Crusoe's wish for advancement materializes when he joins a trading expedition to Guinea.
Economic Progression
- The voyage to Guinea makes Crusoe both a sailor and a merchant; he brings back gold dust worth x300.
- This wealth leads to another African voyage, but Moorish pirates take him prisoner and he is enslaved in Morocco.
- Upon escaping the Moors, a Portuguese captain allows Crusoe to sell his stolen property, including Xury, for a considerable sum.
- Crusoe sets up as a planter in Brazil, hoping to increase his fortune.
Plantation Economics
- Crusoe follows the pattern of European settlement in the Americas by buying land and working it.
- He and his neighbor initially plant for food, then tobacco, but they both need help.
- Crusoe purchases European and African labor to improve his profits.
- His excessive desire for advancing rapidly leads him to act as a slave trader.
- A shipwreck on a third voyage to Africa leads to his arrival on the island.
Island Economics
- A similar pattern repeats itself on the island:
- He acquires land.
- Improves it with his own labor.
- Acquires Friday as additional labor power.
- Before Friday, Crusoe's desires dissipate because there are no competitors; he is lord of the manor.
- There is neither surplus nor a circuit of exchange.
The Shift in Motivation
- When Crusoe's pecuniary desires subside, the fear of cannibals takes over as the driving force of the plot.
- The fear of cannibals renews his desire to escape, but the desire to domesticate Friday soon substitutes for it.
- The novel ends with Crusoe's return to Europe as a wealthy planter and with a synopsis of his island colony's violent fate.
Colonial Narrative
- Robinson Crusoe is best understood as a colonial narrative.
- The novel establishes Crusoe's method of rising in the world as possible because of a developed colonial labor force and the demands of trade.
- African trade, particularly in slaves, provides Crusoe's capital and labor base for his sugar production in Brazil.
- Robinson Crusoe rehearses the early stages of European colonial contact twice, in Brazil and then on the Caribbean island, depicting the shift from planting to a profit-oriented economy.
Emphasis on Differences
- The difference between Crusoe and others is clear in terms of establishing the superiority of enslaver to enslaved.
- He trades in Africans, sells Xury as a slave, and relegates Friday to perpetual servitude.
- Despite the emphasis on differences, Robinson Crusoe corresponds to a stage when the representation of differences was not as concrete as it became later.
Multiplicity vs. Difference
- Multiplicity, not simply difference, is produced in relation to Crusoe, Xury, and Friday.
- Focusing on difference and multiplicity analyzes the complexity of colonial power relations and racial oppression.
- Emphasizing difference and multiplicity means that we can read Robinson Crusoe as a vindication of the European, specifically the British, colonial spirit and yet that such a method reveals its fissures.
Categories of Race
- Categories of the savage (cannibal), Carib, Christian, and slave/servant are examined.
- Race as we understand it today did not anchor European difference and cannot adequately analyze colonial relations.
- Only some differences could justify European domination, not including skin color or status by themselves.
- "Savage" and "Christian" are more applicable categories than "slave."
Savage and Christian
- The savage and the Christian are the most important racialized categories that help produce and maintain a sense of European superiority.
- Racial multiplicity is analyzed in terms of the several categories pertinent to early 18th-century ideas of race.
Crusoe's Early Encounters
- Robinson Crusoe locates the main character in Britain, Africa, and Brazil.
- His significant relations are with the Moors, Africans, Xury, and other Europeans, specifically the Portuguese.
- The racialized categories are the savage, the Christian, and the slave.
- Analyzing these boundaries shows that both difference and multiplicity are relevant to reading Robinson Crusoe.
Xury and Friday
- By focusing on Xury and Crusoe, the similarities of this relationship to Crusoe's subsequent relationship to Friday are demonstrated.
- In both cases, the novel depicts Crusoe's association with a younger, non-European man who does not easily fall into categories of difference.
- Colonialism structures a relation in which Crusoe acquires a non-European man as a (naturalized) servant.
Narrative Functions
- In Africa, piracy fills the narrative function that the hurricane does in the Caribbean, situating Crusoe in an historical power struggle.
- The Moors serve a similar narrative function to the Caribs later.
- For both Xury and Friday, the issue of their status hinges on Christianity.
- The relation between Xury and Crusoe (and then between Crusoe and Friday) alters in relation to the presence of other Europeans.
Conceptual Unity
- Difference and multiplicity cannot be separated conceptually.
- The depiction of Crusoe's enslavement in Morocco by a Turkish pirate begins to emphasize this issue.
- Crusoe's status is most compromised and his body suspended from its self-mastery in slavery.
- Thousands of Europeans were enslaved by the Moors, and some became wealthy renegades by converting to Islam.
Crusoe's Enslavement
- Crusoe becomes a prisoner to a pirate and then his household slave.
- His change of fortune results in a temporary change of status from a merchant to a slave, a change that has nothing to do with his national or personal essence.
- National identities are thrown together by the fortunes of international power differences.
- The novel offers Crusoe's ingenuity in escaping as a significant difference between Crusoe and other slaves.
Multiplicity in Slavery
- Multiplicity is produced in terms of the category of slave because Crusoe is a European Christian.
- The enslavement of European Christians is a little remembered historical phenomenon.
- The section on Crusoe in Sallee suggests that he was treated more as a household servant than a slave.
- The novel seems quite clear about the difference between Moors and West Africans; Moors are neither savage, naked, nor unfamiliar.
Moors vs. Amerindians
- The Moors who enslave Crusoe are represented as frightening, attributing such a depiction to their centuries of maritime and financial power.
- Slavery does not appear to be a particularly clear boundary of permanent difference between people.
- In the novel, slaves are Marescos and European Christians as well as Africans and Amerindians.
- Robinson Crusoe constructs black African savagery as the most significant difference to Europeans rather than European slavery in Morocco or the Muslim religion.
Savagery vs. Slavery
- Savagery rather than slavery constitutes the dominant contrast to Europeans.
- Crusoe and Xury sail southward from Morocco to the "truly Barbarian coast."
- Even though Crusoe fears human savages in Africa, the text offers savage animals instead.
- Crusoe laments "the horrible noises, and hideous cryes and howlings" on the African shore.
Africans and Cannibalism
- The West Africans' skin color and nakedness most clearly separate them from Crusoe and Xury.
- Crusoe's fear of African cannibals is completely unfounded.
- The people bring him food and water, and the novel reveals that these "savages" simply eat wild beasts, not men.
- It is important to note that after his encounter with the West Africans, Crusoe's earlier fear of African savages has been replaced entirely with a fear of savage animals in Africa.
Caribs as Cannibals
- The novel does not strictly maintain the savagery of the Africans as it does the Caribs'.
- The only "real" cannibals, then, are the Amerindians, whose several feasts punctuate the latter part of Crusoe's island sojourn.
- Crusoe's relationship to Xury has been interpreted typically as that of master to slave.
Xury and Crusoe similarities and differences
- Xury and Crusoe resemble each other more than they are dissimilar; Crusoe's greater age seems the only difference between the two slaves.
- The similarity between Xury and Crusoe is further emphasized because of their common difference from the Moors.
- Once out of the context of slavery, a different configuration is formed-first in relation to black Africans and then in relation to Christian Europeans.
Xury fears and position
- When they escape, Xury and Crusoe are allied in their fear of the Moors who enslaved them and then in their fear of the "real" savages, the West Africans.
- The potential danger of the "wild mans" and the resulting fear of being eaten lead Crusoe to notice that which most clearly separates Xury and himself from the West Africans: their skin color and nakedness.
- While Xury's status is neither as powerful as Crusoe's nor as abject as the Africans' on the west coast, his position in the novel is not as clear as it might be.
Xury status in the novel
- Household slave like Crusoe, he is also a European--but not a Christian.
- In most cases, the Marescos had been violently segregated from the Christian population in Spain since the sixteenth century, and they often worked on behalf of the African Moors, especially the pirates.
- Marescos therefore occupied a complex position, considered neither fully European nor fully Moor.
- Upon escape from Sallee, Xury's "worth" as a person is compromised from the beginning because it is construed only in terms of his usefulness to Crusoe.
Crusoe's age and initiative position Xury as a servant:
- Crusoe orders him to perform menial tasks.
- Yet Xury also advises Crusoe and they hunt together in Africa.
- Theirs is not a relation of equals but roles that can be assumed by a trusty servant in relation to a master:
- Friday and Crusoe repeat such a pattern later.
Portuguese influence and Xury
- The arrival of the Portuguese slave ship alters Xury's status vis-a-vis Crusoe even further.
- If the least difference between Xury and Crusoe occurs when they are slaves to the Moors, the greatest difference occurs when they are in the presence of other Europeans.
- In this context, Crusoe assumes the position of the owner of the stolen goods and boat from Morocco.
- The Catholic Portuguese captain treats Crusoe as an equal, even though he possesses only the stolen boat-and Xury.
European Friendships
- The captain offers to purchase Crusoe's goods and saves his life.
- Xury's status seems to slip from servant and occasional partner to a slave because he is considered a legitimate object of exchange.
- Xury's position as an object of exchange between the two European men becomes a sign of their friendship and equality.
- Crusoe's reluctance to part with Xury prompts the captain to mitigate Xury's permanent servitude to a temporary term.
Xury's enslavement and salvation
- The eventual terms of Xury's sale are more akin to indentured servitude than to permanent enslavement,
- Xury's economic mobility and ability to be a "free" subject are silenced by the Europeans' ostensible concern for his spiritual welfare.
- The importance of Christianity as a significant bond between Europeans overrides even historical differences between Protestants and Catholics.
Christianity overrides all obstacles
- Christianity represents the most significant category of difference that excuses European domination and establishes the conditions for enslavement.
- Xury, however, is not the "permanent" savage or slave; he is linked to Europeans by his shared fear of being eaten by the "wild mans" on the west coast of Africa.
- A household slave has he is a European
To account for the changeability of Xury's position, it is necessary to bring the categories "European," "Christian," and "Muslim" to bear on the juxtaposition of the Englishman Crusoe and the Maresco Xury to the Moors, West Africans, and Portuguese.
Xury national origins and islamic ties
- Clearly it is important to identify the nuances between Xury's national origins, which separate him from west coast Africans (and from Friday), and Xury's Islamic associations, a religious category that compromises the similarity to Crusoe.
- The sale of Xury establishes Crusoe in Brazil as a land-rich plantation owner.
- Twice in the novel, Crusoe regrets parting with Xury, not out of loneliness or ethical regret, but because he wishes to command his labor power.
Property of landowners
- The ownership of property-land and slaves-permits the apparent equality of different nationals of European descent on the Portuguese ship and in Brazil.
- The status of European men in a colonial economy depends on the labor supply they command to determine their rank (in South America the labor supply was overwhelmingly either native Amerindian or African).
Slavery in Colonial Economy
- An important explanation for the absence of strife either between countrymen or other European nationals involves shared economic benefits in the Atlantic empire.
- The hospitality of the Africans replaces their savagery, though their complexion and lack of clothing still visibly distinguish them from Europeans and from Xury.
Slavery through out history
- For the Maresco Xury to be positioned as the naturalized slave rather than a West African speaks volumes about the significance of his religious status in comparison to other racialized categories at this time.
- The signification of "slave" as black African seems fairly stable in this instance.
Complex Relations.
- Because Crusoe connects the ugliness of their skin color to a general sense of their disagreeableness.
Multiplicity disrupts the establishment of boundaries but has 3 major functions/related issues:
1) the construction of Friday as neither a savage nor an African in the novel
2) the depiction of Friday and the Caribs as Africans on the 1720 frontispiece to Serious Reflections on the Life and Surprizing Adventures of Robinson Crusoe, and
3) the changeability of Friday's status as a savage, servant, or a slave. While Friday displays a lingering penchant for human flesh and is reluctant to give up his belief in Benamuckee, the novel distinguishes Friday from other savages in remarkable ways.
Crusoe's faith
- The most thoughtful passages on the novel focus on faith and the unfairness of who gets to heaven.
Christian European vs Savage
- Christian is used more than white in terms of identity.
- Between the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, the most important category of difference, Christian, became less dominant: in addition to religion, European and national origin, slavery, and/or skin color all served as competing divisions between Europeans and people both of Amerindian and African descent.
European Connections + Spanish role
- European is associated with skin color and connection to Europe based on trade ports.
- The Spanish occupy the hybrid position that it fails to explain but says that it exists.
- European men have to work to survive in this time, which is different.
The most important attributes in a Savage + Christianity
- Canbolism, Paganism and nakedness/lack of clothing- Crusoe can't bear a naked body b/c its a savage trait.
Clothing + Skin- Palpably seen kinship will lead to destruction as an act of the others
Crusoe and Fridays Connections.
- The connection between white bearded men will have them kill people as a group.