Chapter 2 Study Guide: Understanding Small Group Communication Theory
We look for patterns everyday and we naturally theorize. This process allows us to make sense of our experiences and improve our interactions within groups. This group processess is filled with repetitive phonomena.
The Nature of Theory and the Theory-Building Proces
Theories are born out of repetitive patterns and observations that help us predict and explain phenomena . Theories and small groups help us understand ourseves, others and navigate complexity of small groups. Theories are interrelated facts, observations, and ideas that explains or predicts something.
theories can be formal or informal. Sometimes theories help us make intelliigent decisions. Some theories are explanitory (helps us understand why), some are predictive (guesses).
Everyday Theories: Theories are encountered daily in contexts ranging from academic classrooms and daily conversations to newscasts, political debates, and entertainment (such as fictitious detectives developing theories of crimes to predict outcomes in crime dramas). Examples include evolution, climate change, and the "Big Bang."
Definition of Theory: A set of interrelated facts, observations, and ideas that explains or predicts something. Theory-building is a basic human activity performed when individuals reflect on past events and make decisions based on those reflections.
Two Basic Functions of Theory:
Explanatory Function: Explains how or why phenomena occur by organizing available facts and observations.
Predictive Function: Enables reasonable predictions about future events under similar circumstances, allowing individuals to adapt or control their behavior.
The Process of Theory Building (Grocery Shopping Scenario):
Observing a Phenomenon: Recognizing a repeated pattern of events that requires an explanation (e.g., arriving at the grocery store every Thursday after a late-afternoon class with no waiting lines, but facing at least one person per lane and a wait upon reaching the checkout later).
Organizing Facts and Formulating Explanation: Evaluating variables such as arrival time () and checkout time () to deduce that thousands of workers head home from work during this interval and stop at the store.
Predicting and Adapting: Using the explanation to predict that shopping after a late-afternoon class will repeatedly lead to long lines, enabling behavioral adaptation (e.g., shopping earlier or later in the day).
Theory and Self-Concept ("Self-Theory"):
Definition and Origin: Self-concept emerges as a consequence of interactions with others, beginning with childhood caregivers.
Mechanism: An individual behaves, others respond, and the individual observes these responses to formulate a self-concept based on the reflected appraisals of others.
Function: Explains the self to the self, enabling individuals to predict their own behaviors, act consistently with their self-concept, and select realistic goals.
Theory and Group Communication:
George Kelly's Definition: "A theory may be considered as a way of binding together a multitude of facts so that one may comprehend them all at once. When the theory enables us to make reasonably precise predictions, one may call it scientific."
Application: Explanatory power makes sense of complex group interactions, while predictive precision allows group members to anticipate communicative outcomes and adjust behaviors to increase group effectiveness and satisfaction.
Theory as a Practical Approach to Group Communication
Pre-existing Theories Brought to Groups: Members enter small group meetings with theories regarding themselves (self-concept), other group members, and groups in general.
Influence of Beliefs on Outcomes:
Members holding negative theories about groups (e.g., believing "a camel is a horse designed by committee" or "if you really want something done, do it yourself") act in ways that reinforce group ineffectiveness.
Members believing that groups can operate effectively adjust their behavior to contribute constructively.
The Explanatory Function in Groups:
Helps diagnose group needs by explaining why certain groups are effective while others fail, or why specific leadership styles fit particular situations.
Serves as the essential first step in understanding group dynamics to improve group processes.
The Predictive Function in Groups:
Parallels medical diagnosis: diagnosis (explanation) is a necessary prerequisite to treatment (prediction/intervention).
Allows members to select specific behaviors to achieve group goals by predicting which outcomes follow specific actions.
Time Estimation Tendency: Group discussion predictions regarding task duration tend to be significantly more optimistic than individual predictions due to the belief that "many hands make light work." This often leads to unrealistic time estimates and missed deadlines. Recognizing this allows leaders or members to moderate the effect by allocating additional time.
Process Theories vs. Method Theories:
Process Theories: Theories that explain group and team phenomena. (provides the why, and allows us to better understand why).
Method Theories: Prescriptive ("how-to") theories useful for establishing structured formats for problem-solving and conflict resolution. (predictive)
Communication as Sense-Making in Small Groups
Definition of Human Communication: A transactive process by which individuals make sense of the world and share that sense with others. Communication is the vehicle that drives a group toward its goals.
Dean Barnlund's Definition: "Communication occurs any time meaning is assigned to an internal or external stimulus."
Intrapersonal Sense-Making: Assigning verbal meaning to internal or external stimuli to organize and clarify experience (e.g., feeling a reflex shivering response in a cold room and assigning the word "cold" reduces uncertainty about the environment).
Interpersonal Sense-Making: Progressively discovering what makes another person unique by building explanations based on their beliefs, attitudes, values, and personality to predict future responses and guide personal behavior.
Uncertainty Reduction: Getting to know others is a process of progressively reducing uncertainty (the state of being unable to predict future events).
The Six Personas in One-on-One Communication: Whenever two individuals communicate, at least are involved:
Who you think you are.
Who you think the other person is.
Who you think the other person thinks you are.
Who the other person thinks they are.
Who the other person thinks you are.
Who the other person thinks you think they are.
Complexity in Small Group Relationships:
Complexity increases exponentially with group size. In an group, thousands of perceptual factors interact (e.g., "who I think Ted thinks Rosa thinks Amit is").
Group Beliefs and Performance: Beliefs about group capability directly impact performance. Experiments manipulating feedback (inaccurately reporting high or low baseline performance) demonstrate that false performance feedback influences actual subsequent performance outcomes.
Decision-Making Apprehension: Group decisions involve uncertainty, leading members to view decision-making tasks with apprehension and anticipation of regret.
The 5 Communication Theories
Overview: Because small group communication involves vast variables, no single theory accounts for all interactions. Five holistic theoretical perspectives are utilized:
Systems Theory
Social Exchange Theory
Symbolic Convergence Theory
Structuration Theory
Functional Theory (we will not be covering this this chapter)
1. Systems Theory- all individual components together, the collective output is better. SYNNERGY!!
Definition: The most prevalent theoretical framework; views the small group as an open system of interdependent elements. This theory used to compare it to a machine, however it has shifted to an analogy of an organism analogy. This shift emphasizes the dynamic and adaptive nature of groups, highlighting how they evolve and respond to their environment as a cohesive unit. Your body reacts to the environment, and so does group communication in the systems theory
Body Analogy: Like physiological systems (digestive, nervous, circulatory) that depend on internal organ harmony and react to external environmental changes (e.g., higher elevations cause rapid breathing; higher temperatures induce sweating), small groups process environmental inputs to produce outputs.
Key Elements of Systems Theory:
Openness to Environment: Groups interact continually with external environments (e.g., member turnover, organization goal changes, or weather events like snowstorms canceling meetings or sunny days causing mind-wandering).
Interdependence: Components are interrelated such that a change in one alters all others (e.g., changes in cohesiveness or losing/adding a member ripple through the entire system. A weak group member will weigh down the group eventually).
Input Variables: Resources brought into the group, including members, funds, tools, knowledge, organizational relationships, purpose, and physical environment.
Process Variables: Procedures and interactional behaviors followed by the group to reach goals. Can be subject to environmental and interpersonal challenges.
Output Variables: Outcomes of the group process, including decisions, solutions, personal growth, and member satisfaction. What you are actually producing (slides, projects, presentations).
Synergy: Occurs when the whole is greater than the sum of its individual parts. Group performance often excels beyond individual capabilities. The more a group has synergy, the BETTER the group preforms, you can predict others move, you can be flexible and adapt to changing situations, fostering a collaborative atmosphere that encourages innovative solutions and enhances overall effectiveness.
Entropy: The measure of randomness or chaos in a system. Systems decay over time unless counteracted by active maintenance (e.g., separated interpersonal relationships cool without communication; groups experience entropy when meetings are neglected, members flake, or lack engagement, leading to a decline in group cohesion and productivity).
Equifinality: The principle stating that an open system can reach its final state through multiple paths and from different initial states. There are many ways to get to an outcome, sometimes groups take different paths. Maybe you dont have the right input variables, or the process is weak, and can lead to inefficiencies in group outcomes. Therefore, it's crucial to assess both the quality of input and the effectiveness of processes in order to foster successful group dynamics.
2. Social Exchange Theory- borrows from Psych and Economics
Definition: Explains human behavior and group attraction in terms of rewards, costs, profits, and losses. It compares interactions as economy terms. You must ask the question of “is this group worth it, do the gains outweigh the costs?”
Core Variables: in order to look at the profit (or benefit of working with a group), should be worth the cost minus the rewards. If the profit is negative, or the profit is not as high as you want, it might be more beneficial to leave the group.
Rewards: Pleasurable outcomes, including fellowship, job satisfaction, achievement, status, and meeting personal goals.
Costs: Negative outcomes, including mental effort, anxiety, embarrassment, time, effort, and frustration.
Social Capital: The sway you have in social settings. It is not just a popularity contest. You are building up your trustworthyness in your group, so that when you inevitably make mistakes, your group will forgive you and help you move on. You must be proactive to have a social capital in the positives. Building social capital requires investing time and effort into relationships, demonstrating reliability, and actively participating in group activities.
Mathematical Relationship: Mechanics: Group membership remains attractive as long as profit is positive ().
Community Theater Case Study: Members identified meeting people and performance opportunities as primary rewards, and identified disorganization, lack of coordination, and time issues as primary costs.
Limitations: Fails to account for the impact of gender and power dynamics within groups.
3. Symbolic Convergence Theory- Describes a groups’s identity and culture develops through shared fantasies.
Definition: Explains how communication shapes group identity and culture through shared stories and fantasies, creating a collective consciousness (shared emotions, motives, and meanings). Humans in a group will take on a shared group identity, and will get stronger overtime. (Groups will pass on the stories/fantasies/identity to new members to keep the tradition alive. EX: Sorrority explaining to new recruits what they stand for and what their traditions are. EX 2: founding fathers sharing the fantasy of what it means to be american).
Two Levels of Reality: (1) What actually happens, and (2) Interpretations and beliefs about what happens. The latter guides human memory and behavior.
Fantasy Structure:
Fantasy: A creative and imaginative shared interpretation of events that helps a group make sense of experience and predict the future (usually initiated as a real-life narrative taking the group away from current tasks). In other words: Stories.
Fantasy Theme: Fantasy theme is strung together fantasies (think of it like a chain). The common content of stories told by group members.
Fantasy Chain: A string of connected stories revolving around a central theme,( Fantasy chain are fantasy themes strung together), Fantasy Chain possesses narrative elements such as conflict, heroes, villains, and plot lines.
Function of fantasy, fantasy theme, and fantasy chains: Helps groups indirectly resolve conflicts, address sensitive topics, define core values, and build unique group personalities. It helps tell WHY groups communicate the way they do.
EX: Think about the shared identity of CU Students. Your positive experience with CU will be linked together other alumni, and create a large fantasy chain that reinforces the collective identity of the CU community, illustrating shared values and experiences among current and former students.
Case Scenario ("How Do You Keep a Group on Task?"):
Context: A task force appointed by the Dean of Students to recommend ways to integrate online, commuter, and residential students to reduce dropouts within a deadline.
Composition: Residential juniors/seniors, one single-parent online student, a senior residence hall assistant chairperson, and a sophomore commuter class president-elect.
Dysfunction: Meetings are derailed by off-task fantasy chains (discussing basketball team prospects, making jokes about tuition collection and retention programs) with no chairperson intervention.
4. Structuration Theory- provides a general framework that explains how people structure their groups by making active use of rules and resources.
Definition: Developed by Anthony Giddens and advanced by Marshall Scott Poole; explains how individuals structure groups by actively utilizing rules and resources during interactions with eachotherThis theory highlights the duality of structure, meaning that while rules can constrain behaviors, they also enable individuals to navigate and influence their group dynamics.
This theory looks at individuals’ behaviors in groups rather than the dynamics of the group as a ehole how groups interact with the rules. When we join a new group, we use rules we have used in the past to structure our behavior (EX: coming from the military into college, carrying out the same rules as before). Groups form their own rules about communication, but are all based on internal and external communication.
Social systems are produced and reproduced through a groups use of rules in interactions. The structure is built by the communication, and the communication affects the structure. This is the DUALITY of structure. Stability and change are products of the same process. Groups that dont adapt or change will crumble, the same things that make us stable are the same things that will make us change.
Production: use of rules and resources to create a NEW structure (Change)
Reproduction: The use of rules and resources (structure) to reinforce structures already in place (stability).
Key Concepts:
Systems and Rules: Rules (e.g., "don't talk while others speak") determine how members structure interaction. Members import rules from previous groups (e.g., high school rules applied to college classes; jury depictions applied to deliberations).
Agency and Free Will: Individual actions structure subsequent actions. Members exercise choices within external, structural, and technological constraints.
Virtual Group Dynamics: Members in distributed/virtual groups are significantly less likely to take personal responsibility for group dysfunction, displaying a higher tendency to blame others compared to face-to-face group members.
Rule Modification: Dysfunctional rules can be altered by calling attention to them, violating them, or sharing resources.
5. Functional Theory
Definition: Formulated by Dennis Gouran and Randy Hirokawa; asserts that group communication behaviors directly serve specific functions necessary to achieve outcomes.
Three Essential Propositions for Problem Solving:
Satisfy Task Requirements: Members must understand the issue, identify characteristics of acceptable solutions, uncover realistic alternatives, evaluate options, and select the optimal alternative.
Overcome Constraints: Members must use communication to navigate constraints such as deadline stress, interpersonal conflicts, and self-serving behaviors.
Review Decisions: Members must actively review their decision-making processes and reconsider choices when necessary.
Summary Matrix of Theoretical Perspectives
Systems Theory: Group is an open system of interdependent variables (inputs, processes, outputs) displaying synergy, entropy, and equifinality.
Social Exchange Theory: Group attractiveness depends on positive profit.
Symbolic Convergence Theory: Shared fantasy chains build a unique group identity, values, and collective consciousness.
Structuration Theory: Individuals use rules and resources from past and present contexts to structure social interaction.
Functional Theory: Specific communicative behaviors satisfy task requirements, manage constraints, and review choices to ensure sound reasoning.
Descriptive Model of Small Group Communication
Model Nature: A descriptive, systems-based framework illustrating the constellation of interrelated variables that govern small group interaction.
Core Model Variables:
Communication: What is said, how it is said, and to whom it is said; acts as the primary vehicle connecting all variables.
Leadership: Behaviors that exert influence on the group system.
Goals: The explicit objectives of the group (therapy, task execution, socialization) and individual goals. Requires shared, clear, specific goals for effectiveness.
Norms: Standards governing allowed versus forbidden behaviors.
Formal Norms: Explicitly stated rules (e.g., parliamentary procedure).
Informal Norms: Unspoken habits (e.g., always starting a meeting late).
Roles: Sets of expectations held for individual behaviors within the group context.
Cohesiveness: The degree of attraction members feel toward one another and toward the group itself, fostering loyalty.
Situation: The contextual setting, including task nature, group size, physical seating, location, and time constraints/pressures.
Group Outcomes: The resultant products of group interaction, including solutions, decisions, member satisfaction, agreement, or financial profit.
Group Communication Competence: The ultimate objective achieved by combining sound theoretical understanding with an expanded repertoire of communicative behaviors.
Structural Feedback Model in Systems Theory
Feedback Mechanism and System Environment:

- System processes operate within an overarching **Environment** that continuously encompasses inputs, throughput processes, and outputs.
- **Feedback Loop**: A critical structural pathway connecting system outputs back to inputs and processes, providing necessary evaluations to enable continuous self-correction and adaptation.
Extended Structuration Theory Dynamics
Composition of Social Structures:
Social structures consist of interwoven forces including status hierarchies, task expectations, communication networks, and peer pressure.
Means and Ends: Rules and resources act simultaneously as both the means (the mechanisms utilized during group decision-making) and the ends (the resulting structural outcomes generated by those decisions).
Principle of Agency: Group members are never completely governed by rules; individual members always retain the personal capacity to act otherwise.
Post-Apocalyptic Case Metaphor (The Walking Dead Model):

- **Initial Structure Reliance**: In sudden environmental disruptions, individuals initially rely on pre-existing structures and societal rules from past contexts to organize and rebuild.
- **Intentional Adaptation**: Members intentionally alter and reconfigure rules and resource allocations to respond to changing situational demands.
- **Membership Influx**: Introducing new members into a group restructures the social system by incorporating novel background rules and expectations.
- **Inter-Group Structural Friction**: Significant friction and conflict arise when one group's established rules and resource systems encounter and collide with a different group's established structure.
Advanced Functional Theory Applications
Definition of Function: Refers to the specific effects or consequences that a particular communicative behavior produces within a group system.
Core Functional Outcomes of Communication:
Promotes sound reasoning during group deliberations.
Serves as an error-prevention mechanism against flaws in thought processes.
Fosters and maintains constructive interpersonal relationships among group members.
Foundation for Problem-Solving: Functional theory serves as the theoretical and empirical baseline for structured, sequential group decision-making frameworks.