1. Obedience - Studies

Study

Aim

Sample / Target population

Procedure

Key finding

Conclusion / Use

Milgram (1963)

Investigate obedience to authority.

40 American men, aged 20–50.

Participants believed they were giving increasing shocks (15–450V) to a learner when instructed by an experimenter.

65% reached 450V; 100% reached at least 300V.

People can show high obedience to legitimate authority, even when behaviour conflicts with morals.

Milgram – Telephone variation

Test effect of proximity of authority.

Participants in Milgram's research.

Experimenter left the room and gave instructions by telephone.

Obedience fell 65% → 22.5%.

Greater distance from authority → less obedience.

Milgram – Rundown office

Test effect of status/legitimacy of authority.

Participants in Milgram's research.

Study moved from Yale to a rundown office and was presented as a private company.

Obedience fell to 47.5%.

Higher-status institutions increase perceived legitimacy and obedience.

Milgram – Ordinary man

Test importance of recognised authority.

20 participants.

Experimenter left; an ordinary man/confederate told participants to continue.

Only 20% reached maximum; 80% stopped.

Recognised authority strongly increases obedience.

Milgram – Women (Experiment 8)

Investigate gender differences.

40 women.

Women completed a Milgram-style obedience procedure.

65% reached maximum shock.

Little overall gender difference in obedience.

Hofling et al. (1966)

Investigate obedience in a real-life setting.

22 nurses.

Fake doctor ordered nurses by phone to give an excessive drug dose against hospital rules.

21/22 obeyed.

Legitimate authority can produce obedience even when orders conflict with rules; supports agency theory.

Milgram & Elms (1966)

Investigate authoritarian personality and obedience.

20 obedient + 20 dissenting Milgram participants.

Compared participants' F-Scale scores.

Obedient participants had higher F-Scale scores.

Authoritarian personality is associated with obedience, although correlation ≠ causation.

Dambrun & Vatiné (2010)

Investigate authoritarian personality and obedience.

Participants in virtual Milgram-type study.

Measured authoritarianism and obedience.

Higher authoritarianism → greater obedience.

Supports a relationship between authoritarian personality and obedience.

Blass (1991)

Investigate locus of control and obedience.

Participants from obedience research.

Examined relationship between locus of control and obedience.

External locus associated with greater obedience.

Personality may influence obedience, but situation also matters.

Sedikides & Jackson (1990)

Test effect of physical presence of authority.

Zoo visitors.

Compared compliance with a zookeeper's instructions when he was present vs absent.

More compliance when zookeeper was present.

Supports the importance of proximity/immediacy.

Meeus & Raaijmakers (1986)

Investigate proximity and obedience to psychological harm.

Laboratory participants.

Participants were ordered to psychologically pressure a job applicant; experimenter was present or absent.

>90% obeyed when present vs ~36% when absent.

Physical presence of authority increases obedience.

Sheridan & King (1972)

Investigate gender differences in obedience.

13 women + approximately 13 men.

Participants believed they were giving real shocks to a puppy.

All 13 women reached maximum vs about half of men.

Suggests possible gender differences, but evidence is inconsistent.

Blass (1999)

Review gender differences in obedience.

10 obedience studies.

Reviewed previous research.

Similar obedience for men and women in 9/10 studies.

Overall, little reliable evidence for gender differences.

Kilham & Mann (1974)

Investigate gender differences in Australia.

Australian men and women.

Milgram-style obedience task.

40% men vs 16% women obeyed.

Suggests gender differences can occur, but findings are inconsistent.

Ancona & Pareyson (1968)

Investigate obedience in Italy.

Italian participants.

Milgram-style study; maximum shock was 330V.

85% reached maximum.

Suggests high obedience, but cultural comparisons are difficult because procedures differed.

Frey (2020)

Investigate cultural differences in compliance.

Populations from different countries.

Analysed COVID-19 mobility/contact-tracing data.

Individualistic countries showed more movement during lockdown.

Suggests collectivistic cultures may show greater compliance, although it is not a direct obedience experiment.

Latané (1981)

Explain how social influence varies.

Theory, not one specific sample.

Proposed Social Impact Theory: influence depends on strength, immediacy and number.

Greater strength, proximity and number generally increase influence.

Provides a situational explanation of obedience.



















Studies grouped by what they are useful for

Topic / explanation

Studies to use

Key evidence

High obedience

Milgram (1963)

65% reached 450V; 100% reached ≥300V

Agency theory

Milgram (1963)

High obedience despite moral strain; participants displaced responsibility

Real-life application

Hofling et al. (1966)

21/22 nurses obeyed a doctor's order

Physical proximity

Milgram Experiment 7

Telephone instructions → 22.5% obedience

Physical proximity

Sedikides & Jackson (1990)

More compliance when zookeeper was physically present

Physical proximity

Meeus & Raaijmakers (1986)

>90% obeyed when experimenter present vs ~36% when absent

Legitimacy/status

Milgram Experiment 10

Yale → rundown office: 65% → 47.5%

Authority figure/status

Milgram Experiment 13

Ordinary man giving orders → only 20% reached maximum

Authoritarian personality

Milgram & Elms (1966)

Obedient participants had higher F-Scale scores

Authoritarian personality

Dambrun & Vatiné (2010)

Higher authoritarianism associated with greater obedience

Locus of control

Blass (1991)

External locus associated with greater obedience

Gender

Milgram Experiment 8

Women: 65% maximum obedience

Gender

Sheridan & King (1972)

All 13 women reached maximum vs ~half of men

Gender

Blass (1999)

Similar obedience in 9/10 studies

Gender

Kilham & Mann (1974)

Australian women 16% vs men 40%

Culture

Ancona & Pareyson (1968)

Italy: 85% maximum

Culture

Frey (2020)

Greater compliance/mobility restriction in collectivistic countries

Situational explanation

Milgram's variations

Proximity and legitimacy substantially changed obedience

Individual vs situational

Milgram + Milgram & Elms

Both individual characteristics and situation can influence obedience


The core studies I'd prioritise

For an Edexcel AS exam, I would not spend equal revision time on all 16 studies. Your strongest study bank is:

  1. Milgram (1963) — main study

  2. Milgram's variations — proximity + legitimacy/status

  3. Hofling et al. (1966) — real-life support for obedience/agency

  4. Milgram & Elms (1966) — authoritarian personality

  5. Meeus & Raaijmakers (1986) — proximity

  6. Sheridan & King (1972) — gender

  7. Blass (1999) — gender review

  8. Ancona & Pareyson (1968) — culture

  9. Kilham & Mann (1974) — culture/gender

  10. Latané (1981) — Social Impact Theory