1. Obedience - Studies
Study | Aim | Sample / Target population | Procedure | Key finding | Conclusion / Use |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Milgram (1963) | Investigate obedience to authority. | 40 American men, aged 20–50. | Participants believed they were giving increasing shocks (15–450V) to a learner when instructed by an experimenter. | 65% reached 450V; 100% reached at least 300V. | People can show high obedience to legitimate authority, even when behaviour conflicts with morals. |
Milgram – Telephone variation | Test effect of proximity of authority. | Participants in Milgram's research. | Experimenter left the room and gave instructions by telephone. | Obedience fell 65% → 22.5%. | Greater distance from authority → less obedience. |
Milgram – Rundown office | Test effect of status/legitimacy of authority. | Participants in Milgram's research. | Study moved from Yale to a rundown office and was presented as a private company. | Obedience fell to 47.5%. | Higher-status institutions increase perceived legitimacy and obedience. |
Milgram – Ordinary man | Test importance of recognised authority. | 20 participants. | Experimenter left; an ordinary man/confederate told participants to continue. | Only 20% reached maximum; 80% stopped. | Recognised authority strongly increases obedience. |
Milgram – Women (Experiment 8) | Investigate gender differences. | 40 women. | Women completed a Milgram-style obedience procedure. | 65% reached maximum shock. | Little overall gender difference in obedience. |
Hofling et al. (1966) | Investigate obedience in a real-life setting. | 22 nurses. | Fake doctor ordered nurses by phone to give an excessive drug dose against hospital rules. | 21/22 obeyed. | Legitimate authority can produce obedience even when orders conflict with rules; supports agency theory. |
Milgram & Elms (1966) | Investigate authoritarian personality and obedience. | 20 obedient + 20 dissenting Milgram participants. | Compared participants' F-Scale scores. | Obedient participants had higher F-Scale scores. | Authoritarian personality is associated with obedience, although correlation ≠ causation. |
Dambrun & Vatiné (2010) | Investigate authoritarian personality and obedience. | Participants in virtual Milgram-type study. | Measured authoritarianism and obedience. | Higher authoritarianism → greater obedience. | Supports a relationship between authoritarian personality and obedience. |
Blass (1991) | Investigate locus of control and obedience. | Participants from obedience research. | Examined relationship between locus of control and obedience. | External locus associated with greater obedience. | Personality may influence obedience, but situation also matters. |
Sedikides & Jackson (1990) | Test effect of physical presence of authority. | Zoo visitors. | Compared compliance with a zookeeper's instructions when he was present vs absent. | More compliance when zookeeper was present. | Supports the importance of proximity/immediacy. |
Meeus & Raaijmakers (1986) | Investigate proximity and obedience to psychological harm. | Laboratory participants. | Participants were ordered to psychologically pressure a job applicant; experimenter was present or absent. | >90% obeyed when present vs ~36% when absent. | Physical presence of authority increases obedience. |
Sheridan & King (1972) | Investigate gender differences in obedience. | 13 women + approximately 13 men. | Participants believed they were giving real shocks to a puppy. | All 13 women reached maximum vs about half of men. | Suggests possible gender differences, but evidence is inconsistent. |
Blass (1999) | Review gender differences in obedience. | 10 obedience studies. | Reviewed previous research. | Similar obedience for men and women in 9/10 studies. | Overall, little reliable evidence for gender differences. |
Kilham & Mann (1974) | Investigate gender differences in Australia. | Australian men and women. | Milgram-style obedience task. | 40% men vs 16% women obeyed. | Suggests gender differences can occur, but findings are inconsistent. |
Ancona & Pareyson (1968) | Investigate obedience in Italy. | Italian participants. | Milgram-style study; maximum shock was 330V. | 85% reached maximum. | Suggests high obedience, but cultural comparisons are difficult because procedures differed. |
Frey (2020) | Investigate cultural differences in compliance. | Populations from different countries. | Analysed COVID-19 mobility/contact-tracing data. | Individualistic countries showed more movement during lockdown. | Suggests collectivistic cultures may show greater compliance, although it is not a direct obedience experiment. |
Latané (1981) | Explain how social influence varies. | Theory, not one specific sample. | Proposed Social Impact Theory: influence depends on strength, immediacy and number. | Greater strength, proximity and number generally increase influence. | Provides a situational explanation of obedience. |
Studies grouped by what they are useful for
Topic / explanation | Studies to use | Key evidence |
|---|---|---|
High obedience | Milgram (1963) | 65% reached 450V; 100% reached ≥300V |
Agency theory | Milgram (1963) | High obedience despite moral strain; participants displaced responsibility |
Real-life application | Hofling et al. (1966) | 21/22 nurses obeyed a doctor's order |
Physical proximity | Milgram Experiment 7 | Telephone instructions → 22.5% obedience |
Physical proximity | Sedikides & Jackson (1990) | More compliance when zookeeper was physically present |
Physical proximity | Meeus & Raaijmakers (1986) | >90% obeyed when experimenter present vs ~36% when absent |
Legitimacy/status | Milgram Experiment 10 | Yale → rundown office: 65% → 47.5% |
Authority figure/status | Milgram Experiment 13 | Ordinary man giving orders → only 20% reached maximum |
Authoritarian personality | Milgram & Elms (1966) | Obedient participants had higher F-Scale scores |
Authoritarian personality | Dambrun & Vatiné (2010) | Higher authoritarianism associated with greater obedience |
Locus of control | Blass (1991) | External locus associated with greater obedience |
Gender | Milgram Experiment 8 | Women: 65% maximum obedience |
Gender | Sheridan & King (1972) | All 13 women reached maximum vs ~half of men |
Gender | Blass (1999) | Similar obedience in 9/10 studies |
Gender | Kilham & Mann (1974) | Australian women 16% vs men 40% |
Culture | Ancona & Pareyson (1968) | Italy: 85% maximum |
Culture | Frey (2020) | Greater compliance/mobility restriction in collectivistic countries |
Situational explanation | Milgram's variations | Proximity and legitimacy substantially changed obedience |
Individual vs situational | Milgram + Milgram & Elms | Both individual characteristics and situation can influence obedience |
The core studies I'd prioritise
For an Edexcel AS exam, I would not spend equal revision time on all 16 studies. Your strongest study bank is:
Milgram (1963) — main study
Milgram's variations — proximity + legitimacy/status
Hofling et al. (1966) — real-life support for obedience/agency
Milgram & Elms (1966) — authoritarian personality
Meeus & Raaijmakers (1986) — proximity
Sheridan & King (1972) — gender
Blass (1999) — gender review
Ancona & Pareyson (1968) — culture
Kilham & Mann (1974) — culture/gender
Latané (1981) — Social Impact Theory