AMSCO 5.5 - 5.7

Immigration and Nativism in the Antebellum Era

  • Irish Immigration: Nearly 2 million2\text{ million} Irish immigrated in the 1840s due to crop failures and famine; mostly tenant farmers with few skills and little money, facing discrimination as Roman Catholics; clustered in Northern cities (Boston, New York, Philadelphia), joined the Democratic Party, and eventually gained control of Tammany Hall by the 1880s.
  • German Immigration: Over 1 million1\text{ million} arrived in the late 1840s and 1850s fleeing economic distress and the failed 1848 revolutions; possessed modest means and artisan/farming skills; established homesteads across the Old Northwest, advocating for public education and opposing slavery.
  • Nativist Reaction: Native-born Protestants feared job competition and cultural dilution; formed the Supreme Order of the Star-Spangled Banner, which evolved into the American Party (Know-Nothing Party); demanded extending naturalization from 55 to 21 years21\text{ years} and banning foreign-born citizens from holding public office; nominated Millard Fillmore in 1856.
  • Southwest Conflict: Mexican Americans and American Indians incorporated after the Mexican-American War faced religious discrimination for Catholic practices or traditional beliefs.

Economic Expansion and Regional Divergence

  • Industrial Technology: Rapid factory spread in the Northeast produced ready-to-wear clothing via Elias Howe's sewing machine; communication accelerated following Samuel F. B. Morse's electric telegraph demonstration in 1844.
  • Railroad Expansion: Railroads became the largest U.S. industry; received the first federal land grant in 1850 (2.6 million2.6\text{ million} acres for the Illinois Central Railroad); closely tied Midwestern agriculture directly to Northeastern markets rather than the South.
  • Panic of 1857: Plunged Northern manufacturing and Midwestern agriculture into severe unemployment and price drops while cotton prices remained stable, reinforcing Southern convictions that the plantation system was economically superior and self-sufficient.

The Sectional Debate over Slavery and Literature

  • Fugitive Slave Law of 1850: Placed runaway slave cases under exclusive federal jurisdiction without jury trials for accused fugitives; forced state and local law enforcement to assist; generated fierce Northern resistance and strengthened the Underground Railroad, where Harriet Tubman made at least 1919 rescue trips assisting around 300300 individuals.
  • Antislavery Literature: Harriet Beecher Stowe published Uncle Tom's Cabin (1852), moving Northern sentiment to view slavery as a moral evil; Hinton R. Helper published Impending Crisis of the South (1857), using statistics to argue that slavery economically devastated non-slaveholding Southern Whites.
  • Proslavery Counterarguments: Southern writers argued slavery was biblically sanctioned, historically established, and protected by the U.S. Constitution; George Fitzhugh (Sociology for the South, 1854; Cannibals All!, 1857) attacked Northern "wage slavery" and defended paternalistic master-slave bonds.

Political Realignment and Territorial Crises

The United States After the Kansas-Nebraska Act of 1854

  • Collapse of the Whigs: General Winfield Scott's 1852 loss to Democrat Franklin Pierce splintered the Whig Party over sectional slavery disputes.
  • Kansas-Nebraska Act (1854): Proposed by Stephen A. Douglas to facilitate a transcontinental railroad route terminating in Chicago; divided the Nebraska Territory into Kansas and Nebraska, opening lands north of 36∘30′36^\circ 30' to popular sovereignty and effectively repealing the Missouri Compromise.
  • "Bleeding Kansas": Violent conflict erupted between antislavery settlers funded by the New England Emigrant Aid Company and proslavery Missouri "border ruffians"; resulted in dual territorial governments (Lecompton and Topeka), the proslavery attack on Lawrence, and John Brown's retaliation at Pottawatomie Creek (killing five).
  • Caning of Charles Sumner (1856): Representative Preston Brooks beat Senator Charles Sumner unconscious in the Senate chamber following Sumner's speech "The Crime Against Kansas," demonstrating escalating sectional violence.
  • Rise of the Republican Party: Formed in Wisconsin in 1854 by Free-Soilers, antislavery Whigs, and Northern Democrats exclusively to oppose the expansion of slavery into federal territories; nominated John C. Frémont in 1856, winning 1111 of 1616 free states.
  • Lecompton Constitution (1857–1858): Buchanan urged admission of Kansas under a proslavery constitution known to lack majority support; rejected by Congress and overwhelmingly defeated by Kansas voters in 1858.
  • Dred Scott v. Sandford (1857): Chief Justice Roger Taney ruled that African Americans were not U.S. citizens and could not sue in federal court, that Congress lacked the constitutional authority to deprive citizens of property (slaves) without due process, and that the Missouri Compromise was unconstitutional.
  • Lincoln-Douglas Debates (1858): Abraham Lincoln delivered his "house-divided" speech; in Freeport, Illinois, Douglas stated his Freeport Doctrine (arguing slavery could not exist without local police regulations/slave codes), winning reelection to the Senate but irreversibly alienating Southern Democrats.

The Secession Crisis and Outbreak of Civil War

  • Harpers Ferry Raid (1859): John Brown attempted to seize the federal arsenal at Harpers Ferry, Virginia, to arm an enslaved revolt; captured by federal troops under Robert E. Lee, convicted of treason, and hanged, intensifying Southern dread of armed abolitionism.
  • Election of 1860:
    • Democrats split: Northern Democrats nominated Stephen Douglas (popular sovereignty); Southern Democrats nominated John C. Breckinridge (unrestricted expansion of slavery and annexation of Cuba).
    • Constitutional Union Party nominated John Bell (enforcement of laws, preservation of the Union).
    • Republicans nominated Abraham Lincoln (protective tariffs, free homesteads, transcontinental rail improvements, non-extension of slavery).
    • Lincoln secured the presidency with a 39.8%39.8\% plurality of popular votes and a 59%59\% electoral majority (180 votes180\text{ votes}), carrying every Northern free state without winning Southern electoral votes.
  • Secession of the Deep South: South Carolina unanimously seceded in December 1860, followed by Georgia, Florida, Alabama, Mississippi, Louisiana, and Texas; formed the Confederate States of America in Montgomery, Alabama, electing Jefferson Davis president and Alexander Stephens vice president.
  • Crittenden Compromise: Proposed extending the 36∘30′36^\circ 30' line to the Pacific for all territories; rejected by Lincoln because it abandoned the core Republican commitment to stop the spread of slavery.
  • Fort Sumter (April 12, 1861): Lincoln dispatched food provisions to Fort Sumter in Charleston harbor; South Carolina forces opened fire, sparking the Civil War and uniting the North.
  • Upper South and Border States: Virginia, North Carolina, Tennessee, and Arkansas seceded after Fort Sumter, moving the Confederate capital to Richmond (western Virginia remained loyal and formed a separate state in 1863); Delaware, Maryland, Missouri, and Kentucky stayed in the Union through strategic federal intervention and martial law.

Historical Interpretations of the Civil War

  • Post-War Northern View: Viewed the war as an irrepressible moral conflict provoked by a conspiracy of aggressive slave owners attempting to expand an evil system.
  • Post-War Southern View: Justified secession as a defense of the constitutional compact of states and property rights against Northern majoritarian tyranny.
  • Progressive Era (1900–1917): Characterized the war primarily as a structural economic clash between Northeastern industrial capitalism and Southern agrarianism.
  • Revisionist Era (1920s–1930s): Questioned the necessity of the war, attributing conflict to political blunders and mutual fanaticism rather than unavoidable sectional divergence.
  • Civil Rights Era (1950s–1960s): Reasserted slavery as the fundamental moral and irrepressible cause of the war (notably argued by Arthur Schlesinger, Jr.).