Exhaustive Desk Notes: Mortgage Trading, Agency CMBS, & Market Analysis
Desk Strategy & Operational Requirements: Agency CMBS (HSBC MBS)
Current Trading Context & Performance Deficit:
- Performance and feedback in Agency CMBS (HSBC MBS) post-Justin's departure have been severely lacking.
- Over a period exceeding weeks, zero paper has been moved outside of weighted average AD (average duration / weighted average life) on HCA MBS.
- The desk is actively quoting zero bid-ask spreads and offering paper directly on the bid side—remaining completely agnostic on P&L—solely to preserve market flow, maintain price visibility, and ensure ongoing product relevance.
Mandatory Sales Execution & Feedback Loops:
- Sales coverage must engage on a strict weekly basis with major money managers and bank accounts to gather actionable market color.
- Delayed feedback (e.g., late) is completely non-actionable due to significant underlying rate and valuation movements.
- End-of-month check-ins are explicitly required to ascertain client cash availability and CMBS investment allocations for upcoming monthly cycles.
- Specific required details from clients include exact spread widening thresholds (e.g., widening by or \,\text{bps}) and relative value metrics versus store coupons.\n\n* **Desk Capacity & Balance Sheet Metrics:**\n * The desk actively bids on over \$1\,\text{billion} of CMBS bonds daily via BWICs (Bids Wanted in Competition).\n * Total balance sheet capacity is slightly over \$1\,\text{billion}.\n * Providing ongoing liquidity requires moving block-sized positions; offerings are being aligned directly with live BWIC execution windows.\n * Account performance expectations are elevated across trading and sales. If weekly meetings fail to yield actionable flow, workflow will transition entirely to daily/weekly email updates.\n\n\n# Overall Mortgage Market Overview & Macro Valuation\n\n* **Weekly Rate & Valuation Movements:**\n * Weekly progression: Mortgages widened at the start of the week, tightened on Fed day, widened post-Fed, tightened sharply on Thursday, and gave back minimal gains on Friday.\n * On an Option-Adjusted Spread (OAS) basis, mortgages finished flat on the week but remained 7\text{ to }8\,\text{bps} wider on the month.\n * Fundamental performance: Mortgages underperformed corporate credit and securitized product credit sectors (including CLOs, floaters, and broader credit sectors).\n * Spreads are off six-month highs due to recent snapback, but relatively wide OAS leaves ample room for spread compression.\n\n* **Technical Landscape & Participant Supply/Demand:**\n * **Supply:** Extremely light due to mortgage rates remaining above 7\% alongside entering lower seasonal origination windows.\n * **Asia:** Asian account demand remains low/irrelevant.\n * **Money Managers:** Maintain overweight positions and continue to favor the mortgage sector. Substantial concurrent buying by money managers on Thursday drove sharp market tightening.\n * **Desk Execution:** Rob's team successfully provided liquidity for significantly larger ticket sizes (specifically within flow TBA-focused client tests).\n * **Banks:** Demand is less robust than historical peaks, but smaller allocations (\$500\,\text{million} increments) are sufficient to absorb incoming market supply.\n * **GSEs & Strategic Accounts:** Potential positive demand catalysts include active buying by GSEs (noted by Pulte on Friday) and large hedge funds reallocating out of corporate credit into mortgages.\n\n\n# Debating GSE Buying Activity & Mandates\n\n* **Market Reality Check on GSE Comments:**\n * Assertions regarding aggressive GSE buying mandates are treated with heavy skepticism on the desk and categorized as non-material market noise.\n * With mortgage rates at 7\%5.5\%.\n\n* **Historical Execution & Portfolio Data:**\n * During a severe selloff two weeks prior, GSE activity was limited to a single clip of \$250\,\text{million}.\n * Official balance sheet disclosures show GSE portfolio sizes declined consistently over the last two reported months.\n * GSEs have already met their annual net income/earnings targets and are avoiding taking incremental balance sheet risk.\n * No formal written purchasing mandate of \$200\,\text{billion} exists outside of unverified public tweets/claims.\n\n\n# Specified Pools (Specs) Market Dynamics & Axes\n\n* **Trading Activity & Coupon Stack Distribution:**\n * High activity driven by active money manager two-way flows across a broad coupon stack (2.5\%6\% coupons).\n * Concentration of demand remains lower in coupon within seasoned collateral, supported by most coupons trading at a discount.\n * Active money managers drove buying while overall ETF inflows remained muted.\n\n* **Desk Axes & Buying Incentives:**\n * Seasoning remains well-bid across the entire coupon stack.\n * The desk has acquired seasoning primarily from street dealers and actively seeks to buy directly from clients to replace risk from recent sales.\n * Incentive: The desk is offering 3\text{ to }4\,\text{ticks} in additional concession to sales on any client buys achieved in the discount seasoning space.\n * Pallav and Jaden are distributing CUSIP-specific bond list axes (including exact sizes and levels) to direct sales targeting.\n\n* **Freddie Mac Cash Window List:**\n * Freddie Mac cash window list trades on a T+1 settlement schedule.\n * Carry adjustments were distributed to coverage team clients.\n * Servicer Mix Warning: Client feedback indicates dissatisfaction with the servicer mix in cash window securities, noting these pools are less clean than traditional cash window securities and carry underperformance risk.\n * Total weekly spec sales exceeded \$1\,\text{billion}. The desk is focused on replacing paper, specifically targeting wall-end seasoning stories.\n\n\n# Collateralized Mortgage Obligations (CMO) & Floater Market Analysis\n\n* **New Issue vs. Secondary Floater Dynamics:**\n * **New Issue:** Approximately \$550\,\text{million}+115\,\text{bps}+143\text{ to }+145\,\text{bps}.\n * **Secondary Floaters:** Over \$1.5\,\text{billion} in secondary floater BWICs hit the market, featuring 6-caps, 6.5-caps, and 7-caps from banks, money managers, and hedge funds.\n * **Valuation Disparity:** Secondary floaters are exceptionally cheap relative to new issue pricing.\n\n* **Recent Secondary Floater Executions:**\n * Conventional 7-caps sold at +105\,\text{bps}+135\,\text{bps}10\,\text{bps} off recent lows).\n * OAS Benchmarks: Secondary 7-cap 135\,\text{bps}44\,\text{bps} OAS.\n * Street Balance Sheet Constraints: Street dealers are unwilling to take on inventory due to quarter-end balance sheet costs, resulting in wider secondary spreads. One money manager sold \$235\,\text{million} today in 7-caps and 6.5-caps to rotate into par-priced premium bonds.\n\n* **CMO Desk Axes & Concessions:**\n * **Primary Floater Ax:** Offer 6.5-caps at +130\,\text{bps}+100\,\text{bps}6\%5\,\text{bps}10\,\text{bps}).\n * **Fixed Rate Complex:** Highly depressed market environment. Execution noted: 5.5\%6\% paper sold in the mid-to-high 90s over context.\n * **Fixed Rate Menu Axes:**\n * 5\%5.5\%6\% collateral\n * 5.25\%6\%5.5\% collateral\n * 4.5\%5.5\% collateral\n * **Sales Concessions:** The desk will pay extra CCs (concessions/commissions) on any fixed rate paper that drives deal creation or on discount secondary floaters to clear balance sheet space.\n * **Duration Buyers:** Skittish due to rate volatility and fears of rates reaching 5.0\%5.5\%. Capital is rotating into non-agency and non-QM sectors for higher nominal yields at wider spreads.\n\n\n# Secondary Trading, Ginnie Mae Weakness, & Roll Markets\n\n* **Ginnie Mae (GNMA) Fundamental & Technical Weakness:**\n * Ginnie Mae collateral continues to underperform due to complete absence of bank participation, forcing pricing to fundamental clearing levels.\n * Underlying TBA composition, fast speed ramps, and worst-delivered bond dynamics create poor perpetual fundamental valuations unless explicit yield-takeout programs emerge.\n * Technical Imbalance: Heavy supply increases on Ginnie Mae TBAs matched with minimal take-out demand.\n * Risk Boundary: Severe valuation compression creates short-squeeze risk if bank yield programs re-enter Ginnie paper.\n\n* **Hedge Performance & Roll Market Conditions:**\n * Over the prior two weeks, long positions held against logger hedge ratios experienced losses ranging between 5\text{ to }18\,\text{ticks}6\%6.5\% coupons).\n * Roll Markets: TBA production coupon rolls popped significantly special due to shifting production coupons:\n * 6\%1\,\text{tick}+50\text{ to }100\,\text{bps} annualized specialness).\n * 6.5\%2\,\text{ticks} special.\n\n* **Servicer Convexity Hedging:**\n * Ongoing servicer selling driven purely by convexity/extension hedging as 10\text{-year}4.95\%.\n * Substantial block sales hit the market late Thursday and Friday, maintaining pressure on the mortgage basis.\n\n\n# Derivatives, Structured Products, & Hybrid ARMs\n\n* **Derivatives Axes & Trades:**\n * Prepayment risk across top-of-coupon paper is functionally near zero, driving favorable technicals for mid-to-high strike paper.\n * Executed Trade: Sold conventional loan balance 6.5\%5028 SPs) to a hedge fund.\n * Key Offerings: Ginnie Mae 6\%6.5\%7\% loan balance paper on the offer sheet.\n * Highlighted Ax: Ginnie Mae 6\%\$251.64\,\text{SA}6.6436\%200\text{s} OAS.\n * A large money manager exercise/selling program in derivatives is substantially complete.\n\n* **Hybrid ARMs Execution & GMC Structuring:**\n * **Ginnie ARMs Volatility:** Ginnie ARMs tightened 7\text{ to }10\,\text{bps}\$1\,\text{billion}4\,\text{bps} over the last 3 business days.\n * **Ginnie ARM Axes:** The desk holds \$106\,\text{million}4.5\%5\%5\text{ to }6\,\text{bps} wider due to forward rate uncertainty.\n * **Conventional ARMs Execution:** Strong two-way liquidity:\n * Sold \$125\,\text{million}5.15\%9899 dollar price) to a bank portfolio.\n * Sold \$75\,\text{million} on Friday to a money manager.\n * Sold \$100\,\text{million} across deals today to another money manager.\n * **Conventional ARM Axes:** Target sales of \$70\,\text{million}\$70\,\text{million} block-size Fannie 7/6 ARMs.\n * **Guaranteed Maturity Certificates (GMCs):** Balance reduced to \$45\,\text{million}3.5\text{-year} majority GMC. ARM tightening has made GMC creation off ARMs difficult; future GMCs will shift to fixed-rate underlying collateral.\n * **GMC Spread Pricing:**\n * 5\text{-year}50\text{s}\,\text{bps} over benchmark (aligned with back-line collections).\n * 6\text{-year}60\,\text{bps}.\n * 7\text{-year}60\text{ to }65\,\text{bps}.\n\n\n# Detailed Agency CMBS Secondary Market Conditions & BWIC Schedules\n\n* **Secondary Spreads & Valuation Levels:**\n * Agency CMBS secondary spreads widened 1\text{ to }2\,\text{bps}\sim 2\,\text{bps}\sim 1.5\,\text{bps}).\n * Interest Only (IO) Strips:\n * Full IOs: Trading in the low-to-mid 30s (32\%\text{ to }35\%\,\text{area}; Full IO levels drifted from low 30s to low/mid 30s).\n * Partial IOs: Trading around the 35\%\,\text{area}.\n * Flow Bottleneck: Most Freddie PCs and DUS bonds trade directly cross to end-accounts, with minimal movement off dealer balance sheets.\n\n* **Upcoming Desk Offerings & BWICs:**\n * **Upcoming BWIC:** \$280\,\text{million}5\text{-to-}7\text{-year}31.5\text{ to }32+ levels.\n * **Agency Floater Inventory:** \$100\,\text{million}60\text{ to }63\,\text{bps}\$80\,\text{million}\$40\,\text{million} to Tory's account previously).\n * **Regular DUS Swaps DM Context:** Pricing ranges from 35\,\text{bps}60\text{s}\,\text{bps}.\n\n* **Regional Bank Coverage & Federal Home Loan Bank (FHLB) Activity:**\n * **Cincinnati Banks:** Two largest regional buyers explicitly confirmed zero bond purchases since July.\n * **FHLB System Systemic Advances:** System-wide advances are near zero.\n * FHLB Atlanta: Completely out of the market, likely remaining inactive until November.\n * FHLB Topeka: Spreads were too tight for CMBS, leading them to deploy all available capital into HECMs (Home Equity Conversion Mortgages). Showing interest at +33\text{ to }+35\,\text{bps}7.06\% offering level).\n * FHLB Des Moines: Buying at +75\,\text{bps}75\text{p}.\n * **K-Deal Primary Schedule:** 7-year K-deal pricing tomorrow (pricing around 31.5\,\text{bps}5.5\%6\% pools.\n\n\n# Sales & Trading Money Manager Roundtable Event\n\n* **Event Logistics & Date:**\n * Date: Thursday, October 8 (two weeks from Thursday).\n * Location: Capital Grille (private lower room, below the bar area).\n * Schedule:\n * 17:45\text{ to }18:45 / 19:00: Closed-door account conversation and roundtable with client accounts (Kad attending).\n * 18:00: Early gathering/hang for sales and trading team members in the private room/bar.\n * 19:00$$: Doors open to the broader reception and general audience.