Wild Rice and the Rights of Nature

Overview and the Groundbreaking Lawsuit: Manoomin v. Minnesota DNR

  • Legal Action Overview: In August 20212021, the White Earth Band of Ojibwe filed an unprecedented legal action titled Manoomin et al. v. Minnesota Department of Natural Resources (DNR) in tribal court.

  • Novel Plaintiff Status: The suit named manoomin (the Anishinaabe word for wild rice) as the primary plaintiff, asserting that the plant itself possesses legal personhood and enforceable rights under tribal law.

  • Underlying Infrastructure Dispute:

    • The lawsuit directly contested an industrial water appropriation permit issued in June 20212021 by the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources (DNR) to Canadian energy corporation Enbridge Inc.

    • The state permit authorized Enbridge to withdraw approximately 5 billion gallons5\text{ billion gallons} (5×109 gallons5 \times 10^9\text{ gallons}) of freshwater from regional aquifers and wetlands for the construction and trench dewatering of its Line 3 tar sands pipeline expansion.

    • The Line 3 expansion, originally proposed in 20142014, routes crude tar sands oil from Alberta, Canada, across northern Minnesota to Superior, Wisconsin, cutting directly across Anishinaabe treaty-reserved territories.

    • Tribal communities raised severe environmental objections, amplified by Enbridge's history of environmental catastrophes, specifically the catastrophic 20102010 pipeline spill that released more than one million gallons of crude oil into the Kalamazoo River watershed in Michigan.

  • Core Legal Claims:

    • Plaintiff attorney Frank Bibeau argued that the permitted withdrawal of 5 billion gallons5\text{ billion gallons} of water threatened to deplete and alter hydrological levels essential for wild rice survival.

    • The complaint asserted that the State of Minnesota breached treaty obligations and tribal sovereignty, violating manoomin's specific legal right to clean freshwater habitat, survival, and flourishing as established by tribal statute.

  • Judicial Disposition:

    • The White Earth Court of Appeals ultimately dismissed the lawsuit, ruling that the tribal court lacked subject-matter and territorial jurisdiction over non-tribal state regulatory actions occurring outside the borders of the reservation.

  • Jurisprudential Significance:

    • Despite procedural dismissal, the action marked a watershed moment in ecological jurisprudence by formally translating Indigenous ontological principles of plant kinship into modern legal claims.

    • It created a functional litigation template for treating an individual plant species, rather than an entire geographic feature or watershed, as an independent legal subject possessing rights of standing.

Botanical and Ecological Dynamics of Northern Wild Rice

  • Taxonomic Classification:

    • Wild rice encompasses four distinct aquatic grass species within the genus Zizania, three of which are indigenous to North America.

    • Botanically and evolutionarily distinct from common Asian cultivated paddy rice, which belongs to the genus Oryza; the two genera are entirely unrelated taxonomically and geographically.

    • The primary species situated throughout the Upper Midwest and Great Lakes basin is Zizania palustris, commonly known as northern wild rice.

  • Indigenous Nomenclature:

    • Referred to as manoomin across Anishinaabe (Ojibwe) dialects.

    • Designated as psíŋ within the Dakota language.

  • Habitat and Phenological Growth Cycle:

    • Grows as an annual emergent aquatic grass situated in shallow, slow-moving freshwater rivers, lakes, and wetland margins.

    • Survival depends entirely upon stable water quality and consistent seasonal water-level gradients.

    • Autumn (Fall): Ripened seed grains drop naturally from the flowering head, settling into the soft organic mud of the lakebed.

    • Winter: Seeds undergo an obligate dormancy period submerged beneath lake ice and cold water.

    • Late Spring: Warming water triggers germination; plants anchor roots into benthic silt and develop submerged leaves.

    • Early Summer: Stalks emerge through the water column and develop aerial leaves and floral panicles.

    • Late August: Grains mature and harden, ready for harvest or natural seed drop.

  • Morphological Profile:

    • Mature vegetative stalks extend between 2 ft2\text{ ft} and 8 ft8\text{ ft} (2 to 8 feet2\text{ to }8\text{ feet}) above the surface of the water.

    • Stands form dense, intricate aquatic prairies navigable almost exclusively via lightweight canoes to protect bottom sediment from perturbation.

Processed wild rice grains held in a hand at the Wild Rice House in Finland, Minnesota

Indigenous Cultural Philosophy and Traditional Harvesting

  • Anishinaabe Sacred Relationship:

    • In Anishinaabe cosmologies, manoomin represents a gift from the Creator that wove the foundational cultural fabric of the nation, establishing the basis for sacred ceremonies, songs, oral history, and spiritual philosophy.

    • Under Indigenous relational ontology, manoomin is not categorized as property, raw material, or a commercial commodity; rather, it is honored as a sentient non-human relative endowed with spiritual standing.

  • Ethic of Reciprocity:

    • Human harvesting is bound to mutual obligation: wild rice offers dense physical nourishment to sustain human populations, and human caretakers assume stewardship responsibilities to protect, preserve, and regenerate wild rice beds.

  • Traditional Husbandry and Harvesting Methodology:

    • Contradicts the early European settler narrative that wild rice was an unmanaged wilderness grain that merely sowed itself without deliberate cultivation.

    • The abundance of regional beds is the direct consequence of generational Indigenous management, selective harvesting, and deliberate reseeding.

    • Tying the Sheaves: Approximately 10 days10\text{ days} prior to grain maturation, Anishinaabe women navigate canoes into the beds to gather and tie living stalks into loose bundles (sheaves), preventing high winds and waterfowl from stripping early ripe grains.

    • Ricing in Canoes: When grains reach maturity, a team of two navigates the beds. While one individual poles or steers the canoe, the other unties each sheaf, gently bends the stalks over the gunwale, and uses cedar sticks (knockers) to tap the heads, dislodging ripe grain into the hull.

    • Deliberate Reseeding: The act of striking the rice sheaves intentionally casts a significant portion of ripe seed grains directly into the water column, guaranteeing natural seed distribution into the mud for subsequent growing cycles.

    • Onshore Processing: Harvested rice is processed via a three-phase traditional protocol:

      • Parching: Slow, controlled heating over fire to reduce moisture and loosen the inedible outer hull.

      • Threshing (Jigging): Foot treading or mechanical rubbing to detach the loosened hulls from the grain kernels.

      • Winnowing: Tossing grain into the air from shallow birchbark trays, using wind currents to separate the light chaff from the dense edible seeds.

Wild rice tied into bunches or sheaves while growing in a marsh, 1899

Historical Commodification and Ecological Pressures

  • Eighteenth- and Nineteenth-Century Colonial Bioprospecting:

    • European colonial observers reframed manoomin as an extractable agricultural resource, characterizing it as a low-cost, nearly labor-free crop with commercial potential.

    • Imperial botanists attempted to harvest and transport seed stock across the Atlantic to establish wild rice in European wetlands.

    • The imperial objective was to cultivate a cheap, high-nutrition caloric base to feed enslaved workforces, the domestic urban poor, and expanding imperial military forces.

    • These attempts systematically failed because European scientists could not duplicate the cold-dormancy limnological conditions of North America or replicate the multi-seasonal care and harvesting regimes cultivated by Indigenous stewards.

    • As historical geographer Anya Zilberstein notes, the failed cultivation demonstrated the clear limits of European imperial capacity to absorb local ecosystems and assimilate wild species into imperial political economies.

  • Settler-Colonial Encroachment and Industrial Disruption:

    • Beginning in the nineteenth century, non-Indigenous commercial harvesters invaded Minnesota waters, utilizing destructive techniques such as motorized boats that broke plant roots, premature harvesting before seeds matured, and mechanized harvesters that stripped stands entirely, leaving zero seed for natural reproduction.

    • Widespread industrial logging clogged waterways with silt, agricultural ditching drained wetlands, and hydraulic dams altered natural water cycles, causing devastating floods or desiccation across historical wild rice beds.

    • In 19271927, the State of Minnesota established regulations restricting mechanized wild rice harvesting to preserve stocks, though enforcement was uneven and frequently undermined tribal harvesting rights.

  • Modern Anthropogenic Threats:

    • Climate Change: Unpredictable precipitation events, intense summer storms, altered ice cover, and warming water temperatures disrupt the sensitive dormancy and germination cycles of Zizania palustris.

    • Industrial Extraction and Pollution: Sulfide mining ventures and pipeline infrastructure threaten delicate aquatic chemistry and contaminate the watersheds sustaining northern wild rice.

Global Rights of Nature Movement Timeline

  • Movement Philosophy:

    • Represents a legal and cultural restructuring that rejects the traditional property status of the natural world, arguing that ecosystems and ecological communities possess inherent legal rights to exist, regenerate, and maintain vital ecological cycles.

    • Defined by the Global Alliance for the Rights of Nature (GARN) as the explicit legal recognition that ecosystems hold fundamental rights just as human beings hold fundamental rights.

  • Theoretical Foundations (19721972):

    • Legal scholar Christopher Stone published the foundational essay Should Trees Have Standing? Toward Legal Rights for Natural Objects, proposing that environmental entities should possess legal standing to sue through appointed legal guardians.

    • In 19721972, this doctrine formally entered American legal jurisprudence via Supreme Court Justice William O. Douglas's landmark dissent in Sierra Club v. Morton.

  • Municipal and National Codifications:

    • 20062006 (Tamaqua Borough, Pennsylvania): Became the first municipal government globally to recognize the rights of nature by passing a local ordinance prohibiting commercial waste haulers from dumping toxic sewage sludge within town boundaries.

    • 20082008 (Ecuador): Became the first sovereign nation to constitutionally enshrine the Rights of Nature (Pachamama) in its supreme national charter, granting ecosystems the enforceable right to integral restoration and existence.

    • 20102010 (Bolivia): Enacted statutory protections through the national Law of the Rights of Mother Earth (Ley de Derechos de la Madre Tierra).

  • Jurisprudential Recognition of Riverine Personhood (2010s2010\text{s}):

    • Courts and legislative bodies internationally extended the concept of legal personality to river ecosystems, including the Atrato River in Colombia, the Whanganui River in New Zealand (recognized via the Te Awa Tupua Act), and the Ganges and Yamuna Rivers in Uttarakhand, India.

  • The 2018 White Earth Band Statute:

    • In December 20182018, the White Earth Band of Ojibwe formally passed the Rights of Manoomin resolution and ordinance.

    • Represented the first legal act globally to bestow enforceable legal rights and personhood upon a specific plant species, breaking new legal ground beyond collective ecosystems and waterways.

Relational Jurisprudence and the Plant Humanities

  • Overcoming Legal Plant Blindness:

    • Western jurisprudence historically relegated plant life to the status of passive property, background scenery, or extractable biomass.

    • The Manoomin litigation challenges this human-centric framework by arguing that a plant species can be a victim of concrete legal injury, capable of being harmed in its own right by state and corporate actors.

  • Translating Kinship into Law:

    • By positioning manoomin as a litigant, Indigenous legal theorists demonstrate how ancient relationship-based governance models can be integrated into modern legal structures without relying on commercial-property doctrines.

  • The Plant Humanities Initiative:

    • Conducted in collaboration with institutions like Dumbarton Oaks, the Plant Humanities Initiative places flora at the absolute center of humanistic and legal inquiry, studying the deep reciprocal connections between human societies, legal systems, and the botanical world.

Scholarly Reference Library on Manoomin and Nature's Rights

  • Glenn C. Reynolds (20072007): "A Native American Land Ethic," Natural Resources & Environment, Vol. 2121, No. 33, pp. 16–2016\text{--}20 (American Bar Association).

  • Anya Zilberstein (20152015): "Inured to Empire: Wild Rice and Climate Change," The William and Mary Quarterly, Vol. 7272, No. 11, pp. 127–158127\text{--}158 (Omohundro Institute of Early American History & Culture).

  • Taylor A. Steeves (19521952): "Wild Rice: Indian Food and a Modern Delicacy," Economic Botany, Vol. 66, No. 22, pp. 107–142107\text{--}142 (Springer Nature on behalf of New York Botanical Garden Press).

  • John B. Moyle (19441944): "Wild Rice in Minnesota," The Journal of Wildlife Management, Vol. 88, No. 33, pp. 177–184177\text{--}184 (Wiley on behalf of the Wildlife Society).

  • Bernard Coleman (19531953): "The Ojibwa and the Wild Rice Problem," Anthropological Quarterly, Vol. 2626, No. 33, New Series Vol. 11, pp. 79–8879\text{--}88 (The George Washington University Institute for Ethnographic Research).

  • George Catlin: Ojibwa gathering wild rice near the source of the St. Peter's River, University of Cincinnati.

  • Valeria Kuzivanova and Iain J. Davidson-Hunt (20172017): "Biocultural Design," Ethnobiology Letters, Vol. 88, No. 11, pp. 23–3023\text{--}30 (Society of Ethnobiology).

  • Stanford Law Review (19741974): "Review," Stanford Law Review, Vol. 2626, No. 66, Symposium on Law and Psychology, pp. 1488–14891488\text{--}1489.

  • Albert Ernest Jenks (18991899): Wild Rice Tied in Bunches or Sheaves While in Marsh, National Anthropological Archives, Smithsonian Institution / Artstor.

  • Jessica Milgroom and Don Wedll (20222022): "Preserving Minnesota’s Wild Rice," Minnesota History, Vol. 6868, No. 33, pp. 78–8978\text{--}89 (Minnesota Historical Society Press).

  • Seth Eastman (1849–18551849\text{--}1855): Gathering Wild Rice, Minneapolis Institute of Art.