1929 Shiroyama Reading

Global Depression, End of Globalization, and the Turn to National Self-Sufficiency (1929)

Periodization of the Modern Global Economic System

  • Historical Phases of Globalization:

    • 1870-1929: First Globalization

      • Partially suspended during WWI (1914-1918)

    • 1929 - ca. 1975: Economic Depression, Rise of Nationalism and Autarky, WWII, Post-War Welfare States

    • 1975 - 2017: Second Globalization with ongoing de-globalization tendencies

Notes and Discussion on Periodization

  • The concept of periodization includes approximate dates, indicating trends rather than fixed endpoints.

  • The era starting from 1870 saw an intensification of key globalization elements, although precursors existed prior.

  • The year 1929 is marked as the clear endpoint of the first globalization despite preceding instability.

  • Second Globalization emergence from the mid-1960s, solidified as an ideology by the late 1970s and fully institutionalized by the 1990s.

  • Key moments of de-globalization since 2008:

    • Xi Jinping's rise in China (2013)

    • Donald Trump's first presidency (2017-2021)

    • 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine

    • Possible future implications stemming from potential second Trump presidency starting in 2025

  • Despite ongoing high global trade levels, trends suggest increasing de-globalization towards national and regional economic models.

Understanding Periodization

  • Examines the importance of specifying historical phases and their implications on current global relations.

Three Pillars of 19th Century Globalization

  • Transportation and Communication Technologies: Essential for interconnectedness.

  • The Free Trade Regime: Advocated by 19th-century leaders to lower tariffs and increase trade volume across borders.

  • Gold Standard International Monetary System:

    • Adopted in 1870s allowing currency to be pegged to gold, aiding in stable exchange rates.

    • Advantages included stability, automaticity, and commitment assurance but faced practical instabilities due to gold shipment adjustments.

1st Wave Globalization: Communication

  • Transatlantic Telegraph Cable: Established in 1866.

  • By the late 1880s and 1890s, global telegraphy emerged, drastically changing news distribution and capital flow.

1st Wave Globalization: Transportation

  • Suez Canal: Completed in 1869; a hallmark of modern engineering.

    • Reduced travel distance between India and Europe by 40%.

    • Enabled steamships to facilitate rapid movement of goods and people.

1st Globalization: Migration

  • Migration patterns shifted significantly during this period, favoring migration to urban centers in the West.

1st Wave Globalization: Free Trade Regime

  • Free trade advocates succeeded in promoting significant reductions in tariffs, leading to increased international trade.

1st Globalization: Movements of Goods

  • Enhanced volume of merchandise traded internationally due to improved communication and transport.

1st Wave Globalization: Gold Standard International Monetary System

  • Functionality:

    • Gold was held to match circulating currency, allowing for easy convertibility.

    • Maintained fixed exchange rates between currencies, promoting international trade stability.

  • Advantages:

    • Stable nominal anchor

    • Automatic adjustment mechanisms

    • Credible commitment to maintain value

  • Limitations:

    • Instability due to logistical challenges of gold transport.

Spirit of Internationalism

  • Intangible force promoting collaboration during the first wave of globalization, influencing policies and cultural exchange.

The Great Illusion

  • Concept popularized by Norman Angell in his 1911 book, arguing that global economic integration made warfare between developed nations futile.

    • Key arguments included:

      • Militaristic confrontations were economically detrimental and thus counterproductive.

      • Underlying economic interdependence served as a deterrent against wars.

      • Post-conquest scenarios would degrade the economic viability of conquered lands, disincentivizing imperialist pursuits.

First World War and the Global System

  • The connection of the Great Illusion to the dynamics leading into WWI highlights misconceptions about the permanence of globalization.

John Maynard Keynes: The Economic Consequences of the Peace (1919)

  • Keynes cautioned against punitive reparations imposed on Germany post-WWI; predicted economic ruin for Europe if historical globalization approaches were neglected.

  • He advocated for restoring free markets and international harmony as opposed to revenge and punitive measures, foreshadowing conflict if ignored.

Global Instabilities in the 1920's

  • Accumulating tensions and issues leading up to global depression marked a transformational economic period.

Reaction Against International Migration

  • The backlash against migration intensified from 1900, particularly prominent in restrictive legal policies during the 1920s.

The Circulating Debt Problem

  • The economic strategies and challenges related to international finance during the depressive periods.

New York Stock Exchange Crash in 1929

  • Index crash led to widespread panic, underscoring the volatility of financial markets.

Rise of Tariffs and Breakdown of Trade

  • Imposed tariffs contributed to a regression in international trade networks post-1929.

Beggar Thy Neighbor Policies

  • Economic strategies where countries sought to protect their interests at the expense of other countries' economies, further exacerbating global depression.

Nationalism and the Hardening of Perceptions

  • The decline of globalization led to views of international commerce as a threat; a focus on national self-sufficiency emerged strongly.

  • The 1930s revealed a shift in attitudes towards globalization as a collective mistake and strengthened national policies aimed at prosperity.

    • Significant developments in welfare state programs across various political regimes, including both democratic and totalitarian systems, with mixed results in human rights considerations.

    • Notable expansion with alongside repressive actions toward minorities and ideological purging, highlighting ethical complexities.