YW

Jenson pp.266-269 The Painful Truth

The Painful Truth About Today's Pornography

Workshop Overview

  • Robert Jensen, Ph.D. leads a workshop for women who work with battered women and rape survivors.

  • After three hours of discussion on the porn industry, attendees exhibit emotional distress.

  • A participant expresses profound sadness, stating, "This hurts. It just hurts so much."

  • The pain stems from understanding that pornography reduces women to objects of violence and humiliation.

Main Issues with Pornography

  • There is a pervasive connection between sexual desire and cruelty in male-oriented pornography.

  • The workshop reveals the emotional burden that knowledge of this issue places even on professionals who deal with the consequences of male violence.

  • Jensen argues that pornography is not merely about sex but also about the cultural acceptance of male cruelty towards women.

Understanding Mainstream Pornography

Pornography Genres

  • Jensen's study focuses on mainstream heterosexual pornography, particularly videos that depict explicit sexual activity between men and women.

  • It excludes more extreme forms of pornography such as bondage, sadomasochism, and child pornography, which is illegal.

Research Method

  • Jensen visited various adult video shops to collect data on the most commonly rented and bought tapes, aiming for a fair representation of the predominant genre.

  • The industry produces a significant number of films, with over 11,000 hardcore titles released in 2002 alone, reinforcing the point that these narratives are not isolated instances.

Cultural Impact

  • Mainstream pornography is widely consumed by men and can influence their perceptions and behaviors towards women.

  • Examples of common pornographic narratives illustrate the degrading treatment of women, making it clear that these are pervasive messages in the industry.

  • Jensen stresses the potential implications of these depictions on societal views of women and their treatment in real life.

Illustrative Examples of Mainstream Pornography

Notable Films

  • "Sopornos 4": A parodic take on a popular television series featuring mobsters, which includes graphic depictions of violence and degradation.

  • "Two in the Seat #3": Involves double penetration, where the woman expresses both pain and submission under male aggression, normalized as pleasurable for the viewer.

  • "Gag Factor 10": Depicts extreme instances of physical domination and sexual humiliation, culminating in graphic images designed to titillate through cruelty.

Emotional and Physical Toll on Performers

  • Performers, like BellaDonna in "Two in the Seat #3", share experiences of strenuous preparation that involve physical distress, highlighting the toll of participating in such films.

  • Jensen raises concerns about why such visible pain is left unedited in films, suggesting it either enhances viewer interest or reveals a troubling enjoyment of women's suffering.

The Sexualization of Cruelty

The Dating of Sexual Acts

  • As pornography has evolved, there has been a shift towards incorporating overt cruelty into sexual acts enjoyed by viewers.

  • Jensen posits that this trend might be tied to a cultural understanding where rape is normalized within a patriarchal context, merging the notions of sex and power.

Normalization of Rape Culture

  • Jensen argues that in a society where the predominant narrative around sex is centered on male pleasure, rape and dominance structures thrive as part of sexual norms.

  • This poses a societal dilemma and prompts the question of why there is little public concern over the normalization of such portrayals in mainstream culture.

Men and the Challenge of Conscientious Sexuality

The Role of Men

  • Jensen emphasizes that men need to consciously separate their identities from the culturally embedded dynamic of dominance and submission.

  • The disparity of power in sexual situations is exacerbated by mainstream pornography, influencing interactions in various contexts, including professional settings.

The Broader Implications

  • Men exposed to these images may not exhibit overtly aggressive behavior yet could subconsciously carry biases impacting their treatment of women.

  • Jensen presents a case for discussing pornography's role in shaping sexual ethics and relationships, arguing that critique is necessary to promote healthier sexual norms.

Conclusion

  • The critique of pornography is vital not only for understanding its damaging impact but for advocating for a healthy sexual culture that values empathy and mutual respect.

  • Jensen concludes by asserting that discussions about pornography should focus on fostering an egalitarian approach to intimacy and rejecting narratives that endorse pain and humiliation, thereby affirming the value of women in society.

  1. Pornography perpetuates a culture of male dominance and cruelty towards women, reducing them to mere objects of violence and humiliation, which influences societal views and treatment of women.

  2. The normalization of rape culture within mainstream pornography contributes to harmful sexual norms, intertwining sexual acts with power dynamics that perpetuate dominance and submission.

  3. A critical examination of pornography is essential to advocating for a healthier sexual culture that values empathy and mutual respect, challenging the narratives that endorse pain and humiliation.