Group Influence Vocabulary Flashcards

Understanding Groups and Social Influence

  • Definition of a Group:     * A group is comprised of two or more people who interact with and influence one another and perceive one another as "us."

  • The Purpose of Groups:     * Groups fulfill human needs to:         * Affiliate.         * Achieve.         * Gain Social Identity.

  • Examples of Groups:     * Members of a basketball team.     * Residents of the same dormitory.     * Students attending a lecture class.     * A family.     * Students standing in a lunch line at the cafeteria.

Social Facilitation and Performance

  • Overview of Influence:     * The mere presence of others can significantly influence an individual's response. Major topics include Social Facilitation, Social Loafing, and Deindividuation.

  • Social Facilitation Definition:     * Social Facilitation is the phenomenon where the presence of others increases the likelihood that dominant responses will occur.

  • Historical Foundation:     * Triplett (1898): Conducted a fishing line study to investigate how the presence of others influences performance.     * Zajonc, et al. (1969) Cockroach Study (Simple Task):         * Methodology: Cockroaches were placed in a simple maze where they had to escape a bright floodlight to reach a goal.         * Independent Variable (IV): Whether the cockroach was alone or with an audience (cockroaches in "audience boxes").         * Dependent Variable (DV): Speed to escape.         * Results (Simple Maze):             * Alone: 40.6 seconds40.6\,\text{seconds}.             * With Audience: 33.0 seconds33.0\,\text{seconds}.

  • Social Facilitation vs. Inhibition (Complex Tasks):     * Social facilitation works for simple, well-learned tasks but can hinder new, difficult tasks.     * Zajonc, et al. (1969) Complex Maze Study:         * Results showed that when cockroaches performed in a complex maze:             * Alone: 110 seconds110\,\text{seconds}.             * With Audience: 130 seconds130\,\text{seconds}.

  • Dominant Response Theory:     * A dominant response is the response that is most likely to occur.     * Expert or Easy Task: The dominant response is to perform well.     * Non-expert or Hard Task: The dominant response is to perform poorly.

  • Michaels et al. (1982) Pool Player Study:     * Methodology: Recruited good and bad pool players and observed their performance while alone versus while being observed.     * Dependent Variable (DV): Percentage of shots made.     * Results (Approximate based on study data):         * Expert Players (Alone): ~71%71\% shots made.         * Expert Players (Observed): ~80%80\% shots made.         * Poor Players (Alone): ~36%36\% shots made.         * Poor Players (Observed): ~25%25\% shots made.

  • Underlying Mechanisms of Social Facilitation:     * Mere presence: Leads to alertness, which produces arousal.     * Evaluation apprehension: Concern for how others are evaluating us leads to arousal.     * Distraction: Division of attention between the task and the audience creates conflict, which leads to arousal.

Social Loafing

  • Definition:     * Social Loafing is the reduction of individual effort when working with others on additive group tasks.

  • Latané, Williams, & Harkins (1979) Shouting Study:     * Methodology: Groups of 1,2,4, or 61, 2, 4,\text{ or } 6 people were asked to shout and clap as loud as possible.     * Dependent Variable (DV): Sound pressure produced per person.     * Results:         * 11 person: 3.73.7         * 22 people: 5.25.2 (71%71\% of individual capacity)         * 44 people: 7.27.2 (51%51\% of individual capacity)         * 66 people: 9.09.0 (40%40\% of individual capacity)

  • Differentiating Social Facilitation and Social Loafing:     * Performance is determined by two factors:         1. Can individual efforts be identified and evaluated?         2. Is the task easy or difficult?     * When Efforts ARE Evaluated (Social Facilitation):         * Presence of others leads to alertness, evaluation apprehension, and distraction-conflict.         * Results in arousal.         * Simple Tasks: Enhanced performance.         * Complex Tasks: Impaired performance.     * When Efforts ARE NOT Evaluated (Social Loafing):         * Presence of others leads to no evaluation apprehension.         * Results in relaxation.         * Simple Tasks: Impaired performance (loafing).         * Complex Tasks: Enhanced performance (others absorb the pressure).

Deindividuation

  • Conceptual Question: "If you could do anything humanly possible with complete assurance that you would not be detected or held responsible, what would you do?"

  • Definition:     * Deindividuation is the loss of self-awareness and evaluation apprehension that leads individuals to behave in accordance with group norms.

  • Conditions Leading to Deindividuation:     * Being in a group.     * Anonymity.     * Arousal.

  • Research Findings on Anonymity Responses:     * Frequent categories:         * Criminal acts: 26%26\%         * Sexual acts: 11%11\%         * Spying behaviors: 11%11\%     * Most common specific response: "Rob a bank" (15%15\%     * Nature of responses:         * Antisocial: 36%36\%         * Nonnormative: 19%19\%         * Neutral: 36%36\%         * Prosocial: 9%9\%

  • Diener et al. (1976) Trick-or-Treating Research:     * Methodology: Children approached houses alone or in groups. They were either asked their names (individuated) or remained anonymous.     * DV: Stealing candy.     * Results:         * Individuated/Alone: Lowest rates of stealing (~10%10\%         * Anonymous/Group: Highest rates of stealing (~60%60\%         * Conclusion: When deindividuated, children stole more candy.

  • Norm Obedience:     * Deindividuation leads people to obey group and situational norms.     * Negative norms lead to negative behavior; positive norms lead to positive behavior.

  • Deindividuation Online (Jaidka et al., 2021):     * Methodology: US participants volunteered for a 25-minute25\text{-minute} online discussion regarding gun rights. Conditions varied by being personally identifiable/socially identifiable or not.     * Measured Variables: Rationality and Incivility of postings.     * Findings:         * Highest rationality and lower incivility were associated with being "Personally Visible" and "Socially Visible."         * Highest incivility was associated with being "Personally Anonymous" and "Socially Anonymous."

Group Decision Making and Groupthink

  • Process Loss:     * This refers to any aspect of group interaction that inhibits good problem solving.

  • Groupthink (Janis, 1971):     * Defined as "the mode of thinking that persons engage in when concurrence-seeking becomes so dominant in a cohesive in-group that it tends to override realistic appraisal of alternative courses of action."

  • Theoretical Analysis (Janis & Mann, 1977):     * In situations that breed groupthink, the drive for concurrence leads to symptoms of groupthink and ultimately defective decision making.

  • Preventing Groupthink:     * Be impartial: Leaders should not endorse any position at the start.     * Encourage critical evaluation: Assign a "devil's advocate."     * Subdivide the group: Occasionally break into smaller units, then reunite to air differences.     * Outside critiques: Welcome reviews from outside experts and associates.     * Second-chance meetings: Before implementation, hold a meeting to voice any lingering doubts.

Minority Influence and Leadership

  • Power of the Few (Minority Influence):     * Moscovici (1985): A minority can influence the majority through consistency, self-confidence, and defection from the majority.     * Minorities obtain private acceptance through informational social influence.

  • Leadership:     * Defined as the process by which certain group members motivate and guide the group.     * Best Leadership Qualities: Consistency, self-confidence, vision, communication, and inspirational ability.

  • Transformational Leadership:     * A style of leadership enabled by a leader’s vision and inspiration, which exerts significant influence.

  • Contingency Theory of Leadership:     * Asserts that leadership effectiveness depends on the specific situation.     * Task Leadership: Focused on organizing work, setting standards, and achieving specific goals.     * Social Leadership: Focused on building teamwork, mediating conflict, and offering emotional support.

  • Situational Leadership Scenarios:     * Tech Start-up: Rapid growth requires scaling operations quickly. Skilled teams may lack direction due to a fast-paced environment (may require Task Leadership).     * Nonprofit Organization: Relies on volunteer staff with diverse backgrounds and varying commitment levels (may require Social Leadership to maintain engagement).