Smith Parkhurst 2018

Introduction to Personality and Health

  • Personality significantly influences physical health, with robust associations found in research (Strickhouser et al., 2017).

  • Personality affects physiological functioning and the development of diseases through:

    • Psychobiologic/psychosomatic pathways influencing stress responses leading to disease.

    • Influence on health-relevant behaviors (exercise, diet, adherence to medical treatments).

  • Recent methodological improvements enhance the study of personality and health.

  • Challenges in expanding the evidence base, integrating psychosocial factors, and supporting practical applications for health improvement remain.

Traits Linked to Health Outcomes

Historical Context

  • Mid-20th century psychodynamic studies explored unconscious processes linked to diseases, but faced limitations.

  • Modern research begins with Type A behavior and psychological hardiness, showing growth in understanding personality-health relationships.

Key Personality Traits Affecting Health

Type A Behavior Pattern
  • Characteristics: competitiveness, achievement-striving, impatience, and hostility.

  • Initially considered an independent risk factor for coronary heart disease (CHD).

  • Hostility and related traits emerge as the most significant predictors of CHD (Chida & Steptoe, 2009).

    • Vigorous speaking style is also a predictor (Houston et al., 1997).

Neuroticism and Negative Affectivity
  • Neuroticism: Tendency to experience negative emotions and thoughts.

  • Often leads to increased somatic complaints, initially challenging to correlate with objective health outcomes.

  • Research indicates a strong link to adverse health outcomes like CHD and diabetes (Gan et al., 2014; Knol et al., 2006).

Extraversion and Positive Affectivity
  • Extraversion linked to positive health outcomes and longevity (Boehm & Kubzansky, 2012).

Conscientiousness
  • Key traits include organization, persistence, and discipline.

  • Strongly predicts longevity and health behaviors (Turiano et al., 2015).

Openness to Experience
  • Curiosity and flexibility correlate with longevity and better health outcomes (Iwasa et al., 2008).

Optimism
  • Defined as positive expectations about future events.

  • Optimists display lower cardiovascular disease risk and greater longevity (Boehm & Kubzansky, 2012).

Hardiness and Sense of Coherence
  • Hardiness: Resilience against stress effects on health.

  • Sense of Coherence: Beliefs about the manageability and meaningfulness of life, predictive of lower cardiovascular risk (Surtees et al., 2006).

Type D Personality
  • Combination of high negative affectivity and social inhibition, increasing health risks.

Mechanisms Linking Personality to Health

Stress Moderation

  • Personality influences physiological responses to stress affecting health outcomes.

  • Individual differences in stress reactivity, recovery, and sleep quality are influenced by personality traits.

  • Traits such as hostility and neuroticism lead to poor recovery from stress.

Health Behavior

  • Personality traits are consistently related to health behaviors impacting morbidity and mortality risks (Sutin et al., 2016).

Genetic and Biological Considerations

  • Personality and health effects may arise from underlying biological predispositions.

    • Genetic studies show heritable variance in personality and health outcomes.

Methodological Considerations

Measurement Issues

  • Differing assessment methods for personality traits can create inconsistencies in results (jingle/jangle fallacies).

  • Suggests a need for more consistent and valid measures across studies.

Research Design

  • Prospective studies provide stronger evidence of personality health links compared to cross-sectional designs.

  • Consideration of confounding factors and their measurement reliability is crucial.

Future Directions

  • Emphasizing rigorous replication and integration of personality research with health outcomes.

  • Broadening the focus to include genetic, cultural, and socioeconomic factors influencing health disparities.

  • Understanding early adversity effects on lifetime health trajectories represents an opportunity for preventive interventions.

Conclusion

  • Clear associations exist between certain personality traits and health outcomes, providing avenues for intervention and improvement in health psychology.

  • Antagonistic behaviors and chronic negative emotions pose risks, while positive traits like conscientiousness and optimism offer protective benefits.