Chapter 6

Employee Selection Notes

Internal vs External Staffing

Core Internal Staffing Tools & Techniques
  • Internal Job Posting: Advertising vacancies internally to fill roles with existing employees.

  • Expression of Interest: Inviting employees to express their interest in current or upcoming opportunities.

  • Talent Profiles / Skills Inventory: Documented information on employees’ skills, experiences, and career ambitions.

  • Talent Pools: Groups of employees identified as potential candidates for future or recurring roles.

  • Succession Planning: Identifying and developing talent to fill key positions.

  • Acting Assignments / Temporary Promotions: Short-term placement in higher-level roles for coverage or development.

  • Career Pathing: Defined progression routes that outline advancement opportunities within the organization.

  • Talent Reviews: Formal discussions evaluating employee performance, potential, and readiness for future positions.

Core External Staffing Tools & Techniques
  • External Job Posting: Advertising vacancies to candidates outside the organization.

  • Recruitment Agencies / Headhunters: Employing third parties to source and screen candidates.

  • Employee Referrals: Encouraging employees to recommend external candidates.

  • Talent Pipelines: Nurturing ongoing relationships with potential future candidates.

  • Campus Recruitment: Engaging students or recent graduates through colleges and universities.

  • Social Media Recruiting: Utilizing platforms like LinkedIn for candidate sourcing.

  • Career Fairs & Networking: Attending organized events to connect with potential candidates.

  • Online Application Systems (ATS): Systems for managing external applications and screenings.

Learning Outcomes - Chapter 6

  • LO1: Explain the goals of the personnel selection process, its steps, and the necessity for reliability, validity, and legal defensibility of information gathered during the process.

  • LO2: Describe initial screening tools, interview types, and post-interview screening techniques that firms utilize.

  • LO3: Compare various selection test values and discuss how their validity can be demonstrated.

  • LO4: Explain methods for evaluating candidate information and the decision-making strategies for employee selection.

Overview of the Selection Process

  • Selection Definition: The process of choosing individuals with relevant qualifications to fill job openings.

  • Final Decision Makers: HR managers typically make the final hiring decisions.

  • Cost Considerations: Misses include the costs associated with hiring ineffective personnel (false positives) and the missed opportunities of not hiring potentially successful candidates (false negatives).

  • Goal of Selection: Maximize “hits” (successful placements) and avoid “misses” (bad hires).

Job Analysis

  • Job Specifications: Identify the knowledge, skills, abilities, and other characteristics (KSAOs) leading to superior performance.

  • Assessment Methods: Use interviews, references, and pre-employment tests to measure candidates' KSAOs against the job requirements.

  • Defining Success: Through job analysis, clarity on performance expectations and essential KSAOs is established.

Steps in the Selection Process

  • The selection process varies based on organization and position level, including:

    • Completion of Application

    • Submission of Résumé

    • Initial Interview in HR

    • Employment Testing (aptitude, achievement)

    • Supervisor/Team Interview

    • Reference Checking

    • Background Investigation

    • Hiring Decision

  • Note: Applicants can be dropped at any step of the process.

Obtaining Reliable and Valid Information

  • Information Critique: Must be reliable, valid, and legal; also protecting applicant privacy is critical.

    • Reliability: Consistency of results across interviews, tests, etc.

    • Validity: The degree to which a selection method measures the intended attributes.

Initial Screening Overview

  • Purpose: Filter candidates before in-depth interviews and ensure qualified applicants progress.

  • Methods of Initial Screening:

    • Resume/CV Review

    • Application Form Screening

    • Phone/Video Screening

    • Online Assessments/Tests

    • Pre-Screening Questionnaires

  • Benefits of Pre-Selection:

    • Saves hiring manager's time and improves candidate quality.

    • Enhances candidate experience through timely feedback.

    • Increases likelihood of a better role fit.

Employment Interviews

  • Interview Types: Can involve a single person or multiple members from a team, depending on the job's nature.

  • Validity Concerns: Though interviews are practical for small applicant pools, validity criticisms exist due to their subjective nature.

Forms of Interview Structure
  • Nondirective Interview: Free-form discussion that allows the applicant to guide the conversation.

  • Structured Interview: Uses standardized questions and predefined answers.

  • Situational Interview: Involves hypothetical scenarios to gauge applicant responses.

  • Behavioral Description Interview (BDI): Asks candidates about past behavior in specific situations.

  • Panel Interview: Conducted by multiple interviewers.

  • Sequential Interview: One-on-one interviews in sequence.

  • Video Interviews: Conducted via videoconferencing.

  • Computer-Administered Interviews: Standardized questions via a computer for efficiency.

Guidelines for Interviewers

  • Understand legal obligations and best practices during interviews, including knowledge of the job, establishing rapport, and being transparent with candidates.

Post-Interview Screening

  • Reference Checks: Most reliable information comes from previous supervisors.

  • Background Checks: Standard for many companies, can include credit checks.

Preemployment Tests

  • Definition: Objective measures to evaluate knowledge, skills, abilities, and other characteristics (KSAOs) against benchmarks.

  • Types of Tests:

    • Job Knowledge

    • Work Sample

    • Cognitive Ability

    • Personality and Interest Inventories

    • Honesty and Integrity Tests

    • Physical Ability Tests

    • Medical Examinations and Drug Testing

Validating Tests

  • Validation Types:

    • Criterion-Related Validity

    • Content Validity

    • Construct Validity

  • Content Validity Example: Driver’s license exams assess relevant knowledge.

  • Construct Validity Example: Measures traits like intelligence and personality based on various behaviors.

Selection Decision Making

  • Decision Strategies: Vary based on the type of role to be filled. Factors include potential for diversity and performance measuring methods.

  • Approaches: Clinical (subjective) and Statistical (objective). Two methods:

    • Compensatory Model: High scores in one area offset low scores elsewhere.

    • Multiple-Cutoff Model: Applicants must meet minimum criteria across all dimensions.

    • Multiple-Hurdle Ratio: Sequential strategy; only applicants passing cutoff scores progress.

  • Selection Ratio: Number of applicants relative to hires – e.g., 0.100.10 means 10% will be hired.

Final Decision

  • HR communicates the hiring decision and extends the job offer, emphasizing that it should be documented in writing to prevent misunderstandings.

Activities for Practical Learning

  1. Mock Interview Setup: Teams develop interview questions using different formats.

  2. Reaching Selection Decisions Discussion: Key considerations for hiring decisions, including potential and organizational needs, starting compensation, and factors affecting diversity plans.

Preparation for Next Class

  • Case Study Work: Teams to focus on the case study due by Jan. 30.

  • Reading Assignment: Chapter 3 due by Feb. 6.