Chapter 6
Employee Selection Notes
Internal vs External Staffing
Core Internal Staffing Tools & Techniques
Internal Job Posting: Advertising vacancies internally to fill roles with existing employees.
Expression of Interest: Inviting employees to express their interest in current or upcoming opportunities.
Talent Profiles / Skills Inventory: Documented information on employees’ skills, experiences, and career ambitions.
Talent Pools: Groups of employees identified as potential candidates for future or recurring roles.
Succession Planning: Identifying and developing talent to fill key positions.
Acting Assignments / Temporary Promotions: Short-term placement in higher-level roles for coverage or development.
Career Pathing: Defined progression routes that outline advancement opportunities within the organization.
Talent Reviews: Formal discussions evaluating employee performance, potential, and readiness for future positions.
Core External Staffing Tools & Techniques
External Job Posting: Advertising vacancies to candidates outside the organization.
Recruitment Agencies / Headhunters: Employing third parties to source and screen candidates.
Employee Referrals: Encouraging employees to recommend external candidates.
Talent Pipelines: Nurturing ongoing relationships with potential future candidates.
Campus Recruitment: Engaging students or recent graduates through colleges and universities.
Social Media Recruiting: Utilizing platforms like LinkedIn for candidate sourcing.
Career Fairs & Networking: Attending organized events to connect with potential candidates.
Online Application Systems (ATS): Systems for managing external applications and screenings.
Learning Outcomes - Chapter 6
LO1: Explain the goals of the personnel selection process, its steps, and the necessity for reliability, validity, and legal defensibility of information gathered during the process.
LO2: Describe initial screening tools, interview types, and post-interview screening techniques that firms utilize.
LO3: Compare various selection test values and discuss how their validity can be demonstrated.
LO4: Explain methods for evaluating candidate information and the decision-making strategies for employee selection.
Overview of the Selection Process
Selection Definition: The process of choosing individuals with relevant qualifications to fill job openings.
Final Decision Makers: HR managers typically make the final hiring decisions.
Cost Considerations: Misses include the costs associated with hiring ineffective personnel (false positives) and the missed opportunities of not hiring potentially successful candidates (false negatives).
Goal of Selection: Maximize “hits” (successful placements) and avoid “misses” (bad hires).
Job Analysis
Job Specifications: Identify the knowledge, skills, abilities, and other characteristics (KSAOs) leading to superior performance.
Assessment Methods: Use interviews, references, and pre-employment tests to measure candidates' KSAOs against the job requirements.
Defining Success: Through job analysis, clarity on performance expectations and essential KSAOs is established.
Steps in the Selection Process
The selection process varies based on organization and position level, including:
Completion of Application
Submission of Résumé
Initial Interview in HR
Employment Testing (aptitude, achievement)
Supervisor/Team Interview
Reference Checking
Background Investigation
Hiring Decision
Note: Applicants can be dropped at any step of the process.
Obtaining Reliable and Valid Information
Information Critique: Must be reliable, valid, and legal; also protecting applicant privacy is critical.
Reliability: Consistency of results across interviews, tests, etc.
Validity: The degree to which a selection method measures the intended attributes.
Initial Screening Overview
Purpose: Filter candidates before in-depth interviews and ensure qualified applicants progress.
Methods of Initial Screening:
Resume/CV Review
Application Form Screening
Phone/Video Screening
Online Assessments/Tests
Pre-Screening Questionnaires
Benefits of Pre-Selection:
Saves hiring manager's time and improves candidate quality.
Enhances candidate experience through timely feedback.
Increases likelihood of a better role fit.
Employment Interviews
Interview Types: Can involve a single person or multiple members from a team, depending on the job's nature.
Validity Concerns: Though interviews are practical for small applicant pools, validity criticisms exist due to their subjective nature.
Forms of Interview Structure
Nondirective Interview: Free-form discussion that allows the applicant to guide the conversation.
Structured Interview: Uses standardized questions and predefined answers.
Situational Interview: Involves hypothetical scenarios to gauge applicant responses.
Behavioral Description Interview (BDI): Asks candidates about past behavior in specific situations.
Panel Interview: Conducted by multiple interviewers.
Sequential Interview: One-on-one interviews in sequence.
Video Interviews: Conducted via videoconferencing.
Computer-Administered Interviews: Standardized questions via a computer for efficiency.
Guidelines for Interviewers
Understand legal obligations and best practices during interviews, including knowledge of the job, establishing rapport, and being transparent with candidates.
Post-Interview Screening
Reference Checks: Most reliable information comes from previous supervisors.
Background Checks: Standard for many companies, can include credit checks.
Preemployment Tests
Definition: Objective measures to evaluate knowledge, skills, abilities, and other characteristics (KSAOs) against benchmarks.
Types of Tests:
Job Knowledge
Work Sample
Cognitive Ability
Personality and Interest Inventories
Honesty and Integrity Tests
Physical Ability Tests
Medical Examinations and Drug Testing
Validating Tests
Validation Types:
Criterion-Related Validity
Content Validity
Construct Validity
Content Validity Example: Driver’s license exams assess relevant knowledge.
Construct Validity Example: Measures traits like intelligence and personality based on various behaviors.
Selection Decision Making
Decision Strategies: Vary based on the type of role to be filled. Factors include potential for diversity and performance measuring methods.
Approaches: Clinical (subjective) and Statistical (objective). Two methods:
Compensatory Model: High scores in one area offset low scores elsewhere.
Multiple-Cutoff Model: Applicants must meet minimum criteria across all dimensions.
Multiple-Hurdle Ratio: Sequential strategy; only applicants passing cutoff scores progress.
Selection Ratio: Number of applicants relative to hires – e.g., means 10% will be hired.
Final Decision
HR communicates the hiring decision and extends the job offer, emphasizing that it should be documented in writing to prevent misunderstandings.
Activities for Practical Learning
Mock Interview Setup: Teams develop interview questions using different formats.
Reaching Selection Decisions Discussion: Key considerations for hiring decisions, including potential and organizational needs, starting compensation, and factors affecting diversity plans.
Preparation for Next Class
Case Study Work: Teams to focus on the case study due by Jan. 30.
Reading Assignment: Chapter 3 due by Feb. 6.