Lesson 10 & 11 - Brain and Cognition
Overview of this Section: Brain & Cognition
The cultural brain (can you think of brain as social and culture organ?)
Social brain hypothesis & Dunbar’s number
Cultural Brain Hypothesis
Neuroplasticity & culture
Language & linguistic relativity
Cognition
Analytic vs. holistic thinking
Attention, number learning, attribution
Perception
Spatial perception across cultures
Integrating neuroscience and culture — challenges and possibilities
Neuroscience is also part of culture!
The Cultural Brain
Brain development in relation to social development
Cultural neuroscience: how culture shapes the brain
Biocultural approach (cultural psychology and cross-cultural psychiatry) — culture is “embrained” and brain is “encultured”
Language acquisition
Neuroplasticity — brain architecture (connections, cortical thickness, etc.) is affected by experience
Do cultural practices shape brain function? — perception, cognition, emotion, etc. are all patterned by culture in which they develop
Carpentered world theory — just because culture is different, it doesn’t make culture the source of all variation… there are invarations across culture, so although culture is important, it doesn’t necessarily influence absolutely everything
Mutual Constitution: Culture and Brain
This is mutual constitution operating at the neural level
• Brain is not a neutral substrate that culture writes on
• The developing brain is always already situated in cultural practices,
caregiving patterns, language, and social expectations
• Kwon, Wormley & Varnum (2021): cultural change itself reshapes neural
organization
• E.g. individualism-collectivism shifts across generations correlate with
changes in self-referential processing
• Direction of influence is bidirectional and dynamic – not a one-time imprint
Cultural Brain Hypothesis
We have social brains (new cortical areas dedicated to social processing)
Cultural Brain Hypothesis & Cumulative Cultural Brain Hypothesis
Cultural balues influence how we learn and what we learn — this changes basic brain operations, such as attention, perception, etc.
Overview of Brain and Cognition in Cultural Psychology
Brain & Cognition: Examines the relationship between cultural influences on brain structure and functioning.
Topics include: The cultural brain, social brain hypothesis, cultural brain hypothesis, neuroplasticity, language concepts, cognition differences, and spatial perception across cultures.
The Cultural Brain
Brain Development: Interlinked with social development.
Cultural Neuroscience: Study of how culture affects brain structure and function.
Biocultural Approach: The idea that culture is embodied in brain development and experiences.
Language Acquisition: Changes in neural organization as children acquire language influenced by cultural contexts.
Neuroplasticity: Brain architecture, including connection patterns and cortical thickness, altered by cultural experiences.
Examines how culture affects perception, cognition, and emotion.
Mutual Constitution: Culture and Brain
Mutual Constitution: Cultural context shapes neural development; neural contexts influence cultural practices.
Dynamic Influence: Changes in culture influence neural patterns, affecting how individuals process self-referential information.
Research by Kwon, Wormley & Varnum (2021): Cultural evolution modifies neural organization and functionality.
Cultural Brain Hypothesis
Foundations: Integrates the social brain hypothesis with aspects specific to culture.
Cultural Cognitive Abilities: Since larger brains evolved to manage cultural knowledge, this altered how attention and perception function at a base level (Henrich et al.).
The work of Muthukrishna et al. (2018): Explores the relationship of brain size, social learning dynamics, and cumulative culture development.
Social Brain Hypothesis & Dunbar's Number
Dunbar's Number: Predicts a correlation between neocortex size and social group size.
Typical human's core social group: about 150 individuals.
Further breakdown of social connections into tiers:
1500 people (maximum recognition)
500 acquaintances
150 meaningful contacts
50 friends
15 close friends
5 loved ones
Relationships can be nested based on trust and social complexity.
Variations in Dunbar's Number
Some studies indicate variations in individual capabilities to maintain social connections.
The phenomenon of social media presents further complications.
General consensus places Dunbar's number at approximately 150-200.
Experimental Evidence of Dunbar's Number
Numerous studies provide data on network sizes and social recognition patterns across cultures and populations:
Data show diverse averages: 8 (ideal congregation size), 200 (ideal church congregation), 10 (mean military company) etc.
Neural Underpinnings of Social Cognition
Different brain regions are involved in social cognition:
Anterior Insula, Medial Prefrontal Cortex, Anterior Cingulate Cortex, and more are linked with processing social information.
Language Acquisition and Linguistic Relativity
Infant Language Preference: Babies show preference for their native language early.
Hypotheses on Language and Thought: Different perspectives on how language affects cognition range from strict determinism to weak relativity.
Cultural Influence on Language: Language nuances affect cognitive processing, language as a cognitive tool, labels influencing mental representation.
Cultural Metaphors of Time
Example variances in linguistic representation of time:
Linear (most Western cultures) vs. cyclical (many Eastern cultures).
Spatial metaphors in language shape perception of time.
Analytic vs. Holistic Thinking
Cognitive Styles: East Asian cultures are typically holistic, while Western cultures lean towards analytic thinking.
Causal Attributions: Differentiates between situational and dispositional attributions in behavior.
Importance of social systems in shaping these cognitive styles as discussed by researchers like Heine.
Brain Activation Patterns in Different Cultures
Analytic thinking and attention towards objects affect how different cultures activate specific brain regions.
Studies show cultural variations manifest in the neural signatures during cognitive tasks.
Holistic and Analytic Traditions in Philosophy
Ancient Greece: Emphasis on discrete categorization and formal logic.
Chinese traditions: Focus on interconnectedness and harmony, blending object behaviors with context.
Study of Cognitive Biases in Aging
Older adults show greater cognitive styles influenced by cultural perspectives.
Studies show comparative differences in varying age groups regarding object-focused vs. situational processing (Heine et al.).
Cultural Factors in Attention and Recognition
Attention studies reveal how cultural background influences perception of scenes and contextual awareness.
Differences in recognition abilities highlight holistic vs. analytic tendencies across cultures.
Number Learning Across Cultures
Cultural methodologies affect numeric cognition:
Chinese speakers activate visuo-spatial networks while English speakers engage language networks for math-related tasks.
Attribution Patterns in Different Cultures
Dispositional vs. situational attribution trends illustrated by research highlight differing cognitive approaches among Western and East Asian populations.
Role of Speech in Cognitive Processing
Differences in communication emphasized across cultures, illustrating how thoughts and strategies vary in emphasis on verbal expression.
Foundational studies reveal how cultural norms influence cognitive freedoms in expression.
Spatial Orientation and Language
Different focus on spatial descriptors impacts understanding of position and orientation among various linguistic groups.
Studies explore the effect of egocentric vs. cardinal orientations across cultures.
Implications of Globalization on Cultural Neuroscience
Notably, globalization may lessen cultural distinctions yet increase individual variances in experiences.
The implications present challenges for comparative cultural studies and call for considerations of multiculturistic factors in research.
Integrating Cultural Change and Neuroscience
Envisioning a potential cross-field collaborative approach that incorporates both cultural neuroscience and cultural change, focusing on large-scale longitudinal data collection and analysis to reveal cultural neural transitions.
Closing Reflections on Cultural Neuroscience
Cultural neuroscience serves a dual role: examining how culture shapes the brain while simultaneously examining how neuroscience shapes cultural narratives and societal norms, creating a mutual influence dynamic.