Conformity and Obedience Study Guide

Widespread Nature of Conformity and Social Norms

Conformity is a fundamental and pervasive aspect of social life, representing the way individuals alter their attitudes, beliefs, and behaviors to align with the perceived norms of a group. This phenomenon occurs frequently and often goes unnoticed, as people instinctively adapt to the social expectations surrounding them. By matching the behaviors or attitudes of others, individuals maintain social cohesion and navigate complex social landscapes.

Normative Influence and Social Pressure

Normative influence describes a primary reason for conformity where individuals change their behavior to meet the expectations of a group in order to be liked, accepted, or to avoid social rejection and criticism. This type of influence is driven by the human desire for social belonging and the fear of appearing deviant or "abnormal."

  • The Mechanism of Conformity: In situations involving normative influence, an individual may internally disagree with a group's consensus but will publicly go along with the crowd. This is often referred to as public compliance without private acceptance.

  • Asch’s Line Study Findings: Solomon Asch demonstrated normative influence through a classic laboratory experiment involving line-length judgments. In this study, a participant was placed in a room with several confederates (individuals working with the researcher). When the confederates unanimously provided an obviously incorrect answer about which line matched a target line, the participant often conformed and gave the same incorrect answer. This was a clear demonstration of normative influence because the physical reality was unambiguous; participants conformed not because they were confused about the lines, but because they felt the pressure to avoid the discomfort of standing out or facing potential disapproval from the group.

Informational Influence and Descriptive Norms

Informational influence occurs when people conform because they believe others have more accurate information or a better understanding of the appropriate behavior in a given situation. This is particularly common in ambiguous or novel circumstances where an individual is unsure how to act.

  • The Mechanism of Accuracy: Unlike normative influence, informational influence often leads to private acceptance, where the individual truly believes that the group is correct.

  • The Look-Up Example: A notable example of informational influence involves confederates standing on a busy street and looking up at a point in the sky where nothing is happening. As more confederates look up, passersby are increasingly likely to stop and look up as well. These individuals are behaving this way because they assume those already looking up possess knowledge about an event or object that is not yet apparent. They rely on others as a source of information to define reality.

  • Descriptive Norms: This concept refers to the perception of how most people behave in a specific situation. Individuals use descriptive norms as a shortcut to determine effective or adaptive behavior. For example, if a person enters a quiet library and sees everyone whispering, they will also whisper, relying on the descriptive norm to guide their conduct.

Milgram’s Classic Laboratory Study on Obedience

Stanley Milgram conducted a series of influential and controversial experiments to examine how far individuals would go in obeying an authority figure's orders, even when those orders involved harming another person.

  • Study Procedure: The experiment involved three roles: the Experimenter (authority), the Teacher (the actual participant), and the Learner (a confederate). The Teacher was instructed to administer electric shocks to the Learner for every incorrect answer on a memory task. The shocks increased in increments of 15 V15\,\text{V}, ranging from a "slight shock" at 15 V15\,\text{V} to a lethal level labeled "XXX" at 450 V450\,\text{V}.

  • The Interaction: As the voltage increased, the Learner (who was not actually being shocked) would scream, complain of heart trouble, and eventually become silent. If the Teacher expressed hesitation, the Experimenter would give standardized prods, such as "The experiment requires that you continue."

  • Findings: The results were unexpected and startling. Approximately 65%65\% of the participants (the Teachers) administered the maximum shock of 450 V450\,\text{V}. While many participants showed signs of extreme stress and psychological distress, they continued to obey the authority figure's instructions.

Factors Influencing Obedience Levels

Various modifications to Milgram's original procedure revealed specific factors that could increase or decrease the levels of obedience recorded.

  • Proximity of the Learner: Obedience dropped significantly when the Learner was in the same room as the Teacher, and even further when the Teacher had to physically force the Learner's hand onto a shock plate.

  • Proximity of the Authority: When the Experimenter gave orders over the phone rather than being physically present in the room, obedience rates plummeted.

  • Legitimacy of the Setting: While the original study was conducted at Yale University, moving the experiment to a modest office building in Bridgeport led to a decrease in obedience, suggesting the perceived prestige or legitimacy of the environment impacts compliance.

  • Presence of Dissenters: If there were other "teachers" (confederates) present who refused to continue, the participant was much more likely to also disobey the Experimenter. Social support for non-conformity is a powerful buffer against obedience.

Criticisms and Ethical Concerns of Milgram’s Research

Milgram's research remains a focal point of discussion regarding both its methodology and its treatment of human subjects.

  • Methodological Criticisms: Some scholars argue that the behavior observed was not "blind obedience" but rather "engaged followership," where participants followed orders because they identified with the scientific goals of the experimenter. Additionally, there are concerns about the consistency of the prods used by the experimenters across different sessions.

  • Ethical Concerns: The primary ethical critique involves the severe psychological stress and potential long-term trauma experienced by participants. Although Milgram debriefed the participants afterwards, many found the realization that they were capable of inflicting potentially lethal harm on another human being to be deeply disturbing. The use of deception—leading participants to believe they were actually harming someone—is also a major point of ethical controversy.

Psychological Research Methods in the Real World

To move beyond the limitations of laboratory settings, psychologists employ several methods to study behavior in natural, real-world environments.

  • Field Experiments: These involve manipulating an independent variable in a natural setting to observe its effect on behavior while maintaining some level of experimental control.

  • Naturalistic Observation: Researchers observe and record behavior in its natural habitat without any intervention or manipulation. This provides high ecological validity.

  • Archival Research: This method involves examining existing records, such as census data, crime reports, or social media trends, to identify patterns and relationships in human behavior over time or across different populations.