Legal-History-III-AL

Unit I. Administration of Justice in Surat, Bombay, Madras and Calcutta

  • Emergence of the East India Company: Development of authority under charters.

  • Trading body to a territorial power: Subsequent charters.

Administration of justice in Surat, Madras (1639-1726), Bombay (1668-1726), and Calcutta (1619-1726).

  • Mayor Court.

  • Charter 1726 and Charter 1753: Their defects.

  • East India Company: Also known as The Governor Company of Merchants of London trading into the East Indies.

1. East India Company and its Development

  • Charter divided into 2 groups

  • Key Charter Dates:

    • 31 Dec 1600: Initial charter.

    • 1609, 1625, 1657, 1661, 1668, 1683, 1686, 1693, 1698

  • Administration System.

  • Legal System.

  • Governor and 24 directors managed the company for 1-year tenures with common re-elections.

Charter 1600

  • Primarily for trade; not intended for Indian dominion.

  • Legislative power granted to regulate business and discipline servants.

Charter 1609

  • Granted by James I on May 31, 1609.

  • Privileges in perpetuity.

  • Authorized to continue privileges from Queen Elizabeth's Charter 1600.

  • Power to punish servants for severe offenses during long voyages.

  • First Royal Commission secured in 1601.

Charter 1623

  • Addition of martial law power to the company.

  • English settlers arrived in Surat under Emperor Jahangir in 1612, a key trade location on India's western coast.

Charter 1625

  • Established a new trading body, "Courten Association," which lasted until 1657.

Charter 1657

  • Oliver Cromwell amalgamated various joint stocks into one, ending the conflict between the old company and Courten Associations.

Charter 1661

  • Under Charles II, the company prospered significantly.

  • Shift from trading to territorial power, establishing company territories.

  • Power to punish servants for disobedience.

  • Trading centers (Madras, Bombay, and Calcutta) could resolve civil and criminal cases based on English law.

  • Trials were sent to locations with a governor if none was present.

Charter 1668

  • Charles II transferred Bombay to the East India Company for an annual rent of 1010.

  • Powers to make laws, maintain order, and establish courts of judicature for proper administration of justice.

Charter 1683

  • Company authorized to raise military forces.

  • Judicature court established with 1 person and 2 merchants appointed by the Company to decide based on equity, conscience, and merchant customs.

  • East India Company authorized to establish Admiralty Court.

Charter 1686

  • James II renewed the company's powers and privileges.

  • Company to appoint admirals and sea officers with naval and martial law powers.

  • Authorized to establish a municipality and Mayor court at Madras.

  • Sir Jasiah Child, governor and chairman, established civil and military power policies, securing significant revenue and English dominance.

Charter 1693

  • Old company faced jealousy from a new English company.

  • Whigs came to power, leading to the establishment of a new company, “General Society,” to break the old company's monopoly.

Charter 1698

  • William III granted a charter with advantages to improve company administration.

  • Directors created to control the company and oversee its affairs.

  • Company operated until the Regulating Act 1773, which overhauled its constitution.

3. Administration of Surat (1612-1687)

  • Surat as the Most Important Factory Initially.

  • Important Commercial Centre.

  • Populous Town & International Port.

  • Factory Established at Surat in 1612.

  • Governor and Company of merchant of London training into East.(15 year).

  • Mughal farmaan and special power to them in 1615.

  • Governor and council (less knowledge of law).

  • Qazi Court made by Muslim Ruler to solve cases

  • Defects in Surat:

    • No knowledge of law.

    • Frequent fights between them.

    • Corruption.

    • Hindu and Muslim law applied.

4. Administration of Madras (1693-1726)

  • Divided into 3 phases:

    • 1st phase: 1639-1665

    • 2nd phase: 1665-1688

    • 3rd phase: 1688-1725

  • 1st phase 1639-1665:- (Administrative set up, Judicial Set up, No Established Procedure)

    • The Charters and courts: Company was under the administration of an Englishmen who called agent. They were authorized for civil and criminal cases.

    • Charter 1661: for improving judicial system in madras governor and council appointed for Judge for civil and criminal law according to the laws of England.

    • Black and white town.

    • Black town Choultry Court(officer known as Adigaar).

    • On his corruption EIC appoint company to its post.

    • On serious crime than permission by Hindu ruler and punish according to UK law.

    • No Diwani and Faujdari cases to this court.

    • No judicial system

  • 2nd phase 1665-1688: (Delay in Justice)

    • Judicial system-

    • Appointed Streynsham Master as governor in 1678 the whole judicial system was recognized by him the court of governor and council was designated as high court of judicature.

    • Court will twice a week and decide all civil and criminal cases with 12 jury man and also recognized old choultry court(small cases only) and Indian officer replaced by English officer and of company services.

    • The number of Judge was increased to 3 out of at least 2 were required to preside the trial and sit two in a week i.e. Thursday and Friday.

    • The Judge of choultry court will take care and clerk registers all the punishments. High court of judicature hears appeal of choultry court it’s consist of governor and council.

    • English as court language English is an official language of Madras court till 1680 and after that Tamil, Portuguese and Malayalam.

    • Court of Admiralty(punish to illegal trader or sea matter).

    • Governor and council neither they are regular nor they are ready to give justice in a manner.

    • Tough to solve faujdari matter.

    • Governor and council with 12 faujdari member to solve cases.

    • Judicial power to governor not to agent .

    • Petty Jury (6englishmen and 6 Portuguese )

  • 3rd phase 1688-1725 (Admiraly, Mayor,Choultry Court and Corporation of Madras)

    • Court:

      • Chaultry Court

      • Mayor Court(end of the chapter)

      • Admiralty Court

      • High Court of Madras

  • ADMIRALTY COURT

    • On August 9 1683, Charles II granted charter to the company to establish the courts which was to consist of person learned in the Civil law and 2 merchants appointed by the company.

    • Court got the power to hear and try cases related to the mercantile, maritime, trespass, injury and wrongs etc.

    • Again on April 12, 1686 Charles II issued a new charter with same provisions.

    • Chief Judge of the Admiralty Court was known as the Judge–Advocate.

    • In 1687 company sent from England Sir John Biggs a professional lawyer learned in civil law to act as the Judge advocate of Admiralty Court.

    • After this the Governor and his Council stopped performing their Judicial Functions and the Admiralty Court bestowed justice in all cases civil, criminal as well as maritime.

    • Sir Biggs Died in 1689 and Governor again took the charge of judicial function.

    • In 1692 the Company sent John Dolben as new Judge advocate and in 1694 he was dismissed on the charge of taking bribes.

    • In 1696 company directed that members of the council should in succession serve as the Judge advocate. After William Fraser, a merchant was appointed as Judge advocate later he resigned and no one was ready to become the Judge advocate, so company made the court registrar the Judge advocate.

    • 1698 onwards, under the instructions of the company, the Governor and council started hearing appeals from the Admiralty court in cases involving less than 100 pagodas. After 1704 admiralty court ceased to sit on regular basis.

    • Court dead and Corporation made and Mayor Court form headed by Mayor 1688.

    • The realisation of the need to shift from a “common” to a “civil” lawyer. The Governor and his council relinquished their judicial functions which they had been exercising hitherto the charter of 1661 and ceased to sit as a court. This marked the separation of the Executive from the Judiciary. In 1683 the English Common Law was practically devoid of rules governing mercantile cases.

5. Administration of Bombay (1668-1726)

  • Charter 1668: 1670 judicial plan 1672 new judicial plan 1684-1690 admiralty court conflicts Judicial machinery 1718-1728

  • Court in Bombay.

    • Court of judicature- civil and criminal.

    • Court of conscience- small cases.

    • Contract court-deputy governor and its council-serious matter.

    • Admirality court- according to charter 1648in bombay

  • Portuguese were the first European to acquire the Island of Bombay in 1534, from the king of Gujarat. In 1661, Portuguese king, Alfonsus VI transferred the island to Charles II as dowry on the marriage of his sister Catherine with the British king.

  • Charles II transferred it to the east India Company in 1668 for an insignificant annual rent of 10 pounds.

  • before 1726, the judicial system in the island of Bombay grew in three stages.

BOMBAY JUDICIAL STAGES
  • FIRST STAGE: 1668- 1683

  • SECOND STAGE: 1683- 1690

  • THIRD STAGE: 1718- 1726

First stage 1668- 1683(Judicial system)
  • Charter of 1668. judicial system.

  • Custom officer appointed in each divisions.

  • Jury system.

  • Deputy governor and council(judicial system 1670).

  • Bombay in 2 parts each court has 5 judges.

  • Custom officer has judicial officer.

  • Some Indian appointed as judge and sitting of at least 3 judges is necessary.

  • SURAT PRESIDENCY (GOVERNOR AND COUNCIL).

  • Bombay divided into 2 divisions Each division had one court with 5 judges. The custom officer was to be president of the court.

  • New system consisted of George Wilcox as judge. The court was to have jurisdiction in all cases civil, criminal, probate and testamentary.

  • Bombay was divided into 4 sections. Justices of peace were appointed.

  • court of conscience (small matter and once in a week) delay in judgment and jurisdiction is 20 ciraffin(Portugal coin).

  • Bombay, Mahik, Majgaon, Sion (4 section of Bombay).

  • Follow 125yr. Portugal system. Each division has sanchalak and Justice of peace.

  • The deputy governor and council were constituted as superior court.

Second Stage 1683- 1690 (Admiralty Court)
  • Dr. John St John was a person learned in the civil law.

  • Charter of 1683.

  • King’s Bench of common pleas. 1690 Bombay attacked by admiral Siddi.

  • 1690- 1718 is the dark period in legal history of island. 1687 Bombay became presidency.

  • Appoint Dr. Saint John salary (200200 pound/year) (knowledge of law)

Third stage 1718- 1726 (Indian Judges, Working of the Court)
  • 30 year no court system in Bombay 15/03/1718 new court in Bombay 9 judge (5 bristher+4 Indian)In 1718, a court appeared again in Bombay with chief justice and nine other judges, of whom 5 were British. Indians were called black justices.

  • Awarded imprisonment ‘during pleasure’, which meant indefinite period of custody.

  • Seat once in a week Appeal to Governor general and Council.

  • Work till 1726 than 10/2/1728 royal charter issue Mayor Court. That court name has court of judicature

6. Administration of Calcutta (presidency town in 1699)

Historical Perception in Calcutta Town (1690-1726) (Zamidari Judicial, Kazi and Court, Nawab Court)
  • Origin: In the year 1668, the grandson of Aurangzed, Azimush-shan, and the Subahdar of Bengal gave Zamindari of villages, Calcutta, Sutanati and Govindpur for annual revenue of 1195 Rupees to the East India Company.

  • Collector post (Civil, Criminal and Revenue)

  • Appointed: In the December 1699, Calcutta became Presidency Town and Governor was appointed to administer the settlement. As a zamindar company got all the powers just like other zamindars of that time. Bengal zamindars. In Moghul Empire, zamindars got judicial powers, but collected the revenue and maintained law and order in the zamindari area or villages. For judicial purpose that time Kazis court were established in each district, parganah and villages. They handled civil and criminal matters. Normally village Panchayat solved all problems, In Hindus, elders or Brahmins solved the problems. The judicial system was simple, as everyone knew each other and transactions of each other.Moghul Kings never paid any attention to judicial system that time nothing was organized.

  • Post: The post of Kazi was sold many times , the highest bidder became the Kazi. Justice was purchased , corruption was rampant Kazi never got salary, so kazi court fined the criminal and earned money, after this demanded money from the complainant for giving him justice. The other Zamindars when gave death sentence , the appeal went to the Nawab but company never did this , the appeal from zamindar , collectors court went to the Governor and council In Calcutta that time Collector enjoyed all the powers up to the year 1727 With the charter of 1726 the new system was started in Calcutta Presidency. Before this charter the authority was given by company and zamindar, but the charter of 1726 was a royal charter.

  • Important points of this charter: The importance of this charter is that this charter introduced Uniformity of justice system in all 3-presidency towns. The charter established civil and criminal courts in each presidency towns. The 2nd important point is that before 1726 the courts got authority from the company but after this charter the courts got their authority from the royal British king , The courts enjoyed same status just like the courts which were present that time in England.

  • 1726: With the charter of 1726, the appeals from courts in India went to the Privy Council in This way English law system became accepted to Indians, Indians did not find it foreign and Indians did not have any other judicial system as such. With this charter in each presidency town local legislature was established. Charter of 1726 is also known as judicial charter as this is the beginning of development of Indian law system and judiciary.

Important Fact in that Town
  • Zamindari rights: three villages Calcutta, Sutanati and Govindpur to the English company and this town is different from the other two presidency town in 1699 it’s became presidency town and its governor and council will look out the administration and judicial part in Calcutta. The collector was a company officer appointed by them only.

  • Civil cases: collector will pass the civil court or court of cutchery and ordinarily civil cases solved by arbitration decision based on customs and usages with help of natural justice and equity if contradiction in customs or no customs he also collect the revenue arrears and their cases appeal to the governor and council.

  • Criminal cases: Company adopt the existing Mughal pattern as a faujdari court presided by an English collector was decided criminal cases and punished by whipping, fines, imposing, and banishments. Capital punishments given only on the permission governor or president and council of Calcutta. Death sentence is by whipping not by hanging. For serious crimes the governor and council were authorised to try by the charter of 1661.

  • Collector power: English law: Use of English law with Hindu and Muslim law in judicial process.

Following are the few provisions of charter of 1726 Main Reasons or Aims of Issuing the Charter of 1726
  • The judicial administration and the working of the courts, in the three Presidency towns of India was unsatisfactory.

  • With the growth in Company's trade and commercial activities in India, the population of British Settlements had increased considerably, and Leflore, more cases were coming to the courts for adjudication.

  • The Company desired that the power of courts should be derived from a competent authority so that their decisions would have a binding force and Uniformity in judicial administration could be achieved.

  • Encouraged by the successful working of the Corporation at Madras, the Company wanted to establish similar Corporations at Bombay and Calcutta also. Many Englishmen who settled in India died leaving behind them considerable movable and immovable property. This created problems before the Company relating to distribution and disposal of their assets. Although, the Mayor's Court of Madras established in 1687 was empowered to decide testamentary cases but its decisions were not recognised by the Court in England because it was a Court of the Company and not of British Crown. Therefore, the Company was involved in unnecessary litigation in England at the instance of the relatives of the deceased who died intestate in India. To avoid this, there was a need of a court in each Presidency which could take cognizance of testamentary and intestate succession cases deriving their authority from the British Crown. Thus, in order to solve the above mentioned problems and to establish an effective administration of justice in the Company's settlements in the three presidencies, the Judicial Charter was granted by the British King George I on September 24, 1726 at the instance of East India Company.
    Provisions of the Charter of 1726

  1. Establishment of Corporation at Bombay and Calcutta

  2. Civil Administration and Establishment of Mayor's Court in Presidency Towns

  3. Civil Administration and Establishment of Mayor's Court in Presidency Towns

  4. Justice of Peace

  5. Jury Trial in Criminal Cases Merits of Charter of 1726

    • Establishment of Crown's Court-This Charter has, for the first time established the courts of Crown. The courts established so far were the courts of company.

    • Uniformity in Judicial System-This Charter has, for the first time, established Mayor's Court in all the three presidencies i.e., Calcutta, Bombay and Madras.

    • Provisions of Appeal to Privy Council for the First Time-For the first time a provision was made to appeal to Privy Council from the decisions of Mayor's Court.

    • Application of English Law in Indian Soil-This Charter has for the first time introduced English law into Indian soil. Where there was no express provision of law, the judges used to decide the dispute on the basis of "equity, justice and good conscience."

      • Establishment of Legislative Councils-The Charter of 1726 for the first time, established local legislative councils in which the Governor with the aid of his council used to make bye-laws, rules and ordinances for the regulation of the corporations and inhabitants of the presidencies. Before 1726, the law making powers were vested in the company which could be exercised only by the "Court of Director" of the company in England. On account of the above mentioned merits, the Charter of 1726 constitutes a landmark i.e., a turning point in the legal history of India and proved to be an important event on account of the great significance in the sphere of law and justice, the charter is usually characterised as the 'judicial charter'.

Demerits of Charter of 1726
  • Appointment of .Non-lawmen Judges-before 1726, the traders were to be appointed on the office of judges who were ignorant of law. As judges their main aim was to bring about the settlement between the contesting parties. Even after the establishment of Crown's Court, in 1726.Justice continued to be administered by non-professional judges. Thus, the object of the Charter of 1726 could not be fulfilled.

  • No Separation of Judicial and Executive Powers is Made - Although many attempts were made to separate judicial and executive powers from one another yet the policy of the company was not firm in this respect. The Charter of 1726 also did not admit this division and an intimate relationship between executive and judiciary was maintained.

  • Conferment of Legislative Powers on Governor and Council -The Charter of 1726 empowered the Governor and Council of each presidency-town to make bye-laws, rules and ordinances for the regulation of the Corporations and inhabitants of the Presidencies, They would also prescribe punishment for the breach of such laws and rules. The bye-laws rules and ordinances so framed and the punishments prescribed for breach thereof, were to be reasonable and not contrary to the laws of England and they could not be effective unless approved and confirmed by the Company's Court of Directors in England.

Establishment of Mayors Court
  • The mayor and two council members gave justice and appeal went to the Governor within 14 days. Further appeal could be made to the king in council if matter involved more than 1000 pagodas This way first time Indians got right to file appeal in the king in council.

  • A sheriff was appointed for each ten miles of area by the Governor and council annually, in simple terms he was the police officer. When complained was given to the court, the court issued the summons in writing to the Sheriff and he brought the accused in the court, he handed the summons to the concern party. If party accused did not come on that day, the warrant was issued and Sheriff brought them before the courts, bail was granted sometimes.

  • For criminal jurisdiction, justice of peace was established same like England Criminal jurisdiction system followed all the British criminal system and procedures.

  • Charter of 1726 empowered the governor and his council to make by laws, rules and ordinances for the regulation of corporation. In Madras charter became effective from the 17th August 1727. In Bombay 10th February 1728 Calcutta December 1727 the implementation of charter started. The company directed the courts to maintain records and send them to England to know how they are working. With these establishments common Indians also start to file the more and more cases in the courts. Mayors Court, Governor, and Council always got disputes regarding jurisdiction in presidency towns. This fights resulted into the weakening of Judiciary in the future and executive became powerful. Company adopted policy not to get involved in the Indian customs and disputes but if the matter went to the Mayors Court they adopted English procedures.

MAYOR’S COURT
  • Mayor's Court under the Charter of 1687 — A Corporation was set up by the Company at Madras on 29 Sep., 1688, under the Charter of 1687. It was created with the purpose of associating natives with the Englishmen Its to fulfill this purpose, the Company wanted to undertake certain public fare activities for which funds were needed. The Corporation cotters taxes and raised funds from the inhabitants of Madras.

  • Composition—The Madras Corporation consisted of an English Mayor, 12 Aldermen and 60 or 120 Burgesses. Out of the twelve Aldermen, three were to be the covenanted English servants of the Company while the rest could be of any nationality. The Mayor was to hold office for one year and he was elected by the Aldermen from amongst themselves. The aldermen held office for life or till the residence in Madras, The vacancy of an Alderman was to be filled up by election from amongst the Burgesses. The Burgesses were to be elected by the Mayor and Aldermen while few of them were nominated by the Company from the heads of the various castes.

  • Civil and Criminal jurisdiction—The Mayor and Aldermen constituted a civil court, while the Mayor and three senior Aldermen were Justices of Peace having criminal jurisdiction. The Mayor and two Aldermen formed the quorum. The Court held its sitting only once in a fortnight and decided criminal cases with the help of jury. The Court could award the sentence of imprisonment or fine. Appeals from the decisions of the Mayor's Court lay to the Admiralty Court in ease the value of the civil case exceeded three pagodas, and in criminal cases, where the offender was sentenced to death or loss of limb.

  • Court of Record—The Mayor's court constituted a Court of Records since a Recorder was also attached to the Court. As all the members of the Mayor's Court were lay persons without expertise in law. It dispensed justice "in a summary manner according to equity, justice and good conscience" and law enacted by the Company. Obviously, this was bound to result into uncertainty and lack of uniformity in laws.

  • For the purpose of providing the services of a person having legal knowledge, the Company appointed Sir John Biggs, the Judge-Advocate of the Admiralty Court, as the Recorder of Mayor's Court in 1688. This appointment of Sir John Biggs as a Recorder of the Mayor's court created an anomaly because as a Judge-Advocate of the Admiralty Court, he also heard appeals from the Mayor's Court, with which he was associated as a Judge. However, this anomaly did not last long since Sir John Biggs died in 1689, and thereafter, the Company did not appoint any Recorder in the Mayor's Court.

Working of the Mayor's Court of 1726
  • The Charter of 1726, adopted the principle of independence of judiciary to a considerable extent which was a fortunate development in the legal history of India. But the constant assertion of judicial independence by the judges of the Mayor's court proved irksome to the Governor and Council which resulted into constant conflict and hostility between the two. As rightly observed by Kaye, this made the Corporations, and consequently the Courts, largely autonomous but the Council at times sought to interfere with the functioning of the Mayor’s Court and tried to dictate its terms which the Courts did not like. The strained relations between the Mayor's Court and the Governor and Council also led to the serious differences between the Government and the Corporation which are reflected in the following cases-

  • that the Mayor's Court had no authority to decide cases involving disputes relating to caste or religion of natives and warned the Mayor's Court not to interfere in such cases. The Case of Arab Merchant—In 1930 a dispute arose between the Court and the Council. An Arab merchant brought a suit in the Mayor's Court for recovery of the valuable pearls which were alleged to have been extorted from him by the men who saved him from a burning boat from the coast of Gujarat. The defendants had already been tried earlier for piracy and acquitted. The Council made suggestion to the Mayor's Court against the validity of merchant's claim. But the Mayor's Court ignored the suggestion and decreed the suit. On appeal, this decision was reversed by the Governor and. Council by casting vote of the Governor.

  • The Oath Case of Bombay—In Bombay, a dispute arose in 1726 over the issue of form of oath to be prescribed for Hindu witnesses. The Mayor and Aldermen of Bombay were usually the members of the Grand Jury at a Quarter sessions. A conflict arose between the Bombay Council and the Mayor's Court as to the form of oath for Hindu witnesses. The Grand Jury held up two successive sessions by refusing to find and 'true bills', unless the Hindu interpreter and witnesses were sworn upon the 'Cow' instead of the holy 'Geeta". This touched the sentiments of the Hindu natives and they felt aggrieved.

Comparisons of the Mayor's Court Established Under Charter of 1687 and 1726

Although the Mayor's Court of 1726 were established on the parallel lines to the Mayor's Court of 1687 yet the two differed in the following respects—

  • The Charter of 1687 being a Company's Charter, the Mayor's Court of Madras established under it was a Company's Court whereas the new Mayor's Court under the Royal Charter of 1726 was a Crown's Court.

  • The earlier Charter of 1687 conferred both, civil and criminal jurisdiction on the Mayor's Court but the new Charter of 1726 empowered the Courts to try and hear only the civil cases. Thus, the Charter of 1687 had a wider scope as compared with the Charter of 1726.

  • Under the Charter of 1687 appeals from the Mayor's Court lay to the Admiralty Court while the Charter of 1726 provided that appeals from Mayor's Court lay to the Governor and Council and a second appeal to the Court of King-in-Council of England. There was, however, no provision for second appeals in the earlier Charter of 1687.

  • The Mayor's Courts established under the Charter of 1726 possessed testamentary jurisdiction which the Charter of 1687 had not provided for.

  • The-Charter of 1687 provided fora 'Recorder' in the Mayor's Court who was to be a professional lawyer to advise the court in legal matters. But the Recorder of the Mayor's Courts established under the Charter of 1726 was not necessarily to be a legal expert and judges appointed in the Court were mostly lay persons without any legal training or experience. In this sense, the Charter of 1687 was more in tune with the imperatives of justice as compared with the Charter of 1726.

  • The Madras Corporation established under the Charter of 1687 consisted of twelve Aldermen out of which at least three were to be Englishmen. These Aldermen acted as judges of the Mayor Court, But the new Corporations set up under the Charter of 1726 consisted of nine Aldermen, out of which seven were to be Englishmen. Thus the new Mayor's courts were far more English dominated than the earlier one.

  • No specific procedure and technical rules of law were provided for administration of justice in the old courts but the Mayor's Court of 1726 was bound by the laws and procedure of English Courts of the Crown.

  • Under the Charter of 1687, the Executive Government had nothing to do with the administration of justice but the Charter of 1726 invested the Governor and Council with the power to appeals and decide criminal cases.

In what respect the Charter of 1726 was Inferior to the Charter of 1687

It may be noted that criminal justice in Madras was administered by the Mayor's Court and Admiralty Court established under the Charter of 1687 whereas the Charter of 1726 vested criminal judicature in the executive and this was certainly a retrograde step. Having once divested the executive of its judicial powers, it could not be regarded as a progressive step by any test or standard, to re-invest it with judicial powers. A cardinal principle of good government is to keep judicial and executive powers separate in order to secure liberty and property of the people. Form this point of view the .Charter of 1726 was inferior to that of 1687. Besides, similar was the position with respect to the Indians, participation. The Madras Corporation of 1687 had a sizable Indians representation whereas the corporation of 1726 was to have only two non- English Aldermen and, in practice, none was ever appointed, The mayor's Court of 1726 was thoroughly an English Court with no Indian's participation and it compared unfavorably with the old Madras Mayor's Court of 1687 in this respect also.

FATE OF CHOULTRY COURTS
  • After the Mayor’s Court came on the scene, the Choultry Court lost its importance and functioned as a court of petty jurisdiction trying offences and civil cases up to 2 pagodas.

  • On criminal cases it gave fines, imprisonment, pillory, whipping or slavery as punishment.

  • COMMON CRIMES AND PUNISHMENTS- In the Initial years the Court was doubtful about his power to award the death sentence but in 1712, the Governor and the Council decided that it could award death sentence to natives only. There was a lot of delay in trials and several prisoners were found to be confined to jail for too long. Though capital punishment was to be awarded by hanging some Indians were executed or whipped to death. The governor and council had the power to stay a death sentence.

  • Piracy was a capital offence and punishable with death or banishment. Robbery was punished with death. Witchcraft was punished with fine and pillory.

  • Forgery was to be punished with imprisonment and banishment. Brahmins were not given death penalties in observance of the Hindu sentiments; they were banished instead.

  • A principle called ‘benefit of clergy’ under the English Ecclesiastical Law was invoked by the Englishmen as defence in cases of manslaughter; the accused was branded on the hand and then discharged.

FUTURE OF THE JUDICIARY
  • The British Parliament enacted the Act of Settlement, 1781. The Act directed the application of personal laws for Hindus and Muslims in matters regarding inheritance, succession, caste, marriage, adoption and the like while English Law was applied to others and in all other causes. Nandkumar’s case illustrates the anomalous character of the impact of the application of English law on the Indians and depicts the difficulties that arise.

  • The expansion of its establishments brought new challenges to the East India Company. The Company requested the King to issue a Charter by which special powers could be granted to it. The Company was granted Charter by King George I in 1726 to establish “Mayor's Courts” in Madras, Bombay and Calcutta (now Chennai, Mumbai and Kolkata respectively). Mayor's Courts were not courts of the Company, but courts of the King of England. Mayor's courts superseded all existing courts established in the above places. The Mayor's Courts were authorized 'to try, hear and determine all civil suits, actions and pleas' that may arise within the three towns or within the factories of the Company. The Court consisted of a Mayor and nine Aldermen, seven of whom, including the Mayor, were required to be naturally born British subjects. Aldermen were elected from among the leading inhabitants of the settlement to hold the position for life. The Mayor was elected from the Aldermen.

  • The Mayor's Courts contributed significantly to the formulation of a uniform pattern of judicial functioning in India. The Mayor's Courts administered English law, which was assumed to be the lex loci ('law of the place') of the settlement. The inhabitants of the settlement were governed by the English law, irrespective of their nationality. English law