M8: Sixth Amendment Rights

The Sixth Amendment to the United States Constitution

  • The Sixth Amendment contains the most critical language regarding the conduct of American trials.
  • Complete Verbatim Text: "In all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right to a speedy and public trial by an impartial jury of the state and district wherein the crime shall have been committed, which district shall have previously ascertained by law, and to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation, to be confronted with the witnesses against him, to have compulsory process for obtaining witnesses in his favor, and to have the assistance of counsel for his defense."
  • The Sixth Amendment guarantees 99 distinct trial rights.

The Right to a Speedy Trial

  • Purpose of the Right:
    • Limiting the disruption and anxiety that criminal charges can cause for a defendant.
    • Ensuring that evidence does not go stale over time.
  • Definition of "Speedy":
    • The requirement is that trials take place within a reasonable period of time.
    • Delays of months or even years may be permissible if they are not caused by prosecutorial negligence.
    • Defendants must demonstrate real prejudice, such as the loss of witnesses or other evidence, to prove a violation.
  • Remedies and Statutes:
    • The remedy for a violation is the dismissal of charges, which is considered so draconian that courts often avoid finding violations.
    • The Federal Speedy Trial Act mandates that formal charges be filed within 3030 days of arrest.
    • The trial itself should commence within 7070 days of the filing of charges.
    • There are multiple exceptions to these statutory time limits.
    • Dismissals due to statutory violations are usually "without prejudice," meaning the charges can be reinstated by the government.

The Right to a Public Trial

  • Rationales for Public Proceedings:
    • Serves as an effective restraint on the possible abuse of power by the state.
    • Avoids the historical abuses associated with the secret Star Chamber of medieval England.
    • Keeps all parties, including the defense and the prosecution, "on their toes" due to public scrutiny.
  • Scope and Exceptions:
    • Public access extends to many pretrial proceedings.
    • Pretrial proceedings can be closed to the press under narrow circumstances to prevent publicity from prejudicing potential jurors.
    • Gag orders may be imposed on attorneys to limit information released to the public.

The Right to a Jury Trial

  • Historical Context and Purpose:
    • Viewed as a central means of protecting defendants against state abuse.
    • Involves the public in the definition and application of criminal law.
    • The lineage of this right dates back to the Magna Carta in the 13th13^{th} century.
  • Thresholds and Requirements:
    • Defendants have a right to a jury in any case that can result in more than 66 months of imprisonment.
    • A jury must consist of at least 66 people.
    • In federal courts and many state courts, serious crimes require a jury of 1212 people.
    • Verdicts must be unanimous.
  • Outcomes of Disagreement:
    • If a jury is "hung" (not unanimous), the court declares a mistrial.
    • Retrials are possible following a mistrial.

The Right to an Impartial Jury and Proper Venue

  • Impartial Jury:
    • Juries must be selected in a manner that ensures they are representative of the community.
    • Jurors must not possess bias toward any party involved in the case.
  • Venue Requirements:
    • A defendant has the right to be tried in the jurisdiction (venue) where the crime was committed.
    • Determining venue is generally straightforward except in cases involving multiple locales, such as interstate kidnapping.
    • A change of venue may be granted if pretrial publicity has been so intense that a fair and open-minded jury cannot be found in the original jurisdiction.

The Right to Notice

  • This right ensures the defendant is informed of the nature and cause of the accusations against them.
  • Charging Documents:
    • Indictment: Issued by a grand jury.
    • Information: A charging document produced by a prosecutor when no grand jury is used.
  • Purpose: To provide enough detail about the charges so the defendant can begin gathering evidence and preparing a defense.

The Right of Confrontation

  • This right is viewed as a crucial mechanism for enhancing the reliability of the trial process.
  • Four Key Components:
    • Physical Presence: Defendants have a right to be present during the trial and other significant proceedings.
    • Mental Competence: Defendants must be mentally capable of understanding the proceedings and assisting their counsel.
    • Production of Witnesses: Defendants have the right to force the government to produce accusatory witnesses in the courtroom.
      • This limits the use of hearsay, which is defined as a statement made outside of court by someone who is not available for cross-examination.
      • Prosecutors generally cannot have a police officer recount what witnesses said; they must put the witnesses on the stand for the defense to cross-examine regarding biases, visibility of the crime, or government benefits received for testimony.
    • Face-to-Face Confrontation: This is taken literally as a right to face accusers directly.
      • Separation of witness and defendant is only allowed in rare circumstances, such as a child witness who might be severely traumatized by facing an accused abuser.
      • Even in these cases, cross-examination by counsel must be allowed, and the defendant must be able to watch the testimony via video.

The Right to Compulsory Process and the Right to Testify

  • Compulsory Process:
    • Defendants have the right to use subpoenas to compel witnesses and documents that are material to their case.
    • Limitations: Defendants cannot always compel the testimony of confidential informants due to the "informant's privilege."
  • Right to Testify:
    • Closely associated with compulsory process is the defendant's right to tell their own story in court if they choose to do so.

The Right to the Assistance of Counsel

  • Significance:
    • Often cited as the most important right because it ensures all other rights are enforced.
    • Established by the case of Gideon v. Wainwright, which asserted that lawyers in courts are "necessities, not luxuries."
  • Implementation:
    • The right applies to any case resulting in imprisonment and covers all important stages of proceedings after a formal charge.
    • Indigent defendants (who constitute the majority of defendants) have the right to state-paid counsel.
    • State Systems: Some use salaried public defenders, while others use a court-appointed lawyer system involving rotating local lawyers who may not focus exclusively on criminal law.
  • Waiver and Effectiveness:
    • A competent defendant can waive the right to counsel and choose to represent themselves ("go it alone").
    • If counsel is not waived, the Sixth Amendment requires that the assistance be "effective."
    • While extreme cases of lawyers sleeping or being intoxicated are rare, many fail to prepare adequately.
    • Claims of ineffective assistance of counsel are the most common issues raised on appeal.