SCOTUS Cases APGov
Marbury v. Madison — Judicial Review, Supremacy Clause
Marbury (judge) did not have his commission delivered by James Madison (Sec. of State)
demanded a writ of mandamus (order of the SC) to deliver his commission as Madison refused
cited the Judiciary Act of 1789, allowed Marbury to bring his claim to the SC
SC ruled unconstitutional
while Marbury was entitled to the commission, the Act expanded the Judiciary’s rights because SCOTUS can only address civil cases through appellate jurisdiction(according to Article III); in this case, the SC had original jurisdiction, which violated the Constitution
McCulloch v. Maryland — Necessary and Proper Clause, Supremacy Clause, States’ Rights
Congress created a branch of the national bank in Maryland
Maryland created legislature to impose taxes on the bank
McCulloch refused to pay the taxes
state appeals court decided that the Second Bank was unconstitutional because nowhere in the Constitution did it say that the Congress had the right to create a national bank
SC ruled Maryland legislature unconstitutional
Congress has the right to establish national banks under Elastic Clause as to fulfill their enumerated powers
Maryland has no right to tax instruments of the government
while states retain the ability to tax, the Supremacy Clause gives the most importance to the federal government’s rules
U.S. v Lopez — Congress Exceeds Authority under Commerce Clause
Lopez had state charges pressed for possession of a firearm at school
later, those charges were replaced with federal charges under the Gun-Free School Zones Act of 1990 which resulted in a short prison sentence
he appealed to the SC
SC ruled unconstitutional
Commerce Clause was inapplicable to the scenario: possession of a firearm does not impact the economic productivity of students
Congress exceeded its authority under the Commerce Clause
if it was ruled as constitutional, it would grant Congress the power to regulate and interfere with state’s economies and business
Reno v Shaw — Racial Gerrymandering Under Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment
intention to elect Black representatives in NC, created gerrymandered districts
getting more representation for historically racially discriminated population
SC ruled unconstitutional
based on the Fourthteenth Amendment, guaranteeing equal civil rights, treatment, and citizenships of Americans
separated voters based on race, race cannotbe the main consideration when redrawing district lines
set a precedent for future cases with bad intentions (in the event someone is putting minority groups at a disadvantage)
Baker v Carr — Equal Protection Clause, malapportionment of voting districts
Tennessee did not redraw districts and ignored the changing urban and rural populations
heavily over represented rural areas with less people compared to urban areas
Baker claims malapportionment diluted his votes
state of Tennessee argued that the case was out of the SC jurisdiction (not justiciable) and that state redistricting was out of their jurisdiction
SC ruled unconstitutional
violated Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment — rural votes counted for more than urban votes
federal courts can intervene in state redistricting, is nothing political in nature and upholds the Fourteenth Amendment
established “one person one vote”
Citizens United v. FEC — Violation of First Amendment, Freedom of Speech
Bipartisan Campaign Finance Act (BCRA) made the act of electioneering communications by corporations and nonprofits ILLEGAL 60 days before an election/30 days before a primary (also limited amount of monetary contribution by individuals)
Citizens United was set to release Hillary: The Movie, a film meant to derail her campaign with a bunch of accusations
the release date fell within the 60 days, therefore violating BCRA
appealed to SC under case that BCRA violated their 1st Amendment
SC ruled FEC unconstitutional
violated 1st Amendment — freedom of speech
corporations are groups of individuals
prohibiting advertisements and communications were no different from censorship
economic resources = louder voice in political arena; those with more money have more power
corporations CANNOT directly collaborate with the candidates, but may spend as much money as they want