SCOTUS Cases APGov

Marbury v. Madison — Judicial Review, Supremacy Clause

  • Marbury (judge) did not have his commission delivered by James Madison (Sec. of State)

  • demanded a writ of mandamus (order of the SC) to deliver his commission as Madison refused

    • cited the Judiciary Act of 1789, allowed Marbury to bring his claim to the SC

  • SC ruled unconstitutional

    • while Marbury was entitled to the commission, the Act expanded the Judiciary’s rights because SCOTUS can only address civil cases through appellate jurisdiction(according to Article III); in this case, the SC had original jurisdiction, which violated the Constitution


McCulloch v. Maryland — Necessary and Proper Clause, Supremacy Clause, States’ Rights

  • Congress created a branch of the national bank in Maryland

  • Maryland created legislature to impose taxes on the bank

    • McCulloch refused to pay the taxes

  • state appeals court decided that the Second Bank was unconstitutional because nowhere in the Constitution did it say that the Congress had the right to create a national bank

  • SC ruled Maryland legislature unconstitutional

    • Congress has the right to establish national banks under Elastic Clause as to fulfill their enumerated powers

    • Maryland has no right to tax instruments of the government

    • while states retain the ability to tax, the Supremacy Clause gives the most importance to the federal government’s rules


U.S. v Lopez — Congress Exceeds Authority under Commerce Clause

  • Lopez had state charges pressed for possession of a firearm at school

  • later, those charges were replaced with federal charges under the Gun-Free School Zones Act of 1990 which resulted in a short prison sentence

  • he appealed to the SC

  • SC ruled unconstitutional

    • Commerce Clause was inapplicable to the scenario: possession of a firearm does not impact the economic productivity of students

    • Congress exceeded its authority under the Commerce Clause

      • if it was ruled as constitutional, it would grant Congress the power to regulate and interfere with state’s economies and business


Reno v Shaw — Racial Gerrymandering Under Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment

  • intention to elect Black representatives in NC, created gerrymandered districts

    • getting more representation for historically racially discriminated population

  • SC ruled unconstitutional

    • based on the Fourthteenth Amendment, guaranteeing equal civil rights, treatment, and citizenships of Americans

    • separated voters based on race, race cannotbe the main consideration when redrawing district lines

    • set a precedent for future cases with bad intentions (in the event someone is putting minority groups at a disadvantage)


Baker v Carr — Equal Protection Clause, malapportionment of voting districts

  • Tennessee did not redraw districts and ignored the changing urban and rural populations

    • heavily over represented rural areas with less people compared to urban areas

    • Baker claims malapportionment diluted his votes

  • state of Tennessee argued that the case was out of the SC jurisdiction (not justiciable) and that state redistricting was out of their jurisdiction

  • SC ruled unconstitutional

    • violated Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment — rural votes counted for more than urban votes

    • federal courts can intervene in state redistricting, is nothing political in nature and upholds the Fourteenth Amendment

    • established “one person one vote”


Citizens United v. FEC — Violation of First Amendment, Freedom of Speech

  • Bipartisan Campaign Finance Act (BCRA) made the act of electioneering communications by corporations and nonprofits ILLEGAL 60 days before an election/30 days before a primary (also limited amount of monetary contribution by individuals)

  • Citizens United was set to release Hillary: The Movie, a film meant to derail her campaign with a bunch of accusations

    • the release date fell within the 60 days, therefore violating BCRA

  • appealed to SC under case that BCRA violated their 1st Amendment

  • SC ruled FEC unconstitutional

    • violated 1st Amendment — freedom of speech

    • corporations are groups of individuals

    • prohibiting advertisements and communications were no different from censorship

economic resources = louder voice in political arena; those with more money have more power

corporations CANNOT directly collaborate with the candidates, but may spend as much money as they want