Sociology of Deviance

Deviance in Sociology

Definition of Deviance

  • Deviance involves actions and behaviors that violate social norms.
      - Can include formally enacted rules (e.g., crime) and informal violations (e.g., rejecting folkways and mores).
      - Positive deviance exists in certain situations where violation is not deemed negative.

Relative Nature of Deviance

  • Social norms vary across societies and cultures.
      - An act deemed deviant in one culture may be acceptable in another.
      - Social norms evolve over time, altering perceptions of deviance.

  • Example: Killing is generally wrong; however, allowed in warfare or self-defense contexts.

Types of Deviance

  • Mala in se: Actions considered inherently immoral, like murder and rape.

  • Mala prohibita: Actions that are illegal but not inherently immoral, like drug use.

  • Formal deviance: Violations of laws (e.g., crimes).

  • Informal deviance: Violations of unwritten social rules (e.g., dress codes).

  • Major norms in society include mores, which hold moral significance and oppose taboos.

  • Taboo: Strong social prohibition against certain behaviors, considered deviant by the majority.
      - Comes from Tongan word “tapu” meaning prohibited or forbidden.
      - Examples include murder, rape, incest, etc.

Howard Becker's Typology of Deviant Labels

  1. Falsely Accusing: Individual perceived as deviant without basis.

  2. Pure Deviance: Individual engaging in rule-breaking behavior.

  3. Conforming: Individual adheres to societal norms.

  4. Secret Deviance: Individual’s behaviors are not perceived as deviant.

Sociology of Deviance as Identity Assertion

  • Deviance can reflect individuality and identity.

  • It can be a form of rebellion against dominant cultural norms in favor of sub-cultures.

Theoretical Perspectives on Deviance

Structural Functionalism

  • Concerned with how various societal factors interact to form cohesive systems.
      - Key theorists: Émile Durkheim, Robert Merton.

Émile Durkheim's Contributions
  • Functions of Deviance:
      1. Affirms Cultural Values: Virtue defined through the contrast of vice.
      2. Defines Moral Boundaries: Society learns right from wrong through deviance.
      3. Promotes Social Cohesion: Serious deviance prompts collective reaction.
      4. Encourages Social Change: Deviance challenges social norms and pushes boundaries.

  • Collective Conscience: A set of shared norms that guide behavior; vital for social integration and regulation.

  • Suicide Types:
      1. Altruistic Suicide: Over-integration into society.
      2. Egoistic Suicide: Insufficient integration into society.
      3. Anomic Suicide: Lack of social regulation leads to aimlessness.
      4. Fatalistic Suicide: Excessive social regulation.

Robert K. Merton's Strain Theory
  • Defines deviance in relation to societal goals and means to achieve them.
      - Anomie: Discrepancy between societal goals and legitimate means of achieving them.

  • Describes five types of deviance based on acceptance/rejection of goals:
      1. Innovation: Accepts goals but rejects means (e.g., theft).
      2. Conformity: Accepts both goals and means.
      3. Ritualism: Rejects goals but accepts means.
      4. Retreatism: Rejects both goals and means (e.g., substance abuse).
      5. Rebellion: Rejects societal goals and means, replaces them with own values.

Symbolic Interactionism

  • Refers to communication patterns during social interactions that define reality.

  • Key Principles (Herbert Blumer):
      1. People act based on meanings ascribed to things.
      2. Meanings arise from social interactions.
      3. Meanings are modified through interpretive processes.

Edwin Sutherland's Differential Association Theory
  • Criminal behaviors are learned through social interactions.
      - More exposure to favorable definitions of deviance leads to engagement in deviance (e.g., gangs).

Gresham Sykes and David Matza's Neutralization Theory
  • Deviants may neutralize guilt using five techniques:
      1. Denial of Responsibility: Perceives actions as forced.
      2. Denial of Injury: Considers actions harmless.
      3. Denial of Victim: Sees victims as deserving.
      4. Condemnation of Condemners: Attacks the morality of the accusers.
      5. Appeal to Higher Loyalties: Prioritizes norms over legal boundaries.

Labeling Theory

  • Developed by Frank Tannenbaum and Howard Becker; central to symbolic interactionism.

  • Deviance results from societal labels that individuals internalize, leading to self-fulfilling prophecies.

  • Labels can stigmatize individuals and influence their future behavior, fostering deviant identities.

Primary and Secondary Deviance
  • Primary Deviance: Initial acts of deviance before societal labels are applied.

  • Secondary Deviance: Acts committed after being labeled deviant as a reaction to the labeling.

  • Retrospective Labeling: Recognizing deviant acts prior to label.

  • Prospective Labeling: Anticipating future deviant acts based on labeling.

Broken Windows Theory
  • Suggests minor offenses, if unchecked, can lead to more serious crimes.

  • Policing minor crimes may reduce major offenses.

Control Theory

  • Weak bonds to society lead to increased deviance; strong bonds deter it.

  • Bonds consist of four factors: opportunity, attachment, belief, and involvement.

Containment Theory

  • Each individual possesses safeguards to prevent deviance.

  • Weak social controls may lead to delinquency.

Conflict Theory

  • Focuses on social and economic forces causing deviance.
      - Powerful groups define norms; laws often serve the interests of those in power.

  • Marxist perspectives link deviance to capitalism and exploitation.

Michel Foucault's Ideas
  • Modern power mechanisms subtly control individuals through social norms instead of overt oppression.

  • Institutions impose discipline that shapes societal norms and behaviors.

Biological Theories of Deviance

  • Propose biological factors as contributors to deviant behavior (e.g., Cesare Lombroso's theory).
      - Early theories posited genetic predispositions for criminal behavior but have been largely discredited.

Classical School of Criminology

  • Founded by Cesare Beccaria and Jeremy Bentham; utilitarian perspectives on law and punishment.
      - Advocated for proportional punishments to deter deviance effectively.

The Criminal Justice System

  1. Police: Enforce laws and maintain public order, using discretion based on context.

  2. Courts: Engage in adversarial legal processes, often favoring plea bargaining.

  3. Corrections Systems: Community-based corrections aimed at rehabilitation but may not reduce recidivism.

Jurisdictions of Punishment
  • Punitive Justice: Focus on retribution and deterrence.

  • Rehabilitative Justice: Focus on rehabilitation and societal protection.

Common Deviant Behaviors
  • Antisocial behavior, nonconformity, political abuse of psychiatry, victimology, and workplace deviance.