Lapsley-PlotThickens-2016

Overview of the Review

  • The review focuses on Dan P. McAdams's work, "The Art and Science of Personality Development."

  • It is authored by Daniel Lapsley and published in Human Development, detailing the relationship between personality and its development.

Historical Context

  • Historically, personality psychology focused on stable individual differences using trait models.

  • Developmental psychology concentrated on changes within individuals over time, often neglecting personality stability.

  • Loevinger’s theory introduced the concept of ego development, bridging the gap between stable traits and individual development.

    • Ego development considered a key trait, essential for understanding personal differences alongside intelligence.

Shift in Focus Within Psychology

  • By the 1980s, developmental and personality psychology began exploring their intersections more closely.

  • Lapsley highlights how developmental science differed in terminology and approach compared to personality theories.

  • Damon’s work on personality development emphasized individuality and social relationships, contributing to the developmental foundations of personality.

McAdams's Contribution

  • McAdams's book is noted for its comprehensive exploration of diverse topics related to personality development.

    • It synthesizes various fields: neuroscience, genetics, and culture, providing a broader context for personality research.

    • Addresses developmental foundations of personality traits, particularly emphasizing the significance of the "5-7 shift" in childhood.

Main Themes in McAdams's Book

Personality as Evolutionary Achievement

  • Personality evolves as a response to social needs, crucial for societal functionality and cooperation.

  • Variations in personality traits help individuals navigate social interactions.

Artistry in Personality Development

  • McAdams argues that developing personality is a creative performance, akin to theatrical expression.

    • This performance evolves into narrative identity, where individuals author their stories.

Biopsychosocial Perspective

  • Personality development integrates biological, psychological, and social influences.

  • Traits originate from biological temperament and adapt through social experiences.

Thickening of Personality

  • Over time, the self matures, incorporating layers: as an actor, an agent, and finally an author, shaping personal narratives.

    • Distinct phases of personality comprise identifiable features from childhood through young adulthood.

Critiques and Future Directions

The Emergence of Self

  • Lapsley notes a misalignment in the timeline of ego development as described by McAdams, individually noting the I-self versus Me-self development.

Layers of Personality

  • The metaphor of personality layering needs clarification in dynamic interactions among traits and personal motives.

    • Lapsley suggests deeper integration between personality aspects, rather than viewing them as separate entities.

Social Cognitive Mechanisms

  • A noticeable absence of discussion on social cognition in personality development, despite its significance.

    • The author could benefit from including this aspect in further editions for a holistic understanding.

Moral Development Insights

  • Lapsley raises points about McAdams's view on morality, indicating a need for nuance regarding moral socialization versus general social rules.

  • Suggests extending insights on narcissism and agency in the context of developmental challenges, particularly during adolescence.

Conclusion

  • McAdams's book serves as a vital resource for examining the intersection of personality and development in psychology.

  • By calling attention to narrative identity and the integration of personality traits, the work sets a foundation for continued scholarly dialogue between developmental and personality psychology.