Ib History notes y1
Vocab/Key
6 history concepts
Cause and consequence
change and continuity
significance
perspective
Guided notes VSEPM
V: Environment
S: society
E: economy
P: politics
M: Military
Unit 1
*Questions for first 2 readings in flashcards

*Questions for first 2 readings in flashcards
**How Vikings Discovered Greenland- Video
**
Greenland is only 20 miles from North America vs 200 from Iceland
Initially there were no Native Americans on Greenland’s land
Gunnbjörn Ulfsson got thrown offcourse and found greenland from norway— however this was proven false because his vision was distorted Hillingar (Arctic Mirages)
Snæbjörn Galti: first person to step foot into greenland, attemted to create first settlement
Was killed after getting into argument, this settlement failed
Eric the red got into another mans land, and kills many people, gets sentenced 3 years exile
Erics father in norway was kicked out 20 yrs ago because he also killed someone
Eric went to greenland and explored, and then returned to iceland and tell the citizens abt greenland
**9/23 Video: BBC timetable- Viking Cutting Edge technology, Winroth 72-80.6
**
Norse ship building techniques and materials
oakwood to build entire ship
split in half, smoothed, shaped, fitted to keel
oak is strong and flexible rot resistent follows natrual fibers
rounded hell & shallow keel allows them to beach and come close to shore
clinker design of overlapping planks allow for less water proofing, makes ship lighter & faster\
symmetrical allowing them to directly sail out or in either direction
use of square sails- much faster than rowing
Inspired by the romans
sail made from linen pr wool with animal fats and ochre rubbed in the fabric to seal it
square saild worked well with wind in the right direction, but otherwise could push them the wrong way, the slower the more effective, zig zagging
oars to help maneuver
some ships used maple, birch, and pine
Types of Norse ships
Oseberg Norway Longship
bulkier ship for transporting goods- knarr
Norse navigational skills
focused on coast hugging and river nav first, explored over in open seas
Issues encounteres
tough to split the oakwood in half
shipwrecks
**9/25
What is a perspective?**
opinion or view on matter
way we view things based on experiences and knowledge, emotions playing a role
perspectives one might have: NYC, liberal bubble, american, multi-cultural, family-religion-origin, gender race age characteristics, expertise, wealth/social class
Can perspectives be wrong?
dependent on perspective- how far off are they
depends on how we state it, isw it posited as a universal fact or opinon/belief
how can we ensure accuracy of perspective?
manufacturers design
sorting through variety of views
no 100% certainty of perspectivrd providing full truth
**TedTalk video “Facts, Opinions, & Lies”
**
Which hall mark of understanding perspectives is the most important? why?
reliability- perspective must have truthful foundation based on evidence
able to understand background/context
rationalization- is there academic debate or lies parading as discourse
truth is not relative, undisputable, no wiggleroom
extra awareness of social media
for one group to be right others have to be wrong
How can we distinguish between truth(facts) opinions and lies?
deniers denying the experiences the experiencers went through
deniers take lies and dress them as opinions
take facts and would distort them
9/30
climate change:
making earth warmer, sea levels rise
extreme weather, changing weather, more natural disaster
greenhouse gasses in atmosphere causing warming
impact on habitat, especially in colder regions
***Estevez 51-54
figures 1.29, 1.31, 1.32, 1.34, and 1.35 are sources that historians studying norse exploration can use. Study the five figures and associated information. Do they convince you that there was a Medival Warm Period? Why/why not?
There is a common pattern of higher levels of temperature and indirect factors of temperature that show in all of the graphs that the medieval warm periods levels are rather slightly or significantly higher. I am convinced that there was a Medieval warm period since there is an upward trend between all of the graphs with a clear downward trend after the medieval warm period. Also there is a variety of types of scientific palaeoclimatology data supporting existence of warming period. One scientist doing meta synthesis of data purposefully omitted the tree ring data to focus on all other data bc tree ring tends to dominate. Focusing on other data he was also to find those results, which still supported warming pattern. Respected and expert researchers who are also from range of scientific backgrounds all corroborate. Data from variety of years also corroborate including more modern studies still supporting older ones.
what other sources of information, in addition to palaeoclimatological data, might help you find out about the Medival Warm Period?
Some other sources of information to help find out about the Medieval warm period could be statistics of sales from that time period. For example, what types of crops that were more popular or had a greater level of production. If we know the quality of crops back then we can see what types of environments they were grown in and we can gauge what the temperature was at the time.
HW questions in same packet 61-64
what information do sources B and C give you about the geographical extent of Arctic sea ice between c982 and 1020?
During this time period source B has a graph with the pattern that the arctic ice extent was relatively the same throughout these years. The amount of arctic sea ice was around 10km. However, in source C, it shows how the amount of sea ice decreased in area from march to september 1979.
Some historians argue that new sea routes, which opened up because there was less Arctic sea ice during the Medieval Warm Period, facilitated Norse exploration and the settlement of Greenland and Vinland. To what extent do you agree with this perspective?
I agree with this perspective to a large extent, as reduced Arctic sea ice during the Medieval Warm Period significantly facilitated navigation by opening clearer sea routes, reducing hazards like icebergs and drift ice, and extending the sailing season across the North Atlantic. This climatic window made long-distance voyages between Iceland, Greenland, and Vinland safer and more predictable. However, while climate was an essential enabling factor, it was not the sole cause. Advanced Norse maritime technology—such as sturdy, clinker-built ships like the knarr—and socio-political push factors, including land shortages, exile, and economic incentives (such as trade in walrus ivory and timber), were equally crucial in driving Norse exploration and settlement.
Was the Medieval Warm Period a significant contributor to Norse exploration? Contrast factor with other possible causes with opinion
Unit 1
*Questions for first 2 readings in flashcards
How Vikings Discovered Greenland- Video
Greenland is only 20 miles from North America vs 200 from Iceland
Initially there were no Native Americans on Greenland’s land
Gunnbjörn Ulfsson got thrown offcourse and found greenland from norway— however this was proven false because his vision was distorted Hillingar (Arctic Mirages)
Snæbjörn Galti: first person to step foot into greenland, attemted to create first settlement
Was killed after getting into argument, this settlement failed
Eric the red got into another mans land, and kills many people, gets sentenced 3 years exile
Erics father in norway was kicked out 20 yrs ago because he also killed someone
Eric went to greenland and explored, and then returned to iceland and tell the citizens abt greenland
9/23 Video: BBC timetable- Viking Cutting Edge technology, Winroth 72-80.6
Norse ship building techniques and materials
oakwood to build entire ship
split in half, smoothed, shaped, fitted to keel
oak is strong and flexible rot resistent follows natrual fibers
rounded hell & shallow keel allows them to beach and come close to shore
clinker design of overlapping planks allow for less water proofing, makes ship lighter & faster
symmetrical allowing them to directly sail out or in either direction
use of square sails- much faster than rowing
Inspired by the romans
sail made from linen pr wool with animal fats and ochre rubbed in the fabric to seal it
square saild worked well with wind in the right direction, but otherwise could push them the wrong way, the slower the more effective, zig zagging
oars to help maneuver
some ships used maple, birch, and pine
Types of Norse ships
Oseberg Norway Longship
bulkier ship for transporting goods- knarr
Norse navigational skills
focused on coast hugging and river nav first, explored over in open seas
Issues encounteres
tough to split the oakwood in half
shipwrecks
9/25
What is a perspective?
opinion or view on matter
way we view things based on experiences and knowledge, emotions playing a role
perspectives one might have: NYC, liberal bubble, american, multi-cultural, family-religion-origin, gender race age characteristics, expertise, wealth/social class
Can perspectives be wrong?
dependent on perspective- how far off are they
depends on how we state it, isw it posited as a universal fact or opinon/belief
how can we ensure accuracy of perspective?
manufacturers design
sorting through variety of views
no 100% certainty of perspectivrd providing full truth
TedTalk video “Facts, Opinions, & Lies”
Which hall mark of understanding perspectives is the most important? why?
reliability- perspective must have truthful foundation based on evidence
able to understand background/context
rationalization- is there academic debate or lies parading as discourse
truth is not relative, undisputable, no wiggleroom
extra awareness of social media
for one group to be right others have to be wrong
How can we distinguish between truth(facts) opinions and lies?
deniers denying the experiences the experiencers went through
deniers take lies and dress them as opinions
take facts and would distort them
9/30
climate change:
making earth warmer, sea levels rise
extreme weather, changing weather, more natural disaster
greenhouse gasses in atmosphere causing warming
impact on habitat, especially in colder regions
Estevez 51-54
figures 1.29, 1.31, 1.32, 1.34, and 1.35 are sources that historians studying norse exploration can use. Study the five figures and associated information. Do they convince you that there was a Medival Warm Period? Why/why not?
There is a common pattern of higher levels of temperature and indirect factors of temperature that show in all of the graphs that the medieval warm periods levels are rather slightly or significantly higher. I am convinced that there was a Medieval warm period since there is an upward trend between all of the graphs with a clear downward trend after the medieval warm period. Also there is a variety of types of scientific palaeoclimatology data supporting existence of warming period. One scientist doing meta synthesis of data purposefully omitted the tree ring data to focus on all other data bc tree ring tends to dominate. Focusing on other data he was also to find those results, which still supported warming pattern. Respected and expert researchers who are also from range of scientific backgrounds all corroborate. Data from variety of years also corroborate including more modern studies still supporting older ones.
what other sources of information, in addition to palaeoclimatological data, might help you find out about the Medival Warm Period?
Some other sources of information to help find out about the Medieval warm period could be statistics of sales from that time period. For example, what types of crops that were more popular or had a greater level of production. If we know the quality of crops back then we can see what types of environments they were grown in and we can gauge what the temperature was at the time.
HW questions in same packet 61-64
what information do sources B and C give you about the geographical extent of Arctic sea ice between c982 and 1020?
During this time period source B has a graph with the pattern that the arctic ice extent was relatively the same throughout these years. The amount of arctic sea ice was around 10km. However, in source C, it shows how the amount of sea ice decreased in area from march to september 1979.
Some historians argue that new sea routes, which opened up because there was less Arctic sea ice during the Medieval Warm Period, facilitated Norse exploration and the settlement of Greenland and Vinland. To what extent do you agree with this perspective?
I agree to a great extent with this perspective because less ice opened up more opportunities to travel on water and make more routes. This expanded abilities for the Norse to travel leading to exploration of their social and economic life. Also with less ice this provides safer conditions for ships to travel which gives the Norse more abilities to trade with other settlements. Desire to expand to trade network and looking for new lands already had the norse exploring, but the warm period aided them in this. Norse would have been aware of the decrease in sea ice, which would likely have motivated them to explore these new areas in the N atlantic. still risk, many still died so other factors must be influencing them to explore
10/1
How significant was the medieval warm period to norse expansion?
I think the information it provides is important since it supports that climate change is real since for a while the conditions have been relatively stable and this is more sudden and recent, however if there were more sources and researches to bust this myth it would make the claim stronger. Also since this website is backed up and a trusted source, it is good and also they include official data to support. UN’s purpose is to be objective, bring peace to the world, so they would share information that is supported by a wealth of evidence— established understandings
another perspective challenging established understanding— transparency
provided statistics and historical comparisons between different warming periods
***Useful then as reliable source
is the concept of the medieval warm period too simplistic?
in a way yes ot was one of many factors influencing the norse— an alignment of factors facilitated the expansion
not every part of the world warmed; not every part of the world had the same reaction— some glaciers seem to have expanded like in northern Greenland
HW
Was the Medieval Warm Period a significant contributor to Norse exploration? Contrast factor with other possible causes with opinion
The Medieval Warm Period was a significant enabling factor for Norse exploration, as reduced Arctic sea ice and milder temperatures opened up safer sea routes, extended sailing seasons, and made settlements in Greenland and Vinland agriculturally viable. However, in my opinion, climate alone was not the sole cause, but rather an environmental catalyst (V in VSEPM) that worked in tandem with other critical push and pull factors:
Technological Factors: Advanced ship-building techniques (clinker design, flexible oak hulls, square sails, knarr trading vessels) provided the essential tools for open-ocean navigation.
Socio-Political & Economic Factors: Land shortages and population pressure in Scandinavia and Iceland, political conflict and exile (e.g., Erik the Red), and the drive for valuable trade goods (walrus ivory, furs, timber) provided the direct motivation to expand.
Conclusion/Opinion: While the Medieval Warm Period facilitated safer ocean travel and rendered new lands habitable, Norse expansion was ultimately driven by a combination of technological capabilities, economic motives, and social pressures.
10/6 question
what do you think are the benefits of an interdisciplinary team for the study of Norse adaptation to Greenland environment?
Norse did have livestock, differed between Greenland & Iceland, also differed based on wealth/social status— Iceland had mostly sheep and goats- which was similar to greenland- wealthier people tended to have more cattle
10/7
estevez 90-92
compared to iceland greenlands population was much smaller, wild animals from hunting did not go extinct like they did on celand
farming was importat in both areas but iceland was extreme in altering the landscape not so drastic on greenland
Norse greenlands imported hunting techniques and supposedly practices of maintaining wild populations but on iceland this failed and on greenland it succeeded
more communal organization and shared responsibility and food distribution on greenland than elsewhere
walrus tusks- ivory- became a major trade item for greenlanders used entire animal
SOURCE SKILLS QUESTIONS
what does source H say about the use of manure by Norse settlers in Greenland? Identify at ;east one specific point of content from the source that supports this
did the norse use manure for their farms/pastures? source H says no, nitrogen levels there do not support manure usaye
argues norse in greenland did not have enough animals or manpower to make and use manure (lack of arable land)
what does source I say about the use of manure by Norse settlers in Greenland? Identify at ;east one specific point of content from the source that supports this
argues manure was used based on debris found in drainage ditches, finding microorganisms from manure at hiigh levels— possibly using irrigation to distribute manure
human sources
bishop— wealthy/high social class— cattle (POSSIBILITIES), wealthy had more cattle therefore more poop and had more servants for manpower
sources H and I are both academic articles. What are the pros and cons of academic research as source materials for historians? Use evidence from the context of source H and I tot support argument
Pros: lots of knowledge in subject since they study this for a long time
archaeologists and anthropologists and physicists used to back up claim
Cons: could potentially have bias and limited resources to research with
since they are academic they probobaly have specific resources to use which we are not completelu sure they are reliable, also dont know if they have been updated or facts have changed
source I gets some info from an article from 2009
Sources H and I appear to come to different conclusions about the use of manure by Norse settlers in Greenland. Contrast different arguments used in each source to support proposals
Source H: the norse did not use manure
Source I: the norse did use manure
Estevez 94
no farming in vinland
some evidence of trading with indigenous
focused on huntinf of cod seal whale
similar to foods in greenland but with some additions
most likely brought some domesticated animals for dairy, which was likely a trade product w indigenous
vinland was not a permament settlement— no animal buyers
seems like L’Anse Aux Meadows was only ever a base camp, traveling from greenland to deeper into vinland and back using L’Anse as a way/rest station
10/8
General conventions
avoid using I think, /, etc, …, in conclusion
Paper 1
3 prompts + sources
Paper 1.1-short answer-content
focus on 2+ themes
2+ pgs
2-3 pieces of info from 2 sources, comparative and contrasting info
explain how info responds to the Inquiry Question
does it support or counter main idea? show different perspective?
Paper 1.2-short answer
2+pgs
focus on context, OPVL and how the context influences content
5-6+ pieces of info from one source context and some content
how can you use the context to respond to the inquiry question? how can it help? what might you have to be wary of?
Paper 1.3- extended response
essay
focus on perspectives, based on context and content, from all 3 sources
explain how perspectivres respond to inquiry question- do they support or counter main idea? show diff perspectivrs?
include supporting, countering, different perspectives
10/9
Compare and contrast how the two sources narrate the same event of Norse, Erik the Red, arriving in Greenland
Source I
Erik the Red left Jadri to Iceland due to some killings
Thorvald: Leif erikson Erik the Red’s father
Lots of names and connections
disputes over wood? Saga of Erik— split sides
Includes thoughts and what some characters said during what was occuring— for example erik when he was preparing to voyage— said “he would return to his friends if he found land”
traveled around coast trying to find habitable land
did different things in different places each winter and summer during the period he was away
Spent time in Eriksfjord
went to iceland and also found greenland. reason for naming it greenland
the men who went with Erik claimed the land with him while others went to western settlement
eriks dad forced gto move
Source J
similar explanation of ancestry of Erik the red and leif erikson
Married thjodhild- mentions in both sources
erik had slaves, Eyjolf kinsman killed the slaves and then Erik killed Eyjolf, goes more into detail about who he kills'
was outlawed and mentioned lending thorgest wooden beams
more conflict with wooden beams and they fought, 2 of thorgests sons and other men fell— also ended up picking sides
also plans to find more land and report back to friends after he was outlawed and forced to prepare a ship to leave
arrived at the glacier Blaserkr
describes the same places he went during the winters and summers
erik was defeated after erik and thorgest fought but then reconciled
then found greenland
similarities
EXPLANATION OF HISTORICAL figures eriks dad erik eriks wife son and people they disputed w
specifics of both banishments are very similar wooden beams, and his discover nd exploration of greenlands main land
differences
source J goes into morw detail abt eriks first fight and his banishment talking abt eriks slaves causing a landslidr and eriks neighbors raising
10/16
estevez 40-45 roles of both erik the red and leif erikson
content into about Leif Erikson exploration
source K
The king wanted leif (one of Erik the Reds sons) to sail to greenland on a christianity mission.
leif thought it was hard but willing to take on the challenge
they found self sown wheat fields, grapevines, and maple trees on the lands they encountered and took samples of everything to use in the future
leif took men home (rescued) and this showed great nobility and honor, he was called “Leif the Lucky”, was well liked (objective take?)
influenced by tales Bjarni brought back of unknown lands
preached christianity since mission
souce L
Which types of evidence do you think are most useful for a historian assessing the reliability of the Vinland sagas?
oral histories of the norse that were written down after 200 years and rewritten over time w originals being lost- from norse perspective- likely making history/ancestors sounds more glorious than they were
anonymous authors
why do you think some thing saga of erik the red is more accurate (source K) , some think saga of the greenlanders (source L), some thik both are equally valuable?
10/20
estevez 80-84, VSEPM and settlement of vinland, in text questions on 83 + 84
norse did arrive in Vinland and built small communities, but settlement is too permenant sounding, the Norse did not live there year round
L’Anse Aux Meadows buildings seem to have burned down after the Norse either purposefully as they left or by the indigenous
L’Anse built on coastline, on a rise in the land, not good for farming— but it was good for finding it from sea when returning to the camp
collection of some archaeology found in L’Anse, enough items of typical female origin/use that women, likely in small numbers, were part of the Norse there
Minimal evidence of children- Sagas mention a kid
what do figures 1.65-1.72 tell us about the people who lived at L’Anse aux Meadows?
Does source F support or contradict the conclusions you came to about the people who lived at L’Anse aux Meadows after examining figures 1.65-1.72?
How does the context of Source F influence its value in our understanding of the people who lived at L’Anse aux Meadows?
10/21
Norse Greenlanders found to have imported timber from North America Article
wood taxa analysis is used to distinguish between types of wood: imported, drift, and native
its unclear where the wood imports came from but the Norse relied on the imported wood and other materials (iron) around 50% of usage of wood was driftwood
0.27% of wood was unambiguous imports
25% of total wood was either imported or driftwood
archaeologists looked at where people traded with and limited ranges of where they grow
hemlock and jack pine that was found was most likely from north america
some wood came from europe including oak, beech, and scots pine
OPVL source analysis of zori
context of origin (who what when where)
David Zori: professor of history+ archaeology at Baylor uni— specializing in this
academic book origin “Age of Wolf and Wind: Voyages Through the Viking World”
2024
most likely reliable source
used academic sources to back up findings: fairly reasonable
expert in 2 related fields of study
context of purpose (why)
to teach others (students)
informs others researching topic on how there is evidence to support both that there could have been livestock brung and also to support there wasn’t
not primary source, no first hand experience of norse, from a united states based perspective, could be changed— outsider perspective
hindsight w updated archarological evidencd combined with long standing text evidence— updated, revisits history based on newest
content (what info, vocab, emotions included)
archaeological data was used to shape this writing
sagas prove that Norse brought livestock and they wanted to permanently settle
absence of archaeological evidence, contradicts
Animal bones found suggested absence of livestock
not certain evidence for either side, it seems iffy, not conclusive on if there was livestock
very objective evidence, not much opinion put into source, less prone to bias
10/23 AZTEC UNIT BEGINS!!!
background knowledge of aztecs
based in central america, specifically mexico
religion placed importance on human
Estevez 109,111,122-124
aztec empire known for advanced architecture, complex social and economic structure, and rich religious cultural traditions
very innovative
formed around 1428, combination of about 3 city states, founded on a triple allience, military expansion
region where aztecs lived were challenging due to the climate and physical environment
prone to droughts and flooding, prompted innovation to adapt to conditions, these reasons basically forced them to inovate
one innovation were the chinampas- floating farms
were hunter gatherers living in northern mexico
uesed the term “Mexica” to refer to themselves
believe in gods communicating with them, potentially telling them to migrate from their homeland and then where to settle
Mexica spoke Nahuatl, part of group of languages called Uto-Aztecan family
sites in north western mexico have uncovered pottery, weapons, and tools
recorded oral histories describing migration from north
big migration occured, mexica encountered toltec people, sources available blend natrual and supernatural events
aztecs mean ‘people from Azlan’ but researchers haven’t fpund an actual location, maybe mythological? evidence to show northern mexico as place of origin
list the terms used to refer to people of each opposing side. What impression do you get of each side, based on terms used?
estevez focused on explanatory terms about how the Aztec refered to themselves & how later historians coined the term ‘Aztec’
while prescot in source A used terms like ‘barbarian’ and ‘discordant’ for aztec v his use of terms like ‘Christian’ and ‘Spaniards’ (using actual terminology)
10/27
Camilla Townsed Aztec Article
• Many scholars that study the Aztecs focus on archaeological remains rather than the Nahuatl which cannot be read
• They also look at colonial era painted or glyphic sources, and texts written by Spaniards- could lead to bias/ considered potentially unreliable
• Spaniards depicted the Indigenous people as barbarous, dangerous, violent
• Aztec’s dogs (itzcuintli/xoloitzcuintli) were either food in times of need or pets
• It was said that when the dog owner died the family would kill their dog so it could help them find the land of the dead.
• Archaeological remains and colonial-era glyphic paintings are more reliable as they are self depictions
• There were human sacrifices, large pyramid temples (in which said sacrifices took place)
• Soon after the first military victory over the Mexica, Franciscan friars began teaching young Indigenous students the Roman alphabet.
• They taught them how to read so they could easily convert to Christianity
• People are working to uncover more about the Aztecs by deciphering the Nahuatl texts
• More studies of sources not tinged by the Spaniards but be conducted.
• Nahuas would perform oral accounts of stories, correct each other, tell their own point of view
• These performances would be transcripted, written “annals” were kept of the history
Maria de la Paz Estevez
• Conquistador: conqueror; one of the Spanish people who took part in the conquest and colonization of Mexico (and other parts of Central and South American) from the 16th century onwards.
• Contemporary and secondary sources are used to study the Aztecs
• Language in which the sources are written varies, some in pictographs, some including both pictographs and Spanish notes, some in Nahuatl, some in Spanish
• Chronicle: Record or report
• Friar: A member of a Christian order who serves the Church
• Hernando Alvarado Tezozomoc: Aztec noble in the Spanish colonial times, son of Diego de Alvarado Huanitzin, the governor of Tenochtitlan. He was an interpreter for a Spanish court
• Many materials were written by Spanish friars
• When reading these, we must consider date and purpose because they may be selective in what they choose to include
• Hernan Cortes: Spanish conqueror who led the first phase of the Spanish conquest and colonization of the Americas. Led expedition that conquered Aztec empire, brought parts of Mexico under Spanish rule.
• Linguist: someone who studies the structure of language
• CIvil authorities: Government bodies and officials in charge of the management of civil affairs
• Religious Authorities: Institutions and Individuals that hold power over religious beliefs and practices
• Chronologically: relating to chronological order, which is the order in which something happened.
• Codex (plural codices): An ancient form of book; a stack of written pages bound together to form a book.
• Pictographs: Symbols or small pictures used for words or phrases.
• Glyphs: Symbols or small pictures used for words or phrases.
• The best source for the Nahuatl language was written by Spanish Linguist, Alonso de Molina, Franciscan missionary who learned Nahuatl after coming to America as a child. He wrote the first Nahuatl-Spanish language dictionary, aimed to help priests who were sent to help convert people to Christianity.
• Many of the Aztec written sources are incomplete, illegible, or not well preserved. Can be hard to translate
• Many of the sources by Spanish and Europeans depicted Aztecs as pagan subjugated people.
• Aztecs were influenced by their own belief system
• Aztecs liked to produce several versions of their own history
• Prior to the Spanish conquest, Aztecs wrote info on codices w/ pictographs and glyphs painted on them
• Many of the codices were destroyed by the Spaniards, because they wanted them to convert to Christianity, suppress Aztec laws, records, and customs, destroyed in chaos of battle, regarded as unimported.
• The codices gave info on Aztec history, economy, politics, religion, family, health
• Codex Borgio: pre spanish; rituals and religion
• Codex Borbonicus: c. 1519; Aztec calendar and religious ceremonies
• Codex Mendoza (1541(L politics, economy, conquests, and taxes
• Florentine Codez (1545-1590): Aztec culture, religion, society, and economy; Spanish+Nahuatl
• Codex Telleriano-Remensis (1550-1560): Calendar, rituals, history, and earthquakes
• Codex Azcatilan (c1575-1590): Aztec history, migration, rulers, Spanish conquest, and Christianity
• Other sources they used: Colonial records (wills, petitions, etc.) reveal laws, economy and daily life.
• Studying codices is important because pictographs can have many meanings, context is important.
• Pre-Colombian: before Columbus’s arrival in the Americas (1492)
• Viceroy: governor ruling ofra king or queen.
• Archaeology: studies physical remains to understand the Aztec history and daily life.
• Evidence found: Buildings, tools, weapons, jewelry, pottery, plants,and animal remains.
• Excavation sites: Temples, palaces, shrines, altars, ballcourts, and homes.
• What remains revealed about the Aztecs: information on Aztec cultures and daily life across social and economic classes.
• Challenges: remains may be inaccessible or limited in quantity
• Limitation: major sites reveal info about religious/ political people, not the whole population.
• Ethnography: studies living people and their cultures
• Anthropology: studies humanity, including biology and culture.
• Ethnographers: Interview Nahua people to learn about Aztec traditions, beliefs, and practices.
• Oral traditions: Stories and knowledge passed down through generations
• Limitations: traditions may change over time and be influenced by other cultures
• Challenge: modern practices may differ from those of the ancient Aztecs.
Source- What it tells us
Contemporary written sources- Aztec history and culture
European written sources- Aztec history and culture
Archaeological remains- Daily life, beliefs, technology
Ethnography- Living Nahua traditions
Iconography- Meaning of symbols and imagery
Toponymy- Place names reveal migration and conquest
Numismatics- Coins, trade, and currency
Environmental studies- Human settlements and landscapes
Genetic studies - Migration patterns and disease history
10/28
calpulli= big houses
capul is when a group of people live close to one another, typically with a common connection (family, ethnicicty, artisanship)
city states had independent rulers when going to war
functioned as administrative and economic units, made maps of lands and paid tribute to city state
mexican basin was divided into about 60 city states called altepetl, goverened by ruler: tlatoani
city of Tebichtitland became largest city in region, gained a lot of power
the Mexica gained some wealth from the tepanec
relationship between altepetls were hostile and not good
in late 14th century, the 2 dominant confederations: Tepanec people from Azcapotzalco on western side, and Acolhua people from Texcoco eastern side, but the 1st side had more control
triple allience was formed after war between the 3 altepetls rulers: Itzcoatl, Netzahualcoyotl, Totoquihuaztli
became very good in the military force
power was divided between the 3 rulers/sides, but not completely equal
Tenochtitlan took on dominant role in triple alliance
source g: what elements and items in the image show us that itzcoatl was a significant person?
wearing ‘high quality’ clothing
holding a torch like object the size of his body, shows that he has power and dominance
dominant stance
obsidian serpent over his shoulder, protects Itzcoatl
10/29
annotate context for origin, purpose, and content
Frances F. Berdan was an archaeologist who specializes in the studying of the aztecs— credible
source came from a book, academic source
published in 2017, value of origin is modern study with updated evidence and analysis using all sources available over past couple hundred years— hindsight
evaluate values and limitations
secondary source, so author did not view the events directly, some information could be blured or ignored
content- limited details about types of tribute and actual amounts- how much wealth did this represent?
author is more focused on archaeology rather than purely on history
respond to in text question
tribute systen favored tenochititlan and texcoco with each recieving double of their third ally, Tlapcopan 2/5 shares v only 1/5 share, Tenochititlan seems to take veen more power even above texcoco with much of the tribute stored in tenochititland and its ruler determining distribution
10/30
Bias: prejudice in favor of or againts one thing person or group in a way to be considered unfair
perspective: particular attitude toward way of regarding something: point of view
compare and contrast the perspective drawing stilllifes
I described the drawing and i chose to start from left to right, and what objects were in front vs behind. I tried to describe the positioning of each object and placement i thought that was the most important. I also tried to not complicate my instructions and be as clear as possible. I also compared the proportions of objects a lot so the drawer knows how large to draw the corresponding ones.
this activity informs the difference between bias and perspective because the perspective of the viewer said a lot about how they described the positioning of objects, and no perspective is necessarily wrong, just different since people see things differently. However, a bias is where the opinion or favor is unfair, and I do not believe this activity had any bias.
Depending on the context of the author of a source (in this case the circumstances of where the viewer was), this gives the viewer a certain perspective, that allows them to see or not see different things about a situation. This will impact the content in a source since the context directly relates to the content and tells what is included, but with some details left out or incorrect ones it can skew what is being said.
It is almost impossible for one source to provide the full reality of an event. One source cannot possibly take into account every single perspective someone from the situation may have, and in history a lot of the perspectives from marginalized groups are left out and often times voices are not heard. Additionally, if you depend on one source to tell you everything you need to know, you have the risk of trusting an unreliable author or may encounter a bias which ruins your entire research process.
I think we can have enough sources about an event, when we have captured as many perspectives you can think of, a mix of primary and secondary sources, as well as take factors into account.
whats important and what isnt?
perspective- location in room blocks or reveals diff items
HW- Camilla Townsead
The Mexica arrived in the fertile central basin in the 13th century
willing to put themselves in the military to grow crops on the farm
by 14th century established a permenant town
The Mexica as a whole were a weak and vulnerable population
Dominant city state: Azcapotzalco, populated by Tepanec people
Triple allience allowed them to gain more power, beginning of the aztec empire
expanded to include most of Mexico
started to fluorish specifically Tenochtitlan
1519, Hernando Cortés explored islands off Yucatan peninsula, people of Mexica did not want him coming to Tenochititlan however
europeans and the people Mexica started to fight, newcomers defeated Tenochititlan
the aztecs did not use that name to reference themselves
the aztecs lived in the Aztlan
used the term Mexica to be less vauge and matched the situation better
confusion with the distinguish between names
The people called Mexica became the dominant people in mexico but shared lives with numerous other groups, intertwined
11/4
estevez 133-142
aztecs needed to develop systems to govern people part of empire
altepetls made part of empire
religion in aztec empire was syncretic, absorbed from many other
believed both the universe is unstable and threatened by death+ destruction, and also the need for sacrifice to appease gods, keeps life cycle balanced
had different temples and schools to teach abt religion, taught them according to social class
priests ran the special religious calendar
had rituals/human sacrifices that offered a persxons heart to the gods, seen to access paradise
3 ways people died back then: died on battlefield, died traveling to distant places, and died giving birth to first child
thouht humans have a small role in the world
ended up taking over many smaller city states
bureaucrscy was built up
used religion to control evb
offerings made for the dead on calendar but after 4 years they were completely cut off (clear end point)
war means to expand and protect trade routes
conquered areas had new layer of aztec administration added, but could retain local rules, as long as they aligned w Aztec expectations-tribute
reliance on trade
HW from 133 (wednesday)
do historians agree on causes of flower wars?
(class)
no, historians do not agree, multiple different perspectives including capturing humans for religious sacrifice, to dispose of political rivals within empire, aquire land and resources, and as form of training for aztec warriors
likely some combination and reasoning could have changed over time as wars continued
some larger debate about which wars constitute the Flower Wars
11/5
content and context
source J
Isaac suggests that the reason the flower wars occured are not only because of religion.
Source K
image shows person being sacrificed to sun god at a temple
king on left side
his body parts are demolished and being rolled down the temple, bloody
warriors with shields? and weapons.
there is fire signaling a ceremony
the king is watching all the harm happen
at the bottom there are half spheres inferring the tributes are being held there before being killed, guy in one has blood spilling out mouth
simbolic head floating, godly like
snakes at bottom of temple, to almost eat at the remains
the “servants” are carrying stuff on their backs?
question: the elements suggest the practice was very religious like and brutal.
Source L
2 figures, one with a bird costume (eagle) and the other with what seems to be a jaguar costume. I think the appearance is intended to reflect their behaviors being animal like- almost savage
The warriors being animals showed how people took a lot of control over them and how they were lower on the heirarchy scale
Source M
aztecs used the natural resources- wood, stone, obsidian, cotton, cactus fibers, and some of the weapons seem to have developed from hunting, such as slings and spears, then using animal parts (sinew) to make more weapons
weapons and armor/outfit for warriors signified social class of warriors
no author or reliable background, not great context for source
HW question
The perspectives are used to understand the purpose of aztec warfare because the context of the authors are taken into account for how reliable the information is. For example, in source M, it is not stated that it is an academic source, additionally there is no author, which shows ambiguity and that we do not know who it is or if they are telling the true. Also, those who are professors are more likely to give reliable information. Also, even if the author is not given for some sources, if they are images there is no interpretation of the author since most likely it is a primary source. This allows the viewers to interpret the sources in their own contexts instead of the information being filtered from the author.
11/6
estevez 144-150
Moctezuma l was the second Aztec emperor
he was the “great speaker” from 1440-1466
reforms set how the society works
aztec empire expanded due to the resources and flow of them, as well as training warriors from early age making military good
Moctezuma mainly was able to help the aztecs expand because of the increase in military forces, pushed expansion campaigns
shifting religious focused to god of war/sun
expansion increased wealth, has more access to different resources
allocated money to triple alliance
governing system had to be reformed as wealth increased
Tenochtitlan provided wealth, political stability, and people as tributes +TRADE
tribute system: 2/5 shares and 1/5 share syste, entire gov beauracracy around collecting, distributing
placed many supporters into positions of power as he designed administrative strcture: supreme advisor, counselors
11/12
estevez 164-170: in text questions 165,167,170
agricultural innovations
The mexica did not practice agriculture, mainly hunter gatherers
nomadic before migrating to central mexican basin, then settled and started agriculture
the aztecs grew these species of crops: maize field, milpa, all grown on chinampas
Terrace: form of agricultural innovation which changed the land
types of terraces: metepantle- low earthen ridges with maguey plants, contour- built along curves of hills using stone walls to collect soil for planting and to hold gardens and houses, and cross-channel- stone walls built across streams of ravines to grow large
domesticated animals: turkeys and dogs
lots of the aztecs farmed full time
agriculture tools were made out of: wood, stone, obsidian to make digging sticks, hoes, and hand held blades, and transported materials with woven baskets
Sources C+D
terracing is useful to stabilize the earth in agricultural ways, kind of took over the basins and hills
sloping and northern portions were covered with complex terracing systems by 1519
very little innovation occured to help labor become more efficient, but human labor was still mainly used
terracing itself was a form of innovation, which they used a lot in many aspects of land and their techniques were used a lot when it rained, very advanced. However source D mentions how human labor was still widely used to irrigate and very traditional technology was used for some aspects of labor.
crops
seeds of crops planted into holes of the soil
“three sisters” method, planted seeds of all maize bean and squash together, all contributed something to benefit each other
created corn meal
maize was very important and used throughout for many different uses: its nutritious, versitile, adaptable, easy to dry and store’, also used for religious ceremonies connected to a goddess
cacao beans were luxury, used as curencey due to value
plants + natrual resources for medicine- tomatoes for digestion, salt and honey for wounds
other
animals were food but represented beliefs in the religion, some seen as divine- especially birds since they could fly
11/13
169 in text question HW shareout: how does source help us understand how aztecs adapted to env
terraces- hilly terrain in mexican basin was adapted to, carved into, created more farmland
also used stone wall terraces in swampy/watery areas to trap slit and slowly create new farmland
plentiful food (most of the time), variety of dishes, banquet
variety of plants and nutrient rich ones, maize
variety of animals for meat- fishing, hunting, some domesticated animals, turkeys and dogs