strat 392 1/20

Porters Five Forces

  • Whole Foods proposed acquisition of Wild Oats Markets.

    • Government expressed concerns about potential monopolistic status.

    • Whole Foods' argument: multitude of supermarkets exist in the U.S.

    • Government's classification:

    • Category: natural and organic foods.

    • Potential near-monopoly in natural and organic foods.

    • If classified as supermarkets, Whole Foods would not dominate.

  • Resolution: Acquisition allowed with conditions.

    • Required to divest some stores to prevent geographic monopoly.

  • Key Concepts:

    • Industry classification influences competition and perceived market power.

    • Importance of geographic market analysis in industry structure evaluation.

Case Study: Sabre's Lawsuit by U.S. Government

  • Background of Sabre:

    • Reservation system for airline tickets.

    • Legal scrutiny regarding price gouging on specific routes.

  • Sabre's Defense:

    • Claims broad competition in the airline industry.

  • Government’s Argument:

    • Analysis based on city pairs.

    • Sabre may hold excessive market share on certain routes, enabling anti-competitive pricing.

Industry Definition and Analysis

  • Importance of precise industry definition for evaluating attractiveness:

    • Broader vs. narrower definitions can yield different insights.

    • Essential for investment decisions at high financial stakes.

  • Industries have variable profitability:

    • Airlines: predominantly unprofitable.

    • Security brokers, software, and soft drinks: historically profitable sectors.

Michael Porter's Five Forces Model

  • Introduction and relevance:

    • Porter's framework analyzes industry competition and profitability.

    • Not original to Porter; he popularized it and named it after himself.

  • Industries exhibit different profit margins:

    • Negative returns in sectors like tires and some tech sectors.

    • Average net returns across U.S. industries: approximately 8.71%, weighted: 10%.

  • Key to determine industry attractiveness:

    • Industries yielding over 10%: attractive.

    • Industries yielding below 8.71%: unattractive.

Understanding Porter's Five Forces

  1. Threat of New Entrants

    • Key metrics: entry barriers.

    • Example of high barrier: tobacco industry due to heavy government regulation.

      • Monopolistic profits preserved by entry barriers.

    • Low entry barriers indicated by ease of starting a business.

    • Example Inquiry: How feasible is it for an average person to start a pizza vs. aircraft manufacturing business?

  2. Bargaining Power of Buyers

    • Analyzed through product demand, buyer concentration, and switching costs.

    • Case Study: Individual supplier selling baby ointment to major retailer (i.e., Sam's Club) illustrates vulnerability due to single buyer dependency.

    • Price elasticity of demand: essential in determining bargaining leverage.

    • High switching costs equate to lower buyer power.

  3. Bargaining Power of Suppliers

    • Variable based on market supply diversity.

    • Example: Suppliers in competitive markets versus unique suppliers with proprietary goods.

    • Branding can decommoditize products, enhancing supplier negotiating strength.

  4. Threat of Substitutes

    • Importance of awareness of substitutes and their availability.

    • The ability of customers to shift to alternatives influences pricing power.

  5. Industry Rivalry

    • Indicators of high rivalry: similar pricing strategies, marketing efforts.

    • Industry growth reduces rivalry, while stagnant or declining sectors increase competition