ANCIENTS AND MODERNS
How was antiquity approached - In the 17th and 18th century?
RESTORATION PROCESS- preserved, creation time, ministry of culture (can't modify everything), considering technology, recreating the past decorations on the building (either restoring to the original or completely changing)
Turning into a museum (charity) or for personal use
Landscape with Roman Ruins- Rome under the Pope. How to preserve Rome? You can preserve the past if you know the past, there is a need of preservation
One way is knowing what you have- creating a geography, panorama to know what you need to preserve (the drawing Raphael was asked to do)
The pope did not allow the use of marbles, stones of different quality amd colour to construct new churches
Series of steps of reflection, consciousness that things need to be preserved + also many contradictions
16th century: Initial attraction to huge buildings (like the pantheon), but then understanding you need to preserve even the things that stand on the ground (like sculptures etc) 16th century slide
17th century: A person (sforza) working for the pope included many things that needed preservation (a long list)
18th century: Grand Tours- looking at ancient art, people, European culture in a trip around Europe for many young men. The people (grand tourists) were in a way taking many things from their cultures, which the popes were against – protection
Establishments of museums– bringing back materials that were stolen, bringing them back into the collection MUSEUMS FOR ANTIQUITIES (understanding the need of preserving cultural heritage)
Why should popes care about pagan ancient roman things? It is still power, represents the empire’s importance through roman antiquities (trying to keep up with other european countries)
↓
Fragments
Ruins
The pantheon is WELL PRESERVED, neither fragments nor ruins. But why?
A pope (Boniface) decided to turn it into a church in the 17th century. By turning into a new object but continuing its use, is why we can still see it so preserved today.
The pantheon has a very long life- they remain while people pass
Maerten van Heemskerck
Bases of columns. Inscribing a perfect circle- attractiveness of the building in the renaissance
This building did not match the rules they were trying to make for antiquity – artists try to correct the mistakes
White on a white, a solid on a solid. No continuity → making the verticality that was strived for
The renaissance were trying to correct antiquity (it was imperfect to them)
Copying or bringing elements into new creations still
17th and 18th centuries
Palladio did not study the real building that was corrected in italy
Bernini was not criticizing, but saying that the first part of the building not matching the other creates rhythm and dynamic → the present changes the way one views the past (understanding the past depends on what happened in the present)
The degotetz- measures the whole building
Carlo fontana- working in the academy of rome. Tried to approach the building historically. Not trying to correct it or measure it, but create a history of the pantheon ( also did with the colosseum)
Comparing the ancient with the modern
Noticing the difference between the old and the new (terra piazza the pietra)
Ass’s ears- BOLD intervention into a building that is so old and historical
Bronze for artillery – baldacchino
barberini????
Barberini symbol is a bee- restored in their way
Everybody who intervened also put their “signature” on the building
At the time the building had homes attached to it, underground– first intervention was to liberate it from the other structures, reassembling the marketplace around, liberating the ground in order to see all the columns
Restoration in the 18th century– the attic was very much recreated, only A SMALL PART IS REPLICATING WHAT IT ORIGINALLY LOOKED LIKE (because there was a bold intervention)
Piranesi– postcard for the people, the same building is very dramatized (light and darkness, perspective, people are tiny and building us overly huge), manipulating the power of architecture and its greatness
POWER OF ARCHITECTS- not only one of painters, but also have a conception of the building thinking spatially. An architect can imagine the whole unity as something one could never capture
at first they were only preserving the things that may fall down and included things like sculptures into their lists of preservation
the cardinol (working for the pope)— established punishments for people who were taking a very large range of artistic objects (17th c)
in the 18th century EXPANDING PRESERVATION EVEN MORE, because of grand tours — travels through europe taken as part of their education.
the emergence of museums — stealing monuments
rome was losing is relevance — the pope started trying to preserve as much as he could in order to keep people interested in this region. visiting for the antiquities.
pantheon
CREATE A SUMMARY OF THE TEXTS!!
in the 18th century the pope dedicated the pantheon to virgin mary and turned it into a church
what is amazing about buildings is that they have a longer history than the people who built them and than the people who use them for a certain purpose at a time