Media Policy

Media Policy

Social Media

Regulation

  • Regulation: Restrictions on Companies or individuals, usually to improve a certain societal process

  • Example: Speed limits on highways

  • Media Regulation: Restrictions on media production, ownership, and proliferation aimed at media companies

  • Example: California enacts new curbs on social media for children

Policy

  • Policy: Refers to a specific plan of action with specific goals for enacting regulation

  • Example: Taxing the rich, tax cuts, restricted immigration

  • How Joe Biden and Donald Trump’s border policies compare

  • Media Policy: Refers to policies that specifically regulate the media and communication

  • Example: Pro-corporate, Anti-trust

  • Restoring America’s Leadership in Wireless

Types of Regulation

State Regulation

  • Regulation imposed by “The State” or a sanctioned governing body

  • Can be local or federal

  • Copyright law

  • A series of regulations that allow individuals or corporations to own an “original creative work”

Self Regulation

  • Industries often regulate themselves for business reasons

  • It may be in their best interest to limit 

  • Comic Code Authority

  • Established in 1954 under threat of government regulation

  • Allowed the comic industry to regulate itself

  • “The comic-book medium, having come of age on the American cultural scene,  must measure up to its responsibilities”

  • The Comic Code Controversy: Stan Lee interview

  • He was asked to do an Anit-drug comic by a branch of the federal government

  • Said he wasn’t allowed to because its promoting drugs even though he wasn’t (wouldn’t get seal approval)

  • He published it anyways

  • New York Times featured it (which would make other papers write on it)

  • Papers would have headlines saying things like “Marvel’s drug comic sparks controversy”

Deregulation

  • Policy that removes regulation and rules

  • Telecommunications Act of 1996: Reduced the restrictions on ownership for media companies

  • We are still living in a largely deregulatory act

Media Regulation and Policy in Action

Video

  • State Regulation (Public Notice- talk shows are motivated by …)

  • CBS lawyers said that James T could not be on the talk show

  • Regulatory body/state in this scenario would be FCC chairmen

  • Self-regulation- They chose to take the interview down (CBS)

State v. Private Media

  • Equal Time Rule: 

  • A piece of regulation that states that broadcast stations must provide similar opportunities to competing political candidates to broadcast their messages

  • Last time we saw this really applied was 2016 SNL skit with Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump

  • Radio Act of 1927: 

  • Established a set of regulations that led to the rise of broadcast radio networks

  • Established the FRC (Federal Radio Commision)

Complicating Media Regulation

  • Regulatory Vagueness

  • Media regulation tends to be vague

  • Rarely targets actual content

  • Mainly targets institutions and structures that distribute content

  • It is harder to regulate media than other spaces like highways because you could violate the first amendment

  • Petition

  • Religion

  • Speech

  • Press

  • First Amendment Protections video- They couldn't limit what people are saying, they could only limit the structure 

Private Controlled Media

  • Media systems controlled by individual citizens and corporations

  • Funding comes from direct subscriptions of advertising dollars

  • The United States factors this model

  • NBC, CBS, ABC, Twitter

  • Government can’t control your speech, but they can control private companies which can then control yours

State Run System

  • Other countries have a state-run system

  • Media that is funded and controlled by government officials 

  • BBC, CBC

  • Funding based on taxpayer dollars rather than on advertising

  • Content is managed by the state

The US Commercial System

  • Advantages

  • Allowed the government limited control

  • Allowed a wider range of popular media and content that changed with public tastes

  • Gives the appearance of public choice and free-speach protection

  • Disadvantages

  • Allowed or limited government intervention

  • Limited and programming that was not considered "mainstream"

  • Preferences corporate desires over public needs

  • Did drug companies spend $10 billion on consumer advertising in 2024, making up nearly 25% of evening add minutes

Regulating Media

  • The government has limited control over the airwaves

  • Herbert Hoover (then Secretary of Commerce) deemed the airwaves to be public

  • No company can ever own them

  • Instead they are licensed for a fee to various private entities to be used “in the public interest”

  • FCC

  • Federal (Radio) Communication Established (1927, 1934)

  • FCC Established to regulate communication systems

  • New Chairmen, Brendan Carr

  • Worked as an attorney in communications law

  • Has worked for the FCC since 2017

  • Has shown a policy of more direct aggression towards partisan politics on broadcast programming

  • Corporation for Public Broadcasting

  • The U.S. Government set this up to have something besides private systems

  • Funding that congress allots in the national budget for public broadcasting stations

  • PBS was called on to bring "excellence and diversity” to the airwaves

Defining the Public Interest

  1. He wants more funding for his cartoons

  2. They can't tell studios what to produce, but they control how much money goes to each one

  3. He is advocating for children's education and mental well being which would be considered an interest of the public

  4. Something that benefits a large majority of the public

Media Policy in Practice

TikTok and AI

  • The US has a primarily commercial system run by private companies

  • State vs privately run media systems

  • FCC: mostly controls the distribution of licenses to local TV affiliates

Warnings, Stern Looks

  • Government tends to encourage media self-regulation through indirect measures:

  • Public hearings on matters of concern in the media industries

  • Public statements that suggest more aggressive policies

  • Through Trade regulation and antitrust legislation (Managed by the FTC)

Internet Regulation

  • The internet was determined to have more First Amendment protections than broadcasting

  • Not seen as a limited resource

  • Domain names are regulated by a coalition of international non-profits and international governing bodies

  • Protecting borders becomes complicated

Creation and Early History of TikTok

  • TikTok known as Douyin in China was launched by ByteDance in September 2016

  • Chinese based media company

  • 2017 Musically Merger

Significant Moments in TikTok's Growth

  • Global Expansion

  • TikTok quickly gained popularity worldwide, becoming one of the most downloaded apps globally by 2020

  • U.S. Popularity

  • Old Town Road blows up

  • TikTok and National Concerns

  • 2019 Federal Investigation (Charged with violating child-privacy laws. Settled with government out of court)

  • Accusations of Censorship (Journalists report platform censors content critical of the Chinese government)

  • Military Ban (Military and Pentagon officials are told to delete apps from phones)

  • Federal Pressure (President Trump threatens ban and pushes for American acquisition)

  • American Executives: TikTok hires former Disney executive as CEO

  • New Rules: TikTok announces new rules to deter the spread of coral hoxes and eating disorders

  • Congressional Appearance: TikTok executives appear before congress for several hours of questions

TikTok Legislation

  • 2024 TikTok Bill

  • A bill to ban TikTok of force its sale to a U.S. company gathers steam in Congress

  • Passes COngress and Senate with bipartisan support

  • Lawsuit Filed

  • Supreme Court upholds ban

  • President Elect Trump urges the attorney general not to uphold the law

TikTok Conversation