Week 14 Money, Banking, & the Financial System Pt 2

Emergence of Money from a Barter Economy

Overview

  • The lecture focuses on the evolution from a barter economy to a money economy, posing the fundamental question: How did money come to exist out of a barter economy?

The Barter Economy

  • Definition: A barter economy is characterized by the absence of money.

    • Despite the absence of money, trading still occurs through exchanges.

    • Types of trades in a barter economy:

    • Goods for Goods: Example, exchanging an apple for an orange.

    • Services for Services: Example, trading a haircut for house cleaning.

    • Goods for Services: Example, offering a bushel of peaches in return for cleaning services.

Condition for Trade

  • Double Coincidence of Wants: This condition must be satisfied for a trade to occur between two individuals.

    • Explanation: Two parties must each want what the other has and be willing to exchange their goods or services.

    • Example Scenario:

      • Individual A wants oranges and has apples.

      • Individual B wants apples and has oranges.

      • A and B have a double coincidence of wants:

      • A trades apples for oranges.

      • B trades oranges for apples.

Challenges in Barter Economy

  • The barter system is time-consuming:

    • Individual A struggles to find suitable trading partners.

    • Scenario Example:

    • A meets B, who does not want apples.

    • B prefers bread instead. A thus needs to search elsewhere.

    • Encountering C yields similar results with A seeking a different good.

    • After multiple unsuccessful trades, A finally completes a transaction with D and returns to C to fulfill their original need.

  • Observation: The need for a double coincidence of wants complicates and lengthens the trading process.

Motivation for Change

  • Individuals in a barter economy seek to reduce the time spent on exchanges due to self-interest:

    • Time spent trading leads to inefficiencies.

    • Example of self-interest: A aims to decrease three hours of trading to one hour.

Emergence of Money

  • The notion of certain goods having higher acceptance rates arises as individuals seek ways to facilitate easier trade.

    • Acceptance Rate: Some goods are more widely accepted than others (e.g., Good G has a higher acceptance rate).

    • Components of acceptance rates for goods in the economy:

      • A: 1 out of 10

      • B: 2 out of 10

      • C: 3 out of 10

      • D: 1 out of 10

      • E: 1 out of 10

      • F: 2 out of 10

      • G: 4 out of 10

  • As acceptance rates for G rise, more individuals begin accepting it, leading to:

    • A bandwagon effect, further increasing the number of transactions involving G.

  • Definition of Money: Once a good is widely accepted for exchange and repayment of debt, it is considered money.

Benefits of Money

  • Time Efficiency: Money reduces the time wasted in trading, as individuals trade money for goods instead of seeking direct exchanges.

    • In a time-efficient scenario, A would go to the store and directly purchase oranges with money.

  • Comparison of Time Spent:

    • Time spent in a barter economy: 10 hours per week.

    • Time spent in a money economy: 1 hour per week.

    • Resulting freed-up time: 9 hours, which can be used for increasing productivity or leisure activities.

Money, Currency, and Money Supply

  • Definition of Money: More than just currency; it encompasses all forms accepted for exchange and debt repayment.

  • M1 Money Supply: Components defining the monetary supply, including:

    • Currency Held Outside Banks: This includes coins and paper money (Federal Reserve notes).

    • Checkable Deposits: Refers to balances in checking accounts (e.g., $3,000 in A's account).

    • Traveler's Checks: Denominated checks meant for travelers.

    • Calculation Example:

    • Currency: $100,000,000

    • Checkable Deposits: $200,000,000

    • Traveler's Checks: $5,000,000

    • M1 Money Supply = $100,000,000 + $200,000,000 + $5,000,000 = $305,000,000

Are Credit Cards Money?

  • Credit cards are not considered money despite their acceptance in transactions.

    • Explanation: They represent a line of credit but must be paid off with money.

    • Example Scenario: When using a credit card, the purchaser incurs a debt that must later be settled with cash or check from their account.

  • Distinction: While transactions can occur with credit cards, the actual payment or settlement of debt needs to happen through money (M1).

Summary

  • Transitioning from barter to a money economy arises from the need to reduce time in trading through high-acceptance goods.

  • Money is defined as any good widely accepted in trade and debt repayment.

  • The movement towards a money economy emerges from self-interest, not from a goal to create a monetary system.

  • Benefits of money emphasize efficiency in trade and increased opportunities for productivity and leisure.

  • Components of M1 Money Supply include currency, checkable deposits, and traveler's checks, distinguishing it plainly from instruments like credit cards which cannot serve as money directly.