5.4 — Location Analysis

PART A: INTRODUCTION TO LOCATION DECISIONS

Definition

Location refers to the geographic site where a business chooses to establish its operations — including production facilities, offices, warehouses, and retail outlets.


Why Location Matters

Reason

Explanation

Costs

Location affects rent, labour, transport, and tax costs

Revenue

Proximity to customers affects sales

Competitiveness

Location can provide strategic advantage

Long-term commitment

Difficult and expensive to relocate

Stakeholder access

Access to suppliers, labour, customers

Operations efficiency

Affects supply chain and distribution

Brand image

Prestigious locations enhance image


Types of Location Decisions

Decision

Description

New business location

Where to establish a startup

Expansion location

Where to open additional facilities

Relocation

Moving existing operations to a new site

International location

Expanding to other countries

Multi-site decisions

Managing multiple locations


PART B: FACTORS INFLUENCING LOCATION

Overview

Location decisions involve balancing multiple factors. The relative importance depends on the industry, business type, and strategy.


Cost Factors


1. Land and Premises

Consideration

Explanation

Purchase price

Cost to buy land/property

Rent

Ongoing lease costs

Size

Space required for operations

Availability

Whether suitable sites exist

Expansion potential

Room to grow

Condition

Ready to use or needs renovation

Variation: Urban centres are expensive; rural and peripheral areas are cheaper.


2. Labour Costs

Consideration

Explanation

Wage rates

Prevailing pay levels in area

Labour availability

Pool of potential workers

Skills

Match between local skills and business needs

Productivity

Output per worker varies by region

Labour relations

Unionisation, industrial relations history

Variation: Wages vary significantly between regions and countries.


3. Transport and Distribution

Consideration

Explanation

Proximity to customers

Reduces delivery costs and time

Proximity to suppliers

Reduces inbound transport costs

Infrastructure

Roads, railways, ports, airports

Transport costs

Fuel, vehicles, logistics

Accessibility

Ease of access for deliveries


4. Utilities and Operating Costs

Consideration

Explanation

Energy costs

Electricity, gas, water

Telecommunications

Internet, phone connectivity

Business rates

Local taxes on business premises

Insurance

May vary by location


Revenue Factors


1. Proximity to Market

Consideration

Explanation

Customer access

Convenience for customers

Delivery speed

Faster service to customers

Market size

Population, purchasing power

Competition

Presence of competitors

Visibility

Exposure to passing traffic

Critical for: Retail, hospitality, personal services.


2. Footfall and Visibility

Consideration

Explanation

Pedestrian traffic

Number of people passing

Visibility

How easily the business can be seen

Parking

Availability and convenience

Neighbouring businesses

Complementary or competing?

Anchor tenants

Major retailers that attract traffic


Infrastructure and Resources


1. Physical Infrastructure

Factor

Examples

Transport links

Motorways, railways, airports, ports

Utilities

Power, water, gas, broadband

Buildings

Quality and availability of premises

Technology

Digital infrastructure


2. Human Resources

Factor

Considerations

Labour pool

Size of available workforce

Skills

Technical, professional, managerial

Education

Quality of local schools, universities

Training

Availability of training providers

Unemployment

Higher unemployment = easier recruitment


3. Supply Chain

Factor

Explanation

Supplier proximity

Closer = lower costs, faster delivery

Clustering

Related businesses located together

Raw materials

Access to natural resources

Components

Access to manufactured inputs


Legal and Political Factors


1. Government Incentives

Incentive

Examples

Grants

Cash grants for locating in certain areas

Tax relief

Reduced taxes in enterprise zones

Subsidies

Support for training, infrastructure

Free trade zones

Reduced customs duties

Planning permission

Easier approval in development areas

Purpose: Governments use incentives to attract businesses to areas needing economic development.


2. Regulations

Regulation

Impact

Planning laws

Control what can be built where

Environmental regulations

Restrictions on pollution, land use

Labour laws

Employment regulations vary by location

Health and safety

Compliance requirements

Building codes

Construction standards


3. Political Stability

Factor

Explanation

Government stability

Risk of policy changes

Corruption

Adds costs and uncertainty

Rule of law

Protection of property and contracts

Trade policy

Tariffs, trade agreements

Critical for: International location decisions.


Qualitative Factors


1. Quality of Life

Factor

Explanation

Housing

Availability and affordability

Schools

Quality of education

Healthcare

Medical facilities

Culture

Entertainment, dining, arts

Environment

Climate, natural surroundings

Safety

Crime rates, security

Why it matters: Affects ability to attract and retain talented employees.


2. Business Environment

Factor

Explanation

Clustering

Benefits of being near similar businesses

Networks

Business associations, support services

Innovation

Proximity to research, universities

Entrepreneurial culture

Support for startups


3. Historical and Personal Factors

Factor

Explanation

Existing presence

Already have operations there

Owner's preference

Personal ties to location

Historical location

"We've always been here"

Inertia

Resistance to change


Summary: Location Factors by Business Type

Business Type

Primary Location Factors

Manufacturing

Labour costs, transport, land availability, suppliers

Retail

Footfall, visibility, parking, competition

Services

Customer proximity, labour skills, prestige

Logistics

Transport infrastructure, central location

Technology

Skilled labour, clusters, quality of life

Agriculture

Climate, soil, water, land costs

Extraction

Location of natural resources


PART C: LOCATION STRATEGIES

Types of Location Strategy


1. Cost Minimisation

Focus: Locate where costs are lowest.

Approach

Example

Low-wage locations

Manufacturing in developing countries

Tax-efficient locations

Corporate headquarters in low-tax jurisdictions

Cheap land

Distribution centres in rural areas

Government incentives

Enterprise zones, grants


2. Revenue Maximisation

Focus: Locate where sales potential is highest.

Approach

Example

High footfall

Retail in shopping centres

Customer proximity

Services near target market

Prestige locations

Luxury brands in premium areas

Growth markets

Expanding into emerging economies


3. Resource Access

Focus: Locate near essential inputs.

Approach

Example

Raw materials

Mining, agriculture near resources

Skilled labour

Tech companies in Silicon Valley

Suppliers

Manufacturing near component suppliers

Knowledge

Near universities, research centres


4. Strategic Positioning

Focus: Locate for competitive advantage.

Approach

Example

First-mover

Establish presence before competitors

Clustering

Join industry clusters for agglomeration benefits

Diversification

Spread risk across multiple locations

Market coverage

Network of locations for full coverage


Clustering and Agglomeration

Definition: Clustering occurs when related businesses locate near each other, creating mutual benefits.


Examples of Clusters

Cluster

Location

Industries

Silicon Valley

California, USA

Technology, venture capital

Wall Street

New York, USA

Finance, banking

Hollywood

Los Angeles, USA

Film, entertainment

Motorsport Valley

Oxfordshire, UK

Formula 1, automotive

Fashion District

Milan, Italy

Fashion, design

Bangalore

India

IT services, software


Benefits of Clustering

Benefit

Explanation

Labour pool

Shared pool of skilled workers

Knowledge spillovers

Ideas spread between firms

Supplier networks

Specialised suppliers nearby

Infrastructure

Shared facilities and services

Reputation

Location signals quality

Collaboration

Opportunities for partnerships

Competition

Drives innovation and improvement


Drawbacks of Clustering

Drawback

Explanation

Higher costs

Demand pushes up rents, wages

Competition for labour

Poaching, wage inflation

Congestion

Traffic, overcrowding

Over-dependence

Risk if cluster declines

Homogeneity

May limit diverse thinking


PART D: INTERNATIONAL LOCATION

Why Locate Internationally?

Reason

Explanation

Market access

Closer to customers in other countries

Cost reduction

Lower labour, land, or tax costs

Resource access

Raw materials, skilled labour

Trade barriers

Avoid tariffs by producing locally

Diversification

Spread risk across markets

Government incentives

Attract foreign investment

Competitive response

Follow or preempt competitors

Exchange rates

Benefit from currency movements


Considerations for International Location

Factor

Considerations

Political risk

Stability, government policies

Legal system

Contract enforcement, property rights

Cultural differences

Language, business practices

Infrastructure

Transport, utilities, technology

Labour

Availability, skills, costs, regulations

Exchange rates

Currency risk

Tax

Corporate tax rates, incentives

Trade agreements

Tariffs, free trade zones

Repatriation

Ability to move profits out


Methods of International Expansion

Method

Description

Control

Risk

Exporting

Sell from home country

High

Low

Licensing

Allow local firm to produce

Low

Low

Franchising

License brand and system

Medium

Medium

Joint venture

Partner with local firm

Shared

Shared

Foreign direct investment

Build/buy own operations

High

High


Offshoring vs Outsourcing

Concept

Definition

Example

Offshoring

Moving operations to another country (in-house)

Building factory in Vietnam

Outsourcing

Contracting work to external provider

Using external call centre

Offshore outsourcing

Outsourcing to provider in another country

IT services from India


Benefits of Offshoring

Benefit

Explanation

Cost savings

Lower wages, land costs

24/7 operations

Time zone differences enable round-the-clock work

Market access

Presence in growing markets

Skills access

Tap into global talent

Tax advantages

Lower corporate taxes


Risks of Offshoring

Risk

Explanation

Quality control

Harder to maintain standards at distance

Communication

Language, cultural barriers

Coordination

Managing across time zones

Political risk

Instability in host country

Intellectual property

Risk of IP theft

Supply chain risk

Longer, more complex supply chains

Reputation

Criticism for moving jobs overseas

Hidden costs

Travel, training, management time


Reshoring

Definition: Bringing operations back to the home country after previously offshoring.


Reasons for Reshoring

Reason

Explanation

Rising overseas costs

Wages increasing in developing countries

Quality issues

Better control at home

Supply chain resilience

COVID-19 highlighted vulnerabilities

Automation

Technology reduces labour cost advantage

Speed to market

Faster response to demand

Customer preference

"Made in [home country]" appeal

Government incentives

Support for domestic manufacturing

Transport costs

Rising shipping costs

Sustainability

Shorter supply chains reduce carbon footprint


PART E: METHODS OF LOCATION ANALYSIS

1. Qualitative Analysis

Approach: Consider non-quantifiable factors through discussion, evaluation, and judgement.

Method

Description

Factor rating

Score locations against key criteria

Checklist

Ensure all factors considered

Stakeholder input

Gather views from different parties

Site visits

Physical inspection of potential sites

Expert opinion

Consult specialists


2. Quantitative Analysis

Approach: Use numerical methods to compare locations objectively.


Factor Rating Method

Step

Action

1

Identify relevant location factors

2

Assign weight to each factor (total = 100%)

3

Score each location on each factor (e.g., 1-10)

4

Multiply weight × score for each factor

5

Sum weighted scores for each location

6

Select location with highest total score


Example: Factor Rating Method

Factor

Weight

Location A Score

Location A Weighted

Location B Score

Location B Weighted

Labour cost

0.25

8

2.00

6

1.50

Transport links

0.20

7

1.40

9

1.80

Market proximity

0.30

6

1.80

8

2.40

Labour skills

0.15

7

1.05

5

0.75

Quality of life

0.10

8

0.80

6

0.60

Total

1.00


7.05


7.05

Result: Scores are equal; decision requires further analysis or consideration of other factors.


Break-Even Location Analysis

Compare total costs at different locations to find where each is most cost-effective.

Total Cost=Fixed Costs+(Variable Cost×Quantity)Total\ Cost = Fixed\ Costs + (Variable\ Cost \times Quantity)

Location

Fixed Costs

Variable Cost/Unit

Best When

A

Low

High

Low volume

B

High

Low

High volume

Cross-over point: The output level where total costs are equal.

Qcrossover=FCB−FCAVCA−VCBQ_{crossover} = \frac{FC_B - FC_A}{VC_A - VC_B}


Example: Break-Even Location Analysis


Location A

Location B

Fixed Costs

$100,000

$200,000

Variable Cost/Unit

$50

$30

Cross-over point:

Q=200,000−100,00050−30=100,00020=5,000 unitsQ = \frac{200,000 - 100,000}{50 - 30} = \frac{100,000}{20} = 5,000\ units

Interpretation:

  • Below 5,000 units: Location A is cheaper

  • Above 5,000 units: Location B is cheaper

  • At 5,000 units: Both cost the same ($350,000)


Centre of Gravity Method

Purpose: Find the optimal location to minimise transport costs based on the locations of customers or suppliers.

Formula:

X=∑(xi×Wi)∑WiX = \frac{\sum (x_i \times W_i)}{\sum W_i}

Y=∑(yi×Wi)∑WiY = \frac{\sum (y_i \times W_i)}{\sum W_i}

Where:

  • xix_i, yiy_i = coordinates of each location

  • WiW_i = weight (volume, importance) of each location

Result: Coordinates of optimal central location.


3. Investment Appraisal

Apply investment appraisal techniques to location decisions:

Method

Application

Payback

How quickly will location investment be recovered?

ARR

What average return will the location generate?

NPV

What is the net present value of locating here?


PART F: LOCATION IN THE DIGITAL AGE

Impact of Technology on Location

Factor

Impact

E-commerce

Physical retail location less critical

Remote working

Offices less essential

Cloud computing

Less need for on-site data centres

Video conferencing

Reduces need for travel, central offices

Automation

Reduces labour cost importance

3D printing

May enable local production

Delivery services

Enable distribution from anywhere


Virtual Locations

Concept

Description

Online presence

Website as primary customer interface

Virtual offices

Professional address without physical space

Remote teams

Employees work from anywhere

Cloud services

Infrastructure in the cloud

Digital nomads

Location-independent workers


Omnichannel Considerations

For businesses with both physical and digital presence:

Factor

Consideration

Click and collect

Need pickup locations

Returns

Where can customers return items?

Showrooming

Physical stores for viewing; buy online

Last-mile delivery

Distribution for quick delivery

Customer service

Balance online and in-person


PART G: EXAM APPLICATION

Potential Exam Questions

  1. "Analyse the factors a retail business should consider when choosing a new store location." (10 marks)

  2. "Evaluate the benefits and risks of offshoring production to a developing country." (10 marks)

  3. "Discuss the impact of technology on location decisions for modern businesses." (10 marks)

  4. "Examine the advantages and disadvantages of locating within an industry cluster." (10 marks)

  5. "To what extent should government incentives influence location decisions?" (10 marks)

  6. "Using quantitative methods, analyse the best location for a new distribution centre." (10 marks)


Key Definitions to Memorise

Term

Definition

Location

The geographic site where a business establishes its operations

Clustering

Concentration of related businesses in a geographic area

Agglomeration

Benefits arising from firms locating near each other

Offshoring

Moving business operations to another country

Outsourcing

Contracting work to an external provider

Reshoring

Bringing operations back to the home country

Infrastructure

Basic facilities and systems (transport, utilities, communications)

Government incentives

Grants, tax relief, and subsidies to attract business investment

Footfall

Number of people walking past or entering a location


Key Formulas

Calculation

Formula

Factor Rating Total

Σ (Weight × Score) for each factor

Break-Even Crossover

(FC₂ − FC₁) ÷ (VC₁ − VC₂)

Centre of Gravity X

Σ(xᵢ × Wᵢ) ÷ Σ Wᵢ

Centre of Gravity Y

Σ(yᵢ × Wᵢ) ÷ Σ Wᵢ


Evaluation Frameworks

When discussing location factors:

  • "The most important factors depend on the type of business and its strategy..."

  • "Location decisions involve trade-offs between cost, revenue, and qualitative factors..."

  • "Short-term cost savings may be offset by long-term strategic disadvantages..."

When discussing international location:

  • "International location offers opportunities but involves significant risks..."

  • "The benefits of offshoring must be weighed against quality, control, and reputation concerns..."

  • "Recent trends toward reshoring reflect changing cost structures and supply chain risks..."

When discussing technology and location:

  • "Technology has reduced the importance of location for some businesses but not all..."

  • "Physical presence remains important for customer experience in many sectors..."

  • "Omnichannel strategies require thoughtful integration of physical and digital locations..."