Lecture #6-1 Intro to Defenses to Intentional Torts (1)
Introduction to Defenses to Intentional Torts
Focus on elements of intentional torts and how they relate to plaintiff claims.
Distinction between arguments against the sufficiency of the plaintiff's claims and true defenses.
Types of Arguments in Response to a Plaintiff's Complaint
Defendants' Options: When a plaintiff files a complaint, the defendant can:
Ignore the complaint, risking a judgment against them.
File a motion to dismiss.
File an answer to the complaint.
Motion to Dismiss
Argues that even if the plaintiff's allegations are true, there is no cause of action.
Often based on the inability of the plaintiff to meet one of the elements of the cause of action.
Answer to the Complaint
Document where the defendant either confirms or denies allegations in the complaint.
Lists defenses the defendant claims they can support later in litigation.
Historical Context of Legal Terminology
The term "privilege" in common law referred to defenses in intentional tort cases.
Be cautious: "privilege" now also refers to rights preventing the disclosure of information (e.g., Attorney-Client Privilege).
In this context, "defense" includes both intentional tort defenses and negligence defenses.
Burden of Proof
Plaintiff bears the burden of proof to establish elements of the case.
Defendant bears the burden to argue and prove elements of the defense.
Categories of Defenses
Jurisdictional Defenses
Challenge the authority of the court to hear the case.
Valid arguments lead to case dismissal due to lack of court authority.
Can be presented at any time during proceedings.
Affirmative Defenses
Must be raised as soon as the defendant has enough information regarding the issue.
If not raised in a timely manner, the defense is deemed waived and cannot be raised later.
Typically raised in the answer to the complaint.
Fundamental Concept of Defenses in Intentional Torts
Defenses (privileges) permit conduct that leads to the plaintiff’s complaint.
If the defendant's conduct is excused under the law, it results in no remedy for the plaintiff.
No claim means no recovery; if privilege applies, the cause of action is dismissed, leading to the defendant's victory.
Types of Defenses Based on Impact
Complete Defense: If successful, leads to the complete dismissal of the claim.
Partial Defense: Successful defense does not result in total dismissal but may reduce damages or liability.
Overview of Defenses Available in Intentional Torts
Various defenses will be discussed over the next few lectures.
First topic: Consent - the most important defense in intentional tort cases.