W1, L1

Semester 2 Course Introduction and General Administrative Announcements

  • Welcome and Transition: The session marks the beginning of Semester 22. Students are welcomed back and encouraged to feel refreshed for the new term.

  • Teaching Team for Term 3:

    • Tamaho: Will be leading the instruction on Aotearoa land law.

    • Sasha: Will cover movable property, shifting the focus from the immovable property (land) studied previously.

    • Guest Lecturers: In the final week of the term, practitioners will provide real-world examples on two specific topics.

  • Mid-Year Test Statistics and Grading:

    • Class Size: Over 350350 students (360360 mentioned later).

    • Grade Distribution: The average mark was approximately in the BB to B−B- range. No A+A+ grades were awarded.

    • Grading Standards: A B−B- is considered "reasonably good," a BB is "good," and a B+B+ is "very good."

    • Comparison to NCEA: The lecturers emphasize that law school grading differs from NCEA excellence standards; a BB range grade in the first year of full law papers is considered a very strong result.

    • Moderation: Results are currently being processed and moderated. End-of-semester exams for other subjects often take precedence in marking timelines.

  • Advice for Future Assessments:

    • Historically, grades tend to improve for the end-of-year exam as students adapt to legal reasoning and IRAC requirements.

    • Students are advised to digest provided feedback before seeking individual meetings with lecturers due to high student numbers.

Holistic Marking and Legal Writing Standards

  • Marking Methodology: Questions are marked holistically. Strong performance on one point can offset minor errors elsewhere.

  • The "Maths Problem" Analogy: Law is compared to mathematics in that the "workings" or reasoning must be shown. Even if a conclusion (e.g., "Anne committed fraud") is obvious, the student must provide a step-by-step legal walkthrough.

  • Statutory Application: Conclusions must be explicitly linked to specific legislation (e.g., explaining why conduct meets the definition of fraud in Section 66 of the Land Transfer Act).

  • Professional Style:

    • Answers should not be in bullet points; full sentences and persuasive paragraphs are required.

    • Legal writing must be formal and in good English.

  • Handwriting Legibility:

    • Messy writing can lead to a failure if the examiner cannot read the paper.

    • Students are advised to leave a blank line between sentences/paragraphs to improve readability under exam pressure.

Feedback for Question 1: Land Transfer Fraud and Indefeasibility

  • Scenario Recap: Noah (registered owner) is overseas. Anne (flatmate) hacks Landonline, transfers title to herself, and sells to Tamati, who registers the title. Noah returns to find Tamati in possession.

  • The IRAC Method: Students using the Issue, Rule, Application, and Conclusion method performed best.

  • Key Legal Issues: The central issue is whether Tamati acquires an indefeasible title despite purchasing from Anne, who acquired it through dishonest conduct.

  • Relevant Law:

    • Statute: Land Transfer Act (LTALTA) 20172017, specifically Sections 5151 and 5252.

    • Case Law: Frazer v Walker; Assets Co Ltd v Mere Roihi.

  • Application of Registration Principles:

    • Section 51: Grants registered owners indefeasible title.

    • Section 52: Lists fraud as an exception to indefeasibility.

    • Definition of Fraud: Section 66 of the LTALTA 20172017.

  • Conclusion for Tamati: Tamati is a bona fide purchaser for value. However, the lecturer clarifies that the primary reason he keeps the title is registration itself, not just being "bona fide." Registration is the "key to indefeasibility."

  • Remedy for Noah: Because Tamati's title is registered and he was not party to the fraud, Noah cannot get the land back. He must instead seek compensation under the LTALTA.

  • Question 1b (Mortgage Scenarios):

    • If Anne granted a mortgage to Weka Bank instead of selling to Tamati, the bank (as a bona fide mortgagee) acquires an indefeasible registered interest upon registration.

    • Case Citation: Burmester v O'Brien confirms that a registered mortgage remains on the title even if the transfer to the mortgagor involved fraud.

  • Question 1c (Return of Property):

    • Noah wants the property back. While Anne's title is defeasible (challengeable) due to her fraud, the interests of third parties (Tamati or Weka Bank) prevent a simple return.

    • Section 69 of the LTA 2017: If a victim of fraud contributed to the loss through their own carelessness (e.g., failure to seek legal advice), their compensation may be reduced.

Feedback for Question 2: Leases and Co-Ownership

  • Subject Matter: A complex problem mixing commercial leases and co-ownership dynamics between brothers (Jerry and Terry) and a third party (Donna).

  • Lease Analysis:

    • Applicable Law: The Property Law Act (PLAPLA) applies because the facts specify the property is commercial. The Residential Tenancies Act (RTARTA) is irrelevant.

    • Common Errors: Many students incorrectly applied RTARTA provisions to a commercial context.

    • Implied Covenants (PLAPLA): Includes the covenant not to alter buildings without consent, not to commit waste, to pay rent, and the lessor's duty for quiet enjoyment and non-derogation from grant.

  • Co-Ownership Analysis:

    • Default Presumption: Section 4747 of the Land Transfer Act creates a default presumption of Joint Tenancy in New Zealand.

    • Equitable Presumptions: A Tenancy in Common might be presumed if the property is partnership property or purchased with partnership assets.

    • Severance: Discussion of Burgess v Rawnsley regarding oral agreements to sever a joint tenancy.

    • Outcome Variation: Marks were awarded for the quality of the argument (Reasoning by Analogy) rather than a specific "correct" outcome between survivorship (Joint Tenancy) or passing via a will (Tenancy in Common).

Feedback for Question 3: Landlocked Land

  • Legal Focus: Potential landlocked land and the requirements for attaining reasonable access.

  • Requirement for Analysis: Students needed to analyze the four principles and four factors for determining access and any associated compensation.

  • Critical Issues Noted by Marker:

    • Time Management: Many students did not reach this question or provided only a superficial answer. This question was worth 2525 marks (25 %25\,\% of the test).

    • Lack of Application: Many students listed rules/statutes without applying them to the specific facts of the case.

    • Philosophical vs. Legal Arguments: Some students argued based on "fairness" or "justice" rather than grounding their analysis in the established law of landlocked land.

Introduction to Maori Land Law

  • Syllabus Overview: The next three weeks will cover the history of Maori land (pre and post-settlement), the Treaty of Waitangi, and the statutory framework.

  • Key Legislation: Te Ture Whenua Maori Act 1993 (also known as the Maori Land Act 1993).

  • Key Topics:

    • The Maori Land Court and its jurisdiction.

    • Maori Reserve Regulations.

    • Succession to Maori land.

    • Maori Land Trusts: A critical exam topic covering the removal of trustees, injunctions, and common legal disputes.

  • Administrative Note: A quiz on this material is due by midday on August 7.

Maori Land Tenure Pre-1840

  • Contextual Dates: The Treaty of Waitangi (18401840) and the Declaration of Independence (18351835).

  • Nature of Customary Title:

    • Prior to 18401840, all land was held under Customary Title (Aboriginal Title).

    • Underlying title in New Zealand is currently Crown Title; previously, it was all customary title.

  • Ownership via Tikanga Maori:

    • Communal Ownership (Non-Western): This does not mean a lack of individual rights. It is distinct from Western concepts of "tenants in common" or "joint tenancy."

    • Individual Rights within the Collective: While the hapū (sub-tribe) holds the underlying title, individuals/families have specific rights to gardens (e.g., kumara patches). Interference with a specific garden was a violation of property rights.

    • Responsibility and Obligation: Individual usage was balanced with an obligation to the community (e.g., planting extra to help other families if their crops failed).

  • Boundaries and Pepeha:

    • Boundaries were clearly defined and often defended through war.

    • Pepeha (Tribal Sayings): Used to define territory by invoking geographic markers.

    • Example 1: Ngati Awa boundary: "Mainga Kuria Whare Kituhiro" (from Ngakuriawhare to Tihirao).

    • Example 2: Te Arawa confederation boundary: "Mai Maketu, Kitongariro, Ko Te Arawa Te Waka" (from the Maketu Peninsula to Mount Tongariro).