Persuasion

Dual Approaches to Persuasion

The literature on persuasion suggests that there is no simple, one-solution-fits-all means of persuasion.

Instead, persuasion theorists propose that there are two basic ways of trying to persuade people, or two “routes” to persuasion

Elaboration Likelyhood Model

a model of persuasion maintaining that there are two different routes to persuasion. Created by Petty and Cassiopal

  1. the central route

    1. The route that lasts longest!

  2. the peripheral route

The Central Route

the central route to persuasion occurs when people think carefully and deliberately about the content of a persuasive message, attending to its logic and the strength of its arguments as well as to related evidence and principles.

  • Focus is on the content of the message. Central to the Argument! does not focus on celebrety endorsement, focus on the argument! LOGIC

    • How good, clean, inexpensive the water is. Not focusing on how tom cruise drinks it!

The Peripheral Route

people primarily attend to peripheral aspects of a message—relatively superficial, easy-to- process features of a persuasive communication that are tangential to the persuasive information itself (such as its length or the expertise or attractiveness of the source of the message)

  • What is the “other stuff” jingle, colors, celebrety endorsement" that persuade people

  • The expertise of the person permoting the project!

    • “The leading doctors promote this medicine for brain health”

The motivation and ability of the person impacts what rout the person will take

  • If it impacts them personally → central route

  • If it is irrelevent → peripheral route

The Roles of Motivation and Ability

What determines whether we will engage in central or peripheral processing in response to a persuasive message

  • motivation “is this important for me to pay attenetion to”

  • ability to comprehend the information

Motivation, Ability, and the Central Route to Persuasion

For persuasion to occur via the central route, we have to be both motivated and able to engage in more in-depth processing.

  • If either (or both) is lacking, persuasion generally relies on peripheral cues.

  • They must be able to comprehend and use the information meaningfully!

For long-lasting attitude change, persuasion through the central route is preferable

Example of how if it is a strong argument and personally relevent, people will believe in it!

Strong expert + not personally relevant = increase in attitude

Subliminal Advertising

The Anti-Al Gore advertising that says “RATS”

There is no research to support the idea that subliminal advertising works!

  • In terms of persuasion and chaning opinions

The Elements of Persuasion

Carl Hovland and colleagues at Yale University (1953)

  • They wanted to understand Nazi propoganda

Persuasive messages have three components:

  1. the who, or the source of the message

  2. the what, or the content of the message

  3. the whom, or the intended audience of the message

Source Characteristics

Characteristics of the person who delivers a persuasive message, such as attractiveness, credibility, and certainty

Attractiveness

Attractive spokespeople are more persuasive, even for topics completely unrelated to attractiveness.

  • Happens all the time in ads

Effects of attractiveness are through the peripheral route: attractive people are rated more favorably, and those favorable feelings become associated with the message.

  • This happens across all domains of life

  • How attractive a person is affects how positive they are viewed

  • “That person is attractive, I like what they are selling!”

Credability

People who are seen as knowledgeable and trustworthy are more persuasive.

However, noncredible sources can change attitudes through the sleeper effect:

  • an effect that occurs when a persuasive message from an unreliable source initially exerts little influence but later causes attitudes to shift

  • A study in 1951 had participants rate the likelyhood of a nuclear sumbarine being built in the near future. About 5 days later, they brought in the same participatns that a sub is being built in the next week regardless of what you said. They gave particpants one of two soruces 1. openhimer and 2. a “non-credible” journalist from a soviet propoganda journalist

    • People believed the openhimer essay. It is beleived, a massive attitude shift in that sample!

    • In the second sample with the journalist, immedatly people went “that is suspecious, I am not believing him”, so there was not a major shift, so no attitude change.

      • As time progressed, (4 weeks) there attitudes began to shift towards “i beleive the journalist”

  • Why does sleeper effect occur: People disconect the source and the message! People remember the message, but forget where it came from

Certainty

Sources who express their views with certainty and confidence tend to be more persuasive.

  • It does not mean that the message is correct! Just because someone is confident does not mean that they are correct

If your goal is to persuade someone, be sure to express lots of confidence

Message Characteristics

aspects, or content, of a persuasive message, including the quality of the evidence(In that message) and the explicitness of its conclusions (If you drink the water here is what happens)

  • Quality (data) is important

  • “97% of people who drink mercyhurst water prefer it to other brands and are more hydrated”

Catch: Only useful if the person on the receving end cares about what we are talking about!

  • “I don’t care, I drink dr. pepper”

Message Quality

High-quality messages are more persuasive in general, especially for people who are strong in motivation and ability.

More attitude change will result if the conclusions are explicit in the message

  • “Here is the take away, Here is the BLUF” It directs the people to the main piece of the information

  • Reason we use explicit of concusions becasue of “Recency bias” - if things are more recent in mind, you are more primed to use that infomration vs something that happened two weeks ago!

Vividness

When information is vivid—colorful, interesting, and memorable—it tends to be more effective.

  • Why people remember jingles

Identifiable victim effect:

  • the tendency to be more moved by the vivid plight of a single individual than by a more abstract number of people

  • Ads that say “this is Marie, she need you to get her clean water”

Fear

Fear messages contain vivid information and can be very persuasive.

  • Fear can backfire.

But fear messages are most effective when combined with instructions on how to avoid negative outcomes

  • Give secondary instructions on how to avoid the problems

  • “People will break into your homes. The only way to prevent this is buying a ring doorbell”

    • Debrief - always debrief your participants in a research study. Tell them that if they suffer from depression, here are some resources! Esentially debrieffing on how to avoid negative sideffects!

Culture

It can be important to tailor a message to fit the norms, values, and outlook of a particular cultural group.

  • Individualistics vs collectivist cultures

  • “Here is what we can do for you vs here is what we can do for your group”

Audience Characteristics

Characteristics of those who receive a persuasive message, including need for cognition, mood, age, and audience size and diversity

  • Individualistic differences of those who recieve the messages

  • Idea that it is not a one size fits all to persuasion!

Need for Cognition

drive to think deeply about judgments

  • Think critically! People who enjoy being puzzled, pondering questions

People high in need for cognition are more persuaded by central route messages than by peripheral route messages

Doesn’t need for cognition feel like “motivation and ability”?

Mood

Messages are more persuasive when they match the mood of the receiver.

  • Optimistic messages work best on happy people

  • Pessimistic messages work best on sad people

    • People can often be persuaded by guilt. This is similar to fear… but is most effective when you give people an option to eleviate this guilt

  • People learn better when their mood on recal matches their mood on learning

    • If you are learning stuff happy, then you can remember it better when you are happy

Focus on the Enviorment and the Climate Crisis

Democrats largely believe in climate change, no doubt. Here is the catch, it does not mean that republicans don’t beleive in it, they don’t beleive in it at a higher rate

If both parties both agree in climate change, then why does nothing happen to adress it?

  • One explanation is that just because both parties agree that it is happening, the republican party does not beleive it at a hgiher rate, therefore it is a party over policy issue

    • Even though they know climate change is an issue, people will align with the party even in the face of contradictory evidence. if media pushes the idea that republicans don’t believe in it, then legislators will adhere to “my party doesn’t think climate change is happening”

  • Age of the audeince is an important factor

Age

Younger people are more persuadable than older people.

  • Older people may have strong and long-held attitudes.

  • The beliefs had been held for a long time, that way the belief does not want to chagne

    • Does not mean old people are unpersuasable.

    • INDIVIDUAL DIFFERENCES is important

Children may be most vulnerable to persuasion attempts

  • They lack the abstract reasoning that older people have. This is due to brain development!

  • This is an issue when it comes to the legal system broadly. If you have a kid involved in a legal case, it is easy for lawyers/cops to persuade the child!

The Media and Persuasion

We live in a media-saturated world.

Flynn Effect - if we take IQ scores and compare it to past generations, every since IQ scores have been increasing! This generation is the first generation in which they have been lower than the past generation!

  • The exposure to technology/social media has had some effect on this generation

A 2017 report found that U.S. adults spend an average of 12 hours, 7 minutes a day consuming media.

A 2020 report found 13 hours, 21 minutes of media consumption per day for the average American

The Power of the Media

How powerful are the media in shaping our attitudes?

  • Documenting media effects on people’s attitudes is no simple task.

    • Getting a good grasp on media effects is hard because it is done in a survey manner

  • But growing evidence attest to the media’s power to influence people’s tastes, opinions, and behavior.

    • Shared Attention - If a large group of people are consuming the same media, event, political debate, etc, and everyone has access to it, people then think very deeply about that thing though the central route

    • We are all going to be thinking about politics very deeply because everyone is consuming the same media!

The Media and the Conceptions of Social Reality

Agenda control - efforts of the media to select certain events and topics to emphasize, thereby shaping which issues and events people think are important

  • “Here is what is important”

  • The idea that the media shapes what is importnat

  • There is an effort to resist persuasion, but this clearly happens

Study done in the 80s, they had 3 groups of participants. 2 groups were exposed to shows about foreign energy crisis. Then they had particpants rate how important foreign energy should be to the US. In the 3rd group no shows were given.

  • In the no TV Control, foreign energy crisis was only importnat to 24%

  • In the second condition, they were shown 3 fake shows that highlited the foreign energy crisis. 50% said it was a top 3 important

  • In the third condition. They watched 6 shows that highlited foreign energy, this number went to 65% or 2/3

Simply by altering how much media was given to the person influenced how important the topic was to them!

  • done by Kinder Know this for the Exam!

Media Representations do Not Represent Reality

Media representations do not resemble reality.

  • Males are portrayed three times more often than females.

    • In Primetime TV shows

  • Children, the elderly, racial minorities, and blue-collar and lower-income individuals are underrepresented.

    • White men control what is determined what gets on TV, they can be viewed as negativly. Since there is a bias against the groups. We adhere to the biases of the groups which then makes them underrepresented in the media

TV Consumption and Social Attitudes

Television consumption linked to social attitudes

Heavy television watchers endorse more racial and gender stereotypes, overestimate the prevalence of violence and crime, and overestimate the number of professionals in the population

  • Distortion of attitudes

  • Is it that heavy TV usage is leading to this belief, or are people who already biased in this way (racial stertotypes) consume more TV?

Perceptions of Bias in the Media

Hostile media phenomenon - the tendency for people to see media coverage as biased against their own side and in favor of their opponents’ side

  • If you are a republican, you are more likely to see media coverage as biased against your belief

  • Humans think that they understand the world in a non-biased manner. This is not the case, in reality wer are not fair in terms of our objectivity.

We generally use this fallacy, naive realism - the idea that we see the world in an objective way, even when we do not

Misinformation and the Media

The past decade or so has seen the proliferation of misinformation or “fake news.”

Misinformation can influence people to make misguided decisions about important issues.

  • If people are basing decision based on misinformation, then there will be error built into the decision

Resistance to Persuasion

Why don’t the media have a stronger effect on what we buy, who we vote for, or whether we adopt healthier habits?

The media does have an effect on everything we do!

  • There are multiple options, but are you using the information and thinking critically?

    • If you are doing your own research, whats to determine your own research is crap?

Attentional Biases and Resistance

Attentional biases and resistance

Our minds sometimes respond selectively to information in a way that maintains our initial stance

  • we tend to pay attention to information that supports our own stance on a issue


Selective Attention

People are inclined to attend selectively to information that confirms their original attitudes.

  • For instance, a study found that students who were in favor of legalizing marijuana preferred to listen to strong arguments in favor of their position and arguments against their position that were easy to refute.

Selective Evaluation

We tend to evaluate information in biased ways to support our preexisting opinion.

  • For instance, patients who receive unhealthy diagnoses are more likely to downplay the seriousness of the diagnosis and the validity of the test that produced it.

    • “I don’t beleive in the way that you got that diagnosis”

    • DITTO AND LOPEZ study in 1992


There is a 30 second difference between deficiency and non-deficiency. They gave students a medical test for a condition that is not real (did not tell them that), made up a pancreatic disorder. They had a piece of yellow paper and took your saliva on the paper.First condition: If the paper remained yellow, you had the condition. Second Condition: If the paper changed to green then you also had the condition. In both conditions, the paper was yellow and was always going to stay yellow (no paper was going to turn green). People who were in the condition that they needed the color to change, they payed attention to the test for a shorter amount of time. The condition in which the paper stayed yellow people stared at the paper for a much longer time. The Point is: They did not want the paper to confirm the condition, aka, they wanted the paper to stay yellow, so they stared at it longer!

  • The authors note that people would continue to pour saliva onto the paper in hopes that it would make it change color!

  • The Deficiency bar is people staring at the paper hoping it will change color!

Selective Framing

We tend to selectively frame issues in a manner that shines a more positive light on positions we support and a more negative light on positions we oppose.

  • For instance, proponents of abortion rights frame the issue in terms of choice (“pro-choice”), whereas opponents of abortion frame the issue in terms of life (“pro-life”).

  • You will need to make an example of this on the exam! (use abortion)

Previous Committments and Resistance

Previous commitments - social normative based

  • Attitudes tied to our social identity are more resistant to change.

    • If they are core to you they do not change easily!

  • Public commitments to certain attitudes make them resistant to change.

    • Publicly discussing or announcing an opinion will make it resistant to change because we want to keep a consistent self-concept.

      • “save face”

Thought polarization hypothesis

  • the hypothesis that more extended thought about a particular issue tends to produce a more extreme, entrenched attitude

  • If you give more thought to an issue, your attitude towards that issue will be more firm and harder to change!

  • TESSER study: Had people rate their attitudes on different social issues, ( for or against prositution). They took people’s ratings and gave them time to think about the issue. After thinking about the issue, their ratings became stronger even though it was the same question!

Knowledge and Resistance

Knowledge

  • Attitudes based on more knowledge are more resistant to change.

    • Central Route!

  • Having greater knowledge means we can offer more and better counterarguments to defend our attitude.

    • You have to have the knowledge of the issue first

Molarization of Attitudes

Attitudes backed by moral conviction can also be particularly resistant to persuasion.

  • They can also be harnessed to increase the likelihood of swaying attitudes if a position is framed in terms of the moral principles of the target audience

  • Attidues that are based in moral convictions are harder to changed because people do not want to compromise their morals!

    • Adhering to their morals!

  • If you are trying to change their moral conviction, it will be hard. Try to sidestep the moral conviction

Attitude Inoculation

Small attacks on people’s beliefs that engage their preexisting attitudes, prior commitments, and background knowledge, enabling them to counteract a subsequent larger attack and thus resist persuasion

  • Like the Flu shot! Gives you a little attack against your argument, that way when you come against a big attack, you can counteract it!

Trusim - something that you hold to be true, and it hard to counteract. EX: most people support the idea that brushing teeth after you eat is good!

Study: People looked at basic truism that most people support. Most people have an inital attitude of 13/15 (super strong)

  • Wanted to see how much people would adhere to their truism during an attack! (A guy said toothbrushing is proved to be connected to bad breath/gum disease) A large attack

  • After a very strong attack, people are thrown off and their support of the original truism is dropped by alot (7/15)

  • Third bar SUPER IMPORTANT: If you were given a small, not as well thought out attack against toothbrushing that you can easily difuse, then there was a large attack after the support for the truism had a small drop! SUPPORT FOR INOCULATION

    • The small attack allows you to prepare for a larger attack! Builds counterargumetns!

    • Will be on an exam!!!

  • Fourth Bar: Don’t worry about it!