Defying Boundaries and Escaping Stereotypes: African American Entertainers in the Late Nineteenth Century Study Notes

Chapter Title: Defying Boundaries and Escaping Stereotypes: African American Entertainers in the Late Nineteenth Century

Author: THOMAS L. RIIS

Book Title: Rethinking American Music
Editors: Tara Browner and Thomas L. Riis
Publisher: University of Illinois Press
JSTOR Link: https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.5406/j.ctvfjd0z8.16
Contact: support@jstor.org

I. Introduction to Nineteenth-Century African American Entertainment

  • The grotesque images of blackface minstrelsy from early nineteenth century provoke a shocked reaction from modern audiences.

  • This reaction creates discomfort and avoidance of blackface as well as hidden African American entertainment histories.

  • The complexity of cultural exchanges surrounding African American performing arts often leads to misunderstandings and challenges in historical narratives.

  • Notable works like Spike Lee’s film "Bamboozled" exemplify contemporary efforts to understand and critique the legacy of blackface.

  • John Strausbaugh’s book "Black Like You" (2006) provides a thorough analysis of the issues surrounding racial portrayal in popular culture but is considered insufficient regarding African American perspectives.

II. Historical Context

A. The Postbellum Era

  • By the end of the nineteenth century, African American music styles were thoroughly integrated into the cultural fabric of the United States.

  • Lynn Abbott and Doug Seroff’s analyses in "Out of Sight" (2002) and "Ragged but Right" (2007) show the important connections between various forms of African American music.

B. Evolution of Musical Traditions

  • The popular image of African American music shifted significantly from its origins in folk traditions, cross-class and racial interactions became evident.

  • By the 1890s, greater public appreciation of African American music developed, due to regional influences in the Midwest and South contrasting with the Euro-American immigrant traditions on the East Coast.

  • Specifically, white audiences experienced ragtime years before its mainstream introduction in New York through Ben Harney in 1896.

III. Minstrelsy and Its Contradictions

A. The Minstrel Phenomenon

  • The minstrel show emerged in the 1820s and became omnipresent thanks to its comedic and musical performances by white actors in blackface.

  • Despite being marked by racism, blackface minstrelsy included deep cultural roots with origins in diverse performance practices and rituals, from Shakespearean times to circus acts.

B. Resistance and Adaptation

  • Notable performers like Ira Aldridge challenged the simple stereotype of a black actor and reached international acclaim despite the complications of race in the American theater.

  • After the Civil War, the minstrel show remained a common starting point for many African American performers entering show business.

  • The three-part minstrel performance structure—an introduction, a variety show, and concluding skits—dominated American comedic entertainment.

IV. The Rise of Jubilee Singers and Their Impact

A. Fisk Jubilee Singers

  • The Fisk Jubilee Singers, formed to raise funds for their school, were pivotal in bringing African American spiritual music into the national consciousness.

  • Their tours drew praise from prominent figures like preacher Henry Ward Beecher and contributed significantly to their school’s funding.

  • The diversity of their repertoire focused on sacred songs contrasted with the minstrel tradition, leading to mixed public receptions.

B. Changing Landscape of Black Entertainment

  • By the late 1880s, though the jubilee form started diminishing, authentic minstrel performances by African Americans gained popularity and recognition, embracing more than parody.

  • Female performers gained visibility and involvement in an array of genres, enhancing diversity in theatrical representations.

V. Documentation and the Press

A. Black Newspapers

  • The Indianapolis Freeman served as an essential source for documenting African American entertainment and fostering community awareness through its extensive coverage.

  • Tom Fletcher’s autobiographical narrative provides insights into the experiences of African American entertainers and the boundaries they navigated.

B. Notable Figures and Their Contributions

  • Fletcher and Simond are chronicled for their deep insights into the evolving entertainment landscape, highlighting both personal and collective experiences of black performers.

  • Insights on Tom Fletcher’s experiences as an entertainer point to struggles with racism while he found opportunities in a frequently segregated industry.

VI. African American Migration and Performing Arts

A. Social and Economic Mobility

  • The migration trends post-Emancipation involved ambitious individuals from the South seeking opportunities in urban centers, shaping future talent pools for entertainment.

  • The connections formed during these movements enriched the cultural landscape and promoted diversity in the types of entertainment that emerged.

B. The Expansion of Blackface Minstrelsy

  • Figures like Barney Hicks emerged within the black minstrel tradition, paving paths for other entertainers and identifying locations conducive to professional engagement.

  • The evolution of involvement and narrative for African American performers reflect broader social dynamics during the late 19th century.

VII. Evolving Entertainment Genres

A. Circus and Tented Shows

  • Circus bands and tented variety shows also became prominent forms of entertainment that played significant roles outside formal theaters, reaching broader audiences.

  • These forms ensured the prominent presence of African American entertainers, often allowing them to showcase their talents to mixed audiences.

B. Legacy of Black Artists Abroad

  • African American performers found successful paths abroad, touring Europe, where they contributed to the local reception of American cultural forms.

  • Notable artists like Belle Davis exemplified the multifaceted careers of performers who navigated various genres between continents.

VIII. Conclusion: Understanding Boundaries and Impact

  • The ongoing legacy of blackface minstrelsy and African American entertainers demands acknowledgment of its complexities in shaping American culture.

  • Future historical narratives require more thorough exploration of the intersections in race, identity, and cultural expression to fully appreciate the contributions of African American performers.

IX. References

  • Extensive references diversifying the study of African American music and minstrelsy emphasize the significance of archival work and present-day scholarship in comprehending this multifaceted history.