Lecture 9c - Mapping pollutant plumes
Winthrop Landfill Case Study: Mapping Pollutant Plumes
Introduction
- The lecture explores the use of geophysical techniques to map pollutant plumes.
- The case study is the Winthrop Landfill Site in Maine, USA.
Case Study Site: Winthrop Landfill
- The site typifies issues related to old landfills.
- Originally a gravel extraction site, it was used for waste disposal from the 1930s to the 1980s.
- Environmental regulations were limited in the early days.
- Hazardous chemicals were accepted until the 1970s.
- The site is now closed but monitored by an operator.
Discovery of Contamination
- In 1980, leaking drums were reported.
- Local residents complained about unpleasant odors in their drinking water from local wells.
- Water sampling revealed contamination.
- Leaks at the site indicated a developing problem.
- The problem was centered at the southern end of the site, near a lake.
- Seeps releasing iron-rich fluids were observed on the lakeshore.
USGS Investigation
- A major investigation was conducted by the USGS.
- Aims:
- Understand the issues and impacts of leaks.
- Identify the source region of leaks.
- Define the extent of contamination.
- Assess wider areas within the lakes for further seeps to assess pollution.
Geophysical Techniques Used
- Radiation-based method: Natural gamma logging in boreholes.
- Electrical and electromagnetic (EM) techniques: Insight into hydrogeological characteristics and subsurface fluid composition.
- Magnetic surveys: Identify metal objects and metal-rich deposits associated with seeps.
- Boat-based seismic reflection profile: Detailed model of geology and lithologies under the lake. This is more strongly controlled by the mechanical properties of the rocks, compared to electrical methods, which focus on fluid properties.
- Boreholes: EM measurements of conductivity and natural gamma logging.
Surface Profiles: SF4 Results
- Profile SF4 is located immediately south of the landfill.
- DC Resistivity Survey:
- Low resistivity region (blue) in the center of the profile, close to the surface.
- Electromagnetic Profile Data:
- Pink and blue lines show EM data with different coil orientations.
- Similar increases in conductivity at different depths.
- Stronger signal from the vertical dipole orientation suggests the strongest increase in conductivity may be slightly deeper than 4 meters.
- Magnetic Data:
- Large anomaly on the right end attributed to cultural interference.
- Weak magnetic anomalies coincide with EM data.
Surface Profiles: SF1 Results
- Profile SF1 is parallel to SF4 but nearer the lakeshore.
- Resistivity Section:
- Localized area of high conductivity, deeper than SF4 (around 10 meters).
- High resistivity (red) attributed to bedrock.
- Electromagnetic and Magnetic Radiometry Signals:
- Less conclusive than SF4.
- No clear anomalies in EM data attributed to low conductivity.
- Magnetic data is inconclusive, potentially due to cultural interference.
- The EM and DC resistivity data are still in broad agreement. The lack of a substantial anomaly in the EM data indicate that the main bulk of the low resistivity region is now deeper than the effective depth of the six meter vertical dipole.
Borehole Results
- Well 13 (closest to the landfill):
- Elevated conductivity near the surface (within 4 meters).
- Increased clay content in the top 4 meters.
- Rapid increase in gamma at 12-13 meters, indicating metamorphic bedrock.
- Well 8A (between the two surface profiles):
- Surface conductivity appears relatively low but increases below 7 meters to just over 20 meters.
- Consistent with surface profile data, possibly a pollution plume.
- Gamma signal is very similar to Well 13A but without a large deep signal representative of the bedrock.
- Wells 212A and 212B (adjacent to each other):
- Problems with Well 212A resulted in a lack of conductivity signal between 14 and 22 meters.
- Well 212B shows conductivity increasing gradually from 11 meters to a maximum of 20 meters.
Synthesis of Well and Profile Data
- Consistent picture of a relatively shallow pollution plume emanating from the southern tip of the landfill.
- The plume travels downwards towards the lakeshore, reaching depths of around 20 meters.
Lake Surveys
- Magnetic data showed clear anomalies (orange areas) in the area closest to the base of the landfill.
- Suggests seeps present within the lake bed.
Seismic Reflection Data
- 400-meter profile, measurements down to about 50 meters.
- Vertical scale is exaggerated.
- Data collected on a time basis (milliseconds), converted to estimated depths using an average seismic velocity of 1.5m/s.
- Uppermost reflectors interpreted as soft lake bed bottom segments.
- Underlying areas of folded deposits with cross-cutting reflectors indicating an erosional surface.
- Potential trapped gas bubbles hinder clear seismic signal penetration.
- Paleochannels, incised channels within a paleo surface, filled with sediments.
- Sediments are coarser (medium or gravelly sands) with relatively high permeability.
- Paleochannel deposits could represent subsurface routes for descending pollutant plumes.
Overall Interpretation
- Leachate is released from a narrow zone at the southern end of the landfill.
- Conductivity measurements suggest the plume descends as it travels away from the landfill.
- Seismic data suggest leachate follows channels within the bedrock paleosurface.
- Correlation of magnetic anomalies and iron-rich seeps suggests further seeps are likely within the lake.
Conclusion
- The case study illustrates the successful combination of geophysical techniques to identify the location and depth of a pollution plume.
- Combines ground-based techniques with borehole data and seismic data.
- Includes remote sensing and GPS data (GNSS) for georeferencing.