franks dependancy theorie

Rowstow's Theory

  • Rowstow, an American economist, published his theory in 1960 concerning economic development.

  • He argued that all countries pass through five stages of economic development:

    1. Traditional Society

    • Characterized by a subsistence economy.

    • Most people are engaged in agriculture, producing little surplus food.

    2. Pre-conditions for Take-off

    • Marked by a shift from traditional farming.

    • New industries and infrastructure begin to develop.

    • Increase in agriculture and manufacturing leads to higher profits, which are reinvested.

    3. Take-off Stage

    • This is the fastest growth stage where the majority of the population works in manufacturing.

    • The economy experiences rapid growth in cash crops produce for sale.

    4. Drive to Maturity

    • Characterized by technological advancements that are used throughout the economy.

    • Industries produce a range of goods, and the economy continues to grow.

    5. Age of High Mass Consumption

    • An era where societies enjoy a wide range of goods, signifying high levels of wealth and comfort for consumers.

    • Countries develop their own pathways and strategies for advancement.

  • Criticisms of Rowstow's Model:

    • It is Eurocentric, primarily based on the development experiences of European countries.

    • Lacks consideration for diverse resources and geographical factors that affect development.

Frank's Dependency Theory

  • Frank's theory contrasts with Rowstow's by proposing a core-periphery model:

    • Core Region: Comprised of developed countries like North America, Europe, and Australasia that are wealthy and process raw materials.

    • Periphery Region: Consists of developing countries that often provide cheap raw materials to the core.

    • Historical trade patterns have perpetuated poverty in developing nations.

Support for Dependency Theory:

  • Instances of rich countries interfering in the internal politics of poorer nations.

  • Unbalanced trade practices, where developing countries sell raw materials at low prices but buy finished products at high costs.

  • Non-essential products marketed in developing countries (e.g., Coca-Cola).

  • Aid agreements that require developing countries to give something in return, often leading to debt.

Criticism of Dependency Theory:

  • Some countries that were never colonized (e.g., Ethiopia) remain poor, questioning the link between colonial history and current poverty.

  • Socialist systems may not guarantee development (e.g., Tanzania).

  • There are cases of very poor countries (e.g., South Korea) that successfully developed without the dependency framework.

  • Potentially positive influences from developed countries (e.g., neo-colonialism) can provide opportunities for growth via initiatives and campaigns like Make Poverty History and Free Trade.