Discourse Analysis
Discourse Analysis
Introduction to Discourse Analysis
- Discourse analysis examines language beyond the sentence level, focusing on language in text and conversation.
- It explores how we make sense of written and spoken language, recognize well-constructed texts, understand implicit communication, and participate in conversations.
- Seinfeld's commentary illustrates how pauses can indicate the size of a favor requested, highlighting the use of language beyond its literal components.
- Humans are unique in their ability to perform favors, which involves a level of cooperation not seen in other species.
Interpreting Discourse
- Language users can interpret fragments and notices by understanding underlying relationships (e.g., cause and effect, conditional relations).
- Even with ungrammatical forms, readers attempt to interpret the intended meaning rather than simply rejecting the text.
- Interpretation relies on linguistic knowledge and an understanding of text structure.
- Example: The "My Town" text demonstrates how readers try to make sense of grammatically incorrect language.
Cohesion
- Cohesion refers to the ties and connections within a text, maintaining reference to people, things, and ideas.
- Cohesive ties include:
- Reference: Using words to maintain reference to the same entities (e.g., father – he).
- Lexical relations: Connections between phrases (e.g., a Lincoln convertible – that car).
- Semantic relations: Terms sharing a common element of meaning (e.g., money-related words).
- Connectors: Words that mark the relationship between clauses (e.g., However).
- Verb Tenses: Consistent use of past tenses to link events.
- Cohesion contributes to judgments about whether something is well written.
- Cohesive structure varies across languages, affecting translation.
- Example: Analysis of cohesive ties in the paragraph about the Lincoln convertible.
Coherence
- Coherence is the sense of 'everything fitting together well,' which exists in people's interpretation of language.
- People make sense of what they read or hear based on their experience of the world.
- Understanding text involves filling in gaps and creating meaningful connections not explicitly stated.
- Example: The Lincoln convertible text demonstrates that connectedness is not solely based on word connections; an additional factor, coherence, is required.
Conversation Analysis and Coherence
- Interpretation of discourse involves more than just linguistic knowledge; it requires understanding conventional actions performed by speakers.
- Casual conversation relies on anticipating intentions, often with much of what is meant unsaid.
- Example: Her: "That's the telephone" Him: "I'm in the bath" Her: "O.K."
- Analysis: She requests action, he gives reason for non-compliance, she undertakes the action.
Speech Events
- Speech events vary based on speaker/hearer roles, relationships, topics, and settings.
- These factors influence what is said and how it is said.
- Understanding conversation involves recognizing that people take turns speaking, avoiding silence.
- If simultaneous speech occurs, one speaker typically stops.
- Completion points are marked by asking questions or pausing at the end of syntactic structures.
- Participants signal their desire to speak through short sounds, body shifts, or facial expressions.
- Example: A: "Didn’t you [know wh-" B: "[But he must’ve been there by two" A: "Yes but you knew where he was going"
Turn-Taking
- Conversational styles and turn-taking strategies vary.
- Differences in turn-taking conventions can lead to perceptions of 'rudeness' or 'shyness'.
- Speakers may use strategies to 'hold the floor' by avoiding completion points.
- Techniques include:
- Avoiding pauses at the end of sentences.
- Using connectors like "and," "and then," "so," "but."
- Placing pauses before or after verbs.
- Using hesitation markers such as "er," "em," "uh," "ah."
- These strategies are common and help in negotiating social interaction.
- Examples:
- A: